Italy break English hearts through penalties in Euro 2012
Related coverage
In world soccer, there surely is no greater anguish than a penalty shoot-out involving England.
It’s agony to watch because you know in advance how it will end – with England players, proud men like Steven Gerrard, walking like the dead off the pitch, alone in a world of torment, regret and what-ifs after falling short once again in the toughest, cruellest test any sport has devised for players’ minds.
This time, against Italy in the most enthralling of the four Euro 2012 quarter-finals, the names that got added to England’s hall of penalty infamy were both Ashleys, Young and Cole.
The winger and the left back swelled the sorry group of England players who cracked while faced with just an opposing goalkeeper and their own fear of failure.
Their predecessors included the likes of David Beckham and Gareth Southgate, who managed to turn the shame of his missed penalty at Euro ’96 into a joke, appearing in a pizza commercial with his head hidden in a paper bag.
And Cole and Young won’t be the last. Because England’s record of failure in shootouts is now so consistently awful that it has become a running sore on the national psyche.
The loss to Italy took England’s record in seven World Cup and European Championships shootouts to: Rest of the world 6, England 1.
One.
Uno.
Ein.
No matter the language, that is the astounding number.
Luck is part of it. So is preparation. But mostly, penalty shootouts are won between the ears.
They are about confidence, belief and being able to shut out that inner voice whispering, “You are going to miss this.” The goal looks smaller than it is, the keeper looms like a giant.
Gerrard, who slotted home England’s first penalty early on Monday morning after 120 minutes of football ended 0-0, has described England’s penalty curse as a “mental block”.
In his biography, he suggested England must start practising shootouts at the end of friendly matches, while the stadium is still full.
So that’s an idea for the future. But, in Kiev’s Olympic Stadium, it was just pain.
“We have done the country proud but again we go home with heartbreak and it’s difficult to take,” said Gerrard.
This was the eighth time that Italy has faced a shootout in World Cups and the Euros. It has now won three.
FIFA boss Sepp Blatter isn’t a fan of shootouts, saying last month that “when football goes to penalty kicks, it loses its essence as a team sport”.
He has asked German great Franz Beckenbauer to see if an alternative is possible.
But shootouts are unbeatable drama. This one was no exception.
Like gladiators about to face the lions together, the two keepers, Joe Hart and Italy’s Gianluigi Buffon, shared a hand-slap of mutual respect before the shooting began.
Italy’s Riccardo Montolivo was the first to crack, firing his penalty wide of Hart’s right-hand post. He buried his head in his hands. Perhaps, just perhaps, this might be England’s night after all.
But no.
Young shot high, his penalty slamming off Buffon’s crossbar. England manager Roy Hodgson chewed his lip.
Next up for England was Cole. The Chelsea player nervously licked his lips on the long walk from the centre of the pitch to the penalty spot. He placed the ball on the turf, took seven steps back and stood hands on hips.
Uh-oh, clearly, he was thinking about it too much. Sure enough, his run-up was slow and his shot to Buffon’s left was tame. The Italian guessed correctly, making the block.
Alessandro Diamante then finished the job, ramming the dagger through English hearts by shooting cleanly past Hart.
Cue Italian delirium.
© AFP 2013Sport, all day long. Does this sound too good to be true? We're searching for a Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. If you're a sales star who doesn't mind a hit, kick, throw, or cycle, we want to hear from you. Apply now.

June 25th 2012 @ 10:03am
Worlds Biggest said | June 25th 2012 @ 10:03am | Report comment
Once it went to penalties everyone knew what the outcome was going to be, must have been galling for English supporters. Until England develop creative midfielders and strikers they will always find themselves in penalty shoot outs.This is obviously hampered by the littany of foreign players in the EPL who also happen to be the best midfielders and strikers. The EPL is fantastic but it is also detrimental to English football.
June 25th 2012 @ 11:33am
Bondy said | June 25th 2012 @ 11:33am | Report comment
Thats the rub isnt it, England has built a league that is without doubt the biggest globally with players from Togo, Australia, South Korea Brasil Oman America Argentina and so on.
But theres nothing there for english junior development apart from really Wenger developing Walcott and the Ox thats the English breeding programme find whats english at Arsenal and young,problem not solved.
I have no logical nor rational reason to think England as a footballing nation can sit somewhere near top 6 in world football is beyond me and it illustrates the world rankings are for commercial reasons and no other.
