Debutants win in November, but how will they go in December?
By Kersi Meher-Homji, 30 Nov 2011 Kersi Meher-Homji is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Australian Cricket, Cricket, David Warner, Pat Cummins, Vernon Philander
Mitchell Johnson and Patrick Cummins wag Australia's tail to a two-wicket win against South Africa in the second Test at the Wanderers. Picture: AFP
Related coverage
What a month for three Test debutants from different countries at Test level this November. In the two-Test series between Australia and South Africa, debutants Vernon Philander, 26, from South Africa, and teenage sensation Pat Cummins, from Australia, won all the awards between them.
Opening bowler Philander was the Man of the Match in the first Test in Cape Town and was Man of the Series in the two Test series.
In consecutive innings, he took 3-63 and 5-15 in Cape Town and 1-47 and 5-70 in Jo’burg.
In all, he captured 14 wickets at 13.95.
Fast bowler Pat Cummins made an even more dramatic debut in the Jo’burg Test, claiming 1-38 and 6-79. He also scored an unbeaten 13 in a crisis, hitting the winning runs to enable Australia to win the thrilling Test by two wickets to draw the series 1-1.
He was the obvious Man of the Jo’burg Test.
Thus, the debutants ruled the roost in the Test series.
But wait, there’s more.
In the India-West Indies series, India’s spinner Ravichandran Ashwin, 25, dominated with the ball in all three Tests and hitting a century too in the third and final Test in Mumbai. He won the Man of the Match award in the first Test in Delhi and in the third Test in Mumbai, and the Man of the Series award, as well.
A grand slam, indeed.
His performances: 3-81 and 6-47 in Delhi; 2-49 and 2-137 in Kolkata and 5-156, 4-34 in Mumbai. In the Mumbai Test he scored 103 runs as well. What all-round excellence from someone playing in his first Test series.
Add to this 18 year-old Kurtis Patterson’s stirring first-class debut on Sunday.
In the Sheffield Shield match for NSW against Western Australia at the SCG, Patterson became the youngest player to hit a century (157) in his first-class debut adding 221 glorious runs with Simon Katich.
Now to the first Test starting tomorrow (1 December) in Brisbane against New Zealand. It includes four newcomers, three of whom will make their Test debuts.
There are three quickies: Ben Cutting, 24, from Queensland, Victorian James Pattinson, 21 and Mitchell Starc, 21 from NSW.
I predict that Cutting will be made 12th man.
Another debutant is dynamic opening batsman David Warner, 25, who has a penchant for hitting sixes. Will he tamper his tall hitting with defensive strokes or go the whole hog for tall hit,s a la Sehwag?
His Twenty20 debut for Australia on the MCG on 11 January 2009 against South Africa will be hard to emulate. He spanked 89 runs off 43 balls with 7 fours and 6 sixes. He became the first Australian since John Hodges and Tom Kendall (way back in 1877) to represent Australia before playing a first-class match.
One hopes Warner’s Test debut is just as scintillating.
Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
The Crowd Says (12) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Australian Cricket, Cricket, David Warner, Pat Cummins, Vernon Philander


November 30th 2011 @ 9:37am
sheek said | November 30th 2011 @ 9:37am | Report comment
Wonderful writing Kersi.
“The king is dead, long live the king”, so goes the saying. Just when we thought Australian cricket might be entering a dark & gloomy ice age for a few years, suddenly an exciting new breed of players are jostling for their placein the sun.
Gee, the selectors are going to have some fun in the future deciding between Cummins, Cutting, Pattinson & Starc.
As I turned into my teens in 1970, I recall the years 1970 & 71 were pretty special for the players it introduced to world cricket. Age on debut in brackets.
1970 South Africa – Barry Richards (24) & Lee Irvine (25).
1970/71 Australia – Rod Marsh (23), Greg Chappell (22) & Dennis Lillee (21).
1971 India – Sunil Gavaskar (21).
1971 West Indies – Keith Boyce (27).
1971 Pakistan – Imran Khan (18).
Then, if we clicked over into 1972, there was no let-up.
1972 West Indies – Lawrence Rowe (23) & Alvin Kallicharran (23).
1972 England – Tony Greig (24).
1972 Australia – Ross Edwards (29), Bob Massie (24).
1972/73 Australia – Jeff Thomson (22) & Max Walker (24).
1972/73 New Zealand – Richard Hadlee (21).
Some very handy cricketers there…..
November 30th 2011 @ 12:22pm
jameswm said | November 30th 2011 @ 12:22pm | Report comment
Keith Boyce?
Ross Edwards?
In the same list as Sunil Gavaskar, Dennis Lillee, Barry Richards etc?
November 30th 2011 @ 3:37pm
sheek said | November 30th 2011 @ 3:37pm | Report comment
Well James, they get a mention simply because there were a hell of a lot worse cricketers than those two…..
Boyce did take 19 wickets in 3 tests against England in 1973, including one x 6-for, & two x 5-fors, & did hit a 95 & 69 against the Aussies in 1975/76.
Edwards was a solid middle order batter who averaged 40, a useful backup keeper, & also one of the best cover fieldsmen seen in Australia.
November 30th 2011 @ 10:14am
Brett McKay said | November 30th 2011 @ 10:14am | Report comment
Kersi, Roarer Sledgeross raised a question yesterday that was crying out for your big book of cricket trivia answers: If James Pattinson makes the XI tomorrow, would this be the first instance of brothers playing Test cricket for different countries?
