The Agony and the Agony of State of Origin
By Ben Pobjie, 24 May 2012 Ben Pobjie is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Billy Slater, Cameron Smith, Greg Inglis, Johnathan Thurston, Mal Meninga, NRL, Rugby League, State Of Origin
Darius Boyd scores a try while being tackled by Akuila Uate during State of Origin 1 between Queensland and New South Wales at Etihad Stadium in Melbourne, Wednesday, May 23, 2012. (AAP Image/Action Photographics, Renee McKay)
Related coverage
When will it end? When will the unremitting torture cease and allow a proud-yet-clinically-depressed New South Welshman some psychological respite?
When will the annual agony ease and let me live once more with the sun in my heart? State of Origin time has always been a fraught time, a time for anguish and heartache occasionally punctuated by, not exultation, but relief and exhaustion.
However the grim death-march of the last six years, which now, after last night’s predictable catastrophe, seems likely to stretch to a seventh, is simply too much for a sensitive soul to bear.
Oh, it would be easy to blame the referees. Easy, and accurate. But we won’t get anywhere by heaping opprobrium on the officials. It will do us no good to question their parentage, or their personal hygiene, or demand they return the bugling cash-stuffed brown paper bags that Mal Meninga obviously slipped them before the game.
It will not provide one ounce of solace for us to curse the names of the referees and their descendants unto the seventh generation, or to call upon all the dark gods and demons of the netherworld to wreak hideous revenge upon them.
If State of Origin teaches us one thing, it is that there is little practical benefit to devising elaborate and graphic fantasies about tying up referees with the entrails of disembowelled pigs and suspending them upside down in enormous vats of boiling lard and horse manure. This will get us nowhere. The refs made their decisions, the game ended, they received their medals of honour from Campbell Newman, and the world moves on.
But when will we see relief? I hate to second-guess the wisdom of the universe, but surely we unhappy blues have suffered enough, and it is now time for the cosmic wheel to turn in our favour?
There is not much left to say about the modern Origin era. The fact is that Queensland has been blessed by a collection of freakishly talented individuals hitting their peaks at the same time, and NSW, with its solid selection strategy of choosing players based mainly on the dual criteria of ability to throw punch and ability to blindly pass the ball to nobody, has been unable to match them. Up against the core of the Maroon juggernaut in Johnathan Thurston, Billy Slater, Cameron Smith and Greg Inglis, it is not necessarily any disgrace to have lost so many series.
But that doesn’t mean it doesn’t hurt.
God it hurts. To keep taking this horrible battering every year. You’d think by this stage the Queenslanders would get into a huddle and say “Look guys, the little fellas have had enough. Let’s let them have this one.” But no. No mercy. Can’t you bastards show a bit of compassion, a bit of pity?
Isn’t it enough that we have to suffer the nightmarish indignity of having Phil Gould on our side, babbling his “that’s Origin!” gibberish throughout every game? Have we not suffered more than our share of torment? Apparently not, for it just keeps piling on.
All I want is for Origin period to be a little less depressing. A little less inevitable. I’d like one year when the stone-cold certainty that Queensland will score a try in the dying minutes to be incorrect. I’d like one year when a Blue player giving away a pointless penalty at a crucial stage, or dropping the ball with a try looming, or failing to find the freaking touchline with a penalty kick, came as a surprise to me.
Rather, it hits home with a dull thud of familiarity, the sense that rather than absurd, schoolboy-level mistakes that come along at this level but rarely, they are simply the natural order of things. I’d like a year where I could look forward to both teams lifting for the occasion, as opposed to the current arrangement, where the Queenslanders raise their performance for the big games and the New South Welshmen swap bodies with their local under-15s teams.
I want some hope. Is a little hope too much to ask, in this grey and dismal world? Is it so outlandish of me to want the experience of being a NSW fan to have a bit of light and shade about it, rather than the Gothic nightmare of nausea and self-harm that it has come to be?
Like I said, there is not much to be said about the game. The Maroons won. Because of Thurston, and Smith, and Slater, and Inglis, and Nate Myles and Darius Boyd. Because of their indefatigable defence. Because of their will to win. Because of their experience and coolness under pressure. Because of NSW mistakes and and a lack of killer instinct and of course because of the bloody refs.
But most of all, Queensland won because that’s what Queensland does. It’s not really sport anymore, it’s a law of physics. The earth goes around the sun. What goes up must come down. Queensland wins State of Origin games. There is nothing to be said, and nothing to be done, and all that is left for me to do is despair.
Please, somebody. Make it stop.
