Reds vs Sharks: Super Rugby finals live scores, blog
By Elisha Pearce, 21 Jul 2012 Elisha Pearce is a Roar Guru & Live Blogger
- Tagged:
- live blog, Queensland Reds, Rugby Union, Sharks, Super Rugby
347 Have your say
Will Genia hits the line for the Queensland Reds (Image: Steve Bell / White Devil Images)
The Super Rugby finals are underway and the Reds start their campaign by hosting the Sharks at Suncorp tonight. Join us from 7.30pm AEST for live scores and commentary.
Coming into this match the Reds have been playing their best rugby of the season. That is a claim most Sharks fans would make as well. Given recent form we have enough reason to expect a high quality finals match tonight.
Let’s have a quick look at both sides recent form since the international break to familiarise ourselves with what could be on offer:
Reds
- Beat NSW by 16
- Beat Highlanders by 6 (defended their line to the death to win
- Beat Rebels by 15
Sharks
- Beat Cheetahs by 19
- Beat Bulls by 22
- Bye
Scoring points hasn’t been a big issue for either side since they came back from the break.
The Reds’ victory against the Waratahs last week is a standout performance for them in a match-up that usually produces little scoring.
Couple that with the fact they’ve put 30 on the board twice in their three matches back and you would have to say they are hitting their straps.
The only time they were stifled was against the Highlanders. While they may have deserved to be chasing that match from behind, a standout feature was defending a slender lead to save their season near full-time.
Looking at the Sharks performances I’d be tempted to say they are burning even hotter than the Reds now. Beating the Sharks by 22 points is no mean feat.
It was in Durban and that would have helped but I don’t think anyone would have picked the Sharks by 20-plus and been prepared to put much money behind it. You just don’t see the Bulls blown out like that too often.
They did what they had to do last week against the Cheetahs in a match that only got going in the second half.
They were perhaps a little complacent knowing they couldn’t top their conference and had an eye on this week. It wasn’t an indicator of a drop in form.
There are a couple of factors on each side of this match that could impact scoring: injured playmakers.
The Reds will be missing Quade Cooper and the Sharks Pat Lambie and Frans Steyn. Ben Lucas will fill Cooper’s spot. Frederic Michalak and Tim Whitehead fill in for Lambie and Steyn.
The loss of Cooper will be a definitive impact on the Reds, but it will probably be evened out by the fact the Sharks will be trying to integrate two new players in those important roles.
The Reds went through a slump earlier in the season while Cooper was still recovering from his knee injury, but the losses were more because of the attrition of the second, third and fourth choices at that position as well. Lucas has played quite well in the 10 jersey when required this year.
Michalak is an experienced campaigner now and while not as swift and tricky as in his earlier days will understand what is required to keep the team moving and playing to the team’s plan.
An interesting selection from either side, the Reds have Ben Tapaui back on the bench and the Sharks have picked the impressive Willem Alberts in the second row for this clash.
Alberts has been having somewhat of a break-out season this year, cementing himself as one of the best ball running loose forwards in the game.
Positioning him in the second row is interesting and means Keegan Daniel, Marcell Coetzee and Ryan Kankowski all fit in the starting side.
Those players are going to take some real tackling. Ice packs required for the Reds shoulders come Sunday, no matter the outcome.
The return of Tapaui on the pine is great for the Reds, he can’t be back to full match fitness yet, but he will add some real spark and line breaking ability later in the match as the opposition begin to tire.
Ewen McKenzie would be smart to make sure he gets on around the 60th minute to allow time for him to make his presence felt.
Should Tapaui play well, it wouldn’t be out of the realm of possibility for him to get the nod to join the Wallabies training squad as another long-term option in a weak position.
Everything is poised for a fantastic match tonight. The weather is looking like it will stay fine. So hopefully we see two teams throwing themselves into it! Don’t forget to join us here from 7.30pm AEST for updates, scores and a chance to voice your opinion!
Have you seen the new Wallabies jersey? Want one of your own? We're giving away a brand new 2013 Wallabies jersey to one lucky Roarer, click here to go in the running to win.
The Crowd Says (347) | Page 1 of Comments
The Roar Live Blog: Latest comments displayed at the top of the page | Click here to jump to leave a comment
Have Your Say
Game Information
TeamsReds
15. Luke Morahan
14. Dom Shipperley
13. Anthony Faingaa
12. Mike Harris
11. Digby Ioane
10. Ben Lucas
9. Will Genia (c)
8. Scott Higginbotham
7. Liam Gill
6. Jake Schatz
5. Adam Wallace-Harrison
4. Rob Simmons
3. James Slipper
2. Saia Faingaa
1. Greg Holmes
Replacements
16. James Hanson
17. Ben Daley
18. Radike Samo,
19. Jarrad Butler
20. Beau Robinson
21. Nick Frisby
22. Ben Tapuai
Sharks
15. Louis Ludik
14. JP Pietersen
13. Paul Jordaan
12. Tim Whitehead
11. Lwazi Mvovo
10. Frederic Michalak
9. Charl McLeod
8. Ryan Kankowski
7. Marcell Coetzee
6. Keegan Daniel (c)
5. Anton Bresler
4. Willem Alberts
3. Jannie du Plessis
2. Bismarck du Plessis
1. Tendai Mtawarira
Replacements
16. Craig Burden
17. Wiehahn Herbst
18. Steven Sykes
19. Jacques Botes
20. Cobus Reinach
21. Meyer Bosman
22. Odwa Ndungane
Kick-Off: 7.30pm AEST
Venue: Suncorp Stadium
Referee: Jonathan Kaplan
Last Time: Sharks 27-22 Reds
History: Reds 8, Sharks 6
Betting: $1.52 Reds, $2.55 Sharks
TV: Fox Sports 3 (LIVE)
Latest Rugby Union live odds
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- live blog, Queensland Reds, Rugby Union, Sharks, Super Rugby



4:07am
Dexter William said | 4:07am | Report comment
“Simmons is the new Dean Mumm” quote from PK. Very true.
Bismark standing in the scrum is deliberate and cynical slow down tactic – yellow card.
TMO needs to grow some balls – pointed out by someone earlier.
Link made heaps of mistake in this match. Probably the major factor of why the Reds had no chance to compete.
3:23am
Pedro said | 3:23am | Report comment
A sorry day for Australian rugby. Maybe Link isn’t the mesiah after all?
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
11:06pm
Worlds biggest said | 11:06pm | Report comment
Didn’t see the post game interviews, disappointing to read Genia not congratulating the Sharks. That was a heck of a win. There were plenty of us giving it to Saint Richie after the second Irish game post game and OJ has a long memory so swings and round abouts I guess.
11:11pm
murph73 said | 11:11pm | Report comment
Why should he? They were all out the back blowing Kaplan
11:00pm
Jutsie said | 11:00pm | Report comment
Even after 2 hours im still so disappointed with the reds pack tonite. Their one of my favourite teams when on song but they have rarely played with any intensity this year.
Usually when one of my teams lose a big match im shattered but today I’m angry because its the usual suspects making the same stupid mistakes they have all season. Im looking s. finger, rob simmons and higginbottom. Simmons always goes missing in big games. Finger always make stupid mistakes at crucial times and higgy waits in the backline even when he is desparatley needed at the breakdown battle.
10:55pm
Let the One King Rule said | 10:55pm | Report comment
Finally, the most undeserving Super champions in the history of the tournament are out. Now we can finally dispense with the notion that the Reds were worthy of anything last year. Without SANZAR and the refs giving them handjobs, the Reds were totally clueless all year and now will be the laughing stock of the rest of the Super rugby community. Good riddance!
1:45am
Nick said | 1:45am | Report comment
Completely agree. The reds were handed their crown by the biased conference system. It’s great to see them dispatched to where they belong.
8:06am
Red Kev said | 8:06am | Report comment
You are pathetic.
Last year the Reds won 9 of 10 cross conference matches and 15 of 18 for the season. They were by far and away the best team in the competition. This year they are not playing nearly as well and it is reflected in their results. They didn’t deserve to win this year and they didn’t.
Your inability to accept and acknowledge that is an astonishing display of parochial bad attitudes. Although I don’t know why I’m surprised, South African and New Zealand posters on this site are a lot like the English, just without any of their redeeming qualities.
8:13am
Jutsy said | 8:13am | Report comment
Well said RK!
8:55am
justsaying said | 8:55am | Report comment
Shame on you for taking the bait on that obvious troll RK. And a pity to see you stoop to generalisations of Kiwis and Saffas. These sorts of silly attitudes are not limited by geographical boundaries – just see anything by Murph73 or CraigB…
9:31am
Let the One King Rule said | 9:31am | Report comment
I’m Canadian, actually, and before moving here I lived and grew up in Australia. Huge fan of the Wallabies, but when it comes to my rugby I want my winners to be deserving, and the fact of the matter was that the Reds weren’t last year. Their play was not a scratch on that of past champions, and the fact was their closest competitors were hamstrung by much more challenging draws and other circumstances, as well as a finals system that gave additional undeserved favors to the Reds. The fact that they only just edged out a jetlagged Crusaders team that hadn’t had the opportunity to play a home game all season -and- had lost out on a likely first place finish as a result of a natural disaster pretty much says it all.
Nobody questions or ever questioned the accomplishments of the great Brumbies champions despite them being Australian. The controversy exists over the Red’s victory because virtually everyone but Reds fans recognises and realises that it was tainted. There will always be an asterisk beside their victory, and they will never get any respect from opposition fans for it.
3:21pm
SandBox said | 3:21pm | Report comment
from 2003-2009 Reds fans endured being in the bottom few teams. We finally win one last year, and we get trolls like you trying to marginalise our performance. Let us have this one and only victory
What Red Kev and Mr below said about Reds performance 2011 is correct, please re-read it.
As for your One King. If it’s what I think it means – how would you feel if every time you posted, Reds fans attached YouTube links to Christopher Hitchens?
7:23pm
nick said | 7:23pm | Report comment
Face the facts Red Kev, Most watches of the sport are turning against this conference system and thats because it’s inherently based towards the Aussies.
Disagree? How can you?, the conference is a disgrace to the competition and allows the one or two stronger sides to play matches against extraordinarily weak opponents in home and away.
It was a devalued win and this years winner will be tainted in the same way. Get over yourselves for gods sake. There isn’t a single rugby expert in the media or amongst the former players who believes this is a good system. Indeed, even coaches are coming out against it now.
But there’s always you with your silly little moniker fighting the good fight in your own extraordinarily un-lettered fashion. Well done
7:26pm
nick said | 7:26pm | Report comment
while you are at it, seeing as you’re the bastion of posting moderation Red Kev, why don’t you get on your high horse and have a go at the Aussie types round here who blame this loss an Kaplan?
Or do your grandiose displays of parochial nonsense only extend as far as other nations’ posters?