The answer is no, some Trotts played either side for England and Australia back at the turn of the 20th century, and some Hearnes played either side for England and South Africa back in the early days of isolation, but this may not have been an “official” Test.
Are you aware of any others??
November 30th 2011 @ 10:32am
Matt F said | November 30th 2011 @ 10:32am | Report comment
I’m pretty sure that the Pattinsons will be the 3rd set of brothers to do this, with the other two presumably being the ones you mentioned Brett.
It’s not test cricket but Ed Joyce has played for both Ireland and England whilst his brothers have played for Ireland.
November 30th 2011 @ 10:19am
Kersi Meher-Homji said | November 30th 2011 @ 10:19am | Report comment
Thanks, Sheek.
And what a lineup of greenhorns in your list!
To proceed two decades after your list, both Ponting and Dravid scored 96 on debut, Ponting against Sri Lanka at Perth in 1995-96 and Dravid against England at Lord’s in 1996.
Will they play their last Test together, at Adelaide in late January 2012, and score 96 runs each as well??
November 30th 2011 @ 11:28am
Kersi Meher-Homji said | November 30th 2011 @ 11:28am | Report comment
Brett,
There were three Hearne brothers: George Gibbons (GG) played 1 Test for England; Frank 2 Tests for England and 4 Tests for South Africa; and Alec 1 Test for England. Frank’s son George Alfred Lawrence (GAL) played three Tests for South Africa.
Harry Trott played 24 Tests for Australia. His brother, the tragic Albert Trott, played 3 Tests for Australia and two for England after he was mysteriously dropped from the Australian team despite making a sensational debut.
Instances of fathers and sons playing for different countries: Jahangir Khan 4 Tests for India and son Majid 63 Tests for Pakistan. Also Wazir Ali 7 Tests for India and son Khalid Wazir 2 for Pakistan. But that was because of the partition of India in 1947.
November 30th 2011 @ 2:13pm
Johnno said | November 30th 2011 @ 2:13pm | Report comment
Some points Mark Waugh made.
Mark Waugh made a good point about the loss of Watson and having no all-rounder int he team, and they should of picked an all-rounder for this match i agree. Having a 5th bowler gives the team more balance I think , at least in my opinion. Sometimes an all-rounder in test cricket can be a disruptive influence to the balance of the team if they are not good enough to hold down a spot in either batting or bowling (possibly Andrew Mcdonald falls into this category, and i think shane lee, and shaun young, and Ian Harvey fell into that category if they were picked at test level, and the England all rounder Craig White.
Mark Waugh wanted Dan christian, in the tees this week and no Dave Warner and open with Khawaja. Fair point i have always liked Andrew Mcdonald, and think he did a good bowling job in South africa and he is a good batsmen too he made a test 50 and has good shots. i would of liked to play Dan Christian at 6 or Mcdonald and open with Khawaja.
Shane Watson bowling was very handy, and if Watson returns and still wants to bowl unlike Steve Waugh who after 30 just became a part timer, Watson is 30 now if he still wants to bowl as the 5th bowler put him at 4,5, or 6.
November 30th 2011 @ 2:39pm
Boris said | November 30th 2011 @ 2:39pm | Report comment
Good point Johnno. Looks like Lyon and Pup will be bowling plenty of overs…
November 30th 2011 @ 2:35pm
Boris said | November 30th 2011 @ 2:35pm | Report comment
Not much in the way of opinion here Kersi, I was hoping I get your thoughts/predictions on the debutants…
Do you see Warner lasting the summer as an opener or do you think he doesn’t have the temperament? Where will Watson be batting come the Boxing Day Test vs the Indians?
Neither of the quicks did too much damage in the Australia A side last week – who do you think is the best prospect? Who do you think will survive the axe once Cummins and Harris are fit?
For what it’s worth, while I haven’t seen Warner bat at Shield level I’m almost more confident about his technique than I am about Hughes’. While I’m not expecting him to dominate in the First Test I think he’ll do enough to show he should be there beyond the NZ Series. Unfortuntely with Watson coming back in I think he will have to bide his time and wait for Punter to retire so Watson can slip down the order.
Of the bowlers, if it’s horses for courses I would expect Cutting to get the nod for the First Test – more experienced, has played at the Gabba plenty, and his figures overall are better. Flip a coin between Pattinson and Starc – I’ll go Starc only because he’s a leftie and the selectors will get excited about having some variety in the side.
In terms of who plays once everyone is fit, who the hell knows!? So it’s a bit harder to give a prediction here. Sidds needs to seriously pull his finger out and start taking some wickets. Once Cummins and Harris are fit they should be straight back in, while Johnson should go back to state level and get some form and confidence back before playing another Test.
Anyway, regardless of who ends up getting a game, at least we’ll be able to watch with some optimism for the future and spend hour upon hour talking about it over a beer or two this summer!
November 30th 2011 @ 3:44pm
sheek said | November 30th 2011 @ 3:44pm | Report comment
Kersi,
The great George Headley (22 tests, 1930s) & his son Ron (2 tests, 1973) both played for the West Indies.
Ron Headley’s son Dean played 15 tests for England (1997-99).
November 30th 2011 @ 7:30pm
Kersi Meher-Homji said | November 30th 2011 @ 7:30pm | Report comment
Thanks Sheek for jogging my memory.