WIZ: State of Origin decision will be driven by the dollar
Related coverage
Melbourne have a bad case of the mid-season blues, with five losess in a row, and I think it can be directly attributed to the rigours of this season’s State of Origin battles.
Every State of Origin series is tough, but this most recent one was particularly taxing – both mentally and physically.
If you want proof, look at how few of the Origin stars have been in top form since the series ended. I count Greg Inglis and the Morris brothers, and that’s about it.
Storm coach Bellamy has gone on record saying how frustrated he is with how his team has played over the past month or so.
The question is now: how does he get his side to lift and go back to winning games when they don’t even look like they can score points?
Obviously, they’ve been missing Billy Slater in a big way.
I was at their match last weekend against the Dragons, and while he was clearly short of a gallop, you could just see what a difference Billy makes to the Storm attack. He brings an unbelievable spark to everything they do.
With him back on deck, fully fit, the Storm should rebound very quickly.
But still, it’s clear that the timing of State of Origin needs to addressed.
So here’s an idea: why don’t they take two weekends off from regular NRL action and play the first two Origin matches instead over consecutive Saturday nights.
If there’s then a need for a third and deciding match, they can play that the following Friday night, and let the players back up, if they’re able to, for their clubs that same weekend.
This way, players don’t miss NRL club games, and the Origin is afforded the time and attention that it deserves.
It would also give regular NRL players players a better chance to recover from their niggles and injuries.
To keep the TV network happy, I suggest they play and broadcast three tiers of Origin each Saturday over that period: U16s, U20s and the big boys. It would be a great night of entertaining rugby league.
But while that all may sound good on paper, the reality is that the next decision around State of Origin timing will inevitably be driven by the dollar, especially with rugby league TV rights still up for grabs.
There are a number of commercial implications to be considered by the Rugby League Commission before they’ll agree to changing anything. But this sort of discussion is healthy, if only to bring these concerns to the table.
Outside of Origin, the NRL is shaping up for a cracking finale.
My old mob, the Tigers, simply need to start winning games of football. If they do, they can scrape into the eight. But only barely. They have the talent to do it, but they are also missing five key players right now. It’ll be tough for them.
And speaking of the race for the 8, where were the Knights in the first half of the season? It looks like the players didn’t really believe in what Bennett was doing.
Now he has them all onboard, the team is looking more and more like the Dragons of 2011. Case in point: when Newcastle were up 20-0 against Raiders, they had a penalty in front of the posts. Instead of going for the try, they took the two points.
This is precisely what the Dragons under Bennett used to do. So you know now that Wayne is totally influencing this Knights side now.
They’ll be very tough to beat over the next 5 weeks.
Gary 'Wiz' Freeman is one of the great halfbacks in New Zealand rugby league history. Now an outspoken and popular media personality, he joined The Roar in 2012 as an expert rugby league columnist, and continues in 2013.
- Explore:
- Canterbury Bulldogs, Melbourne Storm, NRL, Rugby League

August 3rd 2012 @ 9:39am
Johnno said | August 3rd 2012 @ 9:39am | Report comment
-The big thing too for global rugby league to survive and have credibility is this. State of origin must be put back in it’s place. It should not be seen as the pinnacle of the sport . The rugby league world cup, test match footy, NRL grand final , tri nations, an old Ashes tour. These should be the pinnacle, not state of origin.
-State of origin should be like the old format a selection trial basically to an Aussie jumper, with out all the kiwis to would be a start.
-If rugby league is serious about rugby league going global, then a series between 2 states in OZ should not be seen as the pinnacle of the sport in the year 2012 and beyond, basketball, rugby union, soccer, water polo, volley ball, these global team sports there pinnacle is a world cup or championship , or Olympic games gold..
State of origin makes money but for how long will it. Also the it does more harm than good theory is starting to show. EG undermining test match footy, the rugby league world cup, and now club footy with the standard and mid season lull happening impacting on tv ratings, and crowd numbers, i hope the players are still standing come finals time.