Ben Pobjie is a writer and comedian writing weekly on The Age, New Matilda and The Roar, whose promising rugby career was tragically cut short the day he stopped playing rugby and had a pizza instead. The most he has ever cried was the day Balmain lost the 1989 grand final. Today he enjoys the frolics of Wallabies, Swans, baggy greens, and Storms. Ben is also the author of the books Surveying the Wreckage, Superchef, and his latest, The Book of Bloke, available from Momentum Books.

May 24th 2012 @ 8:16am
Rugby Realist said | May 24th 2012 @ 8:16am | Report comment
Brilliant stuff. Very enjoyable read. As a Kiwi who follows QLD for no other reason than they once had a NZ coach and were once, ago 7 moons ago, perennial underdogs, i cant quite feel all your pain
However, as you allude to, you are dealing with one of the greatest sides ever assembled, and you were so so close. i doubt that numbs the pain.
Bring on sydney. As a quasi neutral i wont mind if NSW wins, but i know once kick off starts i will be barracking for QLD again. Habit i suppose
May 24th 2012 @ 8:22am
WobbliesFan said | May 24th 2012 @ 8:22am | Report comment
I predicted 8 in a row……NSW to win 1 series (because you can’t go on forever), then QLD to win another 2-3 just because they can, and just before the future immortals retire.
Our halves are the best ever….what you’re seeing in Smith, Thurston (Cronk/Lockyer) is unprecedented. Then you have Inglis, Slater…..etc, etc, etc, etc, etc. Just incredible generational talent. NSW have not, do not and can not match it.
Forget it, drown your sorrows and wait for the legacy to end, because it will only end on its terms, not NSW.
May 25th 2012 @ 12:06am
JVGO said | May 25th 2012 @ 12:06am | Report comment
NSW has the better younger players. Carney, Hayne, Uate, Jennings, Morris, Tamou, Stewart are all younger than their Qld counterparts and will soon supplant them. If Inglis was playing for NSW as he should they probably already would be. when this generation learns to win, they will be ruthless and it will be celbrated like it has really never been before.
May 30th 2012 @ 9:42pm
Ronnie the Eel said | May 30th 2012 @ 9:42pm | Report comment
yep, that’s how QLD won Origin 1 by a massive margin of 8 big points!!!
May 24th 2012 @ 9:06am
oikee said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:06am | Report comment
Mate, i feel your pain. Now just think this happened to Queensland players and fans for 70 years, NSW beating us senseless, even playing our own to give us a beating.
So open that wound, pour some salt onto it sow it back up, put yourself in a darkroom and lock yourself away for another 5 years.
You still feeling bad after that we might give you some relief.
Queenslanders wont get sick of winning, we know what is in stall for us once we do, you guys down south cant wait to throw salt onto our wounded.
It was funny last night, i heard Gus crying, i know it might be in the rules, but it is still a knock-on, to the Greg Inglis try.
Same as the torso rule Gus, it might have come off his torso, but it still is a knock on, this is what i have said for years, and rugby league needs to fix this nonsense.
What should have happened , we go to a break, the viseo ref looks at this incident, it is clear the ball has gone forward, so when the ads are over we have a guy on the sideline, like they do in NFL gridiron, he calls the play, blah blah blah, ball has been kicked out, the ball rolled forward, Queensland scrum 10 metres out, you know, like they do in Gridiron.
And then we only have to sit through one replay of the incident, not this endless looking at all angles while we could be making money from ads.
I am here to help you, it would have meant that NSW still were in the game fairly and squarely. As for this incident, remember 2006, the no try allowed to grothe, a massive off the torso knock on given a try. So stop your bleeding Ben, what goes around comes around. Queensland had 70 years of this injustice.
May 24th 2012 @ 9:41am
BW said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:41am | Report comment
You can’t even celebrate a Ref won game with humility.
May 24th 2012 @ 10:17am
Turnover said | May 24th 2012 @ 10:17am | Report comment
Where are you pulling this 70 years from? I am a Union man, but I thought Origin started in the 80′s.
May 24th 2012 @ 11:16am
oikee said | May 24th 2012 @ 11:16am | Report comment
Yes, your a union man, you have no idea of Queensland NSW rivalry, it started back in 1908 when we became a state run by our own government. A few years later we had our boys playing nSW, then the pokies kicked in and these used our players to beat us, this went on for many years, in the meantime our state had always been put down by NSW, its in the history books.
Its 100 years of rivalry. What your looking at is the reason Origin started in 1980. You know, everything has a porpose.
NSWales copping us a beating is our reason, no need for other codes to get angry.
That is why origin is such a unique concept for league.
