HODGSON: Imagine if all our stars played rugby union
By Matt Hodgson, 15 May 2012 Matt Hodgson is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Aaron Sandilands, AFL, Billy Slater, Jonathan Thurston, Lance Franklin, NRL, Rugby League, Rugby Union, Super Rugby
Matt Hodgson for the Force forces his way through the Stormers defence (AAP Image/ Tony McDonough)
Related coverage
The long trip with the Western Force to South Africa found us in a new country, new time zone, and with a different currency.
But one thing in common stands out between our two countries – our love and passion for sport.
Unlike back home, though, South Africa has rugby union everywhere. Just as when we go to New Zealand, it is amazing being in a place where rugby union is so prominent, and the number one sport in the country. Even during the Rugby World Cup, the excitement around rugby in Australia does not come close to a normal day in these nations.
Such dominant countries, along with comments made this year challenging Australia’s ability to provide enough player depth to sustain five Super teams, has me thinking what Australian rugby would be like if it were the dominant national sport.
Imagine, if rugby were the prominent code in Australia, the talent pool that we could call upon. If the top talent from all the football codes had chosen careers in rugby instead of AFL or rugby league.
There are an abundance of athletes in Australia who would have and could still make a huge contribution to rugby union if they chose to lend their time to our sport. Of course, it would be ideal if they were imprinted with rugby from a young age. But with the physical attributes and skills of some athletes, even a few years of core training and practice could see a transformation, similar to what Israel Folau and Karmichael Hunt are doing in the AFL.
I can see a number of players bolstering the ranks. Imagine the likes of Aaron Sandilands, at 211cm and 122kg, packing down next to Nathan Sharpe or James Horwill. Sandilands would currently cover more kilometres in a game than any back in rugby, and would easily stand over the like of Andries Bekker.
Imagine a backline that contained our current group of youngsters in Kurtley Beale and James O’Connor, then throw in the Hawthorn great Buddy Franklin. There goes the opposition’s chance of playing high balls, and those three on counter would be a sight to behold.
How would you defend that? I know I would hate to do a video analysis on a team that contained those three.
So there’s the second row and the back three sorted, just by adding AFL players. If we now turn our thoughts to the NRL we could have Cooper Cronk or Johnathan Thurston fill in at 10, or they could form your 10 and 12 combination if you wanted to have two ball-playing types in the midfield.
And if I take this dream further, you can’t forget one of the greatest of all three football codes, Billy Slater.
I can hear the commentators now: “Genia to Thurston, a cut pass that misses O’Connor to find Beale, who has both Slater and Franklin in support.” The crowd would be on their feet and salivating with anticipation of what they were about to see. Anything would be possible with so much talent on the pitch.
Here we have all three contact football codes coming together to create a team that would boast the best of the best. A similar strategy would definitely be able to fill all five Australian Super franchises with international-quality talent.
If rugby union were the premier football code in Australia, then there would be countless flow-on benefits to the game beyond the talent pool. The facilities that would be provided would be world-best, state-of-the-art venues for both the playing and viewing pleasure of all.
Imagine sitting in a rectangular stadium each week filled with 80,000 screaming fans in Subiaco. This alone would create a far greater spectacle, regardless of what was on the field, and crowds like these are one of the reasons that we all love sport.
Media coverage would be comprehensive and all games would screen live with the code’s own channel, like the AFL now has on Fox. It would involve best-of-the-best conditions, and it would produce best-of-the-best rugby.
There are so many players in all three codes who have the natural skill and the athletic ability to have made fine rugby players. Aside from those mentioned above, I would go after Matthew Pavlich, Chris Judd, Gary Ablett, Dean Cox, Nic Natanui, Dallas Johnson, Ryan Hoffman, Corey Parker, Dave Taylor, and Greg Inglis.
I know as a player, a fan and just as a sports-loving Australian, I would love to see what it would look like if rugby union were the number one sporting code in Australia, like it is in the countries of our Southern Hemisphere neighbours.
Matt Hodgson is a current Wallaby, inaugural Western Force Player and contributor to The Roar. Matt is focused on rugby but excited by the next phase of his career in Sports Management, Training and professional endeavours. Check out www.matthodgson.com.au for the latest.
