Berrick Barnes and more tries a must for the Wallabies
By David Lord, 15 Sep 2012 David Lord is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Berrick Barnes, James OConnor, Rugby Union, wallabies
Australia rugby union coach Robbie Deans speaks with players Berrick Barnes and Nick Phipps. (AAP Image/Paul Miller)
Related coverage
Four days ago I was pilloried by a senior Roar editor, and quite a few Roarers, as being hairbrained to suggest James O’Connor should be groomed as the Wallaby halfback with Will Genia out for six months after knee surgery.
As it turned out subsequently, O’Connor will miss the entire Rugby Championship with on-going hamstring problems, making my original suggestion purely academic.
Lo and behold, Wallaby coach Robbie Deans has since named Berrick Barnes as fullback for tonight’s clash with the Pumas at the Gold Coast.
O’Connor has never played halfback, Barnes has never played fullback. Is Barnes a hairbrained selection as well?
Not a peep out of anybody. How about that?
Despite the brickbats, O’Connor would have made a real fist of donning the nine jersey, as Barnes will make a real fist of wearing 15.
And the reason? Both are very talented and versatile footballers.
Genia’s long-term injury was the reason for suggesting O’Connor with Nick Phipps not up to speed. The return of Pat McCabe at inside-centre the reason why a spot had to be found for Barnes, whose goal-kicking makes it imperative he’s in the starting line-up.
Barnes has landed 25 of 29 shots at goal this international season. The 86% strike rate is pure gold with the Wallabies really struggling to score tries.
Tryless against Scotland, five in three Tests against Wales, one try in two Tests against the All Blacks, and two tries last weekend against the Boks making it eight tries from seven Tests. Hardly riveting stuff.
On the credit side, the Wallaby defence has only allowed in eight tries to square the ledger.
With Mike Harris briefly in the kicking role against Scotland and Wales, that makes 19 of Barnes’ goals vital three-pointers, that has kept the Wallabies somewhere in touch, especially as ill-discipline has cost 28 successful penalties against them.
So the difference between winning and losing has been the Wallabies’ giving away penalties, making Barnes’ retention a must at all costs.
Wingers Digby Ioane, and Dom Shipperley, who made an excellent debut against the Boks, and consistent outside-centre Adam Ashley-Cooper couldn’t possibly be dropped, so struggling fullback Kurtley Beale had to be the scapegoat for Barnes, and drop down to the bench.
The formula for winning is simple, the Wallabies must score more tries.
Providing Phipps lifts his game and sends Quade Cooper on his way with consistently swift accurate service with no double-pumping, tonight’s Wallaby backline is the best balanced this winter, and if – and it’s a big if – Ioane and Shipperley receive some decent quick possession with room to move, that try-scoring rate will rise accordingly.
Upfront, the Radike Samo experiment starting at eight against the Boks, with Scott Higginbotham coming off the bench, was a huge success.
Samo was a powerhouse, while Higginbotham turned in by far his best Test performance of the season, scoring within minutes of taking the field.
Lock Kane Douglas debuts tonight, and if he throws his massive 202cm, 123kg, frame around with conviction, it could well be the start of a long international career.
And good luck to veteran 34-year-old lock Nathan Sharpe who will captain the side tonight in the absence of James Horwill, David Pocock, and Will Genia – all victims of the captain’s poisoned chalice.
Sharpe has been a tower of strength for the Force and the Wallabies in his farewell season, and it would be fitting if he can lead the men-in-gold to victory in the last three games of the Rugby Championship against the Pumas tonight and the Boks, and Pumas, both away.
Hopefully tonight aimless senseless kicking will be wiped out altogether, and the Wallabies play ball-in-hand.
The Wallabies will be up against arguably the best pack in the tournament, and they sure won’t beat the Pumas if they kick away hard-earned possession.
The visitors, like any decent side, thrive on gift ball and make the culprits pay dearly on the scoreboard.
Looking to join The Roar team? We're searching for an experienced Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. Yes, this does mean you get to work with the site all day long! If you're a digital media sales star, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
![]()
Passionate about your union? Then sign up to The Roar's brand new daily union email, delivering Roaring articles directly to you day-in, day-out. You'll love it!
Click here to join now!
