The Boks’ pivot conundrum
By Neville Darangwa, 21 Sep 2012 Neville Darangwa is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- Elton Jantjies, Johan Goosen, Morne Steyn, pat lambie, Rugby Union, Springboks, The Rugby Championship
Related coverage
With the shenanigans of Mendoza and Dunedin behind us, it’s time to reflect. Let’s start here; the South African national rugby team have made it no secret they harbour the ambition of reaching rugby’s Everest in the near future.
I think it’s fair to say that the pivot position is one of the most influential positions on the rugby field and, as such, among the key determining factors as to whether this goal may or may not be attained.
It begs the question; why is the starting berth in this squad continually occupied by a man who, quite frankly, lacks the impetus to lead such a talented squad to this Promised Land?
Offensive potency, flair and capacity to attack the gain-line with purchase are all qualities the position is yearning for and with Morne Steyn’s creativity about as blunt as the other side of a knife, they remain as far as ever from world domination.
It is also cumbersome and entirely telling to note that the one world class quality he does possess (his kicking) has at times flattered to deceive this season. In fact, Steyn’s kicking was horrendous against the AB’s last weekend, which saw him spurn an opportunity for the Boks to turn their early dominance into points.
In the same breath, other options such as Elton Jantjies and Johan Goosen have excelled and matured in this discipline – among the other qualities they bring to the table. So, aside from experience, what advantage point does Morne have that allows him to don the number 10 jersey evidently unchallenged?
Think of it this way; in the days when this Blue Bulls style kicking game was employed, the Springbok squad had lineout stalwart Victor Matfield and his buddy Bakkies to pretty much swipe any and all lineout ball away from the opposition.
That era is well and truly behind us and, unless we are to witness the reincarnation of this 1-2 punch, we should consider shifting our mentality away from past successes and look forward to an identity which applies to our strengths.
In Johan Goosen, Pat Lambie, Elton Jantjies – and perhaps even the forgotten man Peter Grant – the Boks have no shortage of options. In order to give any one of the aforementioned a fair opportunity, the Bok hierarchy need to show some courage and bring them into the set up immediately so as to allow them a chance to blossom and bring their own unique identity into the mix.
The indomitable force that is New Zealand is looking as imperious as ever. The Wallabies less so, but in comparison to the Bok side that was in many respects outclassed by the Pumas, they too are well ahead of us.
It is true that Heyneke and co. are in a process of crafting what they believe will be a formidable squad, with the inclusion of various young prospects in our forwards a positive sign; but to shoulder the arduous load of expectation that is the South African rugby fraternity, they must in turn allow any one of our talented incumbent pivots a run in the jersey. At least to show some ambition and a willingness to improve.
To insist further, and grant due credibility to the perhaps forgotten depth in the fly half position, I will surmise the credentials of each one of my preferred options.
Let me start off with Pat Lambie. The versatile back demonstrated, to critical acclaim, his abilities at fly half in the 2010 Currie Cup. His creative play invites the midfield to attack the advantage line with ferocity.
In addition, his mobile presence flat in the line allows for fluidity and pace on the attack which could, finally, give our flying wingers a bit of ball. He showed us his cool head under pressure by clinically dispatching of the hapless Bulls and Stormers in successive weeks in those Currie Cup play-offs. Now is the time for him to prove himself in a Bok jersey.
Elton Jantjies is perhaps the most exciting option. With bags of ingenuity and the audacity to attempt video-game stunts, he will add a new dimension. He can dazzle defences with his unpredictable play and draw their attention thus allowing the midfield more room to work their magic.
Many will point to the fact that his flamboyance has at times proved costly with his capacity to make the odd baffling decision a supposed weak point. But a look back at last season’s Currie Cup play-offs tells you all you need to know about this young man. He landed all his spot kicks in the semi-final and final, whereby he masterfully orchestrated a clinical dispatching of the Sharks in the final.
With the bold affirmation by Heyneke Meyer that Johan Goosen will one day be the best fly-half in the world, I have added motivation to call for his inclusion. If you’re to believe all the hype from South Africa, you’ll be led to believe that this is the next rugby great. You know what, he is!
