The outstanding feature of the beginning of the MCG Boxing Day Test, Australia versus India, was the way Ed Cowan fairly bolted out on to the field to start his first Test innings.
To me, setting myself up to a long, langurous and satisfying day watching the cricket from my comfy couch, this was a sign that the newcomer was embracing rather than shrinking from the responsibilities of opening the batting for Australia.
No one could ever accuse David Warner of lacking in enthusiasm but his entry on to the field was sedate by comparison.
The Indians, incidentally, were still in a huddle by the time both openers were already at the pitch.
This slow-motion attitude to the playing of cricket is the infuriating aspect of watching the Indians in the field. Someone once declared that cricket was invented by God to teach the English the meaning of the word eternity. I don’t know what the Indian word for eternity is but they have taken over from the old English pros in the dark and frustrating art of slowing play down.
By team time, for instance, they had managed only 54 overs. Play went on to past 6.30pm, an hour after the proper closing time. This is totally unacceptable.
Ian Chappell and others have suggested that the captains of teams that manage not to bowl 90 overs inside the normal hours of play should be forced to stand down for the next Test. If this was done, there would be none of the infuriating time-wasting that the Indians, particularly, are masters of.
This is written by an ancient who remembers the black and white days of Test cricket when up to 120 overs were bowled in a day.
The highlight of the day from an Australian perspective was the mature, disciplined and restrained (probably too restrained) batting of the Test newcomer, Cowan. He seems to have a method and temperament (rather like that of ‘Barnacle’ Bill Lawry that is made for Test cricket. It was Lawry himself who acknowledged this by pointing out at one stage that Cowan had learnt his cricket playing the four-day game.
I took this to be a response to all the experts, myself included I guess, who have been taken by the way David Warner has used the freedom expected of a Twenty20 player into the Test arena. It is a point well made, I reckon.
It is interesting looking at Cowan’s method. It explains why he could be the barnacle or anchor that the brilliant but fragile Australian batting needs. The first principle of the method is that no ball that does not need to be played is actually played. Cowan let probably 100 balls go past unplayed at.
Providing the judgment is accurate, this is a ploy that could force the frustrated bowlers to bowl at the batsman, thereby opening up both sides of the pitch for scoring shots. To their credit, the Indians refused to play Cowan’s game and at times they pegged Cowan down to a virtual immobility as far as runs were concerned. The lines of Coleridge’s ‘Rime of the Ancient Mariner’ came to mind from time to time: ‘As idle as a painted ship upon a painted ocean.’
There is a point when staying at wicket, Boycott-like, and not scoring runs becomes a liability for the team. Cowan did not get to this point, although he would not want to bat through another two hour opening session, as he did, for only 14 runs.
The second principle of Cowan’s batting is that, unlike David Warner, he does not deliberately hit the ball into the air. The great Bradman hit only one six in Test cricket. He worked out that there are 9 ways a batsman can be dismissed. If you can eliminate being caught out, which is the most common form of dismissal, then all things being equal you are going to have a good Test career.
Cowan is ‘unorthodox’ in his technique, as well as his method. He plants his feet a long way apart. The commentators reckoned that only Graeme Pollock, who was a tall man, had his feet so wide apart. I would have thought that Dean Jones was another who had a wide, very wide in fact, stance.
The difficulty with this stance is that it makes it hard for a batsman to have twinkling feet. Against this, it simplifies batting. The batsman, and Cowan did this for all of his 174 balls faced, was play back by rocking on to his back foot. And he can play forward by rocking forward.
This simple method for Cowan is enhanced, in my view, by a very simple backlift. Instead of trying to time it with the bowler’s release, Cowan raises his bat, in the Tony Greig manner, well before the ball is bowled. He keeps his elbows tucked into his ribs. I think this is a method that Greg Chappell has spent some time on analysing and developing. Once again, as with the stance, the technique is simple and as Cowan showed it can be very effective.
During the lunch break and after, when there was some rain that delayed play for about 47 minutes, the new Australian coach Mickey Arthur reckoned that 300 would be a good score for his team. It looks like Australia will get there with the splendid partnerships between Cowan and Ricky Ponting (who batted almost as if he were in his prime) and then the undefeated partnership of a restrained Brad Haddin (not out 21) and a typically pugnacious Peter Siddle (34 not out).
