Related coverage
Join us for 2011 AFL Grand Final live scores with Collingwood meeting Geelong in a grand final for the first time since 1953. We’ll have live scores and blog from the 2:30pm kickoff this afternoon in one of the best match-ups in years.
Watching Friday’s festivities, as the players reached the steps at Treasury Place, a large banner unfurled in an overlooking tower about 25 stories up: Go Pies! – the thought occurred that this game is truly a hard one to pick.
Michael diFabrizio’s Grand Final preview focused on form and injuries and he drew some interesting comments, but it’s hard to find a clear read on recent events.
Under normal circumstances, any team going into a grand final with two wins against their opponent would be virtually unbackable favourites, but are we ready to give up on the Pies’ chances just yet?
The stats show that Collingwood’s game against Hawthorn in the preliminary was below average, continuing a run of recent poor form, but the key point to not lose sight of is that the Pies went on to win a game that they had all but lost on the stats sheet.
This is a team that knows how to win big games.
The other complexity arises from the fitness questions hanging over key players: Stevie Johnson for Geelong and Darren Jolly for Collingwood.
The clubs are making the right noises about both, but we’ll only know for sure into the first quarter whether they really are fit enough to contribute in a grand final.
Podsiadly and Johnson have been the primary goal kickers for Geelong this season, sharing nearly 100 between them, while Stokes, Varcoe, Chapman, Hawkins and Bartel have contributed a further 127 goals between them.
The spread of goalkickers means Geelong can probably cover for Johnson, but he remains an important part of the Cats’ forward structure, and is always a very difficult player to match up.
An unfit Jolly presents a bit of a problem for Collingwood at centre bounces, where both sides are otherwise very evenly matched in contested footy and centre square take aways.
A further injury cloud for Collingwood remains over Ben Reid. His absence would be sorely felt because of the recent very good form of Tom Hawkins, leaving the Pies to cover two big men in the Geelong forward line.
At the other end, Geelong have problems of their own in containing man mountain Travis Cloke, who was one of the protagonists in last week’s preliminary final in getting the Pies over the line. It’s the sort of raw marking power that wins grand finals.
Man for man, it’s difficult to split these two teams, and the fitness of some key players might ultimately be the deciding factor.
Collingwood remains a team capable of rising to the occasion, but it’s hard to go past the obvious better form of the Cats. Their game plan and dedication to the team ethic have been telling in the run up to the big game. Cats by 3 goals.


October 1st 2011 @ 10:49am
Tom said | October 1st 2011 @ 10:49am | Report comment
C’mon Woodsmen!!!!
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
October 1st 2011 @ 10:51am
Tristan Rayner said | October 1st 2011 @ 10:51am | Report comment
Here we go! My lead in The Roar’s AFL tipping competition all comes down to this… I’m on the Cats. Take it to Collingwood!
October 1st 2011 @ 12:36pm
The Cattery said | October 1st 2011 @ 12:36pm | Report comment
Two hours to go – I’m with the bookies – a 3rd grand final for the Cats in 5 years.
Chris Scott to create history in being a premiership coach on debut, and then has the luxury of rebuilding the squad from next season – because these old cats can’t do it again – you’d have to think.
October 1st 2011 @ 1:51pm
brenda said | October 1st 2011 @ 1:51pm | Report comment
that performance by meatloaf was 1 of the worst ive ever seen it was painful to watch
October 1st 2011 @ 1:52pm
Al from ctown said | October 1st 2011 @ 1:52pm | Report comment
Was it just me or did the Tshirt launchers that meatloaf used look like hotdogs with condoms on them?…
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
October 1st 2011 @ 1:58pm
The Cattery said | October 1st 2011 @ 1:58pm | Report comment
We are Geelong!!
October 1st 2011 @ 2:01pm
mds1970 said | October 1st 2011 @ 2:01pm | Report comment
The AFL does a lot right, and their pre-match entertainment is normally good. But not this time. Meatloaf was terrible.
But a big crowd is building up, should be a cracker of a game. I’m tipping the Cats by 6 points.
October 1st 2011 @ 2:12pm
The Cattery said | October 1st 2011 @ 2:12pm | Report comment
Good point on Twitter, Alice Cooper is in town, right here, right now!
He would have been a good choice.
October 1st 2011 @ 2:14pm
mds1970 said | October 1st 2011 @ 2:14pm | Report comment
The rain continues to fall. Not quite as heavy as an hour or so ago, but it’s still going to be one for the mudlarks.
October 1st 2011 @ 2:14pm
The Cattery said | October 1st 2011 @ 2:14pm | Report comment
Kate Ellis supporting the Pies – one of her advisers should have advised her correctly.
October 1st 2011 @ 2:15pm
The Cattery said | October 1st 2011 @ 2:15pm | Report comment
The Roar’s very own Brett McKay has asked:
what’s been worse in the last half hour: Meatloaf at the #AFLGF or the @QantasWallabies in Nelson? Discuss…