Let’s now cross our fingers and hope that this immensely talented prodigy will be given his opportunity to live up to his billing. His performances for the Free State Cheetahs in Super Rugby before succumbing to injury were nothing short of scintillating. His goal-kicking which saw him lead all scorers in Super Rugby before his unfortunate injury was particularly eye-catching.
He has been given cameo appearances in the Boks’ last two Rugby Championship encounters, which were impressive. He has all the flair in the world and the undying conviction one would associate with Dan Carter. The Grey College phenom may get his opportunity to shine in the green and gold sooner rather than later.
It would be disrespectful in the least not to recognise Morne’s contributions, with his record-breaking three year run forming the backbone of the Boks relative success. But if we avoid looking back, and set our sights on future success, I can only imagine that the daring quest to hijack the All Blacks throne requires a much, much deadlier assassin.
And to ignore this reality could quite possibly spoil the Bok quest for world domination.
Sport, all day long. Does this sound too good to be true? We're searching for a Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. If you're a sales star who doesn't mind a hit, kick, throw, or cycle, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
Have you seen the new Wallabies jersey? Want one of your own? We're giving away a brand new 2013 Wallabies jersey to one lucky Roarer, click here to go in the running to win.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- Wallabies squad announced: Folau in, no Quade Cooper – yet (266)
- Deans: Should he stay or should he go? (245)
- SPIRO’s Lions Diary: Deans goes for experience, plus Folau (238)
- Quade Cooper misses Wallaby squad selection (208)
- Wallabies 25-man Lions squad: analysis (197)
- Quade shouldn’t be fly half against the Lions (184)
- What gives with Israel Folau? (184)
- Time for Wallabies to harness ‘Poly’ power (105)
- Lions cheat-sheet: the Wallaby game plan (138)
- Wallaby six-pack: who gets the June call-up? (123)
- AAC: the man for this moment (22)
- Berrick Barnes inclusion a bright prospect (25)
- Will Genia must stay injury free for the Wallabies to be a chance (50)
- Roar Stats from Super Rugby Round 12 (53)
- Lions cheat-sheet: the Wallaby game plan (138)
- AAC: the man for this moment (22)
- Berrick Barnes inclusion a bright prospect (25)
- Jesse Mogg needs to move back to Queensland (22)
- Open letter to ARU CEO Bill Pulver (pt two): nationalise Super Rugby (18)
- King George you will be missed (12)
- NZRU show the height of sporting arrogance (55)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- Elton Jantjies, Johan Goosen, Morne Steyn, pat lambie, Rugby Union, Springboks, The Rugby Championship



September 21st 2012 @ 4:37am
biltongbek said | September 21st 2012 @ 4:37am | Report comment
Neville, beautifully written and entertaining to read mate.
The reality is South African coaches whilst in their jobs work on a syrvival mentality. i was listening to a radio interview of Jake White.
In specific he made the point that SA coaches once they get to the end of their tenure is merely shrugged off by SARU and they are sent on their way, there is no attempt for the exiting coach to discuss or transfer any of the experience or knowledge that was gained of gameplan or players.
What this effectively means is that the next coach find his job a lonely space to be in and therefor he will often surround himself with trusted people rather than the best people for the job. This in turn means the coach will stick to what he knows and closes shop over how he plans to take his team forward.
Inevitably it means an unwillingness to look outside the box and that is where we find ourselves for the past 12 years since Nick Mallet has left the building.
The question therefor is even if Meyer brings in one of these exciting youngsters, how will he expect them to play?
Look at how the pedantic gameplan has affected Hougaard at scrumhalf, he has lost that X-factor and the scary thing is what will happen to Goosen if he is not allowed to express himself.
We might find ouselves frustrated at the thought of expecting a more expansive attack and left wanting.
September 21st 2012 @ 1:27pm
Gavin Fernie said | September 21st 2012 @ 1:27pm | Report comment
Both Neville (outstanding piece, Neville) and Biltongbek have put it eloquently and clearly; what is ‘it’? ‘It’ is the perennial problem in South African rugby. How does Springbok and Blue Bulls rugby break away from the style and pattern of rugby which,with brief, wonderful moments of aberration in between, has served it so well for so many years.
