How the NRL can exploit the game’s biggest rivalry
By Epiquin, 16 Jan 2012 Epiquin is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- NRL, Rugby League, Sonny Bill Williams
Related coverage
Every season, rugby league showcases some of the best rivalries in Australian sport. Some are friendly; others are fuelled by animosity and passion.
There’s Australia and New Zealand, City versus Country, Manly versus everybody and of course, the biggest of them all, State of Origin.
Despite these contests and their enormous contribution to the game, a bitter conflict has been simmering beneath the surface of rugby league since its conception; a rivalry with the potential to split the game apart and polarise fans like never before.
This bitter feud has erupted on to the field many times during the last hundred and four years, but if the NRL wants to truly capitalise on its potential then it needs to establish a formal outlet for this feud. It would take the form of a new Origin series: The Silvertails versus The Battlers.
Game day would be a fantastic experience, with punters travelling to the Sydney Football Stadium in the heart of Sydney’s affluent east. Upon arrival, Silvertails fans are ushered to the members and corporate areas, while Battlers supporters are herded to the general admission seating, all the while seething with hatred for their hoity-toity counterparts.
As they enter the gates, fans are handed a complimentary soy latte which the Silvertails begin sipping while the Battlers put them aside for hurling onto the field later. At the bar, a portly fellow in a ‘Bring Back the Biff’ t-shirt is offered a selection of boutique imported beers and vintage wines. After studying the selection, he asks for a VB and heads back to his seat, relieved that his mates can’t brand him a sissy for coming back with a Corona and lime wedge.
With the crowd now seated, they watch with anticipation for both teams to take the field. The fans in general admission roar with delight as a rusty old Holden ute drives on to the pitch. Seated in the tray are the seventeen players now known collectively as The Battlers. They are each wearing a blue Bonds shearers singlet with the numbers 1-17 stuck on the back with duct tape.
Coach Tommy Raudonikis stands proudly on the sideline in his well-worn tracksuit. Following the ute is a shiny new stretch limousine being pelted with abuse and stone-cold soy lattes from the stands. Inside, The Silvertails are smoothing the creases in their Gucci playing strips and listening to a motivational seminar from Lachlan Murdoch.
A butler is waiting to greet the limo and to open the door for the players as it slows to a halt.
It is now time for the anthem and the crowd can’t wait for the action to start. Anthony Warlow and the cast of Annie perform ‘Advance Australia Fair’, when suddenly, out of nowhere, Barnesy makes his way through the crowd, belting out none other than ‘Working Class Man’. Thousands of screaming bogans are delighted, while the latte-sippers cover their ears at “that awful shrieking.”
As security escorts Barnesy from the venue, the game gets underway. It is a physical contest with big hits and fancy footwork from both sides. The game takes a turn however when Silvertails half-back Mitchell Pearce crosses under the post for the first four pointer. He celebrates his achievement by taking off his shirt and posing for a photographer from ‘Cleo’ while Battlers fans watch in horror.
Several minutes later, Pearce’s best mate and son of a former Woolworths CEO, Kieran Foran, extends the Silvertails’ lead, and is promptly doused in champagne by his teammates.
It’s half time and Battlers fans are appalled at their teams effort while, in the members area, ‘tails fans are clinking their wine glasses in a toast to their team’s performance, before moving the conversation to the stock exchange. On the pitch, the crowd is treated to a half time performance of A Midsummer Night’s Dream while a slow chant of “Bull****” makes its way around the arena.
Not long into the second half, the tables turn when the punters finally get what they paid to see: an all-in brawl. The melee is allowed to continue for some time before officials break it up, and the grass is littered with bruised Silvertails players. The crowd roars with approval.
Not long after play resumes, Battlers’ captain Paul Gallen barges over the line before jumping into the grandstand to celebrate with fans.
Moments later, Todd Carney equalises with a quick step around the ‘tails defence. With the game all tied up, the fans are on the edge of their seats waiting for the moment that’s going to seal a win for either team.
They don’t have to wait long. Newly signed Silvertails player, Sonny Bill Williams, is distracted when he spots his agent chatting to a representative from the NFL. As he begins planning how to get out of his latest contract, Nathan Merritt dances past him to score in the corner.
The game is over. The Battlers are the victors. As the Silvertails fans make their way back to their cold, empty mansions, Battlers suporters rejoice in the knowledge that the balance has been restored, and eagerly await next year’s rematch at Campbelltown Stadium.
