Hold your heads high, Manly and Souths
By JazzyJase, 25 Sep 2012 JazzyJase is a Roar Pro
Brett Stewart scores for Manly during the NRL final rounds (AAP Image/Action Photographics, Grant Trouville)
Related coverage
Manly and South Sydney were both on the wrong end of the scoreboard in their respective elimination finals on the weekend, and are most likely still nursing sore heads as they contemplate the “what ifs” in the aftermath.
As the disappointment subsides, both teams ought to reflect on commendable 2012 campaigns that give promise for continued and further success in 2013.
Let’s take Manly first up; the reigning premiers carried the weight of expectation before a ball was kicked in anger this season. Manly were hamstrung with numerous lengthy injuries and were unable to field their best squad throughout the regular season.
Added to this was the disruption of Origin duties to key players, yet Manly were able to “turn up” week after week.
Incoming Geoff Toovey was on a hiding to nothing in the coach’s box, however confirmed himself as creditable, shrewd coach. Opposition teams knew that they would be facing a spirited unit when lining up against the Sea Eagles. Manly could be relied upon for attacking flair with plenty of points in them and a committed defensive all year.
Their performance on Friday night was un-Manly like. Forget the drop balls, the ill-discipline and the multiple defensive lapses, what was shown did not reflect what Manly brought to the competition in 2012.
It was clear that a number of players took to the field with injuries and with the bench consisting of four forwards, there was little in the way of outside back troops to call upon.
That is to take nothing away from Melbourne Storm who after a mid to late season slump seem to be taking their game to new heights when the big games are on. Cam Smith (who was under a fitness cloud himself) was at his scheming best and backed up by a willing forward pack, cementing the foundations for the win.
Slater, Cronk and the outside backs capitalised on repeated Manly lapses and ran riot out wide, often at the near crippled Matai’s expense.
We all know the result, Storm reach another GF and Manly are left to lament, for the time being. Looking forward, they have secured a pretty reliable ‘spine’ for seasons to come.
Snake, DCE, Foran, Ballin would be welcome additions to any of the also rans teams for next year. Jamie Lyon is in a class of his own; the way he has performed and led the club for so long.
While the ranks will be decimated somewhat next year with the loss of players Whare, Lussick, Williams and Oldfield, they seem to have a knack of unearthing players to capably fill the breach.
Manly may be licking their wounds for now but should continue to be a powerhouse in the 2013 season.
Moving onto to the Rabbitohs, I suspect this great club is on the cusp of something special in the immediate future.
Similar to Manly and Storm, the weekend’s result turned out to be a one-sided affair that did not reflect the season that South Sydney had.
This great club carries incredible expectation each year. Previous generations of McCarthy, Sattler, Coote and co considered it an honour just to be selected in the Cardinal and Myrtle.
The 2012 vintage can hold their heads high for a season that had them knocking on the door of greater glory.
New coach Maguire took the duties of head coach at NRL level like a seasoned campaigner.
Having served his apprentice under Bellamy at Melbourne and refining his skills in the Old Dart, Maguire instilled an immediate belief within the club.
Noticeably, the South Sydney of 2012 showed a defensive resolve that was previously questionable, particularly when under pressure. Their ability to cross the line was never doubted, but this year has seen the emergence of a more polished Rabbitoh attack.
Much has been said of Reynolds in his debut season (and rightly so), but looking further wide and Everingham has been equally impressive. Merrit continues to sniff out a try at any opportunity. Throw in the superstar that is Greg Inglis and Souths had other teams on notice that they are capable of scoring from anywhere on the park.
Sam and George Burgess have been juggernauts in the middle and on the edges. The return of Asotasi and his leadership with the evergreen Crocker gave South some serious cred in the forwards.
There are lots of highlights for Souths fans to reflect upon for season 2012. This year the mighty Rabbits gave some return for the promise and expectation. In one week for the lead up to the Bulldogs’ game, you could feel a groundswell of support getting behind the Rabbitohs.
No matter who you support, it’s hard not to get caught up in the emotion and passion that is South Sydney.
I imagine the result against the Bulldogs will spur this great club on that one step further in 2013. The addition of Te’o and Lima will bring starch to the forwards and more than cover for the loss of the at times brilliant yet inconsistent Dave Taylor.
Bringing our minds to this weekend’s big one, what an encounter this promises to be.
The regular season determined the contenders and the Dogs and Storm served notice they would be there or thereabouts come September action. Throughout the playoff series, though, both teams have shown their true premiership credentials with scintillating and inspired wins.
The first set the Bulldogs had with the ball on the weekend saw them blaze the length of the field in a display of sheer speed and power.
Meanwhile, much has been said about the Storm’s desire to raise the trophy this season. Should be a classic game.
Follow on twitter @philwoywoy31171
![]()
Passionate about your league? Then sign up to The Roar's brand new daily league email, delivering Roaring articles directly to you day-in, day-out. You'll love it!
Click here to join now!