Of course. the truth is that since 1992 it has not served Springbok rugby at all well. You might say how did we win two RWC Competitions? Yes, we won them by playing disciplined, grind it out, kick and chase rugby, particularly in 2007. RWC rugby is knockout, war of attrition rugby; For the rest of the time, again with notable exceptions, our overall record against the ‘Big Boys’, Australia and the All Blacks, is pretty dismal. The style and pattern of international rugby has changed dramatically in the last 3 years; Springbok rugby has not changed or adapted, so the point Biltongbek makes about the manner in which Goosen, Jantjies and Lambie are ‘allowed’ to play, could negate all the potential flair and brilliance of these three gifted young rugby players.
September 21st 2012 @ 5:02am
Chris said | September 21st 2012 @ 5:02am | Report comment
Johan Goosen is a special player. Give it another years or two and we will have a decade of Goosen v. Cruden battles to watch.
September 21st 2012 @ 7:24am
Myles said | September 21st 2012 @ 7:24am | Report comment
No respect to Aussie flyers?
September 21st 2012 @ 1:52pm
tubby said | September 21st 2012 @ 1:52pm | Report comment
no one has really laid claim to that position for the wallabies for this week, let alone as the long term #10
September 21st 2012 @ 8:26am
Rugby Tragic said | September 21st 2012 @ 8:26am | Report comment
Johan Goosen is ‘a superstar in the making’ – not there yet but as long as the Bok machine does not stunt his talents (like Lambie), the kid will flourish.
Chris, I think there will be the battles of Goosen v Beauden Barrett rather than Cruden. Barrett, like Goosen is an amazing player but needs more game time at the highest level. While Carter is probably considered the premier #10 at the moment, age is going to catch up with him. Goosen is what 20? Barrett is 21
September 21st 2012 @ 6:18am
Hugo Verne said | September 21st 2012 @ 6:18am | Report comment
Neville, many of us share your pain, and many of us are either Aussies, like me, or Kiwis, like a couple of my best pals. We want you guys to be the best you can be so that the rugby gets back to being exciting. But seeing that the SA powers (who are they BTW? Name some names) chose Meyer with the brief to win the old fashioned Bok way, he appears to be hogtied. Unless he gets a green light from his masters to bench Morne and bring in…who? They/Meyer must be wary of throwing in a 20-year old Goosen at 10, but then Jantjes is just two years older than Johan and is a lightweight at 84 kgs. Aaron Cruden is even lighter than this but is still a terrific 10, but will that fact be enough to sway them in Elton’s direction? You couldn’t ask for a better time to try out either player because the Wallabies will be vulnerable at Pretoria – Moore, Timani and Douglas will improve the pack but the Phipps/Barnes combo could be shaky.
September 21st 2012 @ 6:36pm
IvanN said | September 21st 2012 @ 6:36pm | Report comment
HM has stated that he is going to give Morne a rest. Steyn will be dropped to the bench, i expect Lambie or Goosen to start at 10 in Pretoria and Soweto.
the Boks are going to go for it at home, nothing to lose.
Lambie will start at 15,
goosen will start at 10
September 21st 2012 @ 6:55pm
biltongbek said | September 21st 2012 @ 6:55pm | Report comment
Did Meyer confrim this, or is it just an excerpt from one of his previous interviews where what he says and does are two different things?
September 21st 2012 @ 7:52pm
IvanN said | September 21st 2012 @ 7:52pm | Report comment
He said in an interview that Morne needs this break. referring to Morne not starting in the next test. Probably be on the bench in case they need to call on him.
September 21st 2012 @ 7:59pm
biltongbek said | September 21st 2012 @ 7:59pm | Report comment
Yeah, I read that, will wait to see what he does, he has been defending Morne stoically for the past 7 tests, so he hasn’t proven to me yet that he is felxible.
September 21st 2012 @ 8:05pm
IvanN said | September 21st 2012 @ 8:05pm | Report comment
Im quite confident we will see Goosen and Lambie starting in pretoria, Morne will be on the bench to get 15 minutes on his home ground.
I just hope our pack can put in another solid performance, so that the backs get some ‘practice’,
I think thats what they miss the most – is that the reason they cant run the ball that well, is that they never had to.
September 21st 2012 @ 6:30pm
IvanN said | September 21st 2012 @ 6:30pm | Report comment
If the Boks can give consistent game time to Lambie, Goosen and Jantjies.