9:45am
Mr said | 9:45am | Report comment
What utter rubbish, while they had a good draw reds were sensational last year and beat crusaders twice (most teams struggle to do this once), when reds forwards are firing avd cooper is playing with Genia they are almost impossible to control or beat
This year on the other hand reds have been rubbish with forwards MIA all year, while I would have been very annoyed if they had got through to a home final with favorable home draw it does not diminish fact that they are the best team in Aus (by a country mile) (which is why most Nz & SA teams do not like playing them) and won title last year
MR
10:48pm
Worlds biggest said | 10:48pm | Report comment
Firstlly congrats to the Sharks, they were outstanding.Disagree with you Wolfie, Cooper would have made some difference but you could argue that Lambie and Steyne if eligible would have more than equaled the ledger. Losing Lucas early was a big blow as I couldn’t understand Genia shifting to 5/8. Why Harris didn’t slot into 10 & Tapuai 12 is beyond me. Overall the Reds were poor, ball control and errors were criminal and never got any rhythm. The Sharks did a great job of disrupting the Reds ball and defence was superb and won them the match. Even if Cooper played they would have limited him. The Sharks were fortunate not to get a player or two carded for constant infringing plus the Liam Gill no try was ridiculous. What was Matt Goddard thinking. If awarded that would have kep the Reds in the game but really they didn’t deserve it. Sharks simply outplayed them and a great win on the road. The Number 8 was brilliant too.
1:11am
FRugby said | 1:11am | Report comment
McKenzie dropped the ball with his total game plan. He is even more clueless making calls mid game, agree totally stupid decision to play Genia out of position after Lucas injury, all it did was further weaken the whole backline structure where he has been playing all year by knee jerking a sub for Lucas thus throwing out the door the whole preperation- Harris to 10, Tapui to centre- basic. Plus McKenzie obviously doing a Deans by not using his bench, must have been tapped on shoulder to tow the party line in order to get the Wallabies top job next year- it’s called integrity mate and you lost it all tonight. With 15 minutes to go, 17 points down he had not used 1 fresh sub, disgracefull, some fresh legs with 25 to go would have made a huge difference. When he finally begrudgingly put subs on – Radikie, Robinson, Daley, they made an immediate impact going forward, but all too late. And Simmonds, please, he is the softest ever and must be a love child of someone of rugby importance.
2:44am
Banger said | 2:44am | Report comment
Video ref can only give a decision on exactly what the ref asks for. In this instance it is Kaplan’s stuff up, he should of asked if there had been a try scored. Not if he was successful on the first grounding or whatever he said
10:39pm
Pierce said | 10:39pm | Report comment
Wallabies will be fresh for Rugby Championship (or whatever it is called)
10:39pm
James said | 10:39pm | Report comment
thank god the natural order has been restored. Sharks, Stormers, Chiefs and Crusaders. Definately the top 4 sides based on log points and clearly the 4 best sides of the season.
No offense by the Reds but playing fellow Australian sides hasn’t been the best preparation for these finals and now they get shown up by the big boys. The better teams are the ones who have depth. All these 4 sides do.
Let the real battles begin!
10:38pm
matthew said | 10:38pm | Report comment
Really impressed with the Sharks all round. Great appreciation of the space at Suncorp and fantastic offloading in contact to set up their tries and a ruthless defense that rendered the Reds toothless. Pity Kaplan missed Genia’s forward pass for the Reds “try”- I feel the scoreboard doesn’t reflect the dominance the sharks had over the reds.
10:09pm
The Werewolf said | 10:09pm | Report comment
I hope Quade has a good look at himself for that head high tackle.
His ill discipline and suspension cost the Reds that game and their shot at a title defence. if Cooper plays that match I’d say that would’ve brought home the bacon.
10:33pm
Kuruki said | 10:33pm | Report comment
Big call. I think the Sharks were outstanding and to be perfectly honest i think Quade would have added to the easy yards those big forwards were making if anything. You could be right though with Genia remaining at 9 things could have been different. But it’s hard to take anything away from that Sharks performance which was brilliant on attack and defence for 80 minutes.
2:56am
The Werewolf said | 2:56am | Report comment
Sorry i should have said i didn’t mean to take away from the Sharks win. They beat the reds fair and square.
I am just sick of Cooper’s foul play is all. It has consequences.
7:55am
Kuruki said | 7:55am | Report comment
Yeah Cooper needs to get a bit smarter in that area.
8:08am
Red Kev said | 8:08am | Report comment
You’re both way off base, he tackled a guy, the suspension was bogus. The fact the citing commissioner asked him if he considered that it was Barnes he was tackling is proof enough of what a joke it was, as if the plethora of other head high tackles this season weren’t.
1:55am
Nick said | 1:55am | Report comment
Not a chance. Reds were beaten by a superior pack. Cooper would have meant nothing out there tonight
9:58pm
Terry Tavita said | 9:58pm | Report comment
cooper’s absence and genia moving out to flyhalf and the game was practically handed to the sharks..players were playing out of position and practically running into the diffence..genia wasn’t able to work the fringes and no cooper to put runners in to space..it was a bit of a farce really..big call by that idiot brisbane lawyer last week which had perhaps the biggest influence on this match,,
9:57pm
Red Block said | 9:57pm | Report comment
Oh well, it could be worse. We could be Waratah supporters!
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
9:56pm
Royce Strauss said | 9:56pm | Report comment
Maybe this will teach some of you Australian rugby fans some respect. All week the only thing I’ve heard is how much the Reds will win by. I suppose Kaplan was at fault, hey Spiro?
Totally dominated.
10:10pm
David Barbeler said | 10:10pm | Report comment
Mate, see the .au at the end of the web address? You’re on an Australian sports opinion website. You’re more than welcome here of course but you’re going to see a large majority of banter and support for the Reds. If you want it the other way then I suggest you stick to the .co.za fan websites.
Great game by the Sharks. Impenetrable defense.
10:17pm
Handles O'Love said | 10:17pm | Report comment
Of course it was Kaplan’s fault? Did you not see the game? That and Nick effing Frisby. Ewen McKenzie’s worst decision in three years.
Truly, on Kaplan, two weeks ago he penalised Qld twice for deliberate knock downs, and Quade once for using his leg in a tackle. Tonight those rules were forgotten.
2:00am
Nick said | 2:00am | Report comment
Yeah the difference was those were actually knock downs, tonight they weren’t, hence the lack of penalty
11:44pm
Hopperdoggy said | 11:44pm | Report comment
Full credit to the Sharks defence it was awesome. And the reds were their own worst enemies with ball im hand, But, it’s disgraceful that a team can have so much time in a 22 and so many penalties and no yellow card. Sharks were off their feet, interfering, not releasing all bloody night but they got away with it nonetheless. Kaplan go back to ref school and let refs with cojoneslike Joubert get a leg up.
11:48pm
biltongbek said | 11:48pm | Report comment
Yeah, reminds me of a game last October.
9:56pm
Johnno said | 9:56pm | Report comment
-You guys what to know something crazy about this super rugby DRAW.
-If the sharks beat the stormers at newlands. And the chiefs beat the crusaders.
-Then the sharks have to travel back to hamilton NZ.
-Exhasuting i don’t know what is.
10:02pm
Kuruki said | 10:02pm | Report comment
And i’m licking my lips at the thought of that happening.
10:41pm
niik said | 10:41pm | Report comment
The sharks would have to travel to nz no matter who wins wouldn’t’ they?
10:46pm
Kuruki said | 10:46pm | Report comment
Not sure? if they finished below the Crusaders on the table then yes, they would.
10:48pm
biltongbek said | 10:48pm | Report comment
Yes, if the Sharks win, they travel regardless of the other result as they are the 6th ranked team.
9:53pm
Jutsy said | 9:53pm | Report comment
I feared for kafe’s safety when he criticised the genia to ten move during the interview with link lol
9:50pm
Reds fan of Fiji said | 9:50pm | Report comment
kaplan…should never ref again…
9:48pm
Suzy Poison said | 9:48pm | Report comment
Reds really missed Cooper. He is the Reds. That suspension was very debatable. Regardless the Sharks played out of their skins, and might have won anyway even with Cooper. Reds forwards were disappointing considering they never fired at Suncorp. As a Stormers fan, I am nervous, the Sharks clearly have a lot of momentum, the forward pack is scary.
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
9:53pm
Johnno said | 9:53pm | Report comment
Suzy 2 trips in 2weeks across the world will be exhausting , doesn’t matter who you are .
- A fresh no travel no jet lag, Stormers at newllands will be super tough for the sharks,.
9:46pm
nickoldschool said | 9:46pm | Report comment
Good to see that Higginbotham had digested the loss 3 minutes after the final whistle. Classic!
9:42pm
Blue Blood said | 9:42pm | Report comment
We talk about impartial referees and judiciary. What about impartial commentators? Revolting, frustratingly biased commentary that didn’t pay credit to the Sharks for 80% of the game. Tough to stomach. These are supposed to be paid professionals. Try employing some impartial professional comments based in facts. Just a thought.
Disappointing that no Australian teams will be in play in the second week of finals. Disappointing outcome by the 2nd ranked rugby nation in the world.
9:46pm
atlas said | 9:46pm | Report comment
the only way to cope is to treat them as the comedy act they are; excitable, ignorant and uninformed.
At least we were spared Kearns this time.
1:21am
FRugby said | 1:21am | Report comment
Kearns is the worst ever, boring, mono tone, stupid one liners that he thinks are funny, can someone really point out 1 positive aspect he brings to the commentary. Can he possibly talk up anymore his few mates that play for the Waratahs, his agenda is so obvious that in itself is actually becoming funny. go figure?
8:15am
jeznez said | 8:15am | Report comment
I find his jokes funny, he is the colour commentator there to say stupid things. Its Marto and Clarke I don’t like.
9:59pm
Damo said | 9:59pm | Report comment
Blue Blood what game were you watching? Grow another eye mate.
The commentators complimented the Sharks throughout the game.
And through an extremely ordinary performance by Kaplan. Nuff said.
10:04pm
biltongbek said | 10:04pm | Report comment
You’re correct Damo, after every 10 minutes of complaining about Kaplan there was a compliment to the Sharks.
10:05pm
Kuruki said | 10:05pm | Report comment
Yeah i actually thought they were good tonight. Even sounding happy when the Sharks got that intercept try.
10:10pm
Blue Blood said | 10:10pm | Report comment
Damo my comment was no reflection on the referee in this game. It was a generalisation based on many comments made over the last few months to lead into my commentary comment. And if you honestly feel that the commentary was professional, insightful and unbiased then I suggest you grow another ear. Towards the end of the game there was some comments regarding the Sharks but the vast majority of the comments and observations were through red lenses. I’m not a Sharks supporter, nor a Reds, but I do find their drivel embarrassing as an Australian sports lover. If you enjoyed the commentary I will hazard a guess that you are a Reds supporter. In which case I’m sure you enjoyed their chit chat. I hope it was enough to distract you from the rugby performance.
