Manchester United let down by their own stupidity
By Mike Tuckerman, 18 Apr 2011 Mike Tuckerman is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- FA Cup, football, Manchester City, Manchester United, Michael Carrick, paul scholes, Sir Alex Ferguson, Wayne Rooney
Paul Scholes is one of the highest-paid footballers in the world, with the 36-year-old wrecking ball reportedly earning more than £4 million per season. Despite the handsome salary, Scholes committed the kind of foul you’d expect to see in a park game as Manchester United crashed to defeat against Manchester City in the FA Cup.
Scholes’ studs-up, thigh-raking challenge on City defender Pablo Zabaleta came with United chasing the game, after Yaya Toure had taken full advantage of Michael Carrick’s dreadfully misplaced pass early in the second half.
Carrick is another of United’s highest earners, although neither he nor Scholes come close to drawing the astronomical salary Wayne Rooney pulls in.
If you’re to believe the various wage-earner lists drawn up by the media, only Cristiano Ronaldo earns more than United’s enfant terrible Rooney, with the perpetually grumpy English striker purportedly paid more than twinkle-toed Barcelona star Lionel Messi.
Yet, while Ronaldo and Messi were both slotting home penalties as Real Madrid drew 1-1 with Barça in La Liga over the weekend, Rooney was looking forlorn as he sat disconsolately in the Wembley stands.
After launching a foul-mouthed tirade down the barrel of a TV camera following a recent hat-trick against West Ham, Rooney seemed surprised to be handed a two-match suspension by the English Football Association, which resulted in him missing one of United’s biggest games of the season.
That Rooney thought it necessary to swear so egregiously on live TV should come as no great shock.
The surly savant has been mollycoddled his entire life, to the point that he actually believes criticism in the newspapers and from the stands justifies the massive persecution complex he lumbers around on those broad shoulders of his.
And what Rooney has in common with Scholes is a manager in Sir Alex Ferguson unwilling to discipline his players for their constant misdemeanours.
Scholes had only just returned from a two-match ban for accruing ten yellow cards during his side’s league campaign, only to see himself pointlessly sent off for yet another challenge which didn’t need to be made.
It just goes to show that no matter how much a player is paid, you can’t put a price on stupidity.
And while neither Rooney or Scholes deliberately tried to disadvantage their own team through their respective brushes with authority, their reckless individualism ended up costing team-mates dearly and no doubt had United fans tearing their own hair out.
So it is that Manchester City march on to face either Bolton or Stoke City in the FA Cup final, and won’t it be refreshing to see a different name on the trophy this year?
City made the most of United’s generous defending in a predictably tense semi-final affair, but they looked the better side for long periods and no doubt deserved to go through.
I just wish I’d kept up my own football career, for no other reason than I wouldn’t mind earning a hefty sum of money for being entirely useless in an FA Cup semi-final.
I can’t pass, can’t shoot, can’t tackle and I don’t think I’ve ever once made a decisive, defence-splitting pass in an entirely forgettable park footballer’s career.
But I can swear like a trooper, when required, and thigh-grazing tackles are somewhat of a speciality.
That’s the kind of behaviour you’d expect to see from a hopeless amateur like myself, but when it comes to two of Manchester United’s highest-paid stars, their stupidity has let their team down badly.
Mike Tuckerman is a Sydney-born journalist and lifelong football fan. After lengthy stints watching the beautiful game in Germany and Japan, he has settled in Brisbane and has been a Roar columnist since December 2008. Follow Mike on twitter @Mike_Tuckerman
![]()
Passionate about your football? Then sign up to The Roar's brand new daily football email, delivering Roaring articles directly to you day-in, day-out. You'll love it!
Click here to join now!
Looking to join The Roar team? We're searching for an experienced Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. Yes, this does mean you get to work with the site all day long! If you're a digital media sales star, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
The Crowd Says (58) | Page 2 of Comments
Have Your Say
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Football articles
- What A-League matches should be on Friday night FTA? (158)
- Are we supporting the Soccerwhos? (127)
- Scrap the A-League finals and replace it with State of Origin (114)
- The mainstream media continues to ignore football (97)
- Osieck announces Socceroos squad for World Cup Qualifiers (96)
- English football has drama Aussie sport can’t replicate (95)
- The FA Cup final lost its lustre long ago (93)
- Football fans need to forgive Channel Seven (40)
- Channel Seven to broadcast Liverpool, Man United friendlies (84)
- We must learn from Guangzhou humbling (45)
- Socceroos need to give up on World Cup (89)
- Assessing the 2013/14 A-League draw (15)
- Socceroos’ door not closed on Kewell (5)
- Osieck banks on World Cup experience (2)
- Football fans need to forgive Channel Seven (40)
- Socceroos need to give up on World Cup (89)
- Assessing the 2013/14 A-League draw (15)
- Scrap the A-League finals and replace it with State of Origin (114)
- AS Monaco’s taxing promotion to Ligue 1 (17)
- FFA misses opportunity with FTA coverage (23)
- Central Coast Mariners vs Guangzhou Evergrande: ACL live scores, blog (118)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- FA Cup, football, Manchester City, Manchester United, Michael Carrick, paul scholes, Sir Alex Ferguson, Wayne Rooney


April 19th 2011 @ 7:45am
RC97 said | April 19th 2011 @ 7:45am | Report comment
Scholes isn’t paid anywhere near as much in comparison to the city players…
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
April 19th 2011 @ 11:32am
David V. said | April 19th 2011 @ 11:32am | Report comment
Paul Scholes and Ryan Giggs have played at the one club their whole careers, which makes them endangered species or relics in football. Both of them appear more comfortable away from the limelight.
