The Roar
The Roar

AFL
Advertisement

Revolutionising the AFL's trade period

8th April, 2011
Advertisement
Expert
8th April, 2011
7
1228 Reads

The opening two rounds have seen long-term injuries affect teams, crucially to the point they will curtail their season. Several of these injured players are their teams most important.

The Eagles have lost Mark LeCras and Beau Waters, Lions Jonathon Brown and Brent Staker, Saints Lenny Hayes, Crows Jason Porplyzia and Port Adelaide Dominic Cassisi.

Each of the mentioned players is an automatic selection in the respective 22 and will significantly impact the first half success their team has.

AFL trade week traditionally begins nine days following the grand final where there is little activity until the final few days. Recent rule changes have seen teams able to trade rookie listed players which Geelong utilised in 2009 by trading rookie Shane Mumford to Sydney, where he is now the number one ruckman. Other suggestions have been made to allow teams to trade future draft picks.

The NFL trade system is a very successful one and addresses many of the issues the AFL has in regard to early season injuries to critical players. Prior to the CBA negotiation lockout, a traditional NFL calendar would look a little like:

February: Superbowl. End of season.
March: Trade period begins.
April: NFL Draft.
July: Training camps commence.
August: Pre-season begins (four games each team).
September: Roster cut from 75 players to 53.
September: Season kickoff.
October: Trading deadline.

In the NFL model, the trade period lasts seven months! Most importantly, early round trading during the season ensures teams are not derailed by injuries to star players.

Of course, trading for good players at this time can be very expensive after players have dedicated entire pre-seasons to one team. However, it keeps the competition fair.

Advertisement

Additionally, NFL teams are able to place conditions on draft picks traded. This way teams can trade a player for either 3rd or 4th round draft picks – whichever one is higher come end of season.

In 2010, the Minnesota Vikings were able to acquire Randy Moss from New England through by trade during the regular season after number one receiver Sydney Rice was ruled out long term. In week six, Moss proved the difference in a 24-21 win against the Cowboys.

“Moss’ first home game since rejoining the Vikings in trade turned into an afterthought. He finished with five catches for 55 yards, but his biggest contribution might have been in the locker room at the half. Both (coach, Brad) Childress and (quarterback, Brett) Favre credit Moss for encouraging his teammates to create more energy for the second half,” it was said.

The AFL could consider a similar model. We consistently see players star in the pre-season who would be valued higher by other clubs than their own. In these cases, an early season trade could open up opportunities for the player as well as fill injury voids within other teams.

Let’s take Lenny Hayes, for example. A hard in-and-under clearance player, Hayes clearance work is critical to St Kilda. Over the pre-season and first two rounds, Ed Curnow and Mitch Robbinson have been exceptional for Carlton playing in-and-under but are outclassed by Chris Judd, Marc Murphy, Bryce Gibbs and Heath Scotland.

Right now, Ed Curnow is much more valuable to St Kilda than Carlton and if given the window, St Kilda may have inquired about him. The biggest concern about Curnow was his injuries and he has clearly gotten over them.

Now let’s look at the Lions. Losing Brown and Staker means they are short on key position experience. Why not pluck Brad Miller? He looks to be getting limited opportunities at Richmond who are keen to play their younger key position players first. Miller could play in the AFL rather than the seconds.

Advertisement

The Lions could get him for a third/fourth round pick when they are desperate for an experienced body. Chad Cornes or Saetanta O’hailpin wouldn’t be bad acquisitions either.

If the AFL was to introduce a five week trade period at the start of the season, early season injuries will not derail entire seasons. Furthermore, disillusioned players are given an opportunity to leave in the event they have stellar pre-seasons but are still unable to break into the senior team.

It’s a wacky idea but the sub rule has thrown all concepts of logic out the window. At what price will your club pay for early season wins?

close