Deans playing selection cards close to his chest
By Darren Walton, 27 Sep 2011 Darren Walton is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- robbie deans, Rugby Union, RWC, wallabies
Robbie Deans was planning emergency talks with his selection panel before revealing who may be ushered into Australia’s injury-ravaged Rugby World Cup squad on Tuesday.
Deans was going to announce potential replacements after centre Rob Horne and back-rower Wycliff Palu consulted specialists in Christchurch on Monday.
But even after scans had determined their fate, Deans decided against publicising his next move until Tuesday.
Horne, who has a fractured cheekbone, was clinging to the hope he wouldn’t require surgery and may be able to make a miracle comeback in the knockout stages of the tournament, while Palu’s hamstring strain was not considered dire and should only sideline the big No.8 for a match or two.
David Pocock on Monday declared himself available for selection for Saturday’s clash with Russia in Nelson, but a host of former Wallabies, including grand slam-winning captain Andrew Slack, have demanded Deans draft in back-up for Australia’s world-class openside flanker.
In a fairytale comeback that would rival 34-year-old Allan Langer’s mercy dash across the world to inspire Queensland’s 2001 State of Origin rugby league series triumph, Slack called for Deans to send an SOS to Japan-based veteran George Smith.
Others are suggesting one-time Wallabies captain Phil Waugh, but Matt Hodgson and Beau Robinson, who both featured in Australia’s 40-man squad for the winter Tests, remain the most viable candidates for a call-up.
Pocock said the hysteria surrounding the non-selection of a reserve No.7 was unnecessary and said it was Deans and assistant coaches Jim Williams and David Nucifora’s business who they picked.
Armchair critics feared the Wallabies’ worst nightmare had been realised when Pocock’s back injury sidelined him from Australia’s 15-6 loss to Ireland, but the man himself said credit instead must go to European player of the year Sean O’Brien.
“There’s been heaps of talk about it. I personally don’t think Ben McCalman was that bad against the Irish,” Pocock said.
“If you look at his stats, he did a heap of work. I thought Sean O’Brien had a great game; that’s maybe why there’s been a lot of talk about it.”
Along with goalkicking winger James O’Connor (hamstring) and flanker Scott Higginbotham (back), Pocock will resume training on Tuesday after also missing last Friday’s win over the USA.
Barring further mishaps, all three will be available for selection this week.
“I’m keen to get out there,” Pocock said.
“It would be great to get some running in the legs and, yeah, I’m just keen to play.
“I’ve got through a fair bit of work the past couple of weeks just trying to settle it all down and do all the right things and then ran really well yesterday morning, so it should be full training this week.
“It all depends on Robbie (Deans) and what the coaches are looking at for the Russians.”
Pocock said the Wallabies were feeling revitalised after enjoying the delights of peaceful Hanmer Springs with their WAGS, but will need to refocus quickly following two days’ break from training.
“If we beat Russia, it’s going to be a massive step up in intensity (most likely) playing the South Africans in the quarters,” he said.
“They know how to play World Cup rugby and they’ve done well in the past and most of their squad was at the last World Cup.
“So that goes a long way to helping them in the playoffs.”
© AAP 2012Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
The Crowd Says (25) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- robbie deans, Rugby Union, RWC, wallabies


September 27th 2011 @ 7:03am
Damo said | September 27th 2011 @ 7:03am | Report comment
Just do what you do well boys.
Quietly.
Just turn up for the next 4 games quietly and play better than the opposition quietly and if you are good enough and quiet enough about it you might be back in OZ with Bill before anyone notices.;.
Ask yourselves -are you good enough ?
Make it so.
And if or when you win be as polite as Paddys and thank the hosts and come home.
September 27th 2011 @ 7:51am
sph45 said | September 27th 2011 @ 7:51am | Report comment
i like it Damo!
September 27th 2011 @ 11:10am
Robert Stork said | September 27th 2011 @ 11:10am | Report comment
Totaly agree Damo – just hope Deans keeps the Boofheads (plural) and those into self-adulation awayfrom the airwaves.
September 27th 2011 @ 3:07pm
WQ said | September 27th 2011 @ 3:07pm | Report comment
Pity they did’nt get this advice some time ago Damo
September 27th 2011 @ 8:00am
thurl said | September 27th 2011 @ 8:00am | Report comment
“Palu only sidelined for a match or two….That puts his availability into the middle of the knock out rounds . Given his lack of game time so far, he’s really just a passenger. I suppose thats the risk of taking players wo are not fully over their injuries.
The All Blacks will find out soon whether they are in the same boat with Kerian Read.