Scholes is one of the more technically gifted homegrown players of his generation. Yet he mixes that with what you might call a “competitive” streak- and how many ball players can you say have that?
Notice that Roy Keane only developed his nasty qualities after joining United. That’s because Brian Clough would NEVER have let him get away with what he could under Ferguson. Brian Clough believed not only in playing football the right way, on the deck, but also in fair play- no dives, reckless tackles or arguing with referees.
April 19th 2011 @ 2:08pm
Mike Tuckerman said | April 19th 2011 @ 2:08pm | Report comment
Have you opened a can of worms here, David V.? Has Sir Alex Ferguson’s public silence actively encouraged nasty habits in his players? I’d like to see what United fans have to say about this.
April 19th 2011 @ 2:41pm
Fussball ist unser leben said | April 19th 2011 @ 2:41pm | Report comment
Mike
What is your evidence that Man United players have a tendency towards more nasty habits? Surely, you are NOT simply going to draw upon the 2 incidents – Rooney’s swearing at the camera and Scholesy’s red card?
In fact, if you bother to review the FACTS about “fair play” in the EPL this season, you will discover that only SIX of the 19 other EPL teams have a better disciplinary record than Man United.
With a scoring system of Red= 2 points; Yellow=1 point, here are the results, thus far, for the top teams in the EPL this season.
3. Chelsea: 47 pts (45Y, 1R)
4. Spurs: 48 (44Y, 2R)
7. Man United: 52 (46Y, 3R)
11. Liverpool: 59 (55Y, 2R)
15. Arsenal: 65 (53Y, 6,)
19. Man City: 69 (61Y, 4R)
So, the FACTS indicate that, this season, Wenger’s Arsenal team and Mancini’s Man City team each have been sanctioned for their “nasty habits” more than SAF’s Man United team.
And, in the previous season – 2009/10 – Man United were the 3rd most disciplined team in the EPL.
So, please tell us what evidence you have of “nasty habits” being encouraged in Man United players.
April 19th 2011 @ 3:14pm
Mike Tuckerman said | April 19th 2011 @ 3:14pm | Report comment
Who said I have evidence? I merely asked a question.
April 19th 2011 @ 3:37pm
Bondy said | April 19th 2011 @ 3:37pm | Report comment
Fussball ,
Did you recieve a strange email recently about a strange thread that only a few were on.
The big puffy bloke from Victoria.
That thread becomes even weirder.
April 19th 2011 @ 3:42pm
Fussball ist unser leben said | April 19th 2011 @ 3:42pm | Report comment
Apologies, Mike for jumping the gun. As you know, I’m a bit paranoid about anything that is said about my MUFC and MVFC lads … of course the fact that all other clubs hate us and are out to get us doesn’t help my paranoia!
@ Bondy … mate, your message is too cryptic for me to decipher – not quite sure what you mean.
April 19th 2011 @ 4:13pm
Bondy said | April 19th 2011 @ 4:13pm | Report comment
Fussball.
I received an email about 10 minutes ago about a thread recently that only a few were on.
The cryptic element was if you can cast your mind back – ( Those prawns could have come from overseas their’s no point in trying them, if you do eat them you’ll be doomed ).
April 19th 2011 @ 5:47pm
Joseph said | April 19th 2011 @ 5:47pm | Report comment
Man you love rolling out the FACTS stats as if anything in life (including football) is black and white.
April 19th 2011 @ 6:09pm
Fussball ist unser leben said | April 19th 2011 @ 6:09pm | Report comment
@ Joseph
If opinions are not based on FACTS, or past-experiences, or expertise/qualifications then, for me, those opinions are simply mindless ramblings and life is too short to spend even a second pondering mindless ramblings.
April 19th 2011 @ 7:24pm
David V. said | April 19th 2011 @ 7:24pm | Report comment
And when facts about Muscat were rolled out…
April 20th 2011 @ 12:32pm
Joseph said | April 20th 2011 @ 12:32pm | Report comment
I see where you’re coming from, but there’s that grey area that gets missed by stats, as they don’t count how many times a team gets away with bad tackles etc.
You can roll out as many stats s you want, the whole world minus Man U fans still know that red team from Manchester are dirty, and have been for many a year.
April 20th 2011 @ 12:42pm
Fussball ist unser leben said | April 20th 2011 @ 12:42pm | Report comment
@ Joseph
Yes, you are absolutely correct that the refs don’t pick everything up.
In the absence of corrupt referees, such referee oversights would fall within the category of “systematic errors” – i.e. all teams would, over the course of a 38 match season, get the benefit of these such refereeing oversights.
Or, are you suggesting some giant conspiracy where all the referees in England have quietly got together and have decided to only give Man United the benefit of the doubt when it comes to “bad tackles”? If this is what you think, well … you may need to seek answers from people with qualifications that I do not possess.
April 20th 2011 @ 1:23pm
Joseph said | April 20th 2011 @ 1:23pm | Report comment
I agree that most things pan out over a season. I guess im not really talking about tackles in particular, just that I can’t see how anyone can wholly make an opinion based on stats when there’s so much more to the equation, that don’t get lumped into your “systematic errors”.
And no lol I don’t wear tinfoil hats, do you? There’s been a fair few MU fans with them tightly screwed on since that gloomy month yous had not so long ago.
April 21st 2011 @ 12:38pm
Joseph said | April 21st 2011 @ 12:38pm | Report comment
Got nothing to retort with Fuss? Gotta be a first.
April 19th 2011 @ 6:56pm
Bondy said | April 19th 2011 @ 6:56pm | Report comment
Full steam ahead for the World Cup in Qatar. I think.
http://soccernet.espn.go.com/news/story/_/id/909015/world-cup-2022:-swiss-film-crew-arrested-filming-in-qatar-?cc=3436