Expectations of excellence a heavy burden to bear
By Garth Hamilton, 28 Jun 2011 Garth Hamilton is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Blues, Reds, Rugby Union, Super Rugby, Waratahs
Related coverage
The Waratahs leave this season with the greatest prize any Australian Super Rugby team could hope for. Not even the brilliant Queensland Reds ,who still have the chance of winning the competition, can lay claim to it. And yet, it is the greatest gift any team, organisation, country or alliance could hope for.
It is the expectation of excellence.
Waratahs fans expect not just ‘a winning culture’ but a culture of excellence. And they have not been shy in making this known.
They do not turn up just to watch their team win, they turn up to watch a confirmation of their beliefs. Waratahs supporters see themselves and their team as representatives of some higher calling within the rugby world.
Fifteen disciples of running rugby whose greatest challenge doesn’t come from the opposition but comes from overcoming their own fear of losing and opening themselves to their more fabled than practised style of play.
To push the point about the expectation of the Waratahs fans, consider that this is a team that has reached the finals of the Super rugby competition in five of the last seven years and yet evoked sufficient discontent among its supporters to make a ‘fans forum’ necessary.
Waratah fans, much like the great Mark Loane, do not take mediocrity, or even above average, well.
This certainly didn’t happen in Queensland, and growing up in the John Connolly-era, kids like me didn’t care how we beat New South Wales as long as we beat them.
To complain about the style of a win seemed gluttonous and pretentious, but my southern cousins were different.
They expected excellence.
Teams can win without excellence. Underdogs can do the extraordinary, brutes can bully their way to supremacy, and otherwise also-rans can take the gold in a dud year (its called the Sandra Bullock effect).
But without the expectation of excellence, a team cannot reach that higher level.
It was what Brian Clough wanted for Leeds United when he told them that winning everything meant nothing if they weren’t loved.
It was why Ayrton Senna looked so disgusted with himself when he won the 1990 Formula One championship by deliberately taking out Alain Prost.
Its why Rory McIlroy’s style of golf so quickly had the locals at Congressional chanting his name, why Sir Frank Worrell’s West Indies team of 1961 were given a tickertape parade through Melbourne, and why kids born years after the career of Muhammad Ali wear clothes with his image on them.
People often talk of expectations in terms of their weight, the minimums that need to be met and the difficulty to live up to them. But there is another way to view expectations and it is what those in charge of the Waratahs need to realise.
Facing your expectations, not avoiding them, can be a very empowering experience.
Hopefully the Waratahs, as both a team and an organisation, can begin to hold each other to the expectations of excellence that are an essential part of the tradition of that name.
Waratahs fans have every reason to expect that to happen.
Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- Reds back in contention, but Waratahs need a cleanout (287)
- What Hansen’s first squad means for the Wallabies (191)
- ALAN JONES: We have the players, it’s the coaches that are to blame (161)
- Who will be in the Wallabies’ backrow? (158)
- Will Cooper and Mitchell be back in time for Wallaby selection? (156)
- CAMPO: Will Deans change the style of the Wallabies play? (128)
- Tahs out. Brumbies win ugly. And Quade’s back! (124)
- McKenzie or White: who will be the next Wallaby coach? (7)
- Chiefs back on top after downing Bulls (2)
- Rebels know Super improvement needed
- Quade can play way into Wallabies squad (2)
- A Kiwi’s advice to Wallaby supporters (14)
- Confessions of a rugby union traitor (5)
- Reds focus on Brumbies, not finals
- A Kiwi’s advice to Wallaby supporters (14)
- Confessions of a rugby union traitor (5)
- Brumbies vs Reds: a lesson for the other provinces (9)
- Chiefs vs Bulls: Super Rugby live scores, blog (14)
- Hola Argentina, and welcome to the Rugby Championship! (23)
- Irish coaches looking to head Western Force (15)
- Dull Super Rugby coaches equal dull rugby (50)
- Explore:
- Blues, Reds, Rugby Union, Super Rugby, Waratahs



June 28th 2011 @ 2:48am
David Lord said | June 28th 2011 @ 2:48am | Report comment
Brilliant Garth, simply brilliant and right on the button – winning ugly doesn’t cut the mustard in NSW, who have been spoilt by the likes of the Ellas, Poidevin, Farr-Jones, Campese, Hawker, Burke, and O’Connor, just to name a few, exponents of the running game.