The other thing that struck me was the players saying they are feeling revitalised after a couple days at Hamner. It looks to me that other contenders are just starting to warm up after their first three games. Maybe not the French, but England, Wales, Sth Africa Ireland and NZ are running into form without having had a holiday
September 27th 2011 @ 3:09pm
soapit said | September 27th 2011 @ 3:09pm | Report comment
the difference with read though is he had been playing pretty much the whole season so they knew where his form was at.
September 27th 2011 @ 8:42am
formeropenside said | September 27th 2011 @ 8:42am | Report comment
This is a perfect chance to ditch the fragile Horne and never to be match-fot Palu, and Deans ignores it. Incredible.
I maintain that if Australia win the RWC, it will be despite Deans, not because of him.
September 27th 2011 @ 10:06am
jameswm said | September 27th 2011 @ 10:06am | Report comment
It was the Tahs’ fault that Palu got re-injured in the middle of the year. The Wallaby medical staff said his hammy wasn’t ready but the Tahs played him anyway.
Horne has had a bad run – honestly, a fractured cheekbone, that’s unlucky.
How would you feel fos if both Horne and Palu had huge S5 seasons next year?
September 27th 2011 @ 10:18am
formeropenside said | September 27th 2011 @ 10:18am | Report comment
I hope they dont, they play for the Tahs. Still, fit then does not mean fit now.
September 27th 2011 @ 3:20pm
jameswm said | September 27th 2011 @ 3:20pm | Report comment
Ah – so you hate them because they’re Tahs players – state hatred more important than national support.
September 27th 2011 @ 8:56am
Albo said | September 27th 2011 @ 8:56am | Report comment
Palu heading home.
Robinson? Hodgson?
… dare I say Waugh? He may not have the ability anymore but jeez… you know he’d kill himself out there.
September 27th 2011 @ 9:12am
Gary Russell-Sharam said | September 27th 2011 @ 9:12am | Report comment
They should bite the bullet now and replace Palu, what a joke it has been to take him in the first place he has been out injured for most of the season and only had a few matches, he has a history of injury and as far as I can see he has had only one season of playing really good rugby that was in 2009. Beau Robinson should have been there from the start, if you are the form open side flanker for the Super season what else do you have to do to get picked. If you are better than any other player in your position for the season (and I include Pocock as he was out injured for over half the season) why are you not picked for the team, is there some other criteria that coaches use when picking teams other than being the best in your position? Dean’s selection criteria has always mystified me and this is just another example of his peculiar ways. What will be said when we get wopped by SA in the quarter finals and have to come home early, will the media as usual make their feeble excuses again and again that poor old Robbie just didn’t have the players to do the job and if it wasn’t for the injurys we could have gone all the way. What a lot of hog wash. Deans and Co selected 9 players under an injury cloud in the first place at least 5 of them were serious injury problems. Knowing the attrition rate of a WC you would have thought that the selections would have been a bit more circumspect than that. But who am I but a mere old rugby player of over 40 years experience, what would I know????? I am over the Deans thing and for the first time on my life I’m getting really tired of the political agendas that go on with Rugby, my reference is the signing of the national coach before his biggest test, as JON has done with Deans, the WC would have been the perfect test to see what Deans was made of and then when the results of how the Wallabies did at the WC that would have been the perfect time to then negotiate a salary package for the coach or if you changed the coach. I find it incredulous that the ARU have negotiated this before the WC. No commercial business in its right mind would ever have taking this line of action and I can’t see why the ARU have have done this.
Just on other aspects who will they have to sit on the bench with all the players that are injured, gee they must be getting really thin on the ground at the moment. Lucky this is Russia. It is ominous that the other power teams are starting to look really good while we are recuperating at a resort town. It would be fairly obvious that I am not confident of the Wallabies doing that well. I hope and pray that I end up with egg on my face and look really foolish after this rant but I doubt it.
September 27th 2011 @ 10:00am
Bad Cupcake said | September 27th 2011 @ 10:00am | Report comment
I agree with you on Palu but not only because he has been injured but because I have never seen a lazier, less-interested-to-get in the play #8 in my life. His performance against Italy was disgusting…all he was missing to look more relaxed and uninterested was a beach chair and a coldie. One good play the entire game and that was after the Italians lost their hope.
Lazy.
September 27th 2011 @ 11:23am
Touko said | September 27th 2011 @ 11:23am | Report comment
That’s right fairy cupcake, Palu was shocking, invisible, atrocious, abominable against Italy. Matter of fact I didn’t sight him all game.
Oh, that’s right. He wasn’t playing.
September 27th 2011 @ 3:25pm
jameswm said | September 27th 2011 @ 3:25pm | Report comment
LOL @ Touko
I don’t get the bad raps on Palu. I don’t see him as lazy or disinterested. Maybe everyone expects him to move the earth every time he plays.