The Indians with the new ball and play going on to 6.48pm could not break this partnership. Good. I reckon that there was some justice in this. They had meandered around so much they were forced to stay out on the field so long their bowlers were tired in the last hour of play.
Just as virtue is its own reward, lack of virtue (in this case slow-motion play) has played a devil’s tune against India.
As the cliche goes, the Test is nicely poised. My thinking is that batting first and with 277 runs on the board Australia is slightly ahead of India which will have to bat last, unless they destroy the Australian bowling in their first inning.
Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
The Crowd Says (20) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Australian Cricket, boxing day test, David Warner, Ed Cowan, Test cricket


December 27th 2011 @ 1:14am
Johnno said | December 27th 2011 @ 1:14am | Report comment
Edward Cowan is the 1st sydney private school educated player since Matt Nicholson 1998 Ashes boxing day test.
Matt Nicholson was educated at the exclusive Knox Grammar School, on Sydney’s north shore.
Edward Cowan , was educated at Cranbrook school in Sydney’s exclusive Eastern suburbs. The school of many of Sydney’s well do to families. James packer son of the late Kerry Packer founder of world series cricket and Australia’s former richest man.
Edward also played cricket for the prestigous oxford university club in England, and played for British universities.
And we know about this weeks events for the Cowan family which must of been tough, after the families joy of there son being picked in the Australian test team. Edward’s parents had their house broken into in the exclusive Sydney suburb of Darling point in Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs.
Fourtunatly the alleged offender was caught. And Ed Cowan bravely batted on for his family yesterday on boxing day test day 1..
When you look at some of the other uprisings like Ricky Ponting from working class Mowbray in Tasmania, and Dave Warner in working class Matraville sydney,
Places like Cranbrook School, Darling point, Eton which has played Cranbrook school in cricket tours(Eton being the exclusive boys school that many members of the royal family including prince harry and william, and the current UK prime minister David Cameron attended and many other former UK prime ministers attended) the ubringing and background of Ed Cowan must feel like worlds away to the ubringing ricky pointing, Dave warner, and Macksville boy through and through Phil Hughes had.
He was born in paddington sydney on 16th June 1982, has a university degree and has also wrote a book in the firing line, and is 29 years of age and married to Australian Radio and tv presenter Virginia Lette.
Edward bats like Alastair Cook. Strong concentration. Edward said when he 1st entered the cricket scene after school there was a perception he was as “soft as butter”. Well he has showed some fight and concentration yesterday, in getting a test 50, what will happen to Shane Watson when he comes back form injury will be interesting. I am not convinced yet on Edward it was only 1 test innings so far, but his background and uprbiring is very important as not many test cricketers have been produced in the last 20 years from sydney’s exclusive private schools unlike say rugby union and the wallabies and Asutralia’s super 15 teams.
Ed Cowan has an interesting background.
December 27th 2011 @ 8:30am
Steve War said | December 27th 2011 @ 8:30am | Report comment
Ah – the politics of envy..
Above we have “Johnno”‘s eighth (there may be more) rambling, obsessive post about his problems with Ed Cowan’s upbringing and schooling.
He has curiously, some might say suspiciously repeatedly posted regarding a crime committed on Cowan’s parents’ home and on the fate of the accused burglar.
Seriously weird stuff – hopefully this is not going to continue
Watch the cricket at home, save some money and go to night school.
December 27th 2011 @ 12:25pm
Johnno said | December 27th 2011 @ 12:25pm | Report comment
Steve War, lets gets some facts. I point out his parent home being burgled in sydney becoz it is 2 massive things to happen in 1 week or ed cowman, when you are on the verge of making your test rebut in a boxing day test, you can not afford massive distractions, whther it be injury and personal, so it makes it defintaly headline grabbing stuff the media all week if you look at the newspapers were over this story steve war, and i say accused becoz you cant say someone is guilty until proven guilty..
So both stories were massive the test selection and the parent home burglary both grab the headlines and had the potential to derail Ed Cowan’s test debut and test performance, so it is significant that despite these setbacks he has done so well in this boxing day test match . And all players if you look at past newspapers steve war there background is covered , whether it is dave warner, ricky pointing, Usman, Shane Warne, the Waugh brothers, glen mcgrath(the whole country knows how he came to sydney and lived in a caravan). So cricket fans and the media steve war like to know about sports stars background and are curious it is only natural.