10:38pm
ohtani's jacket said | 10:38pm | Report comment
Can’t say I found the commentators biased at all. Horan wore his heart on his sleeve a bit, I guess, but nothing outrageous. It was a blessing to not have to hear Marto or Kearnsy.
11:33pm
Akann said | 11:33pm | Report comment
Horan, Canon and Kafe are class, and I have to say that Clarke has become a lot more neutral over the years. Just keep Marto and Kearns out of it and it will be all good.
10:12pm
BROOKE48 said | 10:12pm | Report comment
BB ;Totally agree ;apart from last gasp consolation try the reds got a hiding.
They were fortunate to be in the finals and in this sharks game mackenzie was again tactically dumb;similar to their huge losses to the Bulls and lowly rated Force.IT was a shame both teams had good players out Lambie and Steyn ;and Cooper.Mind you ill discipline on the field by a couple of reds players has cost the franchise and needs attention next season.
I would be interested to know what the game plan actually was and if there was a B PLAN.
playing genia at 10 was foolish with Harris available and frisbee or tapuai on the bench.The reds may have needed to play genia at 10 in their previous encounter with Sharks but not this time.
And mackenzie considers himself a Wallaby coach.Dont think so son.
9:41pm
Charging Rhino said | 9:41pm | Report comment
Man of the match surely has to be JP Pieterson.
He is on fire this season
9:43pm
Johnno said | 9:43pm | Report comment
top 3 best winger overr of the last 20 years JP peterson is amazing he reminds me so much of the great all black jeff wilson in his prime. Jeff wilson is the greatest all black winger and best winger i have ever seen no 1 then Ntamack of France.
10:22pm
Jerry said | 10:22pm | Report comment
“top 3 best winger overr of the last 20 years”
Seriously? Not even close.
10:49pm
Kuruki said | 10:49pm | Report comment
Gotta love Johnno he comes up with some gems now and then. JP wouldn’t even be top 3 in South Africa in the last 20 years.
10:51pm
biltongbek said | 10:51pm | Report comment
Kuruka, who would you rate above him?
11:01pm
Johnno said | 11:01pm | Report comment
Kuruki do you rate jeff wilson highly. I did.
-I think JP is better than Habana, even Habana at his best.
-South africa’s cup board im sorry is pretty dry kuruki. Boltong i am struggling to find a better book winger than JP.
-Habana i have just said no too.
-Chester williams, stefen terblanche sort a winger, theo van rans burg more a full back, pitta hendrichs was not bad and chester williams not bad but not in JP’s class,
-Piter russow was handy but not as skilled as JP
-Yep JP is no 1 habana 2, chester williams 3
- the best i seen in the last 20 years are Jeff wilson no1 , Ntemack france 2, JP pterson 3, Tune 4, Lomu 5,.
-Rupeni Thau thau talant wise maybe no 1but his stay at the top was too brief and it was done more at super level not test rugby level
11:09pm
Johnno said | 11:09pm | Report comment
James Small and Jacques oliver not bad but JP better than them too.
11:04pm
Johnno said | 11:04pm | Report comment
kuruki turn it up mate. Who else can you suggest higher i have pretty much given the lot. Boltongbeck seems to agree with me too. JP Peterson won a world cup too in 2007 from memory.
-JP Peterson is deceptively very big too. He is 6’4 and 102kg. So athletic and co-ordinated for a big man and really agile, and his reading of a rugby union match is superb like a jeff wilson or conrad smith.
11:26pm
biltongbek said | 11:26pm | Report comment
I with you all thecway, Johno
11:40pm
Johnno said | 11:40pm | Report comment
good man biltongbek JP is certainly very good, and i cant find anyone in SA rugby on the wing better in the last 20 years either. He was also very good in big games has always been. in the world cups, super rugby finals, british lions test matches. Just a good rugby winger simple as that.
11:43pm
biltongbek said | 11:43pm | Report comment
I think JP often gets underestimated because he doesn’t look flashy when he has ball in hand, he looks pedestrian when he runs, but is in reality faster than his leg speed suggests.
The other fact is SA have not had great wings in the past, I would consider Pieter Rossouw as one of our better wingers in the late nineties.
1:03am
lorry said | 1:03am | Report comment
Johnnie, don’t you rate roff highly? I think he was very very good and very consistent. Too
8:09am
Kuruki said | 8:09am | Report comment
LOL mate JP has had one standout season this year and you rate him as 3rd best winger in the past 20 years? you are kidding yourself.
I remember it was not that long ago he forgot where the tryline was. The fact that you think he is better then wingers like Joe Rokocoko. Digby Ioane, Cory Jane, mate JP would not even get a run on start in the All Blacks side. I’d have Richard Kahui over him any day of the week. And the fact that you think he is better then Jonah Lomu just shows how ridiculous your statement is. Jonah is a legend JP is having one standout Super rugby season.
When he backs it up against guys like Cory Jane and Richard Kahui at international level then i will give him more credit. All i have seen from JP against the best at the top level is mediocrity.
5:39am
Charging Rhino said | 5:39am | Report comment
Kuruki- well then I’m very grateful that you’re not the Bok coach or selector if thats what you think.
JP would be the very first name in my Bok team sheet. Then it would be Bismark, Beast & Fran’s Steyn. And a fit Schalk Burger.
Cory Jane…???! Kahui???! Ha ha ha. Digby’s a good attacking winner but have you ever seen him do anything when he plays against JP??? Nothing. Actually have you ever seen anyone get past JP for that matter? He reads the opposition attack soo well every time, his anticipation is exceptional.
It’s not just 1 season by the way. He was the top Super Rugby try scorer in 2007. Dipped in form in early-mid 2008 but was back in 09 for the Lions tour and has gotten better since. Just ask Jean De Villers who he rates is the best backline’s player? He has played against and with him.
Before this SA- England series I was reading an article about Bok selections on Keo, and the only player who’s name never came up to be questioned about his place in the side from all the comments was JP’s. I know I counted all the names. Says something. You’re missing that something.
My best was when JP stepped Lachie Turner inside the Sharks half and left him and the Waratahs backline’s for dead in 2011 super game at Kings Park.
10:40pm
Terry Tavita said | 10:40pm | Report comment
ben tune
1:13am
Johnno said | 1:13am | Report comment
lorry i rate joe roof highly too, but he wasn’t as damaging as peterson or as big . Peterson is 6’4 very deceptive runner as bilgotng said. And very strong roof is good but not as good as JP.
And roff couldn’t even make the wallabies starting team by 2003 , wendall sailor and lote tiquri were ahead of roof, eddie jones picked them ahead of roff. Latham played wing someimtes but was more a fullback.
Tana usage played most of his career in the centres so not including him as a wing. joeli vidiri was brilliant but his career was too short.
The western force fijian winger is brilliant too , but jo just a bit better but not by much , tuilagi the samoan winger is brilliant to as is george north and cuthburt. and flying dutchman tim visser. But i rate JP ahead of all of them and jonah lomu too.
1) Jeff wilson
2) Ntemach france
3) JP
patrice lasquiest was brilliant to the french wing and ben tune of course.
1:50am
biltongbek said | 1:50am | Report comment
Yeah, I liked Joe Roff , but Ben Tune was a killer finisher.
1:58am
Johnno said | 1:58am | Report comment
Émile Ntamack billtong did you rate the french legend of the 90′s. he was amazing some of those tries he got vs the Ab’s. wow.
Jonah Lomu said he was his toughest wing opponent.
2:24am
biltongbek said | 2:24am | Report comment
Yes Johhno, he was an excellent finsher, very strong runner indeed, I also expected a lot from Vincent Clerk, I remember the try he scored in NZ down the touchline 2009?
But he is good rather than great.
5:08pm
Verity said | 5:08pm | Report comment
You mean using his fingers like pokers into Higginbotham’s eyes?
9:28pm
Johnno said | 9:28pm | Report comment
-Link jas cost his wallaby ambitions tonight. Could you imagine if link had a schocker like this in a rugby world cup. His use of the bench disgraceful; Link should never get near the wallabies again not even as an assistant. For me if i was head of the ARU hypothetically. i would stamp Link never allowed ot be head coach of the wallabies.
-Jake white a far superior coach to link and has had the better of Link all year.
-John Plumtree would of been a great coach at the auckland blues but too expensive.
-Lambie and maybe stein to reutrn next week.
-But they will be shaker bait for a fresh as a daisy Stormers waiting for them at newlines cape town.
-2 big trips across the world in 2 weeks will leave the sharks exhausted.
-They will be fish and chips next week for the stormers at newlands.
Playing the match vs the stormers would of been much easier if it was in the shire lol
9:37pm
Banger said | 9:37pm | Report comment
‘Jake white a far superior coach to link and has had the better of Link all year’
brumbies lost both games agains the reds and last weeks capitulation and whites selections in the first game against the Reds were nearly as bad as Mackenzie’s decisions tonight
9:46pm
SandBox said | 9:46pm | Report comment
agreed Banger, classic non-sequitur from Johnno.
Sharks played better, but proud of Reds for getting this far
Kaplan needs a zimmer frame. TMO needs to grow some balls
9:52pm
Johnno said | 9:52pm | Report comment
lol love your work sandbox. sharks the best team tonight.
10:08pm
SandBox said | 10:08pm | Report comment
Sharks pack has been impressive, hope you guys go on with it.
watched the Reds cellar dwelling for many years, so making top half is still exciting for me. Think most Reds fans will look back at this season and ponder what might have been
9:39pm
Jutsy said | 9:39pm | Report comment
I still think link is one of many candidates but just dont agree with him being handed the job on a silver platter like many reds fans (and, according to uncle argyle’s source, many aru officials) are demanding.
9:42pm
Aussie Fan Club said | 9:42pm | Report comment
Mckenzie so sheepish and unsure in pre and halftime interviews hardly inspiring to the players, front rowers dont make good coaches
8:11am
jeznez said | 8:11am | Report comment
AFC, I’m an awesome coach.
9:27pm
ohtani's jacket said | 9:27pm | Report comment
Hmm, Genia didn’t congratulate the Sharks once and Suncorp booed the ref. Stay classy, folks. Gotta love Genia: “I don’t see how it wasn’t inconclusive.”
9:30pm
Red Kev said | 9:30pm | Report comment
Classier than McCaw, get the chip off your shoulder.
9:34pm
RebelRanger said | 9:34pm | Report comment
He was pretty classy making it to the semis..
7:45pm
nick said | 7:45pm | Report comment
He’s not in the same universe as McCaw mate.
9:32pm
Charging Rhino said | 9:32pm | Report comment
Yep not great by Genia. Especially when his team was played off the park by a better tonight
9:33pm
Banger said | 9:33pm | Report comment
fair call on not giving the sharks the credit they desereved. Kaplan however got what he deserved, hes stuff up with the tmo was an absolute joke
9:43pm
Kuruki said | 9:43pm | Report comment
Mate in the heat of the moment you cannot expect a player to worry about things like that. They have just spent the last 80 minutes at war.
I don’t know why people make a big deal about what is or is not said immediately after a game.