Bring in new youngsters like Jordaan, Rhule and Serfontein.
And work on some basic backline skills and play…
Behind a pack that i expect to really dominate anyone – (when Biz,Coenie,Eben,Bakkies,Schalk,Juan,Pierre) adds onto what is already a solid pack –
The future looks good. We just have to be a little more patient.
September 21st 2012 @ 9:44pm
Rugby Tragic said | September 21st 2012 @ 9:44pm | Report comment
I find Rugby so intriguing, the clash of different styles. Running rugby as I think we know it, IMO was started by John Hart, the then, Auckland coach. In all the years I have followed the code, I seem to come back to the era around 1986, the first time I had really witnessed rugby played with the ball in hand as the priority rather than an after thought.
The Boks had traditionally the strongest, or at least consistently the strongest forward pack. Play was dominated by the forwards. And so it has evolved. The reputation of the French and Wallaby backs for being exciting player to watch was made from legends, matching as teams, what the individuals like Gareth Evans, Barry Johns gave the code a few years earlier, etc. Each team played to its strengths.
It is in the DNA of the South African Springboks to dominate in the forwards, feed off mistakes of the opposition, not to take unnecessary risks until the game is safe (o it is too late!). It took exceptional teams to overcome that combative strategy, It is not that the Boks are lacking with exciting backs (see Habana as an oldie and Goosen as a newbie examples) – they are plentiful, but for them to flourish, for them to stamp their mark on the games, they have to deviate from the tried and true game plan that has stood the test of time for their country.
It is my belief that it is the coach rather than the players in SA that are holding the way the game is played back. The brilliance of individuals stymied by a game plan that according to much more superior analysts than yours truly of ‘risk free rugby’. I fear for SA rugby that without a major change in the mindset of the coaches the talents that are there will not necessarily be exposed.
September 22nd 2012 @ 4:47am
Neville Darangwa said | September 22nd 2012 @ 4:47am | Report comment
Thanks a lot Biltong and Gavin I appreciate it…. You guys shared some very interesting views here. I wholeheartedly believe that with the boks massive pack and a change at pivot the boks can outmuscle the ABs and the other rugby powerhouses. Goosen is superb! Jantjies is one of the most flamboyant ballers in the game. If Heyneke truly meant that his men had the coarage to find their way to the top then he needs to show coarage himself and put them in a position to achieve greatness…..
September 22nd 2012 @ 4:45pm
dcnz said | September 22nd 2012 @ 4:45pm | Report comment
Hey guys when is Juan Smith and Schalk back, and what happened to Broussow?
If those guys were fit and Lambie, Juan De Jongh, Frans Steyn, Habana, Goosen, were all firing for the Boks, well then I would be worried as a Kiwi. ..
September 27th 2012 @ 12:15am
biltongbek said | September 27th 2012 @ 12:15am | Report comment
Smith and burger will only be available next year , that is to say if Juan Smit does return.
Brussow is back from injury and playing for the Cheetahs.
September 26th 2012 @ 10:44pm
BenJ said | September 26th 2012 @ 10:44pm | Report comment
News just in: Beeld newspaper report that Morne Steyn is out of the match 22. Thank God.
September 26th 2012 @ 10:48pm
BenJ said | September 26th 2012 @ 10:48pm | Report comment
15: Zane Kirchner
14. Bryan Habana
13: Jean de Villiers (k)
12: Francois Steyn/Jaco Taute
11: Francois Hougaard
10: Johan Goosen
9: Ruan Pienaar
8: Duane Vermeulen
7: Willem Alberts
6: Francois Louw
5: Andries Bekker
4: Eben Etzebeth
3: Jannie du Plessis
2: Adriaan Strauss
1: Beast Mtawarira
16: Tiaan Liebenberg
17: Coenie Oosthuizen
18: Flip van der Merwe
19: Marcell Coetzee
20: Elton Jantjies
21: Jaco Taute/Juan de Jongh
22: Patrick Lambie – sarugby.net
September 27th 2012 @ 7:44pm
Neville Darangwa said | September 27th 2012 @ 7:44pm | Report comment
Cheers to Heyneke Meyer