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- Where is Deans in the pecking order of rugby coaches? (319)
- Wallabies squad announced: Folau in, no Quade Cooper – yet (267)
- Deans: Should he stay or should he go? (245)
- SPIRO’s Lions Diary: Deans goes for experience, plus Folau (242)
- Wallabies 25-man Lions squad: analysis (214)
- Quade Cooper misses Wallaby squad selection (209)
- Quade shouldn’t be fly half against the Lions (184)
- Could Matt Lucas be a Wallaby bolter? (86)
- Australia, time to get behind the Wallabies (207)
- Who can still win the Super Rugby title? (42)
- Deans must forgive Quade: Slack (130)
- SPIRO: Super Rugby TMOs are making too many mistakes (109)
- Rebels’ O’Connor stays on sidelines (11)
- ‘Lucky 29′ journey into despair (part one) (8)
- Australia, time to get behind the Wallabies (207)
- Who can still win the Super Rugby title? (42)
- ‘Lucky 29′ journey into despair (part one) (8)
- My open letter to the ARU (17)
- Super Rugby teams will skin the Lions (116)
- Super B to the rescue for rugby? (53)
- Picking your ‘First V’ for the Wallabies (68)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- Berrick Barnes, James OConnor, Rugby Union, wallabies


September 15th 2012 @ 6:06am
ben said | September 15th 2012 @ 6:06am | Report comment
I am in agreement with Mark Ella and Kurtley should have been left at 15 with Barnes at 12. I would bring McCab back from the bench.
I think that barnes at 15, who has never played there at Super 15 or Test level(that i can remember) is not a terrific idea. Especially since he in not a back 3 player.
He and Phipps will be targeted……
More to the point Kurtley deserves more time to work his way back. When in shape he is a world 15 player. Not sure how this improves from the bench.
Mark Ella was correct i fear. 15 has to be an attacking option, just look at Dagg and Beale when in form.
Barnes at 15 is not a recipe for more tries i fear.
September 15th 2012 @ 6:09am
David Lord said | September 15th 2012 @ 6:09am | Report comment
ben, I never said Barnes will be there to score tries, that’s up to AAC, Ioane, and Shipperley. Barnes is there to pot a lot of goals. If Barnes wasn’t an 86% goal-kicker, he wouldn’t be there, and Beale would do the goal-kicking.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:08am
ben said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:08am | Report comment
Hi David,
i think that 15 has to be an attacking option. Regardless. I dont think that Barnes fits that and should at 12.
September 15th 2012 @ 11:30am
Mantis said | September 15th 2012 @ 11:30am | Report comment
At least he will (hopefully) do less useless kicking from 15.
September 15th 2012 @ 12:16pm
hoqni said | September 15th 2012 @ 12:16pm | Report comment
True
September 15th 2012 @ 3:41pm
Kuruki said | September 15th 2012 @ 3:41pm | Report comment
Do you think he will do less kicking? I think he will now have even more justification to kick the ball away.
September 15th 2012 @ 4:57pm
Mantis said | September 15th 2012 @ 4:57pm | Report comment
I never said less kicking, just hopefully less useless kicking. At least at 15 he will have a bit more time to think about where he puts it, as oppose to his kick and hope tactics he seems to have adopted at 12.
September 15th 2012 @ 6:10am
Sailosi said | September 15th 2012 @ 6:10am | Report comment
Not a peep, a lot of people on the roar have expressed their dissatisfaction at Barnes selection at 15, I think you will find Tim Horn and Rod Kafer found it strange. Berrick Barnes should be nowhere near a Wallaby jersey. He’s slow, unimaginative, lacks vision, a poor kicking game, can’t pass to his right and has poor basic skills which cost the team when under pressure.
September 15th 2012 @ 6:44am
Who Needs Melon said | September 15th 2012 @ 6:44am | Report comment
Sailosi you’ve beaten me to it. I was about to post something very similar.
David if you want to read some peeps, try here: http://www.theroar.com.au/2012/09/11/wallabies-team-to-play-argentina-announced
But I wish Berricks and all the guys the best of luck tonight. I hope they are up for a torrid, brutal game.
September 17th 2012 @ 7:27am
Arnold said | September 17th 2012 @ 7:27am | Report comment
I don’t know who you’ve been watching Barnes isn’t the player you described. Oh I know who you have been watching its cooper get your players right.
September 15th 2012 @ 6:19am
ADSA said | September 15th 2012 @ 6:19am | Report comment
I do think you are right David, it is a more balanced backline, my big worry is Mcabes fitness in the important no.12 position. I am looking forward to seeing Sheehan come on for an angry cameo in the last 20min, ia ma sure he will find soemone a lot bigger to niggle.