What you guys don’t see is what happens after the camera is turned off. They will congratulate the Sharks face to face. Do you think any of the Sharks players are listening to what Genia is saying in his post match interview?.
This whole debate annoys the hell out of me and is only raised in spite, every single time it appears on here.
9:47pm
Red Kev said | 9:47pm | Report comment
Damn right Kuruki, I agree 100%, it is the handshake and congratulations player to player that is important.
10:11pm
Fin said | 10:11pm | Report comment
Not entirely guys. You still have brand you are trying to market in a competitive environment. I think sponsors would rather Ben mowen or Gareth delve in a post Match interview especially after a loss. I personally think it is why pocock is the wallabies skipper instead of genia.
10:20pm
Kuruki said | 10:20pm | Report comment
Genia thanked the supporters, as far as lip servicing your clients that is all he needed to do.
One of my favorite players to listen to after a match was Anton Oliver, because he would tell it like it was no sugar coating anything. I mean seriously these guys are there to play Rugby is nothing sacred from the PC brigade?
9:34pm
Sage said | 9:34pm | Report comment
C’mon OJ. You’ve been the leader of the “who cares what they say” crew and now this from you. Oh well, at least we have true colours at least.
9:38pm
ohtani's jacket said | 9:38pm | Report comment
Sorry, I was blown away by Genia putting that vaunted Australian sportsmanship into action. What a lesson for all the kids out there.
9:36pm
Darwin Stubbie said | 9:36pm | Report comment
Classic
9:55pm
Damo said | 9:55pm | Report comment
Aren’t you blokes happy enough that the Aussie team lost?
Can’t help yourselves can you? Scratch a rugby nut and you’ll find a bigot.
OJ obviously you are embarrassed by ‘the Saint’s ‘ atrocious and self obsessed victory speeches.
It’s not Will’s fault that Richie thinks NZ is the centre of the universe
10:12pm
Kuruki said | 10:12pm | Report comment
Mate when your a Kiwi it is the centre of the universe.
OJ was just having a dig because we got served the same dish. it’s all for shyts and giggles or trolling as we call it these days.
10:27pm
ohtani's jacket said | 10:27pm | Report comment
Trolling? I’m just trying to follow the example set by those gatekeepers of the spirit of the game. Those self-styled bastions of fairness, who have Quade Cooper run messages all game long when he’s supposed to be, you know, suspended.
10:40pm
Kuruki said | 10:40pm | Report comment
LOL
12:19am
IronAwe said | 12:19am | Report comment
Really? You think he shouldn’t be allowed to be with his team? Maybe we should ban him from watching too. And no phone calls or tweets to his team mates either.
I’m blown away.
7:53am
ohtani's jacket said | 7:53am | Report comment
Aside from the fact that he should’ve been banned for life for touching the hair on Richie McCaw’s head, he was suspended. He wasn’t supposed to be on the field, but he was. Repeatedly. I thought the message McKenzie and the QLD management were sending was pretty obvious.
5:51am
Sage said | 5:51am | Report comment
Yes DS, classic Kiwi double standards and such incredible enjoyment from an Aussie loss. Some things never change. At least you’ll have a ripper highlight reel for your “look what the Aussies lost” TV snippet that helps soothe all those national insecurities. Enjoy it boys, I know how important it is to your fragile psyche.
6:23am
Darwin Stubbie said | 6:23am | Report comment
Seriously ? – double standard – you’re having a laugh right or are you really missing the point of the first post …. And how you can somehow infer from that I’m rejoicing in a Aussie loss god only knows
11:29am
Sage said | 11:29am | Report comment
Classic
10:18pm
BROOKE48 said | 10:18pm | Report comment
OJ genia wanted to continue as captain.Be careful what you wish for man.Not a happy chappy after that hiding.
7:46pm
nick said | 7:46pm | Report comment
of course. Inconclusive:Adjective:
Not leading to a firm conclusion; not ending doubt or dispute: “the evidence is inconclusive”.
Thats exactly what that ‘try’ looked like. If you can’t see the ball grounded over the line you shouldn’t be giving it. Simple as that really. None of this inferring or assuming from the footage.
9:24pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:24pm | Report comment
Kafe leads softly in the Genia interview by putting the injuries at the front of the question. Credit to Genia for basically brushing that off and basically saying their mistakes early and bad tackling lead to the Sharks moving forward and capitalising on the missed pressure.
Genia put his cheque book on the line by saying that Gill should have been given a try. Hes pretty disappointed but happy that they tried hard and the effort was there.
9:34pm
Kuruki said | 9:34pm | Report comment
Just a reminder to all those who gave Spiro flak about his neutral ref article…..Don’t let me catch you moaning about the ref !!!!!!
9:49pm
ArtVandelay said | 9:49pm | Report comment
didn’t congratulate the sharks once, disappointing sanchez!
9:24pm
Jutsy said | 9:24pm | Report comment
Link the heir apparent for wallaby head coach role?
The reds pack were as powderpuff tonite (and on many occasions this season) as the wallaby pack at its most insipid so not sure how link would sort anything out.
9:25pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:25pm | Report comment
I don’t think a coach can produce powerful gritty forwards at all. No matter who you pick.
9:32pm
Johnno said | 9:32pm | Report comment
Pal lam produced gritty forwards in 1 week and Link cant and lam lost his job.
9:35pm
Jutsy said | 9:35pm | Report comment
The reds (and the wallabies) have shown in glimpses that when they play with intensity and commitment they can match it with most packs however neither team does it on a consistent basis. If link cant motivate a super 15 pack to do this on a consistent basis im not sure how would manage to do it at the next level.
10:27pm
BROOKE48 said | 10:27pm | Report comment
JUTSY,IF mackenzie was as competent tactically as he is at self promotion he would be a winner.
look at that silly little box he stands behind at the players entrance——what can he possibly see from that vantage point? or is smitten by the grid iron approach and the limelight.
9:23pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:23pm | Report comment
Keegan Daniels happy with that result (derr) and says that the plan wasn’t actually to spread it too wide early but they wanted to protect the ball. He was happy with how relentless they were moving forward and their physicality on the defensive side of the ball too.
9:22pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:22pm | Report comment
Looking to next week the Sharks and Stormers has the chance to be one of the most brutal games of rugby you’ll see.
(The crowd just booed really loudly at Kaplan. Not his fault tonight.)
9:23pm
Morgan said | 9:23pm | Report comment
You have to be kidding! REDS, Kaplan and McKenzie were disgraceful tonight. How could McKenzie not bring on Tapuai at 12, move Harris to 10 and leave Genia at 9. Kaplan did the typical clever trick of evening up the stats when it wouldn’t effect the result.
9:25pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:25pm | Report comment
I’d have gone with your line-up in the midfield too mate. Obviously didn’t trust Taps to last 60min plus.
9:28pm
Terry Tavita said | 9:28pm | Report comment
the biggest call was that stupid brisbane lawyer who gave cooper that one week suspension..his absence had a huge impact on this game, at this stage of the competion..
9:32pm
Johnno said | 9:32pm | Report comment
i agree terry. Go manu Samoa.
9:21pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:21pm | Report comment
The Sharks 30, have soundly beaten the Reds 17 at Suncorp to advance to the Semi final stage of this tournament!
9:21pm
countryboy said | 9:21pm | Report comment
Sharks the better team by a country mile. Next week should be a great couple of games.
9:26pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:26pm | Report comment
Definitely better team. And I’m very much looking forward to the slate next week. Going to be fired up rematch in Hamilton and a violent aggressive encounter at Capetown!
9:31pm
Banger said | 9:31pm | Report comment
yeah their defence was brilliant in the second half
10:04pm
Damo said | 10:04pm | Report comment
Yeh and some of it was from an onside position
10:09pm
biltongbek said | 10:09pm | Report comment
At least some was, the rest of the time they had to crawl around the blockers on the side of the rucks, did you miss Kaplan warning the Reds twice that their blockers around their rucks need to stop?
10:33pm
Wal the Hooker said | 10:33pm | Report comment
Funny that BB I thought the same, and how was Slipper diving off his feet over the ruck a couple times. Many a times this year that was sealing off! Well played Sharks deserved their win, outstanding offence and defence! Wonder if they’ll have it in the tank to go up another gear against the Stormers, that was an awesome effort tonight.
10:40pm
biltongbek said | 10:40pm | Report comment
Wal, I think they might spend their last energy next week, could even pull of the win, the Stormers may be fresh next week, but their last few matches were poor.
If the Sharks do manage to pull of a win, I can’t see them flying back to NZ and win, too much of an ask.
9:20pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:20pm | Report comment
SAMO SCORES! Pick and drive and falls over the line. So that will end it once they take this kick. Crowd streaming out.
Genia puts it over.
9:19pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:19pm | Report comment
SIREN GONE
The Reds still have it and a penalty is given.Yellow now. haha.
Reds are 6m out.
They are still trying to finish their year on a high. Staying tight and running it at the line.
9:18pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:18pm | Report comment
79min
Reds win the kick off and go wide on second phase. There was room but the ball was in Hansen’s hands and he took too long to move it on.
Reds still have it through a penalty. Tap and go. They are 15m out but mostly going sideways and backwards in the face of this strong black wall.
Come to think of it this defense against the Sharks defense next week. I’m tipping first try wins!
Sharks 30 – Reds 10
9:17pm
Johnno said | 9:17pm | Report comment
me you mean no but now that you mention it, well why not kaplan referring has been disgraceful tonight no aussie team in 2nd week of semi finals that is unfair, and an imbalance of power and not fair kuruki.
9:18pm
Kuruki said | 9:18pm | Report comment
Fair? Reds hosting this game was not fair on the Sharks so it’s pretty even in my book.
9:21pm
Johnno said | 9:21pm | Report comment
kuruki mate,, the reds though had to have a book referee. A bit like wales had to deal with alan rolland in NZ a irish ref with french heritage at the rwc not fair. Neither was having a kiwi paddy o’brien as head of the refereeing at the world cup should of been a neutral.
9:22pm
Kuruki said | 9:22pm | Report comment
Mate LOL. That is all.
9:33pm
Johnno said | 9:33pm | Report comment
lol.
9:24pm
atlas said | 9:24pm | Report comment
where would a neutral Referees Manager come from then?
Think about it.
A country that didn’t play rugby?
1:13am
lorry said | 1:13am | Report comment
Brazil
10:25pm
Jerry said | 10:25pm | Report comment
Oh. My. God.
9:22pm
Red Kev said | 9:22pm | Report comment
That’s a fairly stupid comment, the Reds were blown off the park, Sharks deserved to win.
9:39pm
Sage said | 9:39pm | Report comment
With you RK. Impressive defensive performance. Kaplan was his crap self but it didn’t cost the Reds the game. Their errors did plus the Sharks finals defence. Well done Sharks.
9:16pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:16pm | Report comment
Kick is through and over!