May 24th 2012 @ 1:36pm
Ceebow said | May 24th 2012 @ 1:36pm | Report comment
Surley Gus didnt cry as bad as that sook Boyd hahahaha atleast Gus doesnt have tears rolling down his face like a little fkn baby. When he scored last night it was like watching a little kid getting his way but its obvious to see if he didnt he would of went back to Bennett in tears hahahaha and u qlders call us nswelshmen sooks hahaha thats rich.
May 24th 2012 @ 3:12pm
WobbliesFan said | May 24th 2012 @ 3:12pm | Report comment
You make the perfect NSW supporter, which makes it so much sweeter in victory.
May 24th 2012 @ 9:07am
Darryl said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:07am | Report comment
I don’t think that Qld really fired, so if that is the best that NSW has..god help you.
May 24th 2012 @ 9:13am
Lats said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:13am | Report comment
“When will it end? When will the unremitting torture cease and allow a proud-yet-clinically-depressed New South Welshman some psychological respite?”
Nothing personal big guy, but as a Maroons fan, I hope there is no respite.. EVER!!!
May 24th 2012 @ 9:25am
Gerry @ YourLawnAndGarden said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:25am | Report comment
Bit hard to win with 14 men against 13.
May 24th 2012 @ 10:53am
bestywins said | May 24th 2012 @ 10:53am | Report comment
I suppose it was the refs fault that Gallen decided to kick for goal, and it was his fault magain that when the blues had the chance to go deep into Queensland territory with a penalty Carney didn’t find touch and it’s his fault that a pass was thrown to mister nobody when the chips were down. The list goes on and on and on. Cop it on the chin champ that you played half hearted footy for 60 mins and didn’t even come close to scoring
May 24th 2012 @ 11:20am
oikee said | May 24th 2012 @ 11:20am | Report comment
And this from a team that bragged we need to make no mistakes. Even David Carney lost the ball cold trying to get up to play the ball.
And a player running in with a king hit at Taters head, what they want the refs to do, blow Gallen a kiss and say thats legal, you a sweetie Gals.
Mate, Queensland copped this for years from NSW, we had to become the bigger men in the end. And we did.
May 24th 2012 @ 9:27am
Upatya said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:27am | Report comment
Mate Harden up really the Maroons have built a side with world class players and have one other factor of stability which NSW quiet honestly lacks. Check the amount of changes they will make to their side for game 2 and then game 3. As for your comments on the refs, my friend rewatch the game, and some previous ones there has been some blinding inconsistancies. More often than not in favor of NSW. To really sort this problem out the game is big enough to get reps from other countries with no bias to either team. I would be one less complaint the blues would have however they would still only be finishing last in the two horse race.
May 24th 2012 @ 1:51pm
Ceebow said | May 24th 2012 @ 1:51pm | Report comment
You say qld have built a world class side, which means we need the game to be reffed fairly even more if that is the case. How the fk can u beat a world class side when the ref is giving them free passes? Even Qld greats admit the ref had a shocker.
May 24th 2012 @ 3:53pm
Gareth said | May 24th 2012 @ 3:53pm | Report comment
The only reason a QLD great would “admit” the ref had a shocker is to perpetuate this ridiculousness in the NSW camp that each loss is everyone’s fault but their own. It’s taken the Sharks two seasons to shake that sh*thouse attitude of entitlement and realise they’re the only ones who can win their own games. NSW needs to do the same, and the journey starts with sacking Ricky Stuart and his selfish, petulant, entitled attitudes.
May 24th 2012 @ 9:31am
Midfielder said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:31am | Report comment
I understand in part the pain… Out of left field this a youtube made in 2005 when the Socceroos finally made the WC after 32 years … it shows the pain of defeat and often ref’s and crowds calls… akin to last night if only NSW had the kicking boots… what about the shoulder on Haynes on the OLD line and then minutes latter a knock on gives the game to the toads … and then the gloating of the toads who refuse to admit their luck .. even tho they have some NSW players … OMG the pain…
Enjoy …. and our day will come…
Hope you enjoy Reverse the Curse [the curse was put on the Socceroos years before by a witchdoctor a huge tale in itself]
May 24th 2012 @ 9:31am
John said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:31am | Report comment
I….don’t think you even watched the match. NSW were more than matching it last night and weren’t even playing at their best; Carney’s average performance being the key indicator. With the side Queensland have compared to the sides NSW have fielded for the last few years, they should have won every series 3 – 0, and yet only 1 in 6 was a whitewash. You could hardly call that ‘laws of physics’; that NSW never stand a chance. When the Blue finally fielded a competent squad like they did this year (with the exception being most of the bench) it took some of the most universally aggravating ref decisions to pull it back into Queensland’s favour. They scored because of that send off, because of that ‘dangerous’ tackle, and because Inglis is exempt from the rulebook. Queensland definitely weren’t at their best though still defended strongly, but to merely shrug off the officiating as “Oh, it would be easy to blame the referees. Easy, and accurate. But we won’t get anywhere by heaping opprobrium on the officials.” is the opposite of truth. If Jennings had been given the same treatment as Thaiday has every series he’s played in, and if every wrong decision (as Harrigan admitted they were today) was reversed, I’d argue that NSW would have continued to build on the pressure they established in the opening 20 and went on to claim the first game. Your article would have a different shape to it then. The refs need to be berated until they don’t have the confidence for another rep call up, because they successfully managed to give an Origin game the intensity of a regular weekend round.
