Lady Luck deserts Lealiifano
By David Lord, 6 May 2012 David Lord is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Christian Lealiifano, Rugby Union, Super Rugby
The Brumbies win on Saturday night was overshadowed by a key injury to Christian Lealiifano (AAP Image/Dean Lewins)
Related coverage
Christian Lealiifano’s suspected broken ankle took all the gloss off the Brumbies’ impressive 23-6 win over the Waratahs in Canberra last night.
And gave Wallaby coach Robbie Deans an additional headache as to who will wear the number 10 jersey against Scotland and Wales.
The jersey is a poisoned chalice with Quade Cooper, James O’Connor, and now Lealiifano all out of the frame on the injured list.
It was a cruel blow for the 24-year-old Auckland-born Lealiifano, especially as the accident happened well after the final hooter had sounded, with the Brumbies home and hosed.
It was a meaningless time to still be playing.
That’s where Lady Luck played her cards, and she deserted Christian Lealiifano.
So who does Deans turn to now? Kurtley Beale or Ben Lucas?
Beale was brilliant against the Bulls on Friday night in his first hit-out of the season at 10. In a normal world Deans would far prefer to have Beale at 15, but his world has been turned upside down with injuries to key players.
Once considered an outside possibility, Lucas can force his way into contention with an outstanding game against the Crusaders later today in Christchurch. That’s a big ask, but that’s what it will take to catch Deans’ attention.
This Christchurch clash has taken on a new significance now the Brumbies have opened up a 10-point lead over the Reds on top of the Australian Conference. If the Reds lose, with the Brumbies having a bye next week for an assured four points, it will be all over red rover for the defending champions.
Unless something dramatic happens over the final six rounds, the Brumbies deserve to top the local table and have a crack at the title.
Last night they were all poise, never flustered. When centre Andrew Smith scored in the 45th minute, it was after a patient 15-phase assault on the Waratahs’ line – and inevitable.
This new-look Brumbies lineup under South African World Cup-winning coach Jake White has been a revelation. The same can’t be said about Waratahs coach Michael Foley.
The Waratahs enjoyed the bulk of possession last night (58%) but didn’t know how to use it, which translated to having the minor percentage of territory with 39. The Waratahs also won the rucks and mauls 128-71, ran 848 metres to 431, and missed 12 tackles to 28.
The only stat the Waratahs were behind the Brumbies were the turnovers 21-14.
On those figures how on earth did they lose?
Foley has a major problem getting his charges to cope with the simple rugby basics of passing and support play. Many of the passes are too high or behind the receiver, destroying momentum. That’s kindergarten quality.
Last night in the first half, Kane Douglas, Tatafa Polota-Nau, Sekope Kepu, and the skipper Benn Robinson all made clean breaks, try on, but either the pass went to ground, or the support went missing.
Basic errors and opportunities wasted.
Not so with the Brumbies, they are playing positive entertaining rugby and the fans are voting with their feet. Last night at Canberra Stadium a vocal 19,112 turned up, near capacity.
The Brumbies deserve it.
- Explore:
- Christian Lealiifano, Rugby Union, Super Rugby

May 6th 2012 @ 6:26am
Fatty said | May 6th 2012 @ 6:26am | Report comment
White now has same problem as Deans if L’fano has broken ankle….who to play at 5/8 as his backup/firstchoice Toomua is also injured. ?Coleman
May 6th 2012 @ 12:45pm
bluerose said | May 6th 2012 @ 12:45pm | Report comment
White should do a McQueen and try Mogg at n10
May 6th 2012 @ 6:27pm
daryl said | May 6th 2012 @ 6:27pm | Report comment
Coleman has to start at 10, thats his natural position
May 6th 2012 @ 7:35pm
Brett McKay said | May 6th 2012 @ 7:35pm | Report comment
Fatty, Zack Holmes will be an option too, played off the bench for the first couplf of games, looks a promising flyhalf..
May 6th 2012 @ 8:49pm
bmwwilliams said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:49pm | Report comment
While i am gutted for Christian, this needn’t be the end of the Brumbies’ run.
I’ve been very impressed with Robbie Coleman in his cameos this year. Zack Holmes has looked solid too, and is a quality goal kicker to boot.
If the team has taught us anything this year, it’s that they’re not dependent on any one star individual – The next bloke in line can be trusted to step up when he’s needed.
May 6th 2012 @ 6:29am
King of the Gorgonites said | May 6th 2012 @ 6:29am | Report comment
Top crowd. Well done to the people of Canberra.