June 28th 2011 @ 9:08am
AJ said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:08am | Report comment
If that’s Michael O’Connor you refer to,he actually played his rugby for the “boring” old Queenslanders.I guess he only learnt “the running game” when he crossed the border and the code eh?
You guys seriously need to get your hands off it.
June 28th 2011 @ 10:02am
jimmyjam said | June 28th 2011 @ 10:02am | Report comment
AJ, as usual if you went to seaworld on your holidays, you’re a qlder (provided you can play RU or RL)
FYI O’connor was born in NSW (Nowra) raised in ACT (from where he represented Aus Schoolboys in ’77) and played barely 2 seasons in Qld before returning to NSW and playing RL.
So to use your own quote, Get your hand of it and use it to remove the shoulder chips.
June 28th 2011 @ 12:41pm
AJ said | June 28th 2011 @ 12:41pm | Report comment
Ok,jump on the net and find out how many games of rugby union he played for NSW (senior team)?According to the comment I replied to, he was at least in the top ten of the “running game” exponents for the Waratahs.
June 28th 2011 @ 11:13am
jokerman said | June 28th 2011 @ 11:13am | Report comment
Garth, are we talking about the same team here?
Expectations is what forms a lot of misery for people. They expect this, I expect this. I want that….and the outcome is disappointment…as their experience does not meet what they expected.
It is the let down in relationships, as often what you expect in another, simply can’t happen, as they don’t have the ability to be what another expects.
Faith from the heart is different, this is where the All blacks are, though come Word cup time, that can metamorphosis into expectation, which is from mind, and we know the results there.
June 28th 2011 @ 3:10am
Jimbojones said | June 28th 2011 @ 3:10am | Report comment
Not sure I agree with your line of thinking but will run with it for a moment. Maybe in this relentless pursuit of perfection the waratahs seem to have forgotten the basics. It’s a heavy burden for any team to carry and perhaps the tahs fans forget the first lesson, that rugby is played by humans and all humans are capable of mistakes especially when under pressure to perform. More to the point though is the fact that rugby should be fun for the players to play and for the fans to watch. The tahs players never seem to look like they are enjoying their rugby. Perhaps the burden of this expectation is too taxing on player spirit.
I have another theory though – that the culture of Sydney and the arrogance of it’s people is a bad influence on the whole team. The expectation to win reflects the arrogance. Perhaps the tahs should play more of their rugby outside of Sydney, rebuild their fan base in NSW and loose the eastern suburbs attitude.
June 28th 2011 @ 9:22am
Damo said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:22am | Report comment
Don’t agree with your logic Jimbo. Where does the article use the word ‘perfection’?
You’ve set up a straw man with a hospital pass there.
And where is your ‘arrogance’ meter to gauge levels of it in Tahs fans?
However I agree with your conclusion. Tahs need to go west and into the regions to make engagement with the people that could and would love love them, if only they knew them.
A well written piece but it has a narrow focus that will be lost on many readers here. I hope you have a thick skin Garth.
June 28th 2011 @ 2:57pm
jokerman said | June 28th 2011 @ 2:57pm | Report comment
Damo, this is not lost on a narrow focus. Any grounded individual with a beating heart will see through the Faze of illusion.
It reminds me of the shoe company Nike, “Just do it” Slogans. Some people believe the hype and go out and purchase shoes that cost them $300. It costs Nike only $2 to make, but they know people will fall for their advertising. Effectively Nike has convinced its consumers that their imaged has been enhanced by buying their shoes.