May 24th 2012 @ 11:27am
oikee said | May 24th 2012 @ 11:27am | Report comment
I dont remember Fiaday ever coming in third man and try to king hit someone in the head, dont know what games you been watching. that Jennings is nothing but a angry animal, he should have been sent off, would have been in a normal game, he is now public enemy number 1 in Queensland.
Joey Johns, your now off the hook.
May 24th 2012 @ 2:28pm
Mac said | May 24th 2012 @ 2:28pm | Report comment
You truly are special and not very gracious in a lucky victory either…QLD had nothing last night and they showed that in the second half by going nowhere when the piggy back penalties didn’t come like they did in the first half. Still the officials found a way to gift you guys a try and kill the contest. Did you happen to see Inglis in the post game interview. He was visibly embarrassed and understandably so…I’ve seen your other posts going on about 100 plus years of QLD pain and a whole bunch of other laughable rubbish. If you take pride in that victory then all power to you but don’t pretend you are the majority, any true league and or QLD fan would feel very hollow after last night…
May 24th 2012 @ 4:23pm
Pete said | May 24th 2012 @ 4:23pm | Report comment
I’m a “true league and or QLD fan” and I don’t feel hollow at all. Stop crying you sook. No wonder your state team is a joke
May 24th 2012 @ 5:34pm
Mac said | May 24th 2012 @ 5:34pm | Report comment
The joke will be on you when we play without cheating officials and mop the floor with your past it’s use by date forward pack.
May 25th 2012 @ 3:30pm
oikee said | May 25th 2012 @ 3:30pm | Report comment
What, you think i am on my own here, Mac. Look mate, every Queenslander has my back, we know the grub tactics that Gallen the Stewarts, watmoughs and whoever use.
The day you get us to be humble is the day the world stops turning, NSWales deserve every bit of anst, abuse and hated thrown at them, a gurb is a grub is a grub. Leopards dont change their spots.
Yes i said gurb, just to confuse welshmen.
I watched the 2011 1st game on fox, Gallen had his elbow in that many Queenslanders faces i am surprised we did not market his ugly forearm, it was inprinted on all our boys faces.
May 30th 2012 @ 9:53pm
Ronnie the Eel said | May 30th 2012 @ 9:53pm | Report comment
oikee is an excellent example of why QLD was developed as a state in the first place by people from NSW – to get rid of the unsightly and worst of the worst that would never admit when they were wrong and had an intense hatred of the whole population for no reason other than that they saw a few others do things that are nowhere near as bad as they do themselves….
then they act presently as if both NSW and QLD are made up of ppl that were born in the relevant state and that all ppl on the other side of the border are the same. and are thus his enemies… that’s just a prime example of the mentality of QLD supporters…..Dr Phil, they need you in QLD to help them resolve their fantasy resentment complexes!!
May 24th 2012 @ 12:09pm
Tree Hugger said | May 24th 2012 @ 12:09pm | Report comment
Actually Harrigan is denying that he told Ricky Stuart it should not have been a try.
http://www.couriermail.com.au/sport/nrl/referees-boss-bill-harrigan-denies-telling-nsw-coach-ricky-stuart-inglis-try-ruling-was-wrong/story-e6frepbx-1226365447068
Harrigan:
“I still haven’t reviewed the game yet and until I get back to Sydney and have a real good look at it (I won’t be able to say).
“I can tell you the video referee deems Farah plays it with his foot, the ball comes loose. That means it’s a live ball.
“And then when he (Inglis) puts his hands on the ball, that would be a try.”
May 24th 2012 @ 9:36am
Tony Archers Maroon Underwear said | May 24th 2012 @ 9:36am | Report comment
WOW the Qld News Ltd Salary Rorters won thats ‘amazing’ and there were a series of inexplicable ref calls that favored Queensland extraordinary! Same as last year and the year before and the year before and the year before and the year before….