September 15th 2012 @ 6:52am
Bazza said | September 15th 2012 @ 6:52am | Report comment
I still have some doubts McCabe is the right player for inside centre if we want to spread the ball wide. AAC, Ioane and Shipperly need to be fed balls that puts them into space and so far McCabe has not shown that he can do that. I’m sure he will hit it up hard and tackle like a demon but I’m dreading he will get held up in the tackle and we will lose possession…just like we do with those dribble kicks. Maybe we are going in with an 11 man game plan.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:06am
Uncle Argyle said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:06am | Report comment
David,
it appears to me that Berrick Barnes has retained selection in the starting XV as an insurance policy. Whilst I thought Barnes was good against Wales, his form in the Championship not to good except his goal kicking. It is no secret that the Wallabies have struggled in attack hence Barnes is selected to ensure we at least have a drop goal/goal kicking specialist. OK, when your team is not going that well any points are good points I get that but are we limiting our ‘attack recovery’ in the process?
Barnes is conservative. Against South Africa He missed out on opportunities to take on defenders when Australia had numbers and when backs were facing off against forwards in the backline. Australia must start to develop a counter attack from the kick. We were simply out gunned in the kicking duel against South Africa. If we have a back three that were willing to counter attack Australia may start to find some confidence back in its ball running attack.
Berrick Barnes is not the man for that. Kurtley Beale used to be however he has been about as threatening as a slightly petulant teenager. Personally I would have liked to have seen Luke Morahan get a run and Quade given kicking duties, or even bring in Ben Tapaui at 12 and move Pat McCabe to 15. Plenty of hard running in that back line David.
But in fairness to Coach Deans its not my job on the line.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:06am
daniel said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:06am | Report comment
Im sick of everyone giving digby a free pass he has not scored in his last 10 test matches and almost as many games for the reds. He does not offer anything except run hard when someone passes you the ball. His defence and rugby awareness is shocking. He should be dropped if anyone , but because lots of others are playing so poorly he gets makes everyone think he is great. A wingers job is to get tries , defend well against the high ball and get back and help the full back which he rarely does. Mabye I’m just still angry about losing 22 nil to nz and having to sit there and watch him laugh and almost ask sonny bill for his autograph after the game while i was shocked and sad.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:27am
Bazza said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:27am | Report comment
Daniel, if you are still angry about losing 22-0 to the All Blacks then this may ease your anger. Sit down with a drink of your choice and watch the AB v Boks game tonight. For many in the rugby fraternity who have been around a while they still consider this match up of teams to be the’ real’ rugby contest. You may not feel so angry about the Wallabies losing 22-0 to the AB’s after the game.
OH…..and then remember we beat the Boks last week.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:34am
daniel said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:34am | Report comment
Thanks your right Bazza.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:44am
Rugby Tragic said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:44am | Report comment
Bazza, if you are inferring, before the match that the 22 zip scoreline might pale over the NZ v Boks match tonight, I am 100% with you!
If the Boks play their usual game of hoof the pill and challenge for possession in their opponent’s half looking for mistakes to capitalise on or penalties to keep the scoreboard moving, a similar game that the played last week, I think they will get slaughtered. I know, a big call, but the AB back 3 know how to field the high ball and are equipped to diffuse such tactics before launching their own counter with a “thank you very much for possession”. Only Savea had shown an fragility under the high ball in a single test against Ireland but you can bet Hansen and his cronies have addressed that!
OK I can accept that maybe those tactics were deliberate against the Wallabies to test Beale – fair enough but if they give away so much possession against the All Blacks they will suffer. Can the Boks change?… Hmmm don’t think so, it’s in their DNA. Watch over time them take away the advantages of that potential wonder-kid Johan Goosen – they did it to Lambie so I suspect nothing is going to change!
I might end up red faced but I think the Boks will NOT get within 20 of the AB’s tonight.
September 15th 2012 @ 8:02am
Bazza said | September 15th 2012 @ 8:02am | Report comment
Rugby Tragic…….I think they may but even if the AB’s only win by 10 points it will still make the Wallabies loss by 22 look OK. These 2 sides are the traditional rivals of rugby in the Southern Hemisphere and both lift their performance when they play each other. Compared to them we are relatively new when it comes to being competitive against either of them. (I’m talking late ’70′s on) HOWEVER, there is a big chance the AB’s will stick it right to the Boks. There will be no weather elements to contend with in the covered stadium.