May 6th 2012 @ 7:13am
Who Needs Melon said | May 6th 2012 @ 7:13am | Report comment
For the sake of the Wallabies, Australian rugby, the Brumbies aspirations and of course Christian himself, I’d much prefer the Brumbies to have lost that and Christian not be injured. Gutted.
Good win by the Brumbies. I thought Fardy played really well.
May 6th 2012 @ 7:16am
Best 10 said | May 6th 2012 @ 7:16am | Report comment
Speedy recovery Christian and please make sure that you change the photo !
May 6th 2012 @ 8:30am
Justin said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:30am | Report comment
Yes agree Tyrone Smith is CL
May 6th 2012 @ 8:11am
nickoldschool said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:11am | Report comment
KB at 10 and Mogg at n15 vs Scotland? Deans might opt for AAC at 15 though.
Brumbies are so much better/quicker at off-loading, passing/recycling the ball than the Tahs. Their players often get the ball at speed while the Tahs stand still, get the ball and make a few metres… Arent these basic rugby skills?
May 6th 2012 @ 8:27am
PeterK said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:27am | Report comment
totally agree re the backs. The Tah forwards offload, run angles, in support and offload better than their backs.
A team Brumbies beat 8 players (the forwards) and 7 clowns.
Tahs forwards were very good they did their job , majority possession, easily won the battle of the forwards, just the brumby backs are all class.
Look at the difference now that giteau is gone and they listen to larkham.
May 6th 2012 @ 8:48am
Grimmace said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:48am | Report comment
and the brumby backs run straight
May 6th 2012 @ 8:32am
eagleJack said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:32am | Report comment
The injury to Lealiifano made a poor night even worse. Tahs forwards were strong. Can’t help but think a Turner or Mitchell would have finished off the breaks of Douglas and TPN. Our current backs lack class.
May 6th 2012 @ 8:33am
Ilikedahoodoogurusingha said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:33am | Report comment
We have a couple of options for the No 10 spot, Coleman and Zack Holmes.
May 6th 2012 @ 8:36am
Red Ned said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:36am | Report comment
Barnes was made for test match rugby. Though his defense was lazy last night, he is rock solid in the midfield. I’m surprised his name is not being mentioned as our 10. He directs teams well and can stick to a game plan. It’s a shame Lucas hasn’t had a good dig in the gold colors…..even though he would likely be best coming off the bench for a number of options.
May 6th 2012 @ 11:31am
Brett McKay said | May 6th 2012 @ 11:31am | Report comment
Agree Ned, Barnes played his best game of the season last night..
May 6th 2012 @ 11:46am
Justin said | May 6th 2012 @ 11:46am | Report comment
I disagree with this. Barnes did play quite well last night but his organisation leaves a lot to be desired.
Yes he was much improved particularly in the first half. He was much flatter in attack but the Tahs lose their shape way too much and he seems to go missing after a few phases. This is the time he needs to be calling the shots as the defence becomes disorganised. Too often though the Tahs were muddled and confused and he did not stamp his authority on the match and the Tahs tactics.
He ran the ball reasonably but by the second half he had reverted to his deep positioning and throwing cutouts to the left hand side of the field. Contrast his play with the crispness of CL.
The amount of ball the Tahs had he should have been creating havoc but he just doesnt manage to do it. It was a decent performance but hardly worthy of being the first choice 10 for the Wallabies. His miss on Speight was woeful.
May 6th 2012 @ 2:30pm
jeznez said | May 6th 2012 @ 2:30pm | Report comment
When Foley returns then Barnes needs to move to 12 and Foley be given the 10 shirt. Horne back to 13 and we’ll see if the backs can lift. I’m not sure I saw the ball passed through the hands by the Tahs without the runner having to check himself or collect it behind him.
The German move needs a lot more practice at training.
May 6th 2012 @ 2:53pm
Justin said | May 6th 2012 @ 2:53pm | Report comment
Yup, agreed but they wont make those changes Jez and it will be too late…
May 7th 2012 @ 3:03am
jeznez said | May 7th 2012 @ 3:03am | Report comment
Justin, it is already too late, the season is gone and they are playing for pride from here on out.
May 6th 2012 @ 8:41am
sheek said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:41am | Report comment
Having a “crash-ball” player at no.12 seems fashionable these days, but it doesn’t work for the Tahs. Barnes was the only one who appeared capable of directing the Tahs attack. And on most occasions the Brumbies had him covered.
There was no-one else to share the attacking duties, & no variety whatsoever in running angles, switching plays etc, apart from Barnes himself. My neighbour, who was watching the game with me, called it early at about 15-20 minutes in that the Tahs wouldn’t score a try.