Even more extraordinary than News ltd run of success is that people keep tuning into this boring BS
Heres a tip people grab yourself a copy of Ray Prices auto biography and book yourself in for a night on the couch for SOO2
May 24th 2012 @ 12:30pm
Lachlan Simpson said | May 24th 2012 @ 12:30pm | Report comment
mate… what on earth is the go with this salary cap rorters rubbish?? there’s no cap on origin and until you have substantial proof that would suggest the opposite, there are only 4 players out of 17 who had any connection to the salary cap at all. whats more, they were all legally cleared regardless of anyone’s personal opinions and finally, it was years ago. lets stop taking something old and unrelated and using it to fuel the bitterness of the worst period of origin NSW has ever experienced. instead, lets talk sense. there are plenty of people who can look at the game on its merits. if you think referees are the reason QLD have been so dominant you are completely delussional.
May 24th 2012 @ 3:42pm
Tony Archers Maroon Underwear said | May 24th 2012 @ 3:42pm | Report comment
The QLD News Ltd salary rorters have had a huge unspoken competitive advantage unobtainable in any way by NSW, by virtue of the fact that they are able to draw their players predominately from two News Ltd owned clubs Brisbane and Storm. These clubs (as has been proven with the storm) have operated outside the restrictions of the rest of the comp in that they have been able to maintain all their stars playing together year in and year out at the guaranteed highest level in the NRL.
The extent of the storms rorting is well known and if the league had any guts they’d be looking at the other News Ltd clubs. (Broncos im talking about you).
What do you mean by ‘legaly’ cleared do you mean the Deloitte report? I don’t think that legally cleared anybody just ask the player managers.
As for the Refs Im glad I didn’t watch the game as sounds like it was the same predictable garbage as with previous years
SOO is a farce all that it now regularly proves is that no matter how hard ya try a team of top class rorters who play together year in year out will beat a team thats got a weeks preparation…. If you don’t believe me just ask the Kiwis or super coach from Melbourne Stephen Kearney.
May 25th 2012 @ 8:35am
me said | May 25th 2012 @ 8:35am | Report comment
“they are able to draw their players predominately from two News Ltd owned clubs Brisbane and Storm”
And what has that got to do with Origin? Most non-sensical post this week – and from NSW there’s been a lot to choose from.
May 25th 2012 @ 11:30am
Lachlan Simpson said | May 25th 2012 @ 11:30am | Report comment
x2 this rambler is the most prejudiced writer i’ve ever seen. the storm playing group within the maroons is 3 players. broncos, havent been proven fruads but it should be noted that they provided 4 players also this year. moreover, QLD’s tnedancy to select players from the same clubs has far more to do with player availability than the salary cap. and the fact that you didnt even watch the game this year goes to show how out of touch you are with the game and how much of a whinging sook you really are.
May 25th 2012 @ 2:45pm
Tony Archers Maroon Underwear said | May 25th 2012 @ 2:45pm | Report comment
Hey me and LS
Just pointing out what should be obvious SOO has stopped being a worthwhile league/cultural event due to its lost credibility, despite what the Tele and papers keep yelling at you this is true
Slater, Boyd, Inglis, Hodges, Tate, Cronk, Smith, Civoniceva, Gillett, Taylor, Hannant and Thaiday.
Thats 12 out of 17 players that are Bronco and Storm players….a pretty significant proportion of a league team…no?
Interestingly there are only three non News Ltd employees in the current squad Myles, Harrison and.Shilllington.
And yes Origin now has everything to do with the cap as it would be impossible to pick a NSW side that could have had that kind of continuity.
As for the Broncos lets put things in perspective Parramatta were fined a small amount for breaking the cap last year…Parramatta and thats without Sandow.
So if Parra were over the Cap last year (seriously have a look at their team). How is it even remotely possible that the Broncos have been anywhere close to the cap for the last ten years?
jeez you’d have to be pretty prejudiced if you cant join the dots between those two clubs, QLD origin and the Salary Cap.
May 30th 2012 @ 10:08pm
Ronnie the Eel said | May 30th 2012 @ 10:08pm | Report comment
8 out of 17 of the QLD team are drawn from the Storm and Broncos teams, almost half of the side, with total representatives being picked from 5 different clubs. The sense it may make (for the benefit of QLD supporters who don’t have the ability of insight) is that if the nucleus of a side comes from two NRL teams means the majority of the players play together on a weekly basis and are thus more likely to gel together as a team than a side that picks from – especially with the talent available to them…. Compared with NSW where representatives come from 11 different clubs and maybe you will soon see some relevance…. that may make sense for the higgledy-piggeldy nature of the attacking efforts by NSW – not sure of a reason for the same from QLD though….