September 15th 2012 @ 9:51am
Bazza All Black said | September 15th 2012 @ 9:51am | Report comment
Hi guys – if the ABs can get rid of the finishing problems and silly handling errors, they will clean the Boks clocks, if not they may upset us and kick us to death…
September 15th 2012 @ 7:41am
David Lord said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:41am | Report comment
Daniel, the reason why Ioane hasn’t scored for a long time is his inside backs keep kicking away possession, forcing Ioane to become a chasing winger. If he’s given any decent ball. in fact any ball at all, he’s one of the finest finishers in world rugby. But without the ball he’s just making up the numbers – a tragic waste of talent dying of boredom.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:57am
Rugby Tragic said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:57am | Report comment
David, I have been a long time admirer of Ioane and still am – he is/was an excitement matchine. I have been at 3 games so far (match against Argies will be 4th) and watched him play in addition to other matches I have watched in this international season on TV.
I think opposition have him worked out, they know he is a danger but this year more than before he has crabbed sideways much more, often as a result of the ball he gets is not good ball. Rarely does he have the opportunity to beat ‘his man’, he increasingly attracts the defence and the bigger loosies at the breakdown.
He has become a little predictable in that I do not recall him passing the ball in any of the internation matches he has played this year (I might be wrong there but do not recall), I have seen him kick a couple of times only. So his opponents have him figured out and know what they need to defend against, that is take him down, he will take the tackle, no need to worry about offloads as well.
As a finisher he is great, and I agree that often the ball he gets is from his ‘hunting for it’ or the ball he gets is from a person in no greater position than himself. The team is asking plenty of him! For what it is worth, I might sound critical but only for the fact that I also think his talents have not left him but he needs the ball with a bit more space and to become less predictable.
September 15th 2012 @ 9:12am
daniel said | September 15th 2012 @ 9:12am | Report comment
I agree rugby tragic. He is a great explosive runner but that is it. If the wallabies were designing plays to put him in space or one on one then fine have him in the team but they dont so why have him. He does not excell at any other part of a wingers game i.e. positional play, reading the game , catching or kicking. I think wing is moving the way of you need the catching skills of a fullback , kicking skils of a fly half and be able to finish as well. I just think there could be a safer option if your not going to use his skill of ball in hand.
September 16th 2012 @ 8:35am
Rugby Tragic said | September 16th 2012 @ 8:35am | Report comment
Yikes Digby passed last night! …. He PASSED the pill, just once in the first half and at the end of that movement, Radike Samo loss the damn ball in the corner over the line!!
Daniel, it is the media pumping him up to be the ‘world’s best winger’. I do agree he is very good but he need to change his own strategies and not be so predictable. I love his passion and he has been great to watch but becoming a little too one demensional. Anyone recall laast year when that Jerome Kaino picked Ioane up when he was bacically over the line and drove him back several metres? – not saying a try would have been scored IF he passed but the defence did not need to worry about his support players get the ball – it just wasn’t going to happen!
September 15th 2012 @ 2:16pm
bennalong said | September 15th 2012 @ 2:16pm | Report comment
Digby has suffered since QC Has been injured/out of form
He’s a special player, not a classic winger, but perfect IMO for the modern game
But using him to effect has been more difficult with injuries because he needs backup as well as QC putting him thru holes
September 15th 2012 @ 7:17am
Matt said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:17am | Report comment
Has everyone forgotten Harris; also an 80% kicker? He can tackle and pass, has made many good line breaks and strong carries for the Reds this season, and is a genuine second-five and play making option. He also is familiar with Quade, Digby and Shipperley in the back line. AAC is the right choice for the 13 jersey, but I’m out of ideas for fullback. Beale is not up to it at the moment, Barnes’ kick is not long enough. Didn’t McCabe play fullback for the Brumbies?
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download it now [http://itunes.apple.com/au/app/the-roar/id327174726?mt=8].
September 15th 2012 @ 7:29am
Bazza said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:29am | Report comment
Matt…….no, I haven’t, Harris at 12 then either McCabe or Barnes at 15 for me.
September 15th 2012 @ 11:34am
Mantis said | September 15th 2012 @ 11:34am | Report comment
Give Moggy a crack at 15.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:36am
Uncle Argyle said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:36am | Report comment
I like him but would like to see him improve his one on one tackling. He is no speed hump but can drop off a tackle or two.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:41am
Allanthus said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:41am | Report comment
Matt, Harris is a solid player but if he had stayed in NZ, no more than ITM provincial level, not within a sniff of the AB’s.
