Sydney Swans fly in Adelaide, down Crows
By Kirsten Tona, 12 Sep 2012 Kirsten Tona is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- Adelaide Crows, AFL, AFL finals, Sydney Swans
Related coverage
Did you see the Swans’ faces after the game? And their body language? Did you see it? Now that is what they’re talking about.
The Adelaide-Sydney game was not just a test of skill, but of character, and if there’s ever a club that understands the importance of character in the game, it’s the Swans.
There’s very little between the top sides now, and the Swans have as good a line-up and as much depth and skill as anyone. What they don’t yet have is the killer instinct.
But they’re working on it.
There was a moment in the first half of the second quarter when the game still could have gone either way. Dangerfield won a free just outside the attacking 50m and the Crows looked close to closing the two goal gap.
But phenomenal Swans pressure in the backline resulted instead in the pattern we were to see all day: Adelaide struggling like cross-country wrestlers to get their ball into a scoring position, the Swans ‘Super Six’ backline telling them, “Get that s*** offa my court!”, a few beautiful deliveries along the wing and a Swans goal instead: this one by Sam Reid from a perfect Jarrad McVeigh pass.
The Swans have very few holes in their game, but their defence is really the aspect that could deliver them the flag. And let’s not forget, their ’05 victory came from a mark in the backline: they may not have ‘Leaping’ Leo Barry anymore, but with defenders like Lewis Roberts-Thomson, powerful and convincing in his re-vamped role as defender, and Ted Richards, who gave Taylor Walker his worst day this year, we could well see a repeat performance in 2012.
A killer team would have finished Adelaide off in the third quarter; instead the Swans seemed content to let them get a run-on, then stop it. There were moments in the last quarter too when Swans had the ball in their backline and were content to settle and play possession, where a better option might have been to go hard into attack and demoralise the opposition.
They could afford the risk and they need the confidence; the losses to Hawthorn and Collingwood were just too close, a matter of who had the momentum when the siren went and the Swans will need to convince themselves they won’t let it happen again.
And there’s no real reason it should, because if they can muster the self-belief, they have the ability.
Ryan O’Keefe must be one of the most underrated players in the league. He can kick them on the run, from a set shot, from an angle, probably from the stadium roof if he had too, he’s that good. And his goals weren’t even needed on Saturday: that kind of kicking around the ground is just deadly.
Plus he marks, spoils, tackles, runs… with nearly 40 disposals, he proved once again that the Swans dodged a bullet when he didn’t go to Carlton.
Late replacement Mitch Morton: beautiful mark, beautiful goal, beautiful timing for both (answering a hard-earned goal from Sloane), then gets up ready to do it again. The natural forward Swans wanted. Remember, he was Richmond’s top goal-kicker before he came to Sydney, and against Adelaide he showed why.
Does anyone know what position Adam Goodes actually plays? All 18 of them, from Saturday’s viewing, and half-a-dozen of the opposition’s roles as well. He also is just the mentor Lewis ‘Twinkletoes’ Jetta needs; after the game Goodesy was cheering and pointing to him and calling to others what looked like, “That’s my man! That’s MY man!”
I wish I could see the replay from another angle, because I suspect Goodesy had a lot to do with getting Jetta settled after his early nerves. Like a stolid track pony with a twitchy young sprinter. If the stolid pony was also a dual Brownlow medallist.
Mike Pyke is still a worry, big factor in the loss to Geelong. “Made less mistakes this week,” is not what you want to say about a premiership player. He’ll need to lift to match the prevailing attitude now.
Alex Johnson seems no worse from that appaling Longmuire spray he copped last week, he had a terrific game. As did Kennedy (35 disposals), Hannebury, Mattner, Rhys Shaw and Shane Mumford.
Sydney’s depth is the factor that their opponents fail to counter, they are able to run a loose man behind the ball without sacrificing any strength.
Ben McGlynn’s hamstring injury looks like it might be right with the week’s rest, and that will give the selection committee an interesting choice. They may prefer to bring Heath Grundy back (from a one-match suspension) and put him somewhere unusual. A touch of creativity in using a player coming back in a different position can work wonders: look at Lewis Roberts-Thomson.
The Swans could not have asked for a better preparation. Such tough matches in the lead-up to the finals have ironed out many kinks and they will be using the week off wisely – drills, drills, drills. They won’t get away with skill errors against, say, Hawthorn.