December 27th 2011 @ 12:53pm
jamesb said | December 27th 2011 @ 12:53pm | Report comment
Johnno
I, and one would think many others here on the Roar don’t really care about Cowans background, education, religion, his family, his pets, ………..I mean, we really don’t care.
The only thing we care Johnno is if Cowan is up to it as far as an opening test batsmen is concerned.
Thats all.
December 27th 2011 @ 1:10pm
Johnno said | December 27th 2011 @ 1:10pm | Report comment
So Jamesb why do the newsparers make a big deal about it if no on cares, . Last year when Usman made his test debut the newspapers went on and on about his background, his education (about him studying to be a pilot), his ambitions it went on and on. Same with Ed Cowan.
Ricky Ponting the newspapers always go on about his background about being form Mowbray Tasmania.
Same with Dave Warner and the boy form Macksville phill Hughes.
So clearly the newspapers do care and the readers of newspapers do care as they constantly read these background type stories, otherwise the newspapers would not do these stories if they did not sell jamesb.
December 27th 2011 @ 5:14pm
jamesb said | December 27th 2011 @ 5:14pm | Report comment
Lets see Johnno
Newspapers do write alot of rubbish these days and with it comes the absence of genuine investigative reporting.
Its been a long time since i’ve seen a reporter spend 5 years investigating a story, a story which we would have huge ramifications.
The art of investigating reporting is not their anymore Johnno.
The reasons for that Johnno is that there has been a decline in newspaper sales in the last 10 years or so. However, online it has grown tremendously to the point where readers go online to get their info rather than buying a newspaper.
With less revenue, it then impacts on investigating journalism. Here is a piece from Malcolm Turnbulls speech recently:
“Another consequence of this decline in newspapers is that journalists have less time to do the hard, time consuming slog of researching and investigating stories in the way they did before. Those newspapers like The Age here in Melbourne that remain committed to investigative journalism know it comes at a high cost and that its greatest threat is not a writ for libel but the company accountant.”
theres more from his speech when you click underneath:
http://www.malcolmturnbull.com.au/blogs/malcolms-blog/the-future-of-newspapers-is-it-the-end-of-journalism/
Johnno, nowadays its tabloid journalism, concentrating more on personalites rather than debating and concentrating on seroius issues.
December 27th 2011 @ 9:21am
matt said | December 27th 2011 @ 9:21am | Report comment
Why do we focus on where a sportsman went to school? Was Matt Rogers worse at rugby because he didn’t go to a private school like most of the Rugby players around him and does the Australian public like Micheal Clark more today after the “revealing” glimpse at his childhood home in Liverpool?
He played well didn’t he though (Cowan) and I’ll bet when he hit his 50 he didn’t think about his school days. He may have thought of his family and friends and have a sense that all his hard work had made his achievement possible, which, is incidently what pretty much every other person would think.
December 27th 2011 @ 9:57am
Harry said | December 27th 2011 @ 9:57am | Report comment
I get your point matt but just to be accurate – Matt Rogers was a boarder at The Southport School for at least his last 3 years of schooling, and by his own admission he loved it, playing at 10 for 1sts. TSS current Wallabies include Slipper, Simmons, Sharpe, Higginbotham.
December 27th 2011 @ 12:20pm
Geoff Lemon said | December 27th 2011 @ 12:20pm | Report comment
Johnno, let’s consider this dead horse well and truly flogged.
Ed Cowan is 29. He left school 12 years ago. It doesn’t make one squirt of difference to anything to do with his cricket career, nor are grown men going to find themselves unable to communicate due to the circumstances of their childhood. Similarly, it would help if you could grow up and leave this alone.
December 27th 2011 @ 1:11pm
Johnno said | December 27th 2011 @ 1:11pm | Report comment
It was 11 years go Geoff Edward finished in the year 2000.
December 27th 2011 @ 7:27am
Redb said | December 27th 2011 @ 7:27am | Report comment
Terrifically stoic innings by Cowan just what the doctor ordered to restore some starch in Australia’s batting lineup. I was at the G yesterday and his innings was widely lauded by the crowd.
Cowan is the perfect foil to the aggressive Warner as openers.