- Explore:
- Aaron Sandilands, AFL, Billy Slater, Jonathan Thurston, Lance Franklin, NRL, Rugby League, Rugby Union, Super Rugby

May 15th 2012 @ 4:04am
Johnno said | May 15th 2012 @ 4:04am | Report comment
I dream about this moment all the time and desperately hope Asian rugby develops , big tv market China,India,Japan, Sth Korea,Indonesia,,malaysia,phillipines, thailand, sri lanka, kazaksthan which has a good team,Uzbekistan, UAE which plays in Asian 5 nations and rich too the middle east nations, also hong kong and singapore, then more tv money.
And we can have a Asian super rugby comp, more tv money than from South africa, and also test matches and Asian cup like the soccer model.
7evens doing well in Asia as is 15 a side, love the Hong kong sevens. Plus USA/Canada which is in pacific as well. Then all that tv money will come into the sport of rugby union.
And more money to spend on a national under 20 NRL style Toyota cup, and other elite development comps, academies, high performance centres, talent identification. And even more kids will take up rugby if Asia develops. The IRB is now valuing Asia very seriously and putting in big money into development into Asia-pacific and rightly so. They have built a rugby academy in Samoa.
Japan rugby more and more money to be made at the clubs Craig wing there ex league with a junior rugby background.
RYan cross came back to rugby union too.
So yes I dream of seeing Greg inglis, we got SBW to rugby union.
Also T-Rex tony williams, and Jamal Idris, Jarred hargraves, Gary Ablet jnr, get KHunt back to rugby union.
Isreal Folaeu would be sensation at rugby union. As would Jarryd the Hayne train hayne, and billy slater, and the very fast Micheal Jennings.
Craig gower was good rugby player to as is craig wing. Greg Bird, Watmough, mick crocker, luke lewis, Paull Gallen, and James Tamou big and strong.
But yes would love too see Todd Carney as a wallaby, as well as JT and Cooper Cronk , and Cameron smith to is a good 5/8 in league as well as hooker and halfback.
Also jarryd saffy doing well at rugby union , cooper tuna too improving a lot.
So much league talent ready to come to league if there interested and if the ARU can get more money and have an ARC, or an Asian super rugby championship, or a SHemphishpere championship.
May 15th 2012 @ 6:32am
Damien said | May 15th 2012 @ 6:32am | Report comment
LOL..Cooper Tuna.
I know who you meant but thats given me a goof laugh..
May 15th 2012 @ 8:01am
RebelRanger said | May 15th 2012 @ 8:01am | Report comment
Oh Todd Carney at 12 for the Wallabies. Maybe Inglis at 13. Would love to see that..
May 15th 2012 @ 6:18pm
Lorry said | May 15th 2012 @ 6:18pm | Report comment
Todd Carney is a thug. No thanks…
May 15th 2012 @ 4:43am
chris said | May 15th 2012 @ 4:43am | Report comment
Good article and just wished there was a game that mixed Rugby Union/League and Aussie Rules (and even Gaelic)but played on rectangular stadium.
The nearest this will happen is if the Rugby codes agree to join together and that could mean trouble for AFL and GAA.
May 15th 2012 @ 7:32am
Mark Roth said | May 15th 2012 @ 7:32am | Report comment
I’ve often wondered the same thing–especially if they used one of the proposals to merge the laws of the VFL with the NSWRL which popped up before each world war to allow Victoria and NSW to play each other. Before the first proposal, the backers of the plan in NSW claimed that they could convince England and New Zealand to adopt the new rules.
However, a modern merger would just create a new, and very small sport that people only care about for the odd exhibition game or is only played by a few. Pretty much what International Rules is today.
Also, how would a merged code of Rugby be more like the AFL than either of the two existing codes?
May 15th 2012 @ 4:53am
Toa said | May 15th 2012 @ 4:53am | Report comment
l have my doubts players mention would be able to make it. There’s seems to be a perception with high quality rugby league backs being issue an athletic visa base on their highlight reels. There hasn’t been to many backs transfer over as marquee signings that have set the rugby world on fire.
Out of the current players mention Cameron Smith, luke lewis, Jarred Haynes would be worth while pursuing these guys seem to have the versatilely.
May 15th 2012 @ 5:16am
Brett Susan said | May 15th 2012 @ 5:16am | Report comment
Let me tell you as a South African, rugby doesn’t even come close to soccer as the most popular sport here. Although it is popular and well supported, the vast majority of the population wouldn’t be able to tell a bulls jersey from a sharks one….now just imagine if it was the most popular sport… One can only dream….
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
May 15th 2012 @ 9:27am
Tigranes said | May 15th 2012 @ 9:27am | Report comment
Brett
what part of the country you from?
