State of Origin Game II: NSW player ratings
By John Davidson, 13 Jun 2012 John Davidson is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- NRL, NSW Blues, Rugby League, State Of Origin, State of Origin 2012
Greg Bird of NSW in action during State of Origin between Queensland and New South Wales (AAP Image/Julian Smith)
Related coverage
Here are my New South Wales player ratings from the second game of the 2012 State of Origin series against Queensland at ANZ Stadium.
NSW Player Ratings
Brett Stewart
The Manly fullback was shaky in the first half, almost conceding a try in his own in-goal. But he fought back well and burrowed over for a try, then supported Carney brilliantly to grab a second.
Rating: 7.5
Jarryd Hayne
Hot and cold for the Eel. Again solid on the wing, good in defence and dangerous with the ball in hand but made a few mistakes. Pulled a rabbit out his hat by setting up the flukiest of tries with a knock-on-cum-toe-ahead.
Rating: 6.5
Michael Jennings
Quietish in the first half but tackled well and attacked the line well to test the line.
Rating: 6.5
Josh Morris
Few opportunities to run the ball but dependable in defence against Greg Inglis. Great second half try and opportunistic to be in the right place at the right time.
Rating: 7
Akuila Uate
Came up with a howler at the end of the first half, not jumping to catch a bomb which was seized on by Ben Hannant for a Queensland try. Failed under the bomb with Tate tapping to Inglis. He was ok when running the ball and nearly scored – perhaps too honest.
Rating: 4.5
Todd Carney
Much, much better than Game I. Was very good in defence and kicked better in general play, also setting up a try. Though only kicked two goals from four attempts.
Rating: 7
Mitchell Pearce
Made some really good hits in defence and was solid without being flashy in attack.
Rating: 6.5
Trent Merrin
Didn’t come on in the first half but did his job in the second.
Rating: 6
Robbie Farah
One of the Blues best. Kicked well out of dummy half and worked his arse off in defence. Made a heroic 66 tackles.
Rating: 8.5
Paul Gallen
Typical warhorse display from the Cronulla captain, showed great leadership.
Rating: 7.5
Glenn Stewart
Well contained by Queensland again, will little chance to show his ball-playing ability, but defended strongly.
Rating: 6
Luke Lewis
Made an impact when he came on in the first half with some tackle-breaking runs. Then smashed several Queenslanders as he defended like a man possessed in the second 40.
Rating: 7
James Tamou
Not huge minutes but was handful for the Maroon defence.
Rating: 6.5
Greg Bird
Like his former Cronulla teammate Gallen, this was another workman-like performance from a player who relishes the tough stuff. Picked up the man of the match award.
Rating: 8
Tim Grant
Was strong early, putting Petero on his bum with the opening tackle. Had a good debut and will retain his spot.
Rating: 7
Anthony Watmough
Didn’t get huge minutes but didn’t let anyone done when he was on,
Rating: 6.5
Ben Creagh
Again struggled to get into the game, with little minutes and not much impact, and again will be under pressure to keep his spot.
Rating: 5
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- How to increase crowd numbers in the NRL (180)
- How rugby league should expand (132)
- All I am saying is give Pearce a chance (123)
- Why do NRL fans love empty seats? (115)
- Let me tell you why people don’t like Manly (103)
- Ease up on ASADA: NRL boss (90)
- It’s time for Channel Nine to get serious about the NRL (88)
- Is Tom Waterhouse ‘off’ in the government’s eyes? (5)
- Waterhouse $50m NRL deal ‘dead’: reports (2)
- Magpies want equal place in Tigers merger (20)
- Walsh debunks the rigmarole of kicking for goal (13)
- The Knights have arrived, but will they stay? (10)
- NRL the closest competition in the world…just not this week (58)
- The resurgence of the Sydney Roosters (18)
- Is Tom Waterhouse ‘off’ in the government’s eyes? (5)
- Walsh debunks the rigmarole of kicking for goal (13)
- The Knights have arrived, but will they stay? (10)
- The resurgence of the Sydney Roosters (18)
- Newcastle Knights vs Canterbury Bulldogs: NRL Live scores, blog (89)
- Cronulla Sharks vs Canberra Raiders: NRL live scores, blog (100)
- North Queensland Cowboys vs Sydney Roosters: NRL live scores, blog (91)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- NRL, NSW Blues, Rugby League, State Of Origin, State of Origin 2012

June 13th 2012 @ 11:02pm
Johnno said | June 13th 2012 @ 11:02pm | Report comment
farah for me the best player on the pitch followed by tim grant then paul gallen in 3rd spot.
June 13th 2012 @ 11:02pm
Johnno said | June 13th 2012 @ 11:02pm | Report comment
tim grant 2nd best after farah then paul gallen in 3rd spot.