June 28th 2012 @ 12:34pm
Sky Blue Ram said | June 28th 2012 @ 12:34pm | Report comment
Worlds Biggest and Bondy
It’s a popular misconception that england are worse since the influx of foreign players. Logic dictates if you play against the best you’ll improve and since the advent of the EPL England’s records HAS improved. Read Why England Lose for exact stats. (I think our record of wins and draws has gone from 60% to 66%, but don’t quote me, that’s from memory).
June 25th 2012 @ 10:13am
Johnno said | June 25th 2012 @ 10:13am | Report comment
Wouldn’t of fmattered anyway today, England never could beat Germany in penalties, they would of lost on penalties to the germans.
-Germany have never lost a match in a major tournament on penalties, yes never. Just shows the mental strength difference between these 2 teams and football records.
Germany and Italy will be a cracker. England football i still stuck on the long ball andphysical strikers like alan shearer and now wayne rooney. No messi or kaka or Recoba types. Aoran Lennon and the walkout had hope but they faded.
Now England record in last 22 years with penalties
-Italia 90 lose to who else but germany
-euro 96 lost to ho else again but the masters of penalties Germany
-lose France 98 to Argentina on penalties
-lose to Portugal 2006 penalties
-lose euro 2004 to portugal on penalties
-lose today euro 2012 on penalties to italy
Chris waddle,stuart pearce, gareth southgate, david buckram among the names and infamous list and many more
June 25th 2012 @ 12:59pm
Brian said | June 25th 2012 @ 12:59pm | Report comment
For the record Germany lost the 1976 Euro Final on penalties
June 25th 2012 @ 10:34am
Colin N said | June 25th 2012 @ 10:34am | Report comment
Not sure it broke English hearts, in effect justice was done. England were poor and negative while Italy, with the majestic Pirlo, controlled the game.
While it is disappointing to once again lose in this manner, it would have been bordering on a farce if England had progressed.
The reality is that we need to produce more technically gifted players. There is a sign of that with the likes of Wilshere, Ross Barkley, Jack Rodwell and Josh McEachran looking like those type of players, but we can’t rely on a select few, there needs to be a change of mindset in youth coaching.
June 25th 2012 @ 3:05pm
Walt said | June 25th 2012 @ 3:05pm | Report comment
it would have been bordering on a farce if England had progressed.
Why exactly?
Just like England, the Italians had two solid hours to score and were unable to do so. The game was not dirty, nor was the referee deliberately giving one team an advantage.
Two teams played different styles of football and those styles were ineffective on the night. So we get penalties.
June 25th 2012 @ 8:50pm
Colin N said | June 25th 2012 @ 8:50pm | Report comment
Fair points but I repeat, it would have been unjust if we had progressed.
Maybe ‘bordering on a farce’ is a bit strong, but I think Fussball summed it up pretty well. It was amazing how shattered they looked considering they had very rarely looked to close Italy down and almost strolled around the pitch for 120 minutes.
It also shows the value of keeping the ball and it will be interesting to see what happens with Hodgson, whether he tries to develop that style.
June 25th 2012 @ 10:52am
Swampy said | June 25th 2012 @ 10:52am | Report comment
Johnno – pretty sure that, if by some miracle, had England won the penalty shootout, Germany would have eliminated them in the regular 90 minutes in the next game.
England are very good across the back 4. However going forward of that line there is huge issues.
England can’t at present keep the ball. This needs to change for any success to be had.
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
June 25th 2012 @ 11:58am
Johnno said | June 25th 2012 @ 11:58am | Report comment
Swampy i agree Germany are such such such a fine fine side. I love and envy there soccer so much.
England record compared to Germany is embarrassingly bad. Germany are like steffi graph or federer just keeps on winning tournaments or always is in the drivers seat come the crunch, so many semi finals, finals, and winners medals compared to woefully inflated we are the so called home of football england. And the overrated premier league give me the bundesliga any day of the week too.
To me Gemrany are total football not the dutch just look at the records.
Hiddink wasn’t dutch so to speak, he was a wizard in a world of his own. A 1 off like a Garincha of Brazil.
But Germany are the masters of total football for me, and there style right now is so modern and good under gorge low only spain is better.
- However germany’s only bogey side inw old football is Italy. The only side in world football Gemrany almost never beats in a major tournament. LIke penalties are England’s kryptonite so are Italy.
Italy have the best defence off all time, and Germany is a narrow 2nd. Germany should maybe win butt Buffon is still playing well in goals.
SO much young strike power the gemrans have will be a cracker just Germany but never write off Italy the ultimate party poppers.
Italy through sheer will of a defensive wall have ruins so many world cup and euro dreams eg germany 2006.