Daniel, you are surely taking the p? Ioane is the Wallabies one true game breaker, the fact he isn’t scoring tries is down to the failings of the team. He survives on scraps and rarely receives running ball in any space. It shouldn’t be hard to fix – all he needs is a forward pack which delivers ball on the front foot and a midfield with slick passing skills…. Sounds easy…
David, you’re one of many peddling this strange line about the Argies having the best forward pack in the competition. Sure, they are big, combative, tackle like they mean it and very competitive. But, once the conditions improved last week and as the game wore on, the AB’s pack was well on top. The Pumas scrum was good but still well held by NZ. They didn’t cut it for the full 80 mins and if the Wallabies can play with the same aggression and tempo up front that they showed in the last 40 against SA, and sustain this, then they too will help put this myth to bed.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:48am
David Lord said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:48am | Report comment
Allanthus, I would be delighted if the Wallabies can put that “myth” to bed. But it’s far more likely the Puma pack will put the Wallabies to bed.
September 15th 2012 @ 9:28am
daniel said | September 15th 2012 @ 9:28am | Report comment
Sorry im not taking the piss when was the last game digby was this true game breaker people talk about he hasnt scored in his last 10 tests. He was once a game breaker just like beale was 18 months ago just like cooper was 18 months ago. Show something now or give someone else have a chance surely they can’t score less tries. I dont have anything against him I just dont get why he is called this great game breaker when he hasn’t broken a game apart in over a year. If he is relying on others to get him great ball to do things with then they are the game breakers not him. Hes just a finisher and there are plenty of them around.
September 15th 2012 @ 1:16pm
redsnut said | September 15th 2012 @ 1:16pm | Report comment
You have been told why he has not been as effective this year by other posters.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:35am
rabbitfan said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:35am | Report comment
Rubbish, Here’s a player who you say must be in the team for his goal kicking yet hands the ball to the opposition every time he gets it in his hands, the man is a serial instinctive kicker who continually puts his team on the defensive, If Barnes was playing for Germany in 1940 he would have been shot by now.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:36am
Uncle Argyle said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:36am | Report comment
Yes but by whom?
September 15th 2012 @ 9:54am
Sage said | September 15th 2012 @ 9:54am | Report comment
The Gestapo ?
September 15th 2012 @ 10:08am
Uncle Argyle said | September 15th 2012 @ 10:08am | Report comment
The SS?
September 15th 2012 @ 3:48pm
Kuruki said | September 15th 2012 @ 3:48pm | Report comment
My great grandfather who loved running rugby lol.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:46am
moaman said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:46am | Report comment
DL——Your suggestion to “groom” JOC for the #9 spot perhaps isn’t completely hair-brained but I find the the opening paragrah of this article a tad disingenuos when in your earlier piece you were calling for his immediate introduction! …….” Unless James O’Connor is the new Wallaby halfback for the rest of the year…”
it’s one thing to “groom” a talented athlete for a new position–quite another to throw him to the wolves willy-nilly.
Finally-comparing a switch to 15 (for a 10/12 player) to a change to 9 is ‘apples and oranges’.Still-quite rediculous.
September 15th 2012 @ 7:56am
David Lord said | September 15th 2012 @ 7:56am | Report comment
moaman, when I wrote that about O’Connor he was never going to play tonight against the Pumas, but was due nack on duty for the South Africa-Argentina leg. That’s very different to what you have just portrayed.
September 15th 2012 @ 8:07am
Allanthus said | September 15th 2012 @ 8:07am | Report comment
Two points
1. Phipps is competent and competitive and will be far from the Wallabies worst player
2. For O’Connor to be considered at halfback he would be required to have a haircut first. No way the proud union of ex no.9′s would have their reputations sullied by Beiber fever. It’s a number 1 or a number 2 or else stay out wide.
September 15th 2012 @ 8:28am
moaman said | September 15th 2012 @ 8:28am | Report comment
Fair enough DL-My apologies.
September 15th 2012 @ 8:40am
Hansie said | September 15th 2012 @ 8:40am | Report comment
Barnes has played full back. He played there quite a bit for Sydney Uni last year while recovering from his head knocks. Again, your articles would benefit from some basic research.