September 27th 2011 @ 2:42pm
peterlala said | September 27th 2011 @ 2:42pm | Report comment
Gary, for JON to re-sign RD before the world cup was was strange. So why was this unusual stance taken? Does anyone know why the New Zealand Rugby Union chose Henry as the All Black coach in preference to RD?
There must be reasons. But I have never heard them. Despite hubris about “transparency”, it’s a closed-shop at the top.
Another interesting question is who would two of Deans’s greatest players, All Blacks Ritchie McCaw and Dan Carter, prefer as coach, RD or GH?
September 27th 2011 @ 10:24pm
taylorbridge said | September 27th 2011 @ 10:24pm | Report comment
Excellent analysis and much appreciated . Palu and Elsom are yesterday’s men. I would like to hear what role David Nucifora and Jim Williams played in these selections and possible replacements.The Christmas best seller will be the tell all by an insider after the RWC. Robbie is in safe territory fom almost anyone bar Matt Giteau and Phl Waugh. No player keen on further selection will risk a muffled disgruntled mumble let alone speaking out when the national coach has another 2 yrs on his contract.
September 27th 2011 @ 10:21am
Dexter William said | September 27th 2011 @ 10:21am | Report comment
Beau Robinson is the next best 7 we got.
September 27th 2011 @ 11:43am
Cattledog said | September 27th 2011 @ 11:43am | Report comment
Let’s hope the band keeps playing as Deans re-arranges the deck chairs on the Titanic. ‘Let’s not panic anyone by lowering the lifeboats and sending the injured home’. ‘I’m pretty sure they’ll be fit for the final’. ‘They’re good blokes and deserve to be here’. ‘Just unlucky a few of them have fractures and the like, but they’re having a great time so would be harsh to send them home’. ‘Besides, the medical staff think they may get better’.
‘What’s that’? ‘Why didn’t I use the bench’? ‘Jim, David, do we have a bench’? ‘Yes mate, but it’s overrated’. ‘Things haven’t been that diabolical yet’. ‘As we discussed, Robbie, if they were any good they would be in the run on side’. ‘So don’t let those journos heckle you’. ‘Now Robbie, we’re missing a couple of deck chairs…’? ‘Oh that’s right, they’re injured’!
September 27th 2011 @ 12:02pm
Hoy said | September 27th 2011 @ 12:02pm | Report comment
I think we are in trouble here. Other top teams are gearing up in their pools, we are winding down.
If we go out in the quarters, what does that say about our team? Number two in the world, and we are out before 4 other teams. Hard to come back from that. This rolls around every 4 years, and we have been bumped out by a loss in our pool. Shouldn’t have happened. As it is, we could well have been rolled by Wales anyway should they go through.
I am just sick of trying to understand the reasoning behind some decisions. I want some transparency now, particularly as it looks like an early exit.
Why have we signed Deans on a 50% winning rate, BEFORE the world cup, which was what he was signed on for to bring back?
Why does the coaching panel/whatever keep picking also rans in key positions? McCalman at openside? To do what? Fill in? Push in the scrums? He isn’t making any first up tackles on 5/8s, and he isn’t stealing any ball. Why did we persist with Brown and Mumm for so long? They were/are both not international standard by any stretch of the imagination.
Why can’t our team win 2 or 3 in a row? Why do their heads swell with a good win, and then they don’t do the business in important games following on from good wins? Our team is only as good as the next game, and that means they are ordinary. They win well, and look back thinking jeez we were good. They should be thinking “That is what we need to do every game. We need to keep that level up to be a good team”.
So sick of our team at the moment and what they are putting me through.
September 27th 2011 @ 12:11pm
Hoy said | September 27th 2011 @ 12:11pm | Report comment
I am on the verge of dispair.
September 27th 2011 @ 1:07pm
Cattledog said | September 27th 2011 @ 1:07pm | Report comment
I hope I’m wrong, but I have the feeling the despair will be gone in two games…and the Wallabies can get out of there and commence their preparations for the surfing season…and getting the hair coloured…and late nights out drinking again…and recover from those little niggles in time for Chrissy…and
September 27th 2011 @ 3:18pm
the other Steve - and AB fan said | September 27th 2011 @ 3:18pm | Report comment
I’m biting my tongue here, but can offer you and Hoy the consolation that the end will be quick.
September 27th 2011 @ 4:52pm
Sage said | September 27th 2011 @ 4:52pm | Report comment
I think your handling your crystal balls a bit too much tosa whilst biting that tongue. Are your eyes all screwed up too ? I’m amazed you guys can still hear us down here from that lofty perch you’ve inhabited anyway.
September 27th 2011 @ 6:12pm
Thurl said | September 27th 2011 @ 6:12pm | Report comment
but its a great view…