And then they grind out a goal in the 1 opportunity they get eg Socceroos and vs Germany.
Both great sides. We need to go more german in our system i am happy we have gone for holger a german over another fly in fly out dutchman like Pim.
And Mark swarcher our great goalkeeper and penalty shoot out specialist and penalty shot stopper is German heritage both his parents are german born and bread, says a lot about Gemrany’s penalty quality and quality when our very own Goal keeper is genetically German.
June 25th 2012 @ 1:55pm
die manschaft said | June 25th 2012 @ 1:55pm | Report comment
‘ Italy have the best defence off all time’ Not at Euro 2012 they dont, given up 1-0 leads twice already. Italian sides of the past would’ve ground out 1-0 wins.
‘And then they grind out a goal in the 1 opportunity they get eg Socceroos and vs Germany.’ Tell that to Balotelli – should’ve had 2-3 this morning.
June 25th 2012 @ 12:00pm
Worlds Biggest said | June 25th 2012 @ 12:00pm | Report comment
Agree Johnno, Germany are a fantastic team, they will win it all.
June 25th 2012 @ 12:41pm
Stevo said | June 25th 2012 @ 12:41pm | Report comment
When it came to penalties a small part of me wanted England to win so that Germany could pulverise them into the dirt – also would have been fun watching Frau Merkel getting excited as a school girl. As it was the Poms limped into the penalty shootout without hardly troubling Gigi’s goals. What an absolutely negative display from Hodgson and the boys. Anti-football played football this morning and fortunately football won – but only just ‘cos penalty shootouts are a lottery. England’s position in the world’s top 10 is a joke.
June 25th 2012 @ 12:54pm
Fussball ist unser leben said | June 25th 2012 @ 12:54pm | Report comment
For me – as a neutral observer – it would have been unbearable anguish if England had WON the penalty shoot-out.
Normally, I look at the desolate looks on the vanquished players’ faces & feel their pain. Their sorrow. Their sense of despair knowing it will be at least 4 years before they ever get this chance again – for some, the chance will never repeat.
But, today, ENG didn’t deserve anything. Yes, ENG was gallant & adventurous in the 1st half – a total contrast to the 270 minutes of rubbish we’ve seen so far at Eurot2012 from the country that is “the birthplace of our Beautiful Game”.
Thereafter, ENG was back to its worst. No creativity, No adventure. No risks. No energy. No urgency.
So, I’m glad they’re out. Many of these players may never play for ENG again and they’ll be left wondering “what if”.
From afar, it seems to me, there’s something very very wrong with ENG football, which is an odd thing to observe when the ENG professional football league is the most watched & generates the most revenue of all football leagues. I think the EPL needs a major overhaul with serious consideration given to improving the number of “local players” in every squad.
The Bundesliga has set minimum limits for “local players” at each club and the contrast between the quality of the Die ationalmannschaft & The Three Lions has never been greater than at this tournament.
We can only be thankful these two nations didn’t play each other in the Semi-Final since the GER score could have reached double figures.
June 25th 2012 @ 3:17pm
Walt said | June 25th 2012 @ 3:17pm | Report comment
I too usually feel a touch of sadness for the team eliminated on penalties – but then I remember the millions of pounds, the women and the sports cars. I didnt feel anything for England this morning.
As for Englands game-plan, they still rely on the old blood n guts method that won them a World Cup 50-odd years ago. Their reluctance to play a more European style has cost them repeatedly. They dont hold the ball up well, dont force the opposition to react and last night a lot of their players were too happy to give the ball away rather than take responsibility of where it should go.
Their one genuine strike threat, Rooney, had a bad night and may have scored 2-3 if the game were at Old Trafford and he was in his familiar red shirt.
Still, like or loathe England, it isnt a tournament without them. They have done their bit – now down to the big boys.
June 25th 2012 @ 8:23pm
MV Dave said | June 25th 2012 @ 8:23pm | Report comment
So disappointed in this England performance. Over 23 million in England watched on TV as their team could barely pass or control the ball. The gulf between the teams was huge and having been born in England it pains to say that the national team is light years behind the best in the world. Massive changes required from the junior development right through to the professional set up. Will the FA have the balls to make the required changes and more importantly convince the biggest clubs to play a role.
June 25th 2012 @ 9:01pm
Steve said | June 25th 2012 @ 9:01pm | Report comment
Surely the fact that England are so consistently bad at penalties puts paid to the notion that penalties are ‘a lottery’: the idea of a guaranteed outcome contradicts the very concept, and with England, the result is never in doubt.