Captain’s curse hits Wallabies hard
Related coverage
When Wallabies skipper Will Genia hobbled from Patersons Stadium in Perth on Saturday night with a blown out knee, David Pocock said to him, “mate, let’s not have a captain.”
Genia became the third victim of Australia’s alarming captain’s curse and in a devastating blow to the Wallabies’ Rugby Championship and Spring Tour hopes, the star halfback requires surgery and is expected to miss six months of football after rupturing his anterior cruciate ligament.
Skippers James Horwill (hamstring) and Pocock (knee) have already gone down this season with the ‘c’ next to their name and it’s with some reluctance that coach Robbie Deans hands the badge on to veteran Nathan Sharpe.
The leadership and depth of the Wallabies will now be severely tested for the remainder of the year with Sharpe retiring after the Rugby Championship, and Horwill and Pocock only outside chances of travelling to Europe in November.
Melbourne Rebels No.9 Nick Phipps is set to replace Genia in the starting team against Argentina on the Gold Coast this week and Western Force veteran Brett Sheehan has also been called into the squad.
Genia heard three cracks in his right knee when he landed awkwardly with 11 minutes remaining in Australia’s 26-19 win over South Africa and knew his fate almost immediately.
“I’m gutted,” said Genia.
“I took the high ball and as I landed I twisted in on my knee and I got hit and then it twisted further.
“I knew I’d done something as soon as I heard the cracks and then when I got up and tried to take off and couldn’t support any weight I knew I’d done something quite serious.”
The Wallabies say they’re up to the character test that will come with losing a player as influential as Genia.
The Queensland star said he’d help 23-year-old Phipps through what will be just his second start and fourth cap for the Wallabies.
Genia is confident there’s enough experience in the group to cope without a third elected skipper.
“Sharpie assumes that leadership role and what last night and over the last couple of weeks has showed is we’re building depth,” he said.
“I reckon (Phipps) will do really well. He’s got a good work ethic and he’s got a big motor.”
Deans, who has received some relief from the pressure mounting on his job, said the tenacious game of Sheehan will benefit the group and is confident Phipps will cope despite his lack of Test experience.
“Phippsy’s ready. It’s been a challenge for him to be in the shadow … but he’s understood the need for him to really immerse himself in training as though it’s the game,” said Deans.
Lock Sitaleki Timani (hamstring) is highly unlikely for the Argentina fixture, with Rob Simmons or Kane Douglas to replace him.
Veteran hooker Stephen Moore succumbed to a low grade hamstring injury before the Springboks match, while centre Rob Horne tore his hamstring in club rugby.
The positives for the Wallabies are that inside centre Pat McCabe is available for selection against the Pumas and James O’Connor will join the squad with a view to being fit for the trip to South Africa and Argentina later this month.
Winger Drew Mitchell has also managed to avoid needing further surgery on his troublesome leg injury and will return to full training.
© AAP 2013Looking to join The Roar team? We're searching for an experienced Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. Yes, this does mean you get to work with the site all day long! If you're a digital media sales star, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
![]()
Passionate about your union? Then sign up to The Roar's brand new daily union email, delivering Roaring articles directly to you day-in, day-out. You'll love it!
Click here to join now!
The Crowd Says (17) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Rugby Union, wallabies


September 10th 2012 @ 9:50am
Red Kev said | September 10th 2012 @ 9:50am | Report comment
Great call by Deans to leave out White from the early Wallabies’ matches. Of greater concern of course is that it also screws the Reds! Two years in a row with half our playmaking axis boned for the first half of the season.
Oh well, hopefully his recovery will go well and he’ll be back for the Lions series.
Back on topic – it will be interesting to see how the Wallaby team shapes up without the two first choice tighthead props (Palmer and Kepu), the two first choice tight locks (Horwill and Timani) and the first choice eightman (Palu) and scrumhalf (Genia) – that is a lot of the “backbone” of the team gone.
Sharpe as captain is a mistake – he was awful on the weekend. The Wallabies would be better served by retiring him and installing Simmons as the lineout lock and running Pyle/Neville/Douglas in place of Timani (probably Douglas with Neville off the bench). Make Moore or AAC captain.
I will also be very interested to see how Deans structures the backline – I would like to see Tapuai and McCabe brought into the centres with AAC shifted to fullback and JOC brought back via the bench. Barnes and Beale are taking too many poor options (mainly kicking) and to add insult to injury Barnes’ kicking game is just flat out poor – bad distance kicking for the line, poor direction on out-of-hand kicks in play – Kirchner was taking him to school.
September 10th 2012 @ 1:32pm
allblackfan said | September 10th 2012 @ 1:32pm | Report comment
I’d like to know if anyone at the QRU or ARU is even familiar with the concept of player management.
Aust rugby’s two most valuable players were allowed to play every single game this season (Super and Test). End result: Pocock injured, Genia injured.
Genius. What is the ARU’s high performance director doing?
September 10th 2012 @ 1:56pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 1:56pm | Report comment
I saw this article on sat morning
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/sport/rugby-union/there-are-28-players-unavailable-to-the-wallabies-due-to-injury/story-e6frg7o6-1226467655014
Deans mentions in the interview that Genia has played over 1,280 minutes of super rugby this year. After reading that I thought to myself it was only a matter of time before he broke down.