Sharks 30 – Reds 10
9:24pm
Mr said | 9:24pm | Report comment
Great win by sharks given Red’s home game. Excellent Semi next week, if Sharks and crusaders win next week is it home game for crusaders?
9:16pm
Kuruki said | 9:16pm | Report comment
Well done Sharks a very deserving win for a very good performance.
Looking forward to a Chiefs Sharks final in Hamilton !!!!
9:15pm
Johnno said | 9:15pm | Report comment
Maybe next week a fresh Lambie and frans stein will boost the sharks. John Plumtree the kiwi coach of the sharks has outcoached Link.
I can see why Plumtree is on big money, and not coaching in NZ he is on big money in NZ. Vern cotter the auckland blues could not afford either, he is coaching in france. And too think is being viewed a s a wallaby coach when world cup winner Jake white has has the wood on link and been the better coach this year. Jake white for wallaby coach.
9:16pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:16pm | Report comment
I don’t think Steyn can play finals at all because he was signed too late in the year.
9:17pm
Kuruki said | 9:17pm | Report comment
Frans Steyn is not allowed to play next week.
9:15pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:15pm | Report comment
Off the 22 drop Samo runs it up and then off the next phase the Sharks intercept. Kicked ahead and Shipperley just beats Mvovo to it. But they ball him up get on the ball and earn the penalty. Kick at goal coming to kill some time. It’s 6 in from touch 24m out and on the left side of the posts.
9:14pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:14pm | Report comment
75min
Reds have the lineout win and then on the second phase sees Ioane through a hole and Ludik made a fantastic tackle. Seriously stopped him cold like no ones business.
There was a kick through and Pietersen calmly beats everyone else to touch it down.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
9:13pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:13pm | Report comment
And justice to an almost perfect Sharks performance. Seriously. I don’t really see how they could have played better really.
9:36pm
Sharks!!! said | 9:36pm | Report comment
Our discipline needs to improve a bit though, think Kaplan was too scared to pull a card (earlier), luckily!!
6:58pm
murph73 said | 6:58pm | Report comment
At least someone is honest. If the Sharks didn’t have their hometown ref they’d have got a couple of yellows they deserved. Never in my days have I seen such a blatant fix of a rugby match. It’s an absolute disgrace.
6:59pm
murph73 said | 6:59pm | Report comment
It’s not luck. It’s not luck that Durban boy, Kaplan, was flown half way around the world to officiate a Sharks match either.
9:12pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:12pm | Report comment
Sharks win the scrum and Michalak knocks it out up at the 50m line.
9:12pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:12pm | Report comment
Clip of the JP PIetersen influence on the game. He’s been good. He’s quick, very decisive on defense and tries to keep the ball alive on attack.
9:11pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:11pm | Report comment
75min
Ioane takes the tap and goes for the line but drops it over. Ridiculous tackle from Daniel to hold him up by the waist. Strong stuff.
Sharks clear it and reds win the line out.
They go wide and then Daley loses it forward.
The game is too far gone now and they’ll wonder how they didn’t score during the long period of time they had the ball between 50 and 59min right on the try line.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
9:09pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:09pm | Report comment
72min
Sharks win the ball and kick it.. Reds counter and make ground but then things crawl to a halt as Reds look around in bewilderment. They’ve lost it. They don’t even know where they’re going atm. They pick up the ball and pivot all over the place looking for ideas. Tey still have it though and Hansen makes some ground but just pushing forward. Ball tied in the ruck and it’s a penalty now.
Ball kicked away. Pietersen will get a yellow now… no he didn’t
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
9:07pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:07pm | Report comment
69min
Reds make a few metres and then go backwards through dropped ball. Eventually the Reds poke a grubber in behind and it goes out about 15m from pay dirt. Sharks lineout to come.
9:10pm
Johnno said | 9:10pm | Report comment
Kaplan is a disgrace so many yellows should of been given my girlfiend could have had 10 children by now or octuplets(8) even.
9:31pm
Rev said | 9:31pm | Report comment
Yea poor choice of refs by whoever picked it… Kaplan did favour the sharks but on the other end of the stick peyper did favour the saders… IMHO he pinged the bulls a lot more than they deserve because he didn’t want to seem bias and reffs shouldn’t be put in that position… But on that good games around… Reds did well considering the injuries they should keep there heads high
9:36pm
biltongbek said | 9:36pm | Report comment
Doesn’t really matter, Crusaders were much better than the Bulls and the Sharks were much better than the Reds
9:43pm
Rev said | 9:43pm | Report comment
Yes both teams deserved there spots should make a good semi finals round
9:06pm
KiwiDave said | 9:06pm | Report comment
Reds are gone. No coming back now. No Aussie sides left. That is fitting considering how bad they have collectively played this season
9:12pm
Red Kev said | 9:12pm | Report comment
I think a Crusaders Sharks could be on the cards, both teams looked really good tonight.
9:25pm
yewonk said | 9:25pm | Report comment
don’t like the opinions of others no worries just use your power to remove them.
9:05pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:05pm | Report comment
68min
The ball is eventually knocked on to give the Reds another chance.
Kafe says the Reds heads went down when they lost Lucas. Can’t put the blame on that. Gotta be able to compete in the forwards for the fly half to matter much.
Penalty for Reds for a ruck infringement off that scrum. Now a chance to get it down to attack.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
9:04pm
Johnno said | 9:04pm | Report comment
Tim horan and greg martin are so supportive of QLD why i don’t get it or understand. they sound like there queenslanders so favourable is there commentary of the reds. where as kafe is far more neutral.
9:11pm
Jerry said | 9:11pm | Report comment
The commentators are absolutely horrible. And even Kafer isn’t much cop tonight – “Nothing wrong with that” in reference to a fairly blatant shoulder charge by Digby for instance.
9:04pm
murph73 said | 9:04pm | Report comment
How many times can Bismarck stand up in the scrum before a penalty is given to the Reds?
Three penalties on the Sharks line with no yellow?!
A complete fix and a joke
9:10pm
murph73 said | 9:10pm | Report comment
Make that four
9:04pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:04pm | Report comment
66min
Off the scrum Genia tries a cross kick to Ioane and it’s out over the sideline. Harris should be on the field at 10 and Tapaui at 12.
Sharks lineout win and then run through midfield. Not into midfield, through it, like they have all night. Powerful leg drive.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
9:04pm
Jerry said | 9:04pm | Report comment
Reds 16th man saves a try there. I’m referring to the invisible man who trips up Sharks players 5m from the tryline.
9:02pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:02pm | Report comment
64min
Horan points out that every pass they throw is sticking. Well they did just drop one over the line…
It’s not flukey at all. They hit the middle of the park at speed and then use the space they’ve earned. I may have heard that principle a million times related to rugby.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
9:02pm
formeropenside said | 9:02pm | Report comment
Kaplan must never referee again.
That is all.
The Reds never had a shot tonight with Kaplan.
9:03pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:03pm | Report comment
I can’t agree with that. The Reds have been given a few calls I’d have made against them. Especially about 4 forward passes. One of them was worth 7 of their points. but also they were lucky on a few scrums and Genia was offside at a couple too.
9:06pm
Sharks!!! said | 9:06pm | Report comment
I would like to see us get another try, Kaplin Is having a shocker, we have got away with some forward passes. Our intercept try was lucky too, he was off side. Another try puts it outside the Reds saying they were robbed.Especially with that from the TMO
9:04pm
Banger said | 9:04pm | Report comment
the guy is an absolute joke. But we can’t put this result on him.
9:07pm
Red Kev said | 9:07pm | Report comment
Yeah sorry FOS but Kaplan has nothing to do with the Reds losing.
The Sharks have massively outplayed them, and McKenzie moving Genia to 10 has been a terrible decision just as it was last time he tried it.
9:13pm
murph73 said | 9:13pm | Report comment
Wtf??! No, but there’s at least two tries that have been spoiled by cynical infringements and nothing has been done. The Sharks have been deliberately. Spoiling confident that nothing will be done
9:38pm
biltongbek said | 9:38pm | Report comment
What about the Reds try that came from a forward pass?
11:15pm
murph73 said | 11:15pm | Report comment
That’s a single line ball call while the game is in a fast paced mode.
Bismarck repeatedly standing in the scrum is not. Four cynical infringements on their own line is not. Nine in their own 22 is not. Holmes getting punched in the head in front of the touch judge, who reported it to Kaplan but Kaplan did nothing, is not.
An absolute complete and utter fix.
2:27am
biltongbek said | 2:27am | Report comment
Murph, like we were told in the QF last year, the Reds should have adjusted to the referee.
6:56pm
murph73 said | 6:56pm | Report comment
Oh, what nonsense. How can you play a ref who just simply favours his home town’s team. What a lot of crap.
9:41pm
Sage said | 9:41pm | Report comment
That’s twice. Very true RK
9:02pm
Pot Hale said | 9:02pm | Report comment
Loving this match. Ball absolutely everywhere.
9:04pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:04pm | Report comment
They are certainly having a red hot crack!
9:01pm
Red Kev said | 9:01pm | Report comment
Well Ewen needs to give himself an uppercut, putting Genia at 10 has been a shocker every time it has been tried.
9:01pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:01pm | Report comment
Sharks counter brilliantly! Mvovo breaks 2 tackles to halfway and hes now down in backfield.
The Sharks then break through the middle and almost score but KNOCK ON about a metre out. That would have been it. Wow. Brilliant play. Reds don’t deserve to win at all. Sharks are the ones playing rugby tonight. That counter attack and then making the most of space and offloads was fantastic.
9:00pm
Elisha Pearce said | 9:00pm | Report comment
Ioane gets the ball and goes straight over the advantage line. That leads to 2 Reds runs through the ruck area putting them into attacking area. Genia chips and McLeod reads it like a book. Mvovo hits it down field and then the Reds run it.
Reds had a massive overlap that Faingaa butchers instead of being on the bench.
Sharks 27- Reds 10
8:59pm
Johnno said | 8:59pm | Report comment
robinson and sano on too late. Link has used his bench terribly like robbie deans uses his bench terribly.
-Link should never be wallaby coach with brian explosions like this, using genia at 5/8. Weepu plays 5/8 but has lots of experience, , he should of just used harris at 5/8 fate rlucas injured.
-Jake white has had the wood over mckesnie this year and in general record, Jake white for next wallaby coach then cheika and forget link damn hill better too than link and phil mooney too.
9:02pm
Banger said | 9:02pm | Report comment
yeah its fair to say that link has absolutely bottled the use of his bench.
9:10pm
Kuruki said | 9:10pm | Report comment
He could have brought Superman on and they still would have lost to a better side on the night.
9:35pm
RebelRanger said | 9:35pm | Report comment
Big call, the Man of Steel can fly..
8:58pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:58pm | Report comment
Reds win a scrum for the lineout not being straight. Ioane has a whisper to Genia in the backline. “Give me the ball in space, please.”
8:58pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:58pm | Report comment
Samo, Robinson and Tapaui on now. For some reason it was Harris they took off instead of Faingaa though….