August 3rd 2012 @ 4:07pm
Mango Jack said | August 3rd 2012 @ 4:07pm | Report comment
The pinnacle of any sport will be whatever forum displays the highest quality games. In the case of league, that it currently state of origin. In terms of intensity and skill level, it is superior to international matches. Until the quality of international teams improves, there’s not much you can do about it.
August 3rd 2012 @ 4:37pm
Bring Back the Bears said | August 3rd 2012 @ 4:37pm | Report comment
You don’t get quality rep games without rep experience. This is why Super League has started England v Exiles and is why NZ needs it’s own origin.
August 3rd 2012 @ 10:35am
Bring Back the Bears said | August 3rd 2012 @ 10:35am | Report comment
I’m a big advocate of stand alone weekends only due to the fact it will open up the possibility of more mid-season rep games, by having a 2-3 week rep break you can also include the Pac Cup and NZ Origin. Not only will this help strengthen the international game by giving other countries more rep experience but it will also help to prevent future NZ and Pac Island players switching allegiances by providing them with something of their own. Plus it also makes the league calendar and season scheduling more diverse and exciting.
Sure you can include NSW/QLD U16 and U20s as well, but that should be secondary to the above. This could be a massive positive for the NRL if pulled off correctly.
August 3rd 2012 @ 10:38am
Chop said | August 3rd 2012 @ 10:38am | Report comment
Whiz, the Tigers are your old team? With all due respect didn’t you have about 4 old teams?
Apart from that, State of Origin is the biggest money generator for the ARLC and they need to find a way to do it justice.
What about a NSW residents and Toyota Cup Origin double on Friday night and the main game on Saturday night? It gives the network some good footy to watch on the main Friday night and will be a ratings winner on Saturday night.
I also hope that the ARLC seperate the rights for the NRL and the Origin/International series. It would be a massive win for the game I think.
August 3rd 2012 @ 10:44am
Bring Back the Bears said | August 3rd 2012 @ 10:44am | Report comment
What about?
Friday: NSW residents and Toyota Cup Origin double.
Saturday: NZ Origin followed by SOO (both kick off at 7:30pm, the time difference between NZ and Aus will make this work perfectly).
Sunday afternoon: Pac Cup games (Cook Islands, Fiji, Papua New Guinea, Samoa and Tonga.)
August 3rd 2012 @ 2:25pm
Andy said | August 3rd 2012 @ 2:25pm | Report comment
i also would like to see a Under 25′s Nrl side verse the over 25′s the Joey’s verse the Wallaroos excluding all current Origin Australia and kiwi’s
August 3rd 2012 @ 9:48pm
tonysalerno said | August 3rd 2012 @ 9:48pm | Report comment
Andy mate as good as it sounds- the NRL are struggling to deal with origin commitments on the calendar, these ideas will only be able to surface if the nrl would put s.o.o on a stand alone weekend; but i don’t think it will be the case for a while.
August 3rd 2012 @ 11:37am
Dayer said | August 3rd 2012 @ 11:37am | Report comment
Chop … why not the Qld resident team instead of the u20′s. would make a lot of sense.
August 3rd 2012 @ 4:32pm
Chop said | August 3rd 2012 @ 4:32pm | Report comment
I meand NSW v QLD residents and a Toyota Cup NSW v QLD double header.
I do love BBTB’s idea of a Kiwi Island of origin ? ( I don’t know what format really but a kiwi game)
August 3rd 2012 @ 4:50pm
Bring Back the Bears said | August 3rd 2012 @ 4:50pm | Report comment
Not 100% how the kiwi origin would work but would be good to see.
North v South Island seems the most logical but depends on the depth of talent in the south island. I don’t think you could use the junior footy eligibility structure that AUS SOO uses as league is primarily played in Auckland. Perhaps actually incorporate where you were born? (Outlandish idea for SOO I know)
I also don’t mind the idea of NZ homegrown v NZ Exiles (Exiles being NZ reps who left the country at a young age e.g. Tamou, Kasiano and Foran.
The other idea thrown around was Auckland v the rest. I’m not a huge fan of this idea as I think origin should encapsulate more than one city.