Most of the blacks might prefer soccer, but I would be surprised if most blacks in gauteng would not have heard of the bulls, or most blacks in KwaZulu-Natal wouldnt know about the Sharks.
And the PSL doesnt exactly draw too many big crowds, in fact the A-League crowds dwarf it.
May 15th 2012 @ 4:11pm
Photon said | May 15th 2012 @ 4:11pm | Report comment
You are obviously not an African if that is what you think, most people in the location know little about rugby other than the Springboks, For the record I was born in Natal and lived there for 10 years, Lived in the Free State for the next 14 and have been in Gauteng for the last two. Football is far more popular than rugby, the only thing is that in our country most of the people who have money for novalties like sprort tickets are white. That’s why why I go to Loftus or Kings Park or the Free State Stadium surprise surprise 90% of the crowd is white. It’s also easy to say that rugby crowds dwarf football crowds, but the average crowds drawn by the biggest football clubs (Pirates,Chiefs,Sundowns, Celtic) will probably weigh up pretty well against the crowds drawn by the big rugby unions (Stormers,Bulls,Sharks,Cheetahs). In terms of television ratings my suspicion is that there would be no comparision, especially in light of the fact that the most prized advertising space on Supersport is on Supersport 3 and 4 as opposed to Supersport 1
May 15th 2012 @ 6:05pm
Titus said | May 15th 2012 @ 6:05pm | Report comment
I found it interesting that the article doesn’t even mention Soccer/Football, despite it having close to as many participants as the others combined.
Apparently there is only 3 codes of football in Australia.
May 15th 2012 @ 6:55pm
SimonB said | May 15th 2012 @ 6:55pm | Report comment
Possibly because the skills in soccer are not as compatible with the other codes?
May 15th 2012 @ 8:47pm
Titus said | May 15th 2012 @ 8:47pm | Report comment
How do you know that players with skill and creativity wouldn’t benefit Rugby?
How big was Mark Ella? because he is what is missing from the Australian game now, and Campo
May 15th 2012 @ 5:57am
Damo said | May 15th 2012 @ 5:57am | Report comment
Is that the sound of a cannon rumbling down the track on it’s way to a code war, that I can hear?
Yes I dream too. But rather than wiping out AFL and RL we should be finding ways to tap into certain talents while leaving other codes unthreatened.
Both are good games and locked into Aussie culture.
Rather than the futile attempt to redirect Australian culture we need to find ways to bargain for players like slater or Inglis or Sandilands.
Double or triple bill football games may help all codes. Helping the other codes get the international exposure that rugby enjoys may be a bargaining chip to allow rugby some local media space/access to talent.
Nothing harder to change than entrenched culture. Like telling everyone in France to speak english and eat hamburgers. Not likely
to work.
Build bridges not walls. Btw I’d love to see Inglis on the rugby roster.
How good is Shannon Walker in the Sevens?
May 15th 2012 @ 6:30am
Damien said | May 15th 2012 @ 6:30am | Report comment
I think Hodgon’s dream is just like us dreaming we win the lotto.
Its a long way from wiping out the other codes.
Nothing dramatic in it.
May 15th 2012 @ 7:05am
chris said | May 15th 2012 @ 7:05am | Report comment
If Rugby Union can swallow pie and just sort of become what League is then we are half way there as more people in Canada watch the Super Bowl then the Grey Cup.
May 15th 2012 @ 7:27am
Mark Roth said | May 15th 2012 @ 7:27am | Report comment
Just think of all the penalty goals that could be kicked in that world! Any Australia drive past their own ten metre line would create massive risks for any team conceding a penalty.
Seriously though, things would be very different if Australia’s one code of football was Union. Off the top of my head:
1) Would super rugby even exist in the face of dominant domestic play in Australia?
2) Would anyone’s domestic rugby scene be viable in the professional era with the amount of cash available from a league that combines the weight of the AFL and NRL?
3) Would their actually even be a major league in Australia? By that I mean:
Could something like the AFL or NRL develop in an amateur game?
Would one state’s league take over the country or would each state have a functioning league of its own and Interstate (or even State of Origin) matches reserved for representative sides?
This one is a long shot, but if Rugby were introduced and allowed to take over pre-Federation, would there even be an Australian team or would there be Victorian and New South Welsh sides in the Olympics alongside England and Wales–who are also not independent nations.
