Swans’ epic win keeps finals dream alive
By Melanie Dinjaski, 6 Sep 2010 Melanie Dinjaski is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- AFL, ANZ stadium, Carlton Blues, Sydney Swans

Sydney and Carlton players react as the final siren sounds during the AFL 1st Elimination Final match between the Sydney Swans and the Carlton Blues at ANZ Stadium.
Sydney started the game with a relentless attack that left Carlton stunned. But the Blues surged before the first break, closing Sydney’s lead.
There was an odd moment in the first quarter that left everyone (including the umpires) scratching their heads. For what seemed a lifetime an interchange infringement was penalised and then overturned.
Although that was quickly forgotten as a classy performance from both teams saw the scoreboard tick over at a frantic pace, with the Swans taking a 24 point lead at half time.
But it wasn’t long before Chris Judd came to life, pushing Carlton closer and closer to the lead with an exhilarating display in the ruck that brought Sydney’s attack to an absolute halt in the third quarter.
Carlton seemed to have all the run with Robbie Warnock, Andrew Walker and Jarrad Waite being instrumental as the Blues took a 7 point lead going into the final quarter.
On a somewhat sour note though, an incident of ‘staging’ showed its ugly head.
Carlton’s Jarrad Waite made a ridiculous attempt to win a penalty with some remarkable acting. Taking a shoulder bump, he flung his head backward, put his hand to his face in agony and collapsed face down in the turf, and stayed down for a decent amount of time before leaping up and pleading for a penalty from the umpire.
But Waite was clearly guilty of simulation as replays showed there was no head contact whatsoever.
This sent the crowd into a frenzy and the volume only lifted as Sydney began the fight back.
With a deafening ‘Syyyyyyydddd-neeeeyy’ chant reminiscent of an EPL match, the 41,596 fans gave the game an incredible atmosphere that seemed to ooze out of the television screen.
Sydney’s youngsters continued to do their bit with some impressive performances. Paul Bevan kicked three goals, Kieren Jack made the most tackles on the ground, 2010’s Rising Star Daniel Hanneberry had another strong showing, while Josh Kennedy had the greatest impact with 31 disposals.
But it was straight shooter Trent Dennis-Lane who proved to be the match winner.
In his debut season, TDL, as he’s known by fans, has been deadly accurate in front of goal for most of the season despite his small physique. Finishing with four goals, Dennis-Lane’s last two in the final quarter put the Swans 12 points in front.
It was a close finish though, thanks to Lachlan Henderson who scored for Carlton with just one minute to go. But when Carlton’s Jeff Garlett missed his shot and scored a behind with 30 seconds left on the clock, Dennis-Lane’s final contribution was enough to get the Swans over the line, beating the Blues by just 5 points, 99 – 94.
While Carlton players were left in tears as another season had come to an end, the Swans and their fans were overjoyed at the prospect of their retiring heroes Paul Roos and Brett Kirk having one last crack at a grand final berth. And just two more wins could see the Swans well and truly make it too.
Next week Sydney will play the struggling Western Bulldogs in what will be a fascinating hit out between ex-Swan favourite Barry Hall and his old team.
If the Swans win, then St Kilda is all that stands in their way from a chance at winning the flag. Despite the Saints’ miraculous win over Geelong, their collapse in the second half showed that they are not invincible.
I don’t know about you, but I’ve definitely caught a serious case of September footy fever, and I cannot wait to see what happens next week.
You can follow Melanie Dinjaski on Twitter @MelanieDinjaski.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (24) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- AFL, ANZ stadium, Carlton Blues, Sydney Swans

Redb said | September 6th 2010 @ 8:01am | Report comment
What a great game. The Swans played fast open, exciting football in the first half – it was like a time warp back to the 1996 era, kicking long to contests, contested marks, trusting their team-mates up field to win the hard ball. But then with the lead at half time they reverted back to type for awhile in the 3rd qtr and tried to shut the game down just as Carlton really bit down hard and threw everything at the ball – Chris Judd simply dominant and untouchable.
Ended with a great last quarter, epic stuff from the Swannies. How good is Dennis Trent-Lane? Gun player of the future.
Classic final in front of a very good crowd of 41,000 odd, over double the crowd of their last elim final in 2008 against Nth melb.
If the Swans can get McGlynn and Bradshaw fit they will be very competitive.
Melanie Dinjaski said | September 6th 2010 @ 10:24am | Report comment
Tell me about it. With TDL and the assortment of other part time forward showing their stuff, what an added bonus McGlynn and Bradshaw would be!
Footy Legend said | September 6th 2010 @ 7:18pm | Report comment
I wouldn’t be suprised if the swans make the prelims. In fact, I reckon they may even beat the saints and make the grand final.
Derby County FC said | September 6th 2010 @ 9:27am | Report comment
Go the Swannies, i’m not ashamed to say i’m jumping on the bandwagon.
Jay said | September 6th 2010 @ 3:44pm | Report comment
like most of sydney (im also on the bandwagon) – ended up watching the last two quarters instead of the NRL!