8:56pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:56pm | Report comment
Sharks get a penalty for holding on. Pretty sure the Shark was off his feet bear hugging the tackled player there.
8:56pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:56pm | Report comment
59min
Off the scrum the Reds go to Harris. Then wider and Morahan is driven about 15m backward but the Sharks go off their feet and give a penalty. Bruising defense though.
Quick tap and it’s pullled back because they were off the mark. The second time it leads to Alberts eating Faingaa alive. Then Shipperley is hammered as the defense wait on his inside run…
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:55pm
Johnno said | 8:55pm | Report comment
-If sharks win which seems likely now, they will be exhausted for a very fresh stormers. A long trip back to south africa, after just eing in oZ for 1 week, they will be knakered for the fresh as a daisy stormers. Sharks are going to be great bait for the stormers defence next week at newlines cape town.
8:57pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:57pm | Report comment
Yeah I think you’d have to pick the stormers. But if the Sharks start fast I don’t like the Stormers ability to chase a game. The Reds are good at that.
9:25pm
RebelRanger said | 9:25pm | Report comment
I thought the Sharks are going to Waitako..
8:54pm
KiwiDave said | 8:54pm | Report comment
A couple of south african refs at their finest. Why is a SA ref doing this game?
8:56pm
Johnno said | 8:56pm | Report comment
kaplan is a durban by too apparently.
8:57pm
atlas said | 8:57pm | Report comment
didn’t sound SA to me
according to PR: TMO: Matt Goddard (Australia)
9:18pm
Mr said | 9:18pm | Report comment
But not from Queensland so clearlybiased sgainst reds
8:54pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:54pm | Report comment
Scrum was good from the Sharks, they are getting dominance now after a few shaky ones earlier.
Reds get a refeed as it pops up. Lucky.
8:53pm
Jerry said | 8:53pm | Report comment
That was a try to me – you could see the ball on the ground from one angle and from the other he had to be over the line.
8:54pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:54pm | Report comment
Yeah probably was to me. Especially given precedent from recent weeks calls.
8:56pm
Jerry said | 8:56pm | Report comment
Needed the Hurricanes v Chiefs TMO…
8:53pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:53pm | Report comment
56min – Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:53pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:53pm | Report comment
TMO says to Kaplan ‘I can see the ball on the ground, but nothing conclusive” haha. Wow. Don’t even know what to make of that.
5m scrum.
8:53pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:53pm | Report comment
Fairly sure it’s conclusive when the ball is on the ground.
8:54pm
Jerry said | 8:54pm | Report comment
That had to be a try.
9:01pm
Banger said | 9:01pm | Report comment
it was kaplan asked the wrong question tmo can only respond to what the referee asks
8:52pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:52pm | Report comment
Gill looks to have scored a sneaky, sneaky one. The TMO has given about 5 less obvious grounded over the line decisions in the last 2 weeks.
8:51pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:51pm | Report comment
Sharks win that scrum and almost get the turnover!
“IOANEEE” Greg Clarke yells as he lunges for the line off the side of the ruck. Going upstairs and probably just held up unless Gill ripped it and put it down.
8:54pm
Red Kev said | 8:54pm | Report comment
Well I thought that was a try. I hope the Reds can get over from this scrum.
8:54pm
atlas said | 8:54pm | Report comment
really, the commentators are dreadful – the big shout IOANE as whoever has the mic wets his pants; then claims a try has been scored ‘at least a meter over the line’
nice to be so impartial
9:01pm
Mr said | 9:01pm | Report comment
SOP for worst commentators in rugby
8:50pm
KiwiDave said | 8:50pm | Report comment
Gotta love it. 93% possession in the second half and down 7-0 for the half
8:51pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:51pm | Report comment
I don’t know if may people on this side of the Indian Ocean ‘gotta love it’ really!
9:00pm
Mr said | 9:00pm | Report comment
I love it
8:50pm
Banger said | 8:50pm | Report comment
reds need to turn this into points
8:50pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:50pm | Report comment
Ok… maybe not!
(Live bloggers curse maybe?) McLeod under pressure from the offside Genia at the scrum and throws it over the dead ball line.
8:49pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:49pm | Report comment
54min
Sharks win a turnover after Genia took the wrong option at the scrum.
He gave the late, late short ball to Harris and he was hammered. Should have given it wider. McLeod got that ball. Great stuff. He’s my MOTM so far.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:48pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:48pm | Report comment
53min
Frisby gives it to Simmons and he’s given it to Gill who pushes forward. Not much movement, all 1m from the ruck. Another penalty, this time for hands on the ball.
Ref tells Daniels to talk to his men. Yellow next time.
Hansen almost pushed over the line at one point there. It’s the championship moments here. Reds have to capitalise to give themselves a good chance to come home.
8:47pm
stu said | 8:47pm | Report comment
genia needs to be at nine. get taps on
8:48pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:48pm | Report comment
Time for taps. Take of Faingaa. harris and taps would rip this open I think.
8:46pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:46pm | Report comment
52min
Off the scrum Genia put in a cross kick for Shipperley that made him wait instead of being in front.
Harris breaks a tackle and they are still only 5m out. Ad for offside too now.
Reds running at speed onto the ball, it’s stretching the tacklers. Du Plessis in there slowing it down and then Frisby is hammered. Offisde at the ruck Michalak.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:44pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:44pm | Report comment
50min
Frisby throws a bounce pass to Harris off the scrum.
Genia throws an inside ball to AHW on the next move. They are 2m out now!
Frisby dummies and goes but gets pushed back into the ruck and held up over the line. 5m scrum. Almost over there. Crowd giving a little more support now too. Reds need a 7 here, badly.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:42pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:42pm | Report comment
48min
Reds put in a good scrum and Kankowski is brutalised at the back of the scrum.
The Reds earn a scrum at that ruck. They piled in onto that ball. Sniffing a way in here the Reds.
8:41pm
Johnno said | 8:41pm | Report comment
reds need to get Taps and Samo on, bring on Samo for a big 30 minutes.
8:42pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:42pm | Report comment
I’ll agree with that. Maybe take Simmons off for Samo?
8:43pm
Red Kev said | 8:43pm | Report comment
Agree with that 100%.
8:41pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:41pm | Report comment
47min
The Reds backline make a meal of that move and Genia is forced to throw another not called forward pass.
They keep the ball because Faingaa breaks his standing tackler and they now have the ball 5m out. Then a turnover as the Sharks keep the ball up and force a maul. Strong, strong work. higginbotham tries to start something, I’d say get angry like that DURING the play not after would be a good thing for the Reds pack right now.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:40pm
Banger said | 8:40pm | Report comment
they have to get digby involved. This is so far his quietest game that I can remember
8:41pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:41pm | Report comment
His pet play (on the inside ball) has fallen apart every time they’ve tried it tonight. Just happened again with Genia this time.
8:39pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:39pm | Report comment
45min
Long kick off. Sharks kick it back, but not out. Reds have it in the attacking half. They get to almost 22 but then a Shark knocks down a pass and they restart back at 30 for reds… no advantage and its a knock on called not a penalty. 50/50 and fair to give one back to the Sharks I think.
Jordaan off with a hamstring problem and Bosman on.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:37pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:37pm | Report comment
He picked off the Genia halfback pass and ran 60m to score. Too easy. Kick good too.
Sharks 27 – Reds 10
8:37pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:37pm | Report comment
Genia gathers the drop out and throws a not called forward pass! They kick high and regather. Then an INTERCEPT TRY FOR MCLEOD!
8:36pm
Jutsy said | 8:36pm | Report comment
The fox guys keep baggin the genia at 10 move but i reckon it might be a masterstroke.
Genia was struggling with breakdown pressure and harris is pedestrian at 10
8:38pm
Red Kev said | 8:38pm | Report comment
Genia to 10 has just cost them the match, he throws an intercept try for the Sharks.
8:38pm
atlas said | 8:38pm | Report comment
Masterstroke? Or maybe not.
QC giving him tips under the posts ‘don’t give away tries”
8:39pm
Jutsy said | 8:39pm | Report comment
Spoke to soon lol
8:39pm
Kuruki said | 8:39pm | Report comment
Masterstroke for the Sharks after that pass.
8:43pm
Jutsy said | 8:43pm | Report comment
Haha i deserve this. Worst call of the night
8:36pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:36pm | Report comment
Harris missed. Was always going to happen… he baulked himself during the run up. Very weird. 22 drop coming.
8:35pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:35pm | Report comment
Michalak kicks and it’s too flat. Simmons take it and runs. They spread it next phase and Morahan is almost away, then infield pass. They are over halfway.
The ball is slowed at the next ruck and that leads to a penalty to the Reds. Good opening move there, making the most of a nothing kick off.
Sharks 20 – Reds 10 with a kick 5 in from touch 40m out left of goal.
8:34pm
KiwiDave said | 8:34pm | Report comment
Missed out on the Crusaders Bulls game because I was in transit but caught the last 5 minutes of the first half here. Whats with the Reds? 20-10 down? They better hope the jetlag hits the Sharks
Kiwidave from Brunei.enroute to the Philippines
8:38pm
Johnno said | 8:38pm | Report comment
macaw the man loved by kiwis but hated by the rest of the world. The dodgy kiwi kiwis derv had a great game hypnotising the ref as usual just the the rugby world cup grand final. Annoying kiwi mcaw is, can e he just retire or flick off to Japan or french 2nd division rugby
8:33pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:33pm | Report comment
Kafe interviews McKenzie and he’s trying to be positive. Thinks they are getting back into it….
8:31pm
Charging Rhino said | 8:31pm | Report comment
SHARKS!!!!! Are on fire! Hope they keep it up in the 2nd half.
JP Peterson!!! Best winger in the world right now in my opinion. And certainly best defensive winger imo.
To think people questioned his credibility in that World XV side. Ha ha. He’s on fire again. As are the rest on them
8:27pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:27pm | Report comment
To get back in this match the Reds pack needs to man up on defense and stop allowing the Sharks to rumble through the first tackle on nearly every occasion. They are allowing way too much momentum without making them earn it enough.
The Sharks will keep trying to drive the tackles backward and attack the ruck with ferocity but less personell. That is their key. McLeod is doing a good job of picking the forward that is running at a hole and Michalak is having the best fun he’s had in a long time, just floating wide counter attacking passes to men with more room to move than they should.
8:30pm
Pot Hale said | 8:30pm | Report comment
“just floating wide counter attacking passes to men with more room to move than they should.”
Nicely put EP. +1
8:31pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:31pm | Report comment
Thanks PH.
He barely has to even pick the runner at this point. Just put the ball in front of the line and let whichever guy out there run onto it. Great to watch. They are all moving as a team. Forward.
8:24pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:24pm | Report comment
So at the break the Sharks 20, have blown the Reds 10 off the field for 30 minutes of the first half. They will be a bit disappointed to leak that last 7 pointer to give the Reds a lot of hope to go to the sheds with.
8:24pm
Jutsy said | 8:24pm | Report comment
Reds pack has to step the eff up!