This article has used such slogans to convince some that they too are special, and are from a more super breed. It is the ego that wrote this, and it is the ego who responds kindly to it. Both are in the glow of self-enhancing, not from heart, but from mind which is narcissism.
June 28th 2011 @ 11:43am
jokerman said | June 28th 2011 @ 11:43am | Report comment
I agree with the Sydney culture. This article also stems from a position of “I am better…matter what” In Garths mind, The Waratahs have the ultimate prize, that no one can have. Yes they have been beaten, couldn’t get past the quarters, they lack spirit, no one really loves them….but yet! They have the expectation of excellence….so they are the best in the “Excellent” egoic eyes of Garth.
This article really has a soulless, pretentious, snobby feeling to it.
June 28th 2011 @ 6:01pm
Sage said | June 28th 2011 @ 6:01pm | Report comment
Agreed jokerman
June 28th 2011 @ 6:05am
sixo_clock said | June 28th 2011 @ 6:05am | Report comment
The breakthrough thought for me was the concept of building a positive relationship with the ‘available’ fans. That is the key, it is simple, positive, measurable, and worthwhile. Stunning article, Garth, thanks.
June 28th 2011 @ 6:43am
Hughtack said | June 28th 2011 @ 6:43am | Report comment
Fantastic Brian. Tks very much. This is what supporting the Watatahs is all about.
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
June 28th 2011 @ 7:46am
Rabbitz said | June 28th 2011 @ 7:46am | Report comment
The problem is Hickey has said, that he doesn’t care what the fans think about their play. So we can expect all we like, but we still will be delivered the same rubbish until the management and attitudes change.
July 1st 2011 @ 2:51am
Matthew Skellett said | July 1st 2011 @ 2:51am | Report comment
“On da button” Rabbitz, Mr Burke reflected this arrogance when he suggested that the ‘TAHS have ‘the divine right of kings’ to continue to serve up absolute rubbish AND that the fans/rugby-going public should smile, laugh, slap ‘em on the back and pretend nothing has happened and let the ‘gravy train’ go on it’s merry way indefinitely
June 28th 2011 @ 8:05am
Dingo Bob said | June 28th 2011 @ 8:05am | Report comment
What a load of dribble. Do you honestly think Waratahs fans would not turn up if they won Super Rugby in a less than perfect fashion. There is truth to the saying that nobody is perfect and if this is what is required for a Waratahs team to have fans than I’m amazed anyone turns up. Ultimately people like winners and if the Waratahs had won Super 15 in season 2011 regardless of how they played they would have been heaped with praise about their team spirit and how they played the game.
June 28th 2011 @ 8:11am
Jiggles said | June 28th 2011 @ 8:11am | Report comment
“Waratahs supporters see themselves and their team as representatives of some higher calling within the rugby world.”
They sure do, and as such they neglect to do the hard stuff right, the basics, thinking some divine intervention will give them championships, because well they are the Tah’s after all and it’s their right! They will always be also ran’s until they address this attitude.
June 28th 2011 @ 8:30am
p.Tah said | June 28th 2011 @ 8:30am | Report comment
Sorry Jiggles, that is the major beef I have with this article. I don’t know one Tahs supporter who see themselves in this light. We are just frustrated. We are the largest State with the highest number of players, this doesn’t mean we believe we are entitled to win but rather we have the resources we should have got there by now. But you don’t get there by chance. Something is amiss. Do we want excellence? Not necessarily, we just want a title, but in the interim we’ll be cheering the Reds on their joureny through the finals.
.
June 28th 2011 @ 8:52am
Rickety Knees said | June 28th 2011 @ 8:52am | Report comment
Ditto p.Tah and Go the Reds!
June 28th 2011 @ 9:34am
Manoa said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:34am | Report comment
I would suggest that both p.Tah and Rickety Knees comfortably fall into this category of fan. Both continually ridicule and criticise the Waratahs and NSW rugby as an organisation with this underlying belief that the Waratahs should be some unstoppable force whereby success should be expected.