As for the magical factor of psychology, they’re ironing kinks out there, too. At the end of the season they seemed to look around, notice with surprise that they were top of the ladder, get vertigo and promptly fall off.
But they are back on now, the faces of the players as they ran around applauding each other and their supporters, and in the clubrooms singing ‘The Red and The White’ with such gusto they were practically in tune, showed what they have that is taking more obvious teams by surprise:
Character.
![]()
Passionate about your AFL? Then sign up to The Roar's brand new daily AFL email, delivering Roaring articles directly to you day-in, day-out. You'll love it!
Click here to join now!
Looking to join The Roar team? We're searching for an experienced Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. Yes, this does mean you get to work with the site all day long! If you're a digital media sales star, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
AFL articles
- Record low AFL crowd for GWS home match (209)
- Giant challenges ahead for Greater Western Sydney (200)
- Kevin Sheedy sticks by comments (143)
- My open-letter to AFL supporters (91)
- Long, cold winter ahead for Western Bulldogs (86)
- Why we should ease up on the Giants (81)
- A conference system won’t provide AFL equality (73)
- 2013 AFL season: Round Nine preview (0)
- A dummy’s guide to AFL rules (23)
- Australian rules football and improving Indigenous relations (31)
- Round 8 wrap: Melbourne show heart, Collingwood send flag message (4)
- Essendon continue to bomb out (34)
- Why the easybeats can be the hardest to defeat (7)
- My open-letter to AFL supporters (91)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- Adelaide Crows, AFL, AFL finals, Sydney Swans


September 12th 2012 @ 3:11pm
TW said | September 12th 2012 @ 3:11pm | Report comment
This is sort off topic but does include The Swans.
They will travel to Wellington in NZ next Anzac Day to play The Saints. This match has been months in the planning and the go ahead has finally been reached.
The Wellingon City Council has been enthusiastic about this game and were planning a sports gala featuring this match and other football codes matches. They were trying to attract events to the city at that time of the year.
Great idea to show the game on Australian National TV after the annual Anzac Day Clash at the G AND it will be for premiership points, so it is very relevant.
Link–
http://www.afl.com.au/tabid/208/default.aspx?newsid=147501
At this time it appears that the Richmond Tigers and GWS will play a match in India in 2014 at one of the leading cricket grounds over there. This continues the AFL`s intention to take the sport (AFL teams) overseas to selected markets. Also two AFL teams will play in London this year after the season finishes.
September 12th 2012 @ 8:01pm
EddyJ said | September 12th 2012 @ 8:01pm | Report comment
Very good analysis Kirsten. I think the Swans were given a huge leg up by the AFL when they announced that their Preliminary match will be on the Friday night before the Grand Final, giving them an extra recovery day over the winner of the Hawthorn v Adelaide or Fremantle (if they win the match of course). But they will be playing a team (Collingwood or West Coast) that will only have a six-day recovery period, and 21 of the 24 Preliminary finals have been won by the team that has had the week off beforehand (ie, this year, it’s Sydney and Hawthorn).
Doesn’t mean that it will automatically happen, but there’s a pretty good chance that it will (87.5 per cent). I think selecting Mitch Morton was a good move – I’m just surprised that it hadn’t happened earlier in the year… or is he just one of John Longmire’s tricks up the sleeve? Perhaps it’s because he came from Richmond, and they are a bit unruly down there.
Just changing subject slightly, during the Adelaide–Sydney match, Taylor Walker’s mullet looked awful, and I’m sure it’s letting him and his team down. At times, he looked like a peacock trying to attract a potential suitor, which might be OK out in the bush, but just totally unacceptable on the football field. It certainly didn’t help his goalkicking.
Are there any statistics available that show a mullet-to-loss ratio? (ie, the more mullet’s in the team, the greater the chance of a loss). I’d be interested to know.
September 16th 2012 @ 6:42pm
jonathan livingstone swansong said | September 16th 2012 @ 6:42pm | Report comment
hawthorn have about four mullets, so they are gone. Paul kelly for sydney, but hes retired. dont think syd have any other mullets. My theory is that the more collingwood supporters without teeth, the greater the chance of victory-look at the footage. the beer spit coming out with the abuse is brilliant footage.