June 13th 2012 @ 11:06pm
Shungmao said | June 13th 2012 @ 11:06pm | Report comment
Tamou not enough game time, I thought Carney was ordinary but happy to be convinced otherwise, Lewis and Morris inspirational . Farrah strong effort but an 8.5 in not sure. Stuart’s bench should change with Creagh out and Matteo in.
June 13th 2012 @ 11:06pm
Shungmao said | June 13th 2012 @ 11:06pm | Report comment
Tamou not enough game time, I thought Carney was ordinary but happy to be convinced otherwise, Lewis and Morris inspirational . Farrah strong effort but an 8.5 in not sure. Stuart’s bench should change with Creagh out and Matteo in.
June 13th 2012 @ 11:37pm
turbodewd said | June 13th 2012 @ 11:37pm | Report comment
Pearce’s kicks dont quite rack up the distance required. He’s not very dangerous. He is more of a journeyman’s halfback, will not have u troubled in defence.
Carney’s goalkicking is not Origin caliber. Thurston and Cronk and 2 notches above the Blues halves.
June 14th 2012 @ 11:49am
Jimbo said | June 14th 2012 @ 11:49am | Report comment
I realise it was wet, but surely Pearce’s tactic of putting bombs through within the Qld 20 doesn’t make much sense, considering the aerial skill of players like Inglis, Tate, and Hodges? The one grubber that Pearce did kick would have been a Carney try if not for the disgraceful play of Cronk. Surely that would have been an indication that the grubber was a better tactic than the bomb?
June 14th 2012 @ 12:15am
Pete75 said | June 14th 2012 @ 12:15am | Report comment
Robbie Farah tonight broke the record for number of tackles in an Origin match.
Not an Origin type player?
Not tough enough?
June 14th 2012 @ 8:14am
Andy said | June 14th 2012 @ 8:14am | Report comment
Man of the match should have been Robbie Farah and my two points would go to Brett Stewart because without either NSW lose.
June 14th 2012 @ 8:30am
Tony said | June 14th 2012 @ 8:30am | Report comment
Andy,
Your right I thought Birdy was lucky to get Nines man of the match
Farah was epic… Stewart’s Tries power and speed
“GO BLUE”S”
big test in third origin though
June 14th 2012 @ 11:24am
Renegade said | June 14th 2012 @ 11:24am | Report comment
Bird was the best by far.
Farah was great as was Gallen. I didn’t think Brett Stewart had that good a game, he was shaky at the back and he scored 2 tries one was all thanks to Carney and the other was a well worked set play which we have to obviously clap Stewart because he did tremdously well to get over the line.
Once again Merrin and Creagh look out of their depth…..bring in Hinchcliffe and T-rex if his recovered, otherwise Mateo.
June 14th 2012 @ 8:38am
sledgeross said | June 14th 2012 @ 8:38am | Report comment
Disagree, Bird was there doing plenty of tough hit ups when required, and pulled off some big hits in defence. Farah did everything that was asked of him and more in an epic performance, but for mine, Bird was our best player.
June 14th 2012 @ 9:11am
Fivehole said | June 14th 2012 @ 9:11am | Report comment
Bird knocked on at least 3 times. Once he was lucky as the refs bailed him out.
Speaking of the refs, isn’t it fantastic to be talking about the players and not the referees. A good job last night.
June 14th 2012 @ 11:39am
Charles said | June 14th 2012 @ 11:39am | Report comment
Bird was absolutely devastating doing some huge hits at crucial times! Farah was also outstanding, it was hard to split the two but I also gave it to Bird! Gallen again right up there doing his job as if it is 2nd nature! Pearce is rated too highly, he is a passenger into what is such a crucial role, he has to go! Hayne is wasted on the wing, bring back Brett Morris and drop Uate! Merrin and Creagh are not up to it and replace with Hinchcliffe is a wise move as he is tough and can play well as a back rower if not needed as hooker!
June 14th 2012 @ 1:01pm
John said | June 14th 2012 @ 1:01pm | Report comment
Everyone is saying drop Uate. He isn’t in great form, I will give you that but he is the best winger in Australia when he is in form. He will get the job done in SOO 3. As a loyal Brisbane and QLD supporter, let me tell you I fear no one more than Uate when he is on song.
June 14th 2012 @ 11:04am
sledgeross said | June 14th 2012 @ 11:04am | Report comment
Yep, Bird did drop teh ball a bit. Doesnt change the fact he was our best forward and stood up when we needed him t5o.
June 14th 2012 @ 11:38am
george said | June 14th 2012 @ 11:38am | Report comment
i hate queenslanders but credit due the refs wer nt blamed by meniga and smith so that was it no more carry on