Melanie Dinjaski said | September 6th 2010 @ 4:54pm | Report comment
THAT was a good move. I flicked over during half time and knew I made the right choice by sticking with the AFL!
TomC said | September 6th 2010 @ 10:06am | Report comment
Great game, but can’t help but feel sorry for the Blues after losing two tight elimination finals in consecutive years.
Melanie Dinjaski said | September 6th 2010 @ 10:25am | Report comment
Yeah Carlton have had it tough these past few years, but they’ve definitely improved though, and Judd will keep that going for sure.
Redb said | September 6th 2010 @ 11:09am | Report comment
Do not waste your sympathy for Carlton – trust me, if they’d won you would regret any thoughts of kindness
slickwilly said | September 6th 2010 @ 4:05pm | Report comment
couldnt agree more redb – as a magpie supporter carlton can go rot in………………………………………………. (
Melanie Dinjaski said | September 6th 2010 @ 4:55pm | Report comment
Now I can’t help but feel sorry for TomC…
slickwilly said | September 6th 2010 @ 5:23pm | Report comment
thats the spirit melanie
ac said | September 6th 2010 @ 10:20am | Report comment
i hope the Swannies do well. They are a great team and a good ambassador for the game.
GB said | September 6th 2010 @ 11:13am | Report comment
I was at the game and at quarter time you could be mistaken for thinking the game was over for the Blues..even at half time the Swans were still dominating. Cue the 3rd quarter and take a bow Chris Judd. He almost single handedly dragged the Blues back into it and had a chance in the final term to take Carlton to 2 goals up except he hit the post. The last quarter was a nail biter. I thought McVeigh and Shaw were very good for Sydney along with the usual supporting cast of Goodes, Jack, Kirk etc etc. They should beat the Bulldogs this weekend. The Saints though will be a lot tougher.
pH said | September 6th 2010 @ 8:39pm | Report comment
A fantastic match – see-sawing, tight passages, open passages, some great skills on show, champions (Goodes and Judd) showing their briliance, a roaring crowd in the last quarter, a clear sky and the scarlet v the navy blue meant it was always easy to see who the good guys were (whichever team you followed).
beaver fever said | September 7th 2010 @ 3:58pm | Report comment
Was a very exciting finish, good luck to the Swannies, good crowd, which looked bigger than 41k.
Neutral Fan said | September 7th 2010 @ 4:19pm | Report comment
I admit I’m a league fan first, but watching this game I see why it’s a popular sport. I rarely watch AFL i try to watch a few games throughout the year but they tend to be one-sided games so seeing this close, see-saw game was a great spectacle to watch. League, Union, & Football are my main sports, but I could take up AFL if the games were always at this high quality.
Mister Football said | September 7th 2010 @ 4:28pm | Report comment
NF
One thing we all know is that just as you can’t pick your family, you can’t ever be sure whether you’ll end up watching a great game, a fair game, or an absolute shocker – that goes for all four codes (indeed all sporting events).
It’s the nature of the beast.
I’ll say this though, when the weather is lousy outside, it’s fantastic to snuggle up and watch a good game of football (of any description).
Melanie Dinjaski said | September 8th 2010 @ 9:16am | Report comment
Couldn’t agree with you more Mister Football. And Neutral Fan, that was my opinion of AFL for a long time too, and I had no interest in it as a result, but the Swans were definitely responsible for regaining my interest in AFL, especially in their Grand Final years a few back. I think they are definitely one of those teams who love, and always seem to find themselves in a last minute fight back to win. I like that.
Redb said | September 8th 2010 @ 9:52am | Report comment
That’s true if your not attached to a team but as a neutral observer obviously the tight games are the best. Once you adopt a team though it goes to a different level of enjoyment.
Shame said | September 7th 2010 @ 11:51pm | Report comment
Great umpiring, I am sure the AFL is crying crocodile tears that the Swans are still in the competition and their most hated club Carlton was tossed out.
The free kick shots on goal the Swans received for trivial incidences just confirms everyones suspicions about the Swans being the AFL’s lovechild.
Redb said | September 8th 2010 @ 9:50am | Report comment
Sounds like sour grapes to me.
Many Sydney fans complain they get rough treatment from Vic biased umpires. Go figure
JamesP said | September 8th 2010 @ 11:41am | Report comment
Actually from a crowd point of view they may have preferred Carlton to take on the Dogs (70k?) to the Swans (50k at best)
Although the Swans did achieve their bext TV viewers in Sydney for the entire year 127k. For a Sunday (and a Fathers Day at that), its a pretty good result. Obviously the close game helped!!
Mister Football said | September 8th 2010 @ 7:58pm | Report comment
good point
I’m still bitter that in 1982, when the VFL sent South to Sydney, I’m certain the umps favoured the Swans every time they came up against the Scraggers – remember when little McKenna copped a high one and the ump waved play on?
c’mon – surely everyone remembers it!!