June 28th 2011 @ 10:15am
Damo said | June 28th 2011 @ 10:15am | Report comment
No Manoa, you are incorrect about ‘this category of fan’
This category of fan is also a code fan fighting for the code in the nations largest and most code- competitive city.
When the Tahs win the code gets some. And vica versa. And the winning is not just on the scoreboard. The Tahs and the code could be so much more in this city and state.
That it is not is a crying shame IMO.
If Sydney were a surf spot and the Tahs were a surfer on a board they have just missed another set of beautiful rideable waves.
June 29th 2011 @ 8:33am
GrecoRoman said | June 29th 2011 @ 8:33am | Report comment
“If Sydney were a surf spot and the Tahs were a surfer on a board they have just missed another set of beautiful rideable waves.”
QFT!!
June 28th 2011 @ 1:20pm
p.Tah said | June 28th 2011 @ 1:20pm | Report comment
Monoa, I do not “continually ridicule and criticise the Waratahs and NSW rugby as an organisation”. I have stood by them through thick and thin for years and will always do so, because they are my team. I would say that in the vast majority of my posts I have stuck up for them (the coaches, the board, the players and the admin).
June 28th 2011 @ 8:55am
Jiggles said | June 28th 2011 @ 8:55am | Report comment
Sorry pTah – it has just been my experience in Sydney so far, especially in the Eastern Suburbs in pubs watching rugby with Tah fans. I think the Waratah’s are actually a good team, and as a reds fan I would love to have your record over the past 10 years, no championships and all.
It is just frustrating listening to these ‘fans’ watch rugby and demanding the Waratah’s play like the reds, or the Crusaders or the Stormers, when their team is inherently different with a coach who I think is a little out of his depth. The only argument a lot of these fans can come up with as to why the Tah’s should be perennial SR favorites is because well they are the Tahs and they finished in the finals last year so they should win it this year, ignoring there have been no substantial changes for improvements in the off season which would suggest a title is in the tables, which is completely illogical.
I actually think the Fan culture is a massive issue for the Tahs and something that has to be managed.
For the record I am still not convinced the Reds are a championship winning team; however I am very happy with this season, and will be win or lose this weekend or the next, as I was with last year. Anything is better than the 5-7 years we spent in the doldrums!
June 28th 2011 @ 9:47am
Damo said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:47am | Report comment
Jiggles, pTah and Rickety, this fan issue keeps coming up.
Fan expectation is the big element that has not been properly analysed.
The major point from a marketing point of view is that Tahs management is failing to provide a product that is attractive to fans.
For Hickey (and he doesn’t create the product he only polishes it and puts it on display) to say that the fan forum had little influence on things, says it all.
There is no problem at the Tahs that a lucky break with injuries won’t fix?
I had sympathy with Hickey till that comment. The hangman can have his way for all I care now.
The Tahs problems are parallel with The code’s problems in Australia. This point is completely missed in the article.
I want the Tahs to be good, to be visible , to be known city and state wide because I want the CODE to be known and appreciated in Australia’s largest city.
Because I want the next TPN or Kurtley or Dave Dennis, playing in the U/14s this weekend out west to be playing rugby in 5 to 10 years time and not lost to another game ( or none).
So Garth, whilst I love the psychology in your ‘pursuit of excellence’ line there is a social reality that is invisible in your piece.
Teams need people, passionate people. And people need teams, passionate exciting teams.
At the moment these two groups are in different fish bowls trying to kiss each other through the glass. Or maybe something less affectionate.
June 28th 2011 @ 1:37pm
p.Tah said | June 28th 2011 @ 1:37pm | Report comment
Jiggles don’t judge Sydney on the Eastern suburbs! The are majority are wonderful people but there are pretentious people there, as there are in other areas throughout Australia.
For what its worth, I dont want the Tahs to be clones of the Reds or the Crusaders. I may as just watch those teams.