Glad s. finger was dragged
8:23pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:23pm | Report comment
It goes to ground and Higginbotham runs off the back and loses it forward in contact. HALF TIME.
8:23pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:23pm | Report comment
Reds take the kick off, kick, Sharks return it and Genia got into the air to gather against Kankowski.
He is then hit high by Du Plessis and Reds earn a lineout at the 10ms line in attacking territory. They win it and maul, no metres gained though.
8:22pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:22pm | Report comment
38min
Harris doesnt miss either. He took that at the 15m mark on the left of goal.
Sharks 20 – Reds 10
8:21pm
Mr said | 8:21pm | Report comment
Good try for reds against run of play, [insert 10 minutes of silly Aussue TV commentary here]
8:21pm
Pot Hale said | 8:21pm | Report comment
Nice strike by Genia. Forward pass on the one-two?
8:22pm
atlas said | 8:22pm | Report comment
forward for sure – expected asst ref to call that one back.
8:25pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:25pm | Report comment
Possibly a little. The ball is allowed a metre forward in rugby anyway I thought!
8:25pm
hog said | 8:25pm | Report comment
Commentators didn’t say a thing and that was about 2 metres forward
8:26pm
Jerry said | 8:26pm | Report comment
Noticed that there were no replays you could judge the pass from – the producers know their audience….
8:35pm
Sharks!!! said | 8:35pm | Report comment
Don’t think Kaplin is looking for forward passes, we have got away with a few!
8:20pm
The Werewolf said | 8:20pm | Report comment
Higginbotham is the best winger in the country!
8:20pm
Kuruki said | 8:20pm | Report comment
Good man Genia get your boys back in the game mate.
8:20pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:20pm | Report comment
Sharks clear into touch for their penalty. They maul off the lineout and McLeod launches it high. It is allowed to bounce (NEVER DO THAT) and then the sharks toe forward. Reds scramble and Frisby manages to get it back.
Genia grubbers it away and falls over chasing. Sharks pounce on it.
Reds turn over at halfway.
REDS TRYYYYY!
8:21pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:21pm | Report comment
Good counter attack there by the Reds. Turned over. Genia got it at a wide first receiver position. He gave it to Higginbotham and then backed up to receive the offload. He scores just before halfway to keep the Reds in it.
8:22pm
Red Kev said | 8:22pm | Report comment
Seriously why not make Higginbotham a 13 or 14? I am a big fan of the guy but what was he doing out on the openside wing?
8:33pm
Jutsy said | 8:33pm | Report comment
I just came to a realisation that the reds r seriously missing a fit and firing samo. He does way more breakdown work than higgs
8:18pm
Mr said | 8:18pm | Report comment
Kaplan having good game as ref
8:18pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:18pm | Report comment
35min
Off the lineout Genia dummies and beats 1. Just dragged down and then through the phases Reds give away a penalty. Kankowski at the breakdown there. Good work.
Sharks 20 – Reds 3
8:17pm
Pot Hale said | 8:17pm | Report comment
Michalak is sitting in the biggest LazEBoy 10 armchair behind his pack. He’s enjoying himself.
8:18pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:18pm | Report comment
Haha, good point mate. He’s on cloud 9 tonight. No pressure at all.
8:22pm
RebelRanger said | 8:22pm | Report comment
I reckon he’s playing horrible. His kicks aren’t finding too much distance and that poor pass led to Genias try.
Genia is going okay at 10 now..
8:17pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:17pm | Report comment
Sharks win their scrum under a fair amount of pressure. They clear for the line and get to 25m out.
Reds mess up their play and the Sharks get a lineout now…
ball back into touch again this time 19m out.
Hansen on for Faingaa btw. Reds lineout.
8:16pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:16pm | Report comment
32min
Reds take their lineout. Schatz runs through midfield. Then they come back to the right where Simmons almost breaks and offloads to higginbotham! He’s taken by Ludik but then there was a knockon at the back off the ruck.
Crowd fairly quiet now.
Sharks 20 – Reds 3
8:14pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:14pm | Report comment
Reds earn a penalty off the kick off when Genia tries to clear. I think for offside.
I’ve never seen an attempt at a field goal (at fly half, not the 50m returning kick ones) where the player has been SO SO open. The Reds are completely back pedalling when on defense.
8:12pm
RebelRanger said | 8:12pm | Report comment
Beautiful, beautiful rugby. That drop goal was gold.
Pre-game odds, Sharks at $2.80 hahaha had a good laugh at that..
8:12pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:12pm | Report comment
30min
Sharks are running at gaps and passing into gaps beautifully they almost get to the line and then Michalak drops the most open, unchallenged drop goal I’ve ever seen. Wow… the Reds are nowhere near this so far.
Sharks 20 – Reds 3
8:11pm
Johnno said | 8:11pm | Report comment
reds are having a horror night, a bit like the brumbies last week and the aussies vs scotland and samoa, it is just not going ot be the reds night no matter what they do.
-Jet lag may save the reds bacon as the sharks will tire.
8:13pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:13pm | Report comment
I don’t think this is like the Brumbies too much. They failed to step up and were beaten. The Reds have been obliterated so far. Not allowed to get into the game.
8:11pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:11pm | Report comment
28min
Reds try to run off the kick off but S.Faingaa drops it. They are shaken and not really playing in pods as well as they normally do yet.
Sharks attacking scrum straight after the Reds get on the board.
Sharks 17 – Reds 0
8:10pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:10pm | Report comment
Harris makes that kick. Reds get on the board.
Sharks 17 – Reds 3
8:10pm
Johnno said | 8:10pm | Report comment
In news hot of the press roar. an aussie brett gosper sone of kevin gosper has just been appointed CEO of the IRB. I thought JON was going to get the job..
http://www.irb.com/newsmedia/mediazone/pressrelease/newsid=2063233.html#gosper+appointed+irb+chief+executive
8:09pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:09pm | Report comment
23min
Morahan fields the clearing kick and almost gets through a gap, but gets thrown to ground well by Kankowski and then A.Faingaa gets monstered to ground by Alberts. Reds then have to put 5 in the next ruck to keep the ball. Simply being over powered at the moment. I thought coming into it the Sharks were in better form, but they are in much, much much better form.
Reds win a penalty for not releasing and rolling away quickly enough.
Reds kick for goal coming from about 40m out.
Sharks 17 – Reds 0
8:09pm
Banger said | 8:09pm | Report comment
whats with the substitution. genia at fly half and not harris wtf.
8:10pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:10pm | Report comment
Yeah I thought they should leave Genia at 9 where he gets more touches and controls things a bit better.
8:08pm
Pot Hale said | 8:08pm | Report comment
Lovely, lovely rugby by the Sharks. Great try. Michalak playing out of his skin. Great backline passing and offloading. A pleasure to watch this game so far.
8:07pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:07pm | Report comment
Kick off from Reds and Harris almost gathers but knocks on.
8:06pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:06pm | Report comment
The Sharks are running the ball brilliantly but it all starts because they commit 1 to the breakdown for every 2 Reds and have men wide to either tackle or run at overlaps. It’s powerful work.
8:05pm
Kuruki said | 8:05pm | Report comment
Sharks killing the Reds with some brilliant running rugby.
8:11pm
Red Kev said | 8:11pm | Report comment
Yeah, the Reds are getting schooled. The Sharks are playing beautifully.
Frisby at scrumhalf is really not up to it. I agree with Kafer, Tapuai to 12 and Harris to 10 would have been smarter.
8:18pm
Kuruki said | 8:18pm | Report comment
Crazy move considering the big Sharks forwards are making some big yards. You would think a big boy like Tapuai would have been a much better choice.
8:05pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:05pm | Report comment
SHARKS COMBINATION TRY!!!
8:06pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:06pm | Report comment
23min
The ball popped out of the Reds ruck and the Sharks throw it wide immediately. Pietersen runs an infield angle, steps one, offloads and its over under the posts with little in front of him for Jordaan!
Kick is good as well!
Sharks 17 – Reds 0
8:04pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:04pm | Report comment
21min
Genia at 10 and Frisby at 9.
Reds win the short lineout and keep it tight for 2 phases. Then they go wider and don’t really make any ground.
Genia then kicks it long and Mvovohas to kick it back. Reds have it just over halfway now.
Sharks 10 – Reds 0
8:03pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:03pm | Report comment
Saia Faingaa is having his left arm checked out as well.
8:03pm
ohtani's jacket said | 8:03pm | Report comment
The Reds are cheating more than the All Blacks and Crusaders combined.
8:03pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:03pm | Report comment
And still can’t get in the game!
8:02pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:02pm | Report comment
20min
Ball is run about 40m by THE BEAST and then a turnover. Reds run it about 40 back! Then Sharks pick up a dropped ball that Simmons couldn’t keep a hold of.
Simmons gets talked to by ref for obstructing.
That was a fast and furious passage of play. Frisby is on for Lucas who can’t put weight on one of his legs.
Sharks 10 – Reds 0 and their 3rd string playmaker at 10 now.
8:00pm
Elisha Pearce said | 8:00pm | Report comment
19min
Pressure on that Sharks lineout and there is a fumble backward but they regather. Alberts rumbles it forward and then they kick. Reds have it in the attacking half immediately. Genia tries to combine with Shipperley but it’s covered and then Lucas almost breaks the line. Lucas down in back play…
Reds have to commit a lot to win the ball and it’s slowed everything down .
8:11pm
Kuruki said | 8:11pm | Report comment
Very interesting decision to leave Harris at 12 after Lucas went off.
8:16pm
Kuruki said | 8:16pm | Report comment
Maybe Link is no different to Dingo after all. Why would you play Genia at 10 wtf is he doing. Moving the best halfback in the World to 10 when Mike Harris is on the paddock and Tapuai on the pine? I think the Link for Wallaby coach brigade just took a big hit with that call.
7:59pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:59pm | Report comment
18min
Reds go three passes wide and Morahan made the wrong pass, Ioane open but threw it shorter and Shipperley was tackled well by Pietersen.
They keep the ball and Lucas stabs it out just on the Sharks 22 to put a little pressure on.
Sharks 10 – Reds 0
7:58pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:58pm | Report comment
17min
Ball goes two wide and Morahan gathers. He chips shorter and its easy to gather for Kankowski again. Sharks spread it but THE BEAST throw a forward offload in the tackle. This game is going at a million miles and hour and the Reds are only just holding on at the moment.
Sharks 10 – Reds 0
7:57pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:57pm | Report comment
Long throw is called not straight by Kaplan there. Scrum for the Sharks at the 15mark about 30m from their line. Great spread in the backs.
7:56pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:56pm | Report comment
15min
McLeod box kicks and it’s not out. Morahan kicks for Shipperley to chase but can’t gather it.
Sharks spread it and then kick ahead.
Reds gather and they spread it wide too and then kick through Harris.
Chase is great from the Reds, Kankowski gathered and shrugged off 1 but the 2nd and 3rd man hit him out of bounds.