Love your NRL? The Roar has openings for live bloggers - with possible paid opportunities. Tell us which upcoming game you'd like to trial on.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- A simple vision for a nationwide NRL (181)
- Are the Bears finally to come out of hibernation? (146)
- Listen to the fans and allow Central Coast Bears in (113)
- Super League on the up in 2012 (79)
- Rugby league’s new era: where to now? (72)
- ARL commission ready to take on AFL (68)
- NRL changes finals system: Bye, bye McIntyre (63)
- Barba not fazed by NRL fullback rumours
- NRL’s McIntyre finals finally at an end (4)
- NRL preview 2012: Broncos pack want to be NRL’s best in 2012 (5)
- Origin in Melbourne is great for rugby league in Victoria (95)
- Young NRL talent to watch in 2012 (6)
- Maguire needs to bring pride and glory back to Redfern
- My mates told me the McIntye System had to go (5)
- Origin in Melbourne is great for rugby league in Victoria (95)
- Young NRL talent to watch in 2012 (6)
- Maguire needs to bring pride and glory back to Redfern (1)
- My mates told me the McIntye System had to go (5)
- New commission will make the right calls for NRL’s future (0)
- NRL TVC: Back to the future with Bon Jovi [video] (33)
- My fearless predictions for the 2012 NRL Season (6)
- Explore:
- NRL, Rugby League, Sonny Bill Williams

January 16th 2012 @ 8:27am
Andy said | January 16th 2012 @ 8:27am | Report comment
A funny article and a good idea, but there are a few problems with such a game for instance, it is another match for players to get an injury, and there may not be many players from different teams being viewed as Silvertails. Finally, players will feign injury to not play in an event, especially if they are going to be labelled a silvertail.
January 16th 2012 @ 8:37am
DumpStar said | January 16th 2012 @ 8:37am | Report comment
Now you just have to come up with team lists.
I nominate Nathan Hindmarsh as the captain of the Battlers.
Braith Anasta would have to be a certainty for the captain of the silvertails.
January 16th 2012 @ 8:56am
John said | January 16th 2012 @ 8:56am | Report comment
A humorous article, I really enjoyed the read. Oh & Silvertails vs Battlers… get it on!
January 16th 2012 @ 9:37am
Petebix said | January 16th 2012 @ 9:37am | Report comment
This is actually pretty much how state of origin started
January 16th 2012 @ 10:26am
turbodewd said | January 16th 2012 @ 10:26am | Report comment
Technically silvertails are rah rahs and follow union.
January 16th 2012 @ 10:36am
clipper said | January 16th 2012 @ 10:36am | Report comment
You’re right turbodewd. Perhaps a better idea would be the Battlers vs the Bludgers. They could have a couple of stories on A Current Affair or Today Tonight to really get it going.
January 16th 2012 @ 12:47pm
True Blue said | January 16th 2012 @ 12:47pm | Report comment
Yeah like those well known silvertails Tinkler, Bouris, Packer, Murdoch, Politis, Holmes a Court etc who all follow(ed) rugby league.
January 16th 2012 @ 10:43am
Gareth said | January 16th 2012 @ 10:43am | Report comment
I’d love to see the official NSW team go up against a publicly voted team of the blokes who missed out. The winner gets to take on Queensland. The NRL can later sell the rights to the classic sporting underdog film that ensues.
January 16th 2012 @ 12:02pm
Al said | January 16th 2012 @ 12:02pm | Report comment
Top read! I’ll be sure to pass it on to my father, being an ex magpie,and him continuing to complain about the silver tails, im sure he’ll love it! Possibly get tommy to have a read next time they have an old boys reunion lol. Not too keen on carney in the team tho… Hindmarsh as dumpstar recommended for sure! Matty groat would be on the cards in years to come too.. Great article!
January 16th 2012 @ 12:18pm
Paul said | January 16th 2012 @ 12:18pm | Report comment
After the IC takes control all the players will be Silver Tails
January 16th 2012 @ 1:29pm
Patrick Angel said | January 16th 2012 @ 1:29pm | Report comment
+1
January 16th 2012 @ 1:29pm
Patrick Angel said | January 16th 2012 @ 1:29pm | Report comment
Drunks vs Overtly Religious?
January 16th 2012 @ 6:28pm
Johnno said | January 16th 2012 @ 6:28pm | Report comment
i find the fibro VS silvertail thing is kinda dead now in rugby league.
Rugby league is no longer a working class sport, it is mainstream, and does working class really exist in Australia in 2012 anyway.
The aussie working class hero knock about bloke tommy rodunokis and john sattler types don’t exist any more in society or in rugby league by the current generation.
Back in Tommy and john’s day, players had 9-5 jobs, were more likely married and with kids, .
And many were jobs like taxi driver, butchers, electricians, plumbers, builders, during the day, train at night after work, then play on weekends,.
Now they are full time elite athletes, distanced form the community at large as most don’t have 2nd jobs, so they are not integrating with society at large on a daily basis.
And this knockabout aussie yobbo bloke type footballer who lives off white bread and ham sandwiches, and smokes a pack of cigarettes a day and plays footy on weekends , and hates manly the silvertails , simply does not exit any more.
January 16th 2012 @ 11:29pm
Sea Eagle of Brisbane said | January 16th 2012 @ 11:29pm | Report comment
Man, you are dead right. All elite sportsmen now days have plenty of money (how well off at the end of their careers is depend of how much they save).
This is a pretty ordinary article of yesteryears (perhaps 30 years ago would have been a hit), Man, can we have some footy rather than these kindergarten stuff, please.