It didnt help this year that reds had so many injuries at 10, meaning genia was the only constant in the 9-10 axis, his back up lucas was out for a large portion of the year or was playing at 10.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:26pm
Kuruki said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:26pm | Report comment
Every team goes through there ups and downs with injury. The All Blacks faced it in the past. The Boks have a crisis of their own. The Wallabies also. It’s not just in Rugby. I am a Fremantle supporter and for the past 2 years we have had a major injury crisis. You can manage players as much as you want but some things are just unavoidable.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:39pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:39pm | Report comment
To an extent injuries are unavoidable but some injuries such as soft tissue injuries and ligament damage may also indicate poor management of strength/fitness training and recovery sessions.
JOC’s injury was avoidable, he strained his hammy during the mid year break but they rushed him back for mortlock’s farewell game and the strain became a serious tear. Same with beale, he stuffed his ribs up in the last welsh test and then it got worse because they played him in the mortlock game instead of resting him.
And lets not forget mitchell, the best example of poor management of inuries.
I am an essendon supporter so know what your going through
September 10th 2012 @ 1:40pm
JTG said | September 10th 2012 @ 1:40pm | Report comment
What is the thinking behind Brett Sheehan!!!! Another great selection decision, what about Ben Lucas or even Brendan McGibbon surely either of them would be better than Sheehan
September 10th 2012 @ 1:52pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 1:52pm | Report comment
Lucas is injured, mckibbin is not any good.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:14pm
PeterK said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:14pm | Report comment
Moore as captain. Sharpe cant even manage the lineouts well, and is too soft.
Pyle for Sharpe to call lineouts and actually contest more of them. Neville for Timani. Pyle far more physical than Simmons who is the new Mumm. Nevllie offeres more passion, heart and impact than Douglas. Douglas is a journeyman.
Obviously Deans will instead make Sharpe captain, and bring in Douglas to start.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:17pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:17pm | Report comment
PK Douglas will be solid in the scrum though so I think he is required especially against the argies. As a rebels supporter I would love to see pyle or neville given a call up but with deans preferring not to have a specialist lock on the bench I think douglas is the better option as starting lock as neither of the rebels locks have done well at scrum time.
Actually the rebels lineout is pretty woeful too lol.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:26pm
PeterK said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:26pm | Report comment
Neville is a good solid tight lock in the scrums as well. He used to be a rower and provides a lot of power there, rebels just had a very poor thp. The rebels LHP is not that good either.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:33pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:33pm | Report comment
neither is their hooker lol, I still cant believe they headhunted higgy when they already have jones, delve and saffy. Should have got some decent front rowers or beau robinson.
September 10th 2012 @ 2:27pm
Red Kev said | September 10th 2012 @ 2:27pm | Report comment
Simmons demolished Neville and Pyle twice this year in the Reds v Rebels matches. While I am definitely of the opinion that you can’t play both Sharpe and Simmons, ol’Razor is past it, did nothing but give away penalties last match and is failing in his duties in the lineout. Simmons runs a much better lineout, if we actually want to use it as a weapon he needs to be there.
Pyle runs a shambles of a lineout.
Neville might (and I disagree) offer more “passion and heart” than Douglas but he’s a lightweight compared to Douglas at scrum time, he’s not ready.
Run one of the Rebel’s locks off the bench, and take both on the EoYT, but they are competing for essentially the fourth locking spot behind Simmons, Horwill and Timani.
September 10th 2012 @ 6:16pm
Blue Blood said | September 10th 2012 @ 6:16pm | Report comment
Why even take Pocock or Horwill on Spring tour even if fit? Why not use it to blood new talent or to give match time to your 2nd and 3rd string players so that we have some depth in the Wallabies? Then when someone goes down it isn’t the end of the world. Phipps or White should have had more experience by now. Pocock should have played a 3rd less games the last 4 years with Hodgson and Robinson on 20-odd caps each. Same goes for Sharpe, Genia and likely others. Deans is a senseless tool with his use of the bench and team selections over the last 4.5 years. It is frustrating to watch form players constantly get over looked and depth under utilised. I get you have your favourites but Deans flogs them. Pocock’s career will be drastically shorter because of his mismanagement by Deans. Genia and others too.
September 10th 2012 @ 8:31pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 8:31pm | Report comment
Because if deans takes 2nd string team and we lose to france, wales and england we will slip down the rankings. The seeding for the next world cup will be decided early next year so we cant afford to slip too far down.
Also what happens when deans picks a 2nd string team? We lose to samoa/scotland, get accused of having no respect for the opposition and demand that he get the can.
September 10th 2012 @ 9:24pm
Blue Blood said | September 10th 2012 @ 9:24pm | Report comment
Surely the few flogged stars could stay home Jutsie. Even if just Pocock, Genia and Sharpe hadn’t been on your the last 4 years we’d be better off in key positional depth. If we can’t win without these players then we don’t deserve the 2nd world rating
September 10th 2012 @ 9:34pm
Jutsie said | September 10th 2012 @ 9:34pm | Report comment
In general I dont mind putting in a few experimental players for the nov tests.
But this nov we definitely need to take as full a strength team as possible cos like I said its imperative that we beat the french, welsh and english this nov to maintain a high ranking before the seeding for the next world cup is decided.
Another thing you have to factor in is how much whining JON and the ARU do when the NH teams send second string down here in june. Imagine how much flak we’d cop for being so hypocritical if we sent a 2nd string team up there.
September 10th 2012 @ 9:48pm
Lorry said | September 10th 2012 @ 9:48pm | Report comment
And noone wants rugby to end up the joke that international soccer is (except for the WC of course)
Aust. need to send strong teams, as do the others.
All rugby has is international (and to lesser extent provinvial) competition