… and finally how awesome is Sydney we’ve got a bridge AND an Opera House! Take that Queensland!!
June 28th 2011 @ 2:59pm
Big Steve said | June 28th 2011 @ 2:59pm | Report comment
P.Tah you can break that down further. Dont judge the eastern suburbs on the view that is stereotyped on this site. Not everyone who lives there is pretentious. I live east and go to club rugby games as often as I can (usually 5 or 6 a year) and go to the tahs when ever I am in sydney (probably 80% of the games over the last 10 years). I find the continued attitude to the eastern suburbs on this site very judgemental and a gross generalisation.
The choice of where I live has no impact on who I am or what interests I have.
June 28th 2011 @ 3:13pm
p.Tah said | June 28th 2011 @ 3:13pm | Report comment
Big Steve, I agree,
I wrote: “The are majority are wonderful people but there are pretentious people there” that doesn’t even make sense but what I had intend to write was that “The majority of people in the Eastern Suburbs are wonderful people but there are pretentious people there as there are in other areas throughout Australia.”
June 28th 2011 @ 9:57pm
jokerman said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:57pm | Report comment
The eastern suburbs are just not the same after all the kiwis left Bondi beach.
June 28th 2011 @ 3:20pm
jokerman said | June 28th 2011 @ 3:20pm | Report comment
@Jiggles….That is why I find this article so pretentious!
June 28th 2011 @ 8:23am
Charles Plowdog said | June 28th 2011 @ 8:23am | Report comment
Garth, I apologise for this but I think the premise of your article is a load of rubbish. It is well written and an interesting thought but that is all. No doubt as a matter of principle ‘tahs supporters (and indeed supporters of all teams) have the ‘expectation of excellence’ but to put this on some sort of pedestal, it smacks of arrogance. This notion that the fans don’t take mediocrity well is based on some view about Mark Loane’s position, and after all he’s a Queenslander, and some commentary about Senna and McIlroy the relevance of which is tendentious.
I doubt if one can compare the passions of supporters of team and individual sports. The former is more long lasting, possibly life-long, and is there regardless of the members of the team as a rule. The latter is because of some attachment we form with the individual (how else do we explain the continuing importance of Greg Norman to Australians). I am sure that we all want the teams we support to be excellent; but I really doubt that that we want that over and above a premiership. Collingwood’s win in the 1990 Grand Final is no less valued by Collingwood supporters, I believe, because it was a pretty boring slugfest of a game. And the the real quality of the Reds has been shown this year through their ability to win against many comers and in many circumstances; more power to them.
Thanks but the best your article does is give some solace to long suffering ‘tahs fans, so as to let them believe, mistakenly, that in order to be a real winner you’ve got to look good when doing it.
June 28th 2011 @ 9:10am
Adam said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:10am | Report comment
Heratige, pithy sayings and fan forums aside, the reality is that in a season chock full of entertaining games played by exciting sides, the Tahs have served up some of the most boring rugby in the competition. Aside from the hardcore supporters most fans want to be entertained and the Tahs simply haven’t delivered. This from a side that has or had some of the most exciting players in the competition. The number of games they lost or ruined by reverting to an inane kicking game after dominating a running style in the opening half has been woeful. Winning hard and ugly will do if that is all that is on offer but the modern game and particularly the Super XV comp has evolved past that. This season I would have had more satisfaction from being a Cheetahs supporter than a Tahs. Luckily I follow the Reds
June 28th 2011 @ 9:11am
Mick the clown said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:11am | Report comment
Interesting thoughts, but diasagree.
I dont expect excellence. – I expect that the tactics will be those of a professional rugby team, – (not those of a 14d’s high school rugby
June 28th 2011 @ 9:46am
M.O.C. said | June 28th 2011 @ 9:46am | Report comment
Absolutely – I think the tah’s fans simply expect the players and coaches to figure out how to play the game they are paid well to do.