Reds sneak home against Highlanders
Related coverage
Wallabies five-eighth Quade Cooper played his best game of 2012 as Queensland kept their Super Rugby title defence alive with a nail-biting 19-13 win over the Highlanders on Friday night.
The Reds almost gave up a 16-point second-half lead before escaping with a penultimate-round victory with three minutes of gutsy defence on fulltime at Suncorp Stadium.
The desperate Highlanders attacked the line over multiple phases but a string of try-saving tackles, including two by man-of-the-match Cooper, saved the day before Jake Schatz produced a ruck turnover.
Their fifth straight win moves Queensland into the top six with just their last-round match against arch-rivals NSW to come on Saturday week.
A loss would have virtually been curtains for the home side who would have dropped to eighth.
Cooper, noticeably growing in confidence in his fourth match back from knee surgery, was a stand-out to show he’s back near the form which took the Reds to last year’s title.
The Wallabies five-eighth regularly took on the advantage line, muscled up in defence and threw some signature spiral passes that put his teammates into space.
The goalkicking of Mike Harris, who slotted five from six, was also crucial for the Reds as they scored one try to the Highlanders’ two.
Queensland looked home and hosed when prop James Slipper was rewarded for a strong display with a 57th-minute try in the right corner for a 16-3 lead.
But the Highlanders fired back with tries to Adam Thomson and Chris King off the back of concerted pressure to close the gap to six points with six minutes left.
Missed conversions cost the visitors dearly, meaning they needed a converted try at the death to win instead of a mere penalty goal, which they could have taken.
The win came at a worrying cost for the Reds as lock Rob Simmons (knee), flanker Beau Robinson (foot) and winger Chris F’Sautia (hamstring) were all injured.
It was gut-wrenching to see teenage talent F’Sautia tear his hamstring as he made one of the few line breaks of the first half off a Cooper cut-out pass.
The Australian Under-20 three-quarter has battled hamstring issues for the past three years and Queensland had believed they had solved his problems.
The previous match between the two sides resulted in a 11-try special but that was in stark contrast to a stop-start first half dominated by Jonathan Kaplan’s whistle and Highlanders handling errors.
“We’ve got to get some clarity around the breakdown,” frustrated Reds coach Ewen McKenzie said as his side led 6-3 at halftime. “It’s pretty hard work there, they’re counter-rucking pretty hard.”
Relieved Reds captain Will Genia praised his team’s backs-to-the-wall effort in an energy-sapping end to the game.
“It’s all about character, especially at the breakdown contest and defence, and when you’re pushed to the limits on your tryline you just have to front up and we did,” Genia said.
Queensland now sit one point behind the Brumbies (54) on the Australian conference table and require the ACT-based team to lose their last two matches against NSW and the Blues to be a realistic chance of hosting a play-off.
Coach Ewen McKenzie defended their decisions to take penalty goals instead of tries for a bonus point.
“I can guarantee that if you say `we’ll go out there and score four tries’ it doesn’t happen,” McKenzie said.
“Everyone can be an expert sitting on the sideline (but) you have to get the four points first.”
Kaplan whistled 27 penalties for the match and, while 17 were against Queensland, the Highlanders ended the match incensed that no Reds were sin-binned for the 10 penalties they received while on hard attack.
“The amount of penalties in the red-zone hindered our game,” said coach Jamie Joseph.
“We certainly did enough to win that game and that’s what’s most frustrating.”
Joseph also revealed the South African whistle-blower entered their dressing room before the match to warn three Highlanders about their discipline at the ruck.
“That’s the first time that’s ever happened in my experience,” he said.
© AAP 2013The Crowd Says (10) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Highlanders, Reds, Rugby Union, Super Rugby

July 7th 2012 @ 8:50am
stillatragic said | July 7th 2012 @ 8:50am | Report comment
Well done Reds. I thought they were the better team with the ball in hand but the game was played by the whistle and that never leads to a good spectacle. I agree, a yellow card to either team may have tidied things up. Kaplan warned both teams enough, and the Reds’ scoring opportunities were almost always disrupted. 3 points lost rather than 5 or 7. I’m sure I’ve seen discussion on those tactics. Anyone know why was Cooper penalised for what seemed an innocuous tackle? Now if the Tahs beat the Brumbies tonight……
July 7th 2012 @ 11:13am
Jutsie said | July 7th 2012 @ 11:13am | Report comment
Kaplan said it was dangerous because he used his leg to bring the bloke to ground, was bloody pedantic and so were the two intentional knock down rules.