I thought he was simply airing his early frustration, but this is how it turned out.
The other observation is leadership. There is an appalling lack of leadership across the Tahs team. Neither Robinson nor Barnes can be considered natural leaders, although they should be part of any leadership group. But they need help from other senior players.
On the other hand, very impressed with the Brumbies. White has them playing a simple brand of rugby, but it’s effective because everyone is on the same page, so to speak.
Interesting to read an article about Rocky Elsom the other day. Elsom concluded from his long experience that you don’t necessarily need the best plan, but one that everyone is together with.
That pretty well sums up the Brumbies…..
May 6th 2012 @ 9:47am
David Lord said | May 6th 2012 @ 9:47am | Report comment
And separates the Waratahs sheek.
May 6th 2012 @ 8:53am
sheek said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:53am | Report comment
Oh, there was another observation – why on earth are the Tahs backs standing so deep on set plays especially?
By the time the ball got to the outside centre the defence was on them, & they hadn’t even reached the advantage line. This is basic stuff gone crazy.
May 6th 2012 @ 10:05am
Blinky Bill of Bellingen said | May 6th 2012 @ 10:05am | Report comment
I believe when Rocky came onto the field he assumed the Captain’s role. Fair enough. What gets me though is that despite us being somewhat ‘patchy’ at the lineouts, he decided we’d roll the dice and bank on a win with a lineout, and I assume a rolling maul to score a try. Result? Throw not straight. Opportunity lost.
Maybe the Canberra crowd got to him?
Dead right Sheek about standing too deep in the backs. I was watching and wondering with all that ball movement (and we were going from one side of the field to the other), just why were weren’t progressing the ball. We were in fact going no where and at times actually going backwards.
Man alive, I live for the day I see one of our monster forwards accelerate onto the ball, bust the line and pop a lovely pass to another monster running at pace or a back running off their shoulder. Is this too much to ask from our coaches?
May 6th 2012 @ 1:20pm
PeterK said | May 6th 2012 @ 1:20pm | Report comment
The tah forwards DID accelerate onto the ball, make busts and offload to another forward in support, I had only 1 complaint with the forwards. What did not happen was fater backs supporting all those breaks the forwards made. Palu made 14 runs, 4 offloads for instance.
I was very disapointed when Mowen was yellow carded we went for the line out instead of a 5 metre scrum. With a man short we had a real chance at a pushover try or a penalty try.
Going for the lineout with Ulugia throwing was very stupid.
Out of the brumby forwards I was realy disapointed with their big no 8. I was really hoping he would match the tah power forwards and push for a wallaby spot. But he was a non entity when faced with power and size against him.
The tahs backs are very useless, as is Foley.
White should be the Wallaby coach not McKenzie (or Deans).
May 6th 2012 @ 8:58pm
Carnivean said | May 6th 2012 @ 8:58pm | Report comment
Pushover try probably wasn’t considered possible as at the time the Brumbies had the far superior front row, with Moore and Alexander on the field, whereas TPN and Robinson were off for the Tahs. It might have still been possible, and it was what I called at the screen, but hindsight tells me that the lineout was the more likely try provider at that point in the game.
May 6th 2012 @ 11:30am
Brett McKay said | May 6th 2012 @ 11:30am | Report comment
Sheek, the big difference in the Tahs this week was that Barnes stood a lot flatter, ran a whole lot more, and credit to him, had probably his best game of the year. His adjustment in his depth was noticeable.
What was also noticeable is that while Barnes played flatter, Carter and the rest of the Tahs backs stayed back, as you mention. And this played right into the Brumbies wider defenders, too, with Carter and Kingston not getting over the ad line all night.
Barnes played it right by starting flatter, going to the line. The rest of the Tahs backs should’ve gone with him..
May 6th 2012 @ 11:40am
sheek said | May 6th 2012 @ 11:40am | Report comment
Brett,
Spot on – that’s exactly how I saw it – Barnes stood flatter & ran more, but the rest of the backline remained too deep…..
BTW, I hope you & other Roarers are sitting down – last night’s Brumbies vs Waratahs match was the first super rugby game I watched in full since the opening round, and… and… and… I actually enjoyed it, although it wasn’t vintage fare…!!!
May 6th 2012 @ 11:46am
Brett McKay said | May 6th 2012 @ 11:46am | Report comment
that’s it then – we’re set for 40 days and 40 nights of rain….
May 6th 2012 @ 2:33pm
jeznez said | May 6th 2012 @ 2:33pm | Report comment
welcome back sheek!