Robbie Deans backs Rocky Elsom as captain – for now
By Darren Walton, 12 Aug 2011 Darren Walton is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- 2011 Rugby World Cup, Rocky Elsom, Rugby Union, Rugby World Cup, Springboks, wallabies, Wallabies coach
Related coverage
- Rugby Union news
- Wallabies news
- Rugby World Cup 2011 news
- South Africa Springboks news
- Rugby 2011 news
- 2013 Wallabies squad news
You couldn’t call it unconditional support, but Wallabies coach Robbie Deans has backed besieged captain Rocky Elsom to silence the doubters against the Springboks on Saturday.
With the Rugby World Cup less than a month away, Elsom is under mounting pressure to return to his barnstorming best after failing to hit his straps in Australia’s opening three Tests of the year.
In a scathing attack, former Wallabies fullback and high-profile commentator Greg Martin this week claimed Elsom should not only be stripped of the captaincy but also make way for dynamic Queensland flanker Scott Higginbotham.
“Rocky Elsom at the moment doesn’t deserve his spot in the team,” Martin said on Fox Sports’ Back Page.
But after naming Higginbotham slightly out of position at No.8 on Thursday, for what will be the 24-year-old’s first Test start, and retaining Elsom as blindside flanker and captain, Deans defended his embattled leader.
He said criticism was “the nature of the industry and he’s not alone in that” and attributed Elsom’s scratchy form to the Wallabies as a whole being below par, particularly in last Saturday’s 30-14 loss to the All Blacks in Auckland.
“He was more industrious last week but I guess as a team we all suffered insofar as we didn’t play as one,” Deans said.
“The key for us is it’s a team game. It always is. It’s the ultimate team game, rugby, and that’s what makes it so rewarding when you do put it all together off the back of a lot of hard work.
“It doesn’t just happen. It takes a lot of preparation, a lot of time and effort from many people who have got varied skills.
“So that’s the piece of growth we’re looking for this week.”
Martin also claimed the apparent taboo subject of the Wallabies discussing Elsom’s lack of form as “the elephant in the room no-one talks about”.
When asked directly on Thursday whether he had ever considered a change of captaincy, Deans indicated the big flanker was in the same category as every other player – a week-to-week proposition.
“Oh mate, let’s just concentrate on this Test match,” Deans said.
After a series of impressive cameos off the bench, Higginbotham demanded his selection.
“He’s earned this start,” Deans said.
“He’s done well with the time that he’s had and he’s got the prospect of a lot more time and we’re looking for a similar enthusiasm and industriousness in that time.
“It’s a different skill starting at the front end, so there’s some realities you’ve got to deal in with that.
“But I’ve got no doubt he’ll be up for it.”
In relegating Ben McCalman to the bench, Higginbotham’s big break comes a year after he experienced the despair of suffering back spasms in the warm-up and having to be scratched from his scheduled debut against the Springboks in Bloemfontein.
“It was a tough thing to go through,” Higginbotham said after joining recalled lock Nathan Sharpe as one of two changes to Australia’s starting line-up.
Sharpe has replaced young Reds second-rower Rob Simmons, who has a shoulder injury.
With Sharpe promoted and Dan Vickerman asked to play a full game of club rugby in Sydney as he continues his comeback, developing second-rower Sitaleki Timani won a spot on the bench.
Deans also included the versatile Radike Samo after opting for five reserve forwards, while prop Salesi Ma’afu replaces Pek Cowan on the bench and winger Lachie Turner drops off.
© AAP 2013Sport, all day long. Does this sound too good to be true? We're searching for a Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. If you're a sales star who doesn't mind a hit, kick, throw, or cycle, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
Have you seen the new Wallabies jersey? Want one of your own? We're giving away a brand new 2013 Wallabies jersey to one lucky Roarer, click here to go in the running to win.



August 12th 2011 @ 7:00pm
Dexter William said | August 12th 2011 @ 7:00pm | Report comment
We lost because we were tactically beaten by a smarter team last week.
We did have the cattle last week, but we played the wrong game. It was definitely a coaching problem.
I am a supporter of Deans from day 1, but now I am perplexed by most of his decision making.
He needs to take stock, and make the decisions (including the Rocky being captain) that will win us the RWC. His reputation is on the line. Stop trying to please everyone. Be true to the objective of winning the RWC and cut loose anyone who gets in the way.
RD, here are the things to consider:
1) Captaincy. Make a change now or say that Elsom is the RWC captain – not the week to week basis comment you let on in the news today. By the way my choice is Genia / Horwill. Pocock has not shown enough that he will make a good captain.
2) Get rid of the many soft c show ponies in our pack. Sharpe, Simmons, Alexander, Maafu (a joke), Cowan, MaCalman, Hodgson etc. We will never win the RWC will soft coc-ks.
3) Do not carry injured players or hoping for injured players to come back into the squad. The chances of them winning us the RWC is slim. Palu, Barnes, Robinson, Mitchel, Horne, etc. were all great players, but there is just not enough time to get them ready. Carrying one or two players coming back from injury in a 30 man team is the maximum. We are already carrying AAC, Elsom, McCabe, who are iffy or out of form at best.
4) Get on with building teamwork. It is more important than the prefect team who has got no time to play together. Adding one or two new players at a time is what any good team can afford.
5) Tactically we were rubbish last week, you were shown up as a bad coach. Be brave and act boldly and if you have to, lose on your own terms. Stop the politics of making everyone happy and just do the right thing.
August 12th 2011 @ 10:36pm
jameswm said | August 12th 2011 @ 10:36pm | Report comment
THey won’t change it. Deans’s hands are tied – he is forced to pick Elsom, but doesn’t want to.
Higgy is more of a 6 than an 8, for when Palu is back.
August 13th 2011 @ 11:08am
bennalong said | August 13th 2011 @ 11:08am | Report comment
Same ol’ Same ol’!
We lose, and the bitter and twisted emerge.
They (Deans / O’Neil) went with the Captain, who just happened to have played no footy.
Richie McCaw has been ordinary since his return to the Crusaders………….until the last games for the Blacks.
Rocky should be given game time and time to prove himself, ……………….he hasn’t played badly.
Genia didn’t play well and doesn’t need to be Captain to direct the troops. Same applies to Cooper.
Rocky DID speak to Joubert
The A team has only played two games, you slaggers. Get behind them for the next two, THEN take stock with some facts to work on.
Pathetic, negative, unsportsmanlike, personal criticisms pollute these pages
GO the WALLABIEEEEEES!
August 13th 2011 @ 11:15am
Johnno said | August 13th 2011 @ 11:15am | Report comment
No benneloang we are Australian teams who want our sports team to win, we like winners not losers, we don’t pay good money to go to the matches to watch them lose, and hel pay the wages to watch them lose. Deans and O’neil are pat of a sinking ship of titanic proportions, we are becoming the laughing stock of international rugby.