I could go on…
May 15th 2012 @ 7:33am
nickoldschool said | May 15th 2012 @ 7:33am | Report comment
Changing codes isnt that easy. look at Folau and Hunt in the AFL, what a waste of talent!
May 16th 2012 @ 4:31am
Bear said | May 16th 2012 @ 4:31am | Report comment
A waste of talent? Karmichael is dominating for the Suns. He is one of their better players. It’s only his second year of playing AFL. Some might argue he was wasting his talent playing League.
As for Folau. What do you expect after 5 games in the AFL.?
May 15th 2012 @ 8:44am
Manoa said | May 15th 2012 @ 8:44am | Report comment
Todd carney at 12, is this a beat up. That wouldn’t be a dream it would be a nightmare unless your an all blacks supporter.
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
May 15th 2012 @ 8:48am
Andy said | May 15th 2012 @ 8:48am | Report comment
If this was to happen Australia would dominate the rugby world and it would probably be a bad thing for rugby as nobody would come near them. The good thing now is there are five countries that can win the world cup and another five or so that are not too far behind.
What would happen though if Australia took rugby as serious as they do league the world cup would be a one horse race. This is one of the reasons why the Rugby league world cup struggles is because nobody wants a one horse race. Even though they last the lost the last world cup they had the world cup since 1975.
May 15th 2012 @ 10:25am
Old Rugby Boy said | May 15th 2012 @ 10:25am | Report comment
Andy,
you should check who are the Rugby League World Champions. I think you will find it is not Australia. I am in the position where I travel monthly on business and Rugby Union is as not as popuar as it thinks it is. Soccer for outstips Rugby Union world wide and as much as Rugby Union supporters will not accept it, Rugby League is making rapid gains world wide. I think the reason for this is because the current laws of the game I love are just to complex. If you are a new comer to any of the Rugby codes the very simple rules of Rugby League make it much easier to pick up.
The trouble of the premisis of this article is that if the best AFL and Rugby League went and played Rugby Union there would not be one of the current Wallabies in the test side.
May 15th 2012 @ 10:34am
Justin2 said | May 15th 2012 @ 10:34am | Report comment
Can I ask where “Rugby League is making rapid gains world wide”?
May 15th 2012 @ 10:58am
Old Rugby Boy said | May 15th 2012 @ 10:58am | Report comment
Hi Justin2,
To my horror, I found Rugby League being played right across Europe. I have seen games being played in nearly every eurropean country. They even play seond tier tests. I think it is called the European Shield. I am not sure if Germany or Russia is the current holder but a german business associate told me that Rugby League should become the second football code in Germany in 10 years. I even saw games of Rugby League in the black townships of South Africa. There are two competing professional Rugby League competions in the USA, both being televised and I understand the US pays test matches against the West Indies and Canada. I looked on Wikipedia and there are 40 nations with Rugby League test sides. Most of them would be rubbish but I think we can blame Rupert Murdoch and Sky TV for his world widebroadcasts of Super League.
May 15th 2012 @ 5:24pm
Justin said | May 15th 2012 @ 5:24pm | Report comment
Well have a look at Rugby across Europe and the sides in the East. They are actually good teams. Rugby is now in the Olympics so many countries, name the US are hungry for success due to increased funding.
League? Care factor…
May 15th 2012 @ 5:40pm
Old Rugby Boy said | May 15th 2012 @ 5:40pm | Report comment
Not the point, old boy,player numbers are starting to climb, rapidly and that must be a worry. If we stick our heads in the sand and sit back and “look at rugby union across Europe etc ” Rugby League will overtake us. I have had a look at Rugby Union across Europe, I go there every second month. The picture is not as rosy as the IRB istelling us. Rugby League is taking over in some countries. When you go to Europe you will see Super League in nearly every country, on Sky. The Heiniken Cup is not as widley broadcast and does not rate as well. To make sure Rugby Union grows we shouldnt be disparaging about Rugby League we have to make Rugby Union better.
May 15th 2012 @ 6:02pm
p.Tah said | May 15th 2012 @ 6:02pm | Report comment
Best way to pretend you’re a rugby fan is to make up a name like ‘Old Rugby Boy’ and use cliches such as ‘old boy’ when referring to others. Any guesses who this poster really is?
May 16th 2012 @ 5:40pm
Justin2 said | May 16th 2012 @ 5:40pm | Report comment
Gee and if I say I go to Europe a couple of times a year and see the exact opposite then what happens?
Sorry Old Boy but no one is buying what you are selling…