Kaplan made several yellow card warnings but never actually went to the pocket, was a very poor performance by him.
July 7th 2012 @ 12:41pm
Red Kev said | July 7th 2012 @ 12:41pm | Report comment
Yeah that call about the tackle being dangerous was complete crap.
July 7th 2012 @ 12:24pm
redsnut said | July 7th 2012 @ 12:24pm | Report comment
The knock down by QC looked to me as a genuine attempt to catch the ball, as he had two hands up for it.
I don’t have a recording, and it looked like it bounced off his arms.
July 7th 2012 @ 1:01pm
Jutsie said | July 7th 2012 @ 1:01pm | Report comment
Yeah and he was out in the clear for a runaway try if he caught it as there were no highlanders near him, why would he intentionally knock it down in that instance instead of catching it.
I think kaplan has been listening to justin marshall’s commentary a bit too much.
July 7th 2012 @ 2:20pm
Red Block said | July 7th 2012 @ 2:20pm | Report comment
Lucky for Kaplan the Reds got over the line. The crowd at Suncorp were ready to lynch him.
He and Bryce Lawrence should be denied entry to Australia as ‘characters of ill repute’.
Best part of the night though was Aunty Shirley, an Aboriginal elder, who welcomed every one and said, ‘Now enjoy the game between the Qld Reds and … Um??’
Classic!
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
July 7th 2012 @ 4:14pm
atlas said | July 7th 2012 @ 4:14pm | Report comment
. . . McKenzie defended their decisions to take penalty goals instead of tries . . .
and the right decision that was; wonder how Joseph would answer the same question as they gave up shots at goal in favour of another scrum early on, esp when it became apparent Kaplan had left his yellow card in the locker room.
Even though it was season over without a bonus point win, ‘a win is a win’
July 7th 2012 @ 11:06pm
Mick said | July 7th 2012 @ 11:06pm | Report comment
The rub of the green and all favored Q’Land. Kaplan was unsighted on the last play to see one: Genia hadn’t released Mackintosh; two Schatz was off his feet (not supporting his body weight) playing the ball; and three: Mackintosh had released the ball it just took the reds a while to pick it up because they were coming in from the side, off their feet and not supporting their body weight. Possible penalty try? Wouldn’t that have been interesting for the finals.
Regardless, the Highlanders missed their opportunities earlier and despite it being Cowan’s last game playing him ahead of Smith cost them quick recycle ball to play with through a challenging back line.
Think the Reds will make it to the finals (given the Waratahs brain farting propensity to kick away good ball constantly) and then it’s anyone’s game as I think the top four teams from NZ (Chiefs & Crusaders) and Oz (Brumbies and Reds) can take any game on the day, all have good forward packs that can consistently keep possession and backs that can attack. As to the SA teams, well waiting on the Stormers (who may get a fright from a desperate Cheetahs) but I think they will get through with the Bulls and then we’ll see which style of game can win finals rugby again.
Here’s hoping it’s running attacking rugby and not defensive offense and territory. Given an upswing in these games for the refs to favor the team holding the ball at the breakdown it may favor the former style.
July 8th 2012 @ 9:24am
Dasher said | July 8th 2012 @ 9:24am | Report comment
With the Sharks all -too-conveniently taking a bonus point try over the Bulls and a South African referee killing any opportunity for the Reds to get a bonus point, I think we’ll now see three South African sides in the finals and only one Australian. Suspect ha…
July 8th 2012 @ 9:41pm
Matty said | July 8th 2012 @ 9:41pm | Report comment
its about quality not quantity. I suspect the SA sides will drop out like flies come finals time