December 27th 2011 @ 8:54am
Chris said | December 27th 2011 @ 8:54am | Report comment
There are some encouraging signs that Australia is starting to build an impressive team – Cowan and Warner balance each other nicely as openers, Clarke is turning out to be a very good captain, and there is an exciting bunch of bowlers starting to make their mark.
December 27th 2011 @ 9:19am
cruyff turn said | December 27th 2011 @ 9:19am | Report comment
Cowan showed enough to suggest he can play at international level. Good concentration and shot selection. As Redb said, a good foil for the attacking Warner. The other positive was that you never had that sinking feeling he was going to perish at any moment, unlike his predecessor. Hopefully he can rotate the strike a bit more in future, similar to what Khawaja needs to do.
I’ll be interested to see if Ed will be in the side in 2-3 years time, because by then Nic Maddinson, who I rate highly, will most likely be in contention for a Test spot.
Johnno, who gives a rats what kind of school he attended? Is it important?
December 27th 2011 @ 9:57am
Purple Shag said | December 27th 2011 @ 9:57am | Report comment
Hope Phil Hughes was at home taking notes on how an opener should play (especially balls a few inches outside off stump). Cowan certainly looked every bit the Test batsmen. Hopefully when Hughsie’s pushing 30 he’ll be able to say the same.
http://therestijustsquandered.com/2011/12/25/boxing-day-magic-the-five-best-aussie-performances-on-crickets-biggest-stage/
December 27th 2011 @ 10:02am
Harry said | December 27th 2011 @ 10:02am | Report comment
Disappointing duck by Marsh but what did anyone expect after his “preparation” was that hit and giggle Big Bash farce.
Australian batting was better than the awful humiliation of last year, but is still nowhere near strong enough. Its hard to post match winning scores when 2 of your 6 batsmen don’t trouble the scorers.
December 27th 2011 @ 5:46pm
Tommy said | December 27th 2011 @ 5:46pm | Report comment
He looked good yesterday. Just what we have been crying out for really. I wouldn’t surprise me if he now stays in the team for 3-4 years.
December 27th 2011 @ 6:19pm
jamesb said | December 27th 2011 @ 6:19pm | Report comment
Cowan could stay there for the next 5 years and get 50 tests under his belt.
But theres a long way to go
December 27th 2011 @ 6:25pm
Johnno said | December 27th 2011 @ 6:25pm | Report comment
i won’t give Ed Cowan the tick of approval until he racks up 20 tests. then we will know what hsi value is, as coaches form other teams work out stategies to get him out and his weaknesses, rookie’s often fade once coaches work them out and do video footage on them.
Think Mike hussey and Greg Blewett, and even NZ’s Lou Vincent when they started out.
With hussey some were syaing he was the best batsman ever since don bradman, but his average slowly went down as teams worked out his weaknesses.
December 27th 2011 @ 7:49pm
Swampy said | December 27th 2011 @ 7:49pm | Report comment
I was not educated at one of Australia’s finest schools like Ed Cowan, but I like many others, probably including literates like Ed Cowan, find your posts johnno extremely difficult to read. It appears you can type as fast as your mind thinks but I would be glad if once in a while you filtered your thoughts before they were transmitted via the keyboard.
There is nothing to report in regards to Ed Cowan’s upbringing.
The reason media report on guys like Punter & Clarke’s upbringing is that they are feel good stories. Giving hope to those in less fortunate circumstances that you can rise above or be successful despite the lot you’ve been given.
Letting people know that Cowan is from a priviledged background is basically rubbing it in the face of those that have less. It is unnecessary and in poor taste to make comment on.
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
December 27th 2011 @ 8:18pm
Johnno said | December 27th 2011 @ 8:18pm | Report comment
Swampy i was hardly rubbing it in, i as being imformative and letting the puplic know about Edwards upbringing just like, pup, punter, and Dave Warner’s upbringing.
And I am not the minority the newspapers laways go on about player’s background as peoplel take an interest in it.
And never once did I support or were against Edwards background.
I do think he was given access as an article wrote to pristine grounds at cranbrook School to train on, and recieved training form some famous ex cricketers, one the famous cricket writer and former county player who passed away recently.
Edward has done well to get an oppurtunity and seems ot have taken his oppurtunity.
But many fans like to know players backgorund it is not being nosey just curious , and fans are allowed to be curious swampy we pay to watch the stars play, so we have a right to find out players background.