7:55pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:55pm | Report comment
13min
Good high kick off and Faingaa managed to hit Daniels hard and they get a turnover. Sharks toe the loose ball out but Reds regather and have it about 35 out. They need to get on the scoreboard…
Genia puts Harris away on the blindside again but Harris is out before he can drop the ball into play.
Sharks 10 – Reds 0
7:53pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:53pm | Report comment
12min
Michalak adds the 2 extras off his halfstep run-up.
Sharks 10 – Reds 0.
7:53pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:53pm | Report comment
Morahan was easily stepped at the end but that backline movement was swift and drew the defenders early.
7:52pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:52pm | Report comment
McLeod going through the phases and putting runners in gaps well tonight. Like his work.
Sharks run off their kick off and get right back into the attacking half. They are moving quickly. Reds need to muscle up and stop them before flooding rucks now.
Only 20m out now. Its mostly through the forwards or 1 off Michalak. Then there is space way out wide and a bounce pass finds its way to Pietersen and TRY SCORED IN THE CORNER!
7:50pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:50pm | Report comment
9min
Sharks open the scoring through Michalak.
Sharks 3 – Reds 0
7:49pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:49pm | Report comment
8min
Sharks win the ball off the top and keep it in midfield. Then going left the ball is slowed at the next ruck. They are just 35m out though..
Now room and Sharks almost break the line! Advantage too. Only 22 out! Reds committing to the breakdown leaving room wider!
Du Plessis and Daniels almost score! Penalty though as he drops it. Brought back for a kick at goal!
Reds 0 – Sharks 0
7:48pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:48pm | Report comment
7min
Reds lineout it was.
They win it and Gill runs off Genia. The ball spills forward and Sharks gather and smash it downfield!
Higginbotham gets it just in time and runs it out as he had no support there.
Du Plessis is back up and taking his lineout spot. He’s working his neck out.
Reds 0 – Sharks 0
7:47pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:47pm | Report comment
Reds spread it wide off the lineout but it ended with Harris being thrown to ground. Reds piled in to win their ball. They go 2 passes wide the other way and it ended with a nice little grubber behind the defensive line. Out just outside the 22 of the Sharks.
Du Plessis down and looking very groggy from a head clash.
7:46pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:46pm | Report comment
5min
Sharks win their ball and Michalak knocks it out at the Reds 10ms line. Just trying to get it out of their half.
Reds 0 – Sharks 0
7:45pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:45pm | Report comment
Oooh. The set move off the scrum didn’t work. Lucas put the inside ball for Ioane but it wasn’t timed well enough. That was the pet Cooper-Ioane move there.
7:44pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:44pm | Report comment
3min
Sharks win the lineout there. Good work. That gives McLeod another box kick chance, not out. Ioane gathers and Morahan bombs too long. Counter from Sharks. Michalak takes it to their 10ms line. Small knock on at the back of the next ruck. Reds committed to that quickly. Good work.
Reds 0 – Sharks 0
Reds scrum 35m out.
7:44pm
Johnno said | 7:44pm | Report comment
I hope this semi is more exciting than the bulls vs saders match. I have a good feeling this match will open up. reds to win but just.
-With Kaplan refereeing you never know what is going to happen, which team will get the benefit of the doubt. In matches refs, usually 1 team gets all the luck it is very cut and dried. I have a feeling SANZAR wants 1 aussie team in the 2nd week of the finals, so Kaplan refereeing may reflect that. Just like it was convienant for rugby for NZ to win the world cup, i think. ANd craig joubert is the touch judge and he is capable of anything.
7:57pm
Kuruki said | 7:57pm | Report comment
“I have a feeling SANZAR wants 1 aussie team in the 2nd week of the finals, so Kaplan refereeing may reflect that. Just like it was convienant for rugby for NZ to win the world cup”
Hahahaha mate your gold. Maybe just maybe the teams will decide what happens by the way they play.
8:07pm
Johnno said | 8:07pm | Report comment
Kuruki read my comment just made about 5minutes about you and the kiwis. Ut is in the bulls vs saders blog i wrote it after your comment, you will love it.It will give you a red face and give you high blood pressure, but you kiwis deserve it.
-you know it truue too . It is pure gold and pure truth kuruki. You kiwi mate
9:05pm
RebelRanger said | 9:05pm | Report comment
what did you say? lol..
7:15pm
nick said | 7:15pm | Report comment
Why would SANZAR want that? Why? theres absolutely no reason to want that.
The conspiracy nut jobs like you are all the same, the more ridiculous the assertion the more likely its true in your eyes. Why was it convenient for the ABs to win the RWC, that makes NO sense at all.
7:25pm
Johnno said | 7:25pm | Report comment
It was convieneiant actually nick. Conspiracy theory or not, and there are many people with conspiracy theories some valid, you are very naive if you think match fixing in sports doesn’t exist and rugby is so sacred at the pro level and craig joubert had a good game last final. Why . 2 reasons. A SH team liekt he ALL Blacks the most successful sports team on the planet going to a NH world cup in england 2015, to defend there tittle is more marketable than the french a NH team.
-Also the next 4 years in europe tours , format he SH teams. The AB’S will eb far more marketable over the next 4 years for the big end of season matches at twickenham being under the marketing banner of world champions, so financially the IRB and the home unions will make more money out of the AB’S begin world champs, but come 2015 a NH team will win you watch.
-England V Wales Final
-Or England V France final
-or england v NZ final or boks
-But either way england will be in the grand final no question
7:41pm
nick said | 7:41pm | Report comment
That is such rubbish.
The ABs sell out Twickeham as it is, where they going to put the rest of these people attracted by the world champs showing up? Thats just nonsense. And yes, most conspiracy theories are completely untrue and the believers in them have issues that stretch far beyond what they see in word around them.
You actually think that these referees are deliberately altering the outcomes of games? altering the outcome of games involving far and away the best side in the world that really doesn’t need their help? Why didn’t they fix 07 for the NH? why the Boks? what good did that do? Why not Wales in 2011? The six nations would be a hell of a money spinner with a RWC champ in the mix.
The reason? Cos they’re not fixing anything.
Has it ever occurred to you that the home team may make it into the final because of the support and lift they get from playing at home? You seem to think that ALL world cups are fixed.
Joubert had a good game in that final actually. Ive seen the various videos made by people showing all the alleged instances but mostly they claims made are actually incorrect. Not a lot of people actually know the laws of rugby rather than bar room assumptions about them.
7:51pm
Johnno said | 7:51pm | Report comment
nick i suppose you thought durban borna nd bread had a good game last night in brisbane too. turn it up. and turn it up without he joubert ref standard too he had a shocker.
Not all world cups are fixed . But the AB’S got dudded big time vs the french in 2007 Q/F too,.
8:02pm
nick said | 8:02pm | Report comment
Kaplan last night?
Yeah he was alright actually, you’re going to have to have specific complaints if you wanna win a fight about the ref. Just saying ‘he was woeful’ or something to that effect doesn’t cut it.
Or are you one of those guys who sits on the fence and says ‘he was bad but he didn’t cost them the game’?
Well there’s your question Jonno: Was last nights game fixed? you seemed to think it was but in the other direction. Did Kaplan decide the outcome?
Or was it the far simpler (and therefore far more likely than a massive refereeing conspiracy that involves all the unions, refs and IRB officials without ONE breaking the code of silence all these years to blow the whistle) reason that the Reds were weak at the breakdown, tackled poorly, brought nothing on attack and their coach made a poor decision when he lost his back up playmaker?
8:05pm
nick said | 8:05pm | Report comment
show me a single video that contains all these massive errors (or, as you seem to think, deliberate cheating) that Joubert committed in the RWC?
As i said the ones Ive seen are mostly factually incorrect and basically rants by men who should know better.
Ive seen one by that Aussie troll Matt Williams (think thats his name) who gets most of his calls concerning Joubert factually wrong. Laws must’ve changed since he learned them.
8:11pm
Johnno said | 8:11pm | Report comment
Nick that was the footage i was going to show from setanta, aussie and former waratah coach matt williams is right. Kaino should of been penalised at a very crucial time of the match.
And Kapalsn was rubbish last night all the QLD fans thought so.
8:29pm
nick said | 8:29pm | Report comment
Thats it? One penalty?
How about the ones he DID give them only to see the kicks sail wide?
Were the French in on the fix too? That why they missed the match winning penalty?
I dealt with that video on another thread, Williams is flat out wrong in most of his assessments there. Yu won’t see it though i imagine as your convinced already, i can’t be bothered going through them again cos i was quite in depth concerning Williams inaccurate statements of law.
He’s a predictable curmudgeon so it’s no surprise he thinks what he thinks but unfortunately, he’s factually incorrect regarding 90% of the claims he makes in that vid.
8:54pm
nick said | 8:54pm | Report comment
u also haven’t answered my question but Kaplan?
Fix or not?
7:43pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:43pm | Report comment
Sharks win the lineout and its kicked out about 30m from Sharks line.
7:42pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:42pm | Report comment
1min
Sharks clear it after a phase but it doesn’t go out.
Two passes infield and then Harris stumbles to his knees into the tackle. Reds have it in hand on halfway. Forwards grouped nicely on the blind and Higginbotham is away!! The play eventually ends with the ball over the sideline… good play though.
Reds 0 – Sharks 0
7:41pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:41pm | Report comment
Reds kick off through Quade COoper! Good high one to the 22. Kankowski takes it and it his hard.
7:40pm
Kuruki said | 7:40pm | Report comment
I want the Reds to crawl into next weeks semi against the Chiefs. Cmon Sharks beat the hell out of them and then gift them the win with some ill discipline.
7:43pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:43pm | Report comment
Well Higginbotham just smashes McCleod. Haha.
7:39pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:39pm | Report comment
Here come the Reds!!!! Loud cheer!
7:38pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:38pm | Report comment
Here are the Sharks.
Greg Clarke says the Sharks are a bogey team because they have “won 2 of the last 5 of the past 6 games.” (???)
7:37pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:37pm | Report comment
Not far from everyone getting onto the field now.
Kafe points out how hard the Reds front row will need to work tonight. Good point now that he mentions it. The Sharks front 3 are massive!
7:34pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:34pm | Report comment
Replays of Digby’s tackle that got him 4 weeks earlier in the year. Ouch.
7:31pm
AndyS said | 7:31pm | Report comment
So then, after me then:
Crusaders supporters – “GO SHARKS”
All other NZ supporters – “C’MON YOU REDS”
Nonaligned Australians – whatever, depending on your secondary allegiances (wouldn’t want anyone accused of disloyalty)
Saffers – vote your conscience. Probably “GO SHARKS” to guarantee a SA team in the final, but excusing a “C’MON YOU REDS” if you think it would be an easier job to ensure the home final.
7:31pm
Elisha Pearce said | 7:31pm | Report comment
Not long til kick off now folks! So far I haven’t cranked the volume on my tv so I can’t tell exactly where the Lord of the Rings music is at yet.