August 3rd 2012 @ 10:42am
Tony Archers Maroon Underwear said | August 3rd 2012 @ 10:42am | Report comment
How about one game per year instead of three
August 3rd 2012 @ 12:21pm
dogforlife said | August 3rd 2012 @ 12:21pm | Report comment
Origin doesnt work on weekends with ratings or otherwise, mid week people have no prior commitments like kids sport, weddings, birthday parties.. etc. Its a free hit for the ratings midweek also, as there is no real competition from any other sport and in places like Melbourne, Adelaide, Hobart on the weekends how many viewers would be lost to AFL? Then take small businesses like cafes, bars, and to a lesser degree restaurants, already busy on the weekends, they love Origin nights as it’s like a Friday / Saturday in regards to patronage making three big nights in a week instead of two. Origin works best mid week, we have tried every night over the years and they stick with Wednesday because history shows it works better. Why do so many people feel the need to reinvent the wheel when it’s already been done?
As for player welfare arguments, follow Hooks lead at the ponies, rest them and give some up and coming talent a go, that’s how they get better. Not every team can attract origin players, and the ones who do are brought back to the pack every year at that time. That’s the price you pay for having a team with rep players, why should we now give those teams an even bigger leg up over the year.
August 3rd 2012 @ 12:24pm
Dayer said | August 3rd 2012 @ 12:24pm | Report comment
Mate, put the game on and watch them come. n
August 3rd 2012 @ 2:52pm
Jay said | August 3rd 2012 @ 2:52pm | Report comment
I doubt you’d get 400k melbourne viewers if state of Origin was on a weekend or Friday up against the AFL.
August 3rd 2012 @ 3:11pm
Bring Back the Bears said | August 3rd 2012 @ 3:11pm | Report comment
While I agree with you, it doesn’t really say much about the confidence in your product if you’re unwilling to pit your premiere sports event against a round 13 AFL club match (for example).
The blessing and curse with SOO is that it is only ever played between NSW and QLD. Now I am a passionate Blues fan and love SOO, however if NRL will eventually have to make a decision about focusing on heartland or expanding nationally. If they want to expand, the current format needs to change and the focus on what is the pinnacle of the sport needs to change from SOO to international.
August 3rd 2012 @ 2:22pm
Andy said | August 3rd 2012 @ 2:22pm | Report comment
i say leave it as it is.. its up to the club to want to rest their talent after origin or not. that also lets the young guns get a taste on NRL.
our players are highly tuned athletes and altho the game is taxing on the body, they should be able to back up…
not much difference between playing a monday night game then playing a friday night game…
You dont bring players from lower grades if you dont think they are good enough, so having your big guns out shouldnt make a difference if the players are good enough to be there, then they are good enough to play at that pace.
i personally would love to see more rep games…
August 3rd 2012 @ 2:30pm
Gwils said | August 3rd 2012 @ 2:30pm | Report comment
Rugby league is a punishing game, it’s taxing on the players, not to mention the spectators.
August 3rd 2012 @ 3:38pm
Christo the Daddyo said | August 3rd 2012 @ 3:38pm | Report comment
SOO will always be mid-week. There’s too much financial risk to move it. And why would you play it over consecutive weekend? Part of the beauty of the current structure is all the intrigue and build up in between the three games.
I don’t feel sorry for the players – they get big bucks for playing sport. And I don’t feel particularly sorry for the clubs who have lots of SOO reps in their teams – a great deal of running a successful team comes from astute list management. Deal with it.
August 3rd 2012 @ 4:16pm
Mango Jack said | August 3rd 2012 @ 4:16pm | Report comment
I’m sure the networks and ARLC are also measuring the negative impact origin has on club games straight after it. I don’t have figures, but I understand club game ratings take a hit for the period of origin and for a few weeks following , which is probably due to a few factors, but mainly just too much of footy. Having a representative window, for origin and other games, may be best for all forms of the game.
August 3rd 2012 @ 4:56pm
PEP said | August 3rd 2012 @ 4:56pm | Report comment
Don’t forget that the SOO players don’t play for their clubs the week before an SOO game.