Looking to join The Roar team? We're searching for an experienced Group Sales Manager to lead our team in Sydney. Yes, this does mean you get to work with the site all day long! If you're a digital media sales star, we want to hear from you. Apply now.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- How to increase crowd numbers in the NRL (181)
- How rugby league should expand (133)
- All I am saying is give Pearce a chance (123)
- Why do NRL fans love empty seats? (115)
- Let me tell you why people don’t like Manly (107)
- Ease up on ASADA: NRL boss (90)
- It’s time for Channel Nine to get serious about the NRL (90)
- Select The Roar’s NSW State of Origin I team (18)
- Stop the clock, NRL is running out of time (30)
- Once were Warriors, now are worriers (28)
- Wests Tigers at sixes and sevens for years (17)
- Listen Blues fans, let’s not kid ourselves (9)
- Pre-season draw sacrifices quality for quantity (21)
- Dave Smith’s crowd plan gaining credibility (41)
- Once were Warriors, now are worriers (28)
- Wests Tigers at sixes and sevens for years (17)
- Listen Blues fans, let’s not kid ourselves (9)
- Pre-season draw sacrifices quality for quantity (21)
- Dave Smith’s crowd plan gaining credibility (41)
- How accurate is the NRL ladder? (4)
- Channel Nine’s Broncos love-in continues to frustrate (18)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- 2012 NRL season, Manly Sea Eagles, NRL, Rugby League, South Sydney Rabbitohs


September 25th 2012 @ 8:15am
Billo Boy said | September 25th 2012 @ 8:15am | Report comment
League is broken. Souths & Manly had no hope once their opponents got momentum up & fatigue sets in. The dominant team walks off the mark when they have the ball & wrestle hold downs & ignore the 10m when tackling. There’s no escape & it results in one sided finals that are boring & leaves the impression the beaten team didn’t put in.
This week’s grand final will be a mind numbing wrestle for 80 minutes or the first team to get on top in the wrestle will win by 40 points.
September 25th 2012 @ 12:02pm
JazzyJase said | September 25th 2012 @ 12:02pm | Report comment
i’ve been watching replays on fox recently of old grand finals / finals games from the early 90′s.
Agree that wrestling is a blight in the modern era, but as a spectacle the game is so much faster and powerful today.
Disagree that League is broken old mate
September 25th 2012 @ 1:17pm
B.A Sports said | September 25th 2012 @ 1:17pm | Report comment
Billy Boy
Souths had all the momentum in their semi, walking off the mark in attack and getting quick play the balls, holding down longer in defence. But they didn’t win, and even if Reynolds had stayed on, they didn’t look like winning. Their only plan for scoring is big bodies pushing over the tryline from close range – and it doesn’t beat the best teams – hence their poor record against the Top 8 all season.
The Dogs and Storm both beat their oppoenents through expansive play, beating their opponents on the fringes.
Better luck next year.
September 25th 2012 @ 9:30am
OldHand said | September 25th 2012 @ 9:30am | Report comment
Manly and Collingwood – out in the one night – life is good!
September 25th 2012 @ 10:38am
Mals said | September 25th 2012 @ 10:38am | Report comment
Good write up. Both Manly & Souths will be playing final series footy again next season.
September 25th 2012 @ 1:25pm
JazzyJase said | September 25th 2012 @ 1:25pm | Report comment
Cheers Mals, appreciate the feedback.
Souths will be all the better next year after having a taste
Hopefully same will apply for the mighty Sharkies
September 25th 2012 @ 11:37am
The Superhighway said | September 25th 2012 @ 11:37am | Report comment
The real heroes of these clubs are the seedy money men who supposedly keep these teams under the salary cap.
Ian Schubert must be receiving the same brown paper bags stuffed with cash that the players get.
They’re not foolin’ me Jazzy, they’re not foolin’ me I tells ya.
It’s poor form, no, a disgrace!
September 25th 2012 @ 11:58am
JazzyJase said | September 25th 2012 @ 11:58am | Report comment
You’re on the money TSH.
They are all riding on Schubert’s gravy train
September 25th 2012 @ 11:39am
mike from tari said | September 25th 2012 @ 11:39am | Report comment
Alas for Souths, David Taylor had already moved to the Gold Coast before the final series, if Madge couldn’t get Taylor to fire up god help the Titans, it also would have been interesting if Reynolds had not got injured, once he was injured Souths seemed reluctant to use their backline, they just kept driving it up through the ruck, anyway being a fan for 55 years I am pleased with the way we finished.
September 25th 2012 @ 7:20pm
Paul Schlanger said | September 25th 2012 @ 7:20pm | Report comment
Not too many years ago Bulldogs and Storm were the disgrace of the NRL having been caught out cheatIng their salary caps. Now we are all suppose to revere these teams as the best of the 2012 season. I find it very difficult to believe that both of these teams could get themselves back to the top of rugby league in such a short period of time without having some residual benefit from their outrageous hehaviour and the subsequent punishment (or lack thereof).
In a more recent event the sport loving public was exposed to behaviour akin to cheating, this time from an arm of the administration of the sport. The Cowboys coach demonstrated enormous restraint and probably fear of sanctions for describing the decisions of the cowboys manly game only as incompetent. I am prepared to go that step further and call it for what it is. No fair minded person could possibly call a try when the ball was obviously tapped forward as replay after replay showed and called decisively by commentators. Not to mention the previous bad decision that also led to a try to Manly. Cheating is not a word too far away from appropriate. One can only speculate on the motives. Maybe it’s a QLD-NSW thing, who knows.
For my liking there is too much cheating in this sport to take it seriously
September 25th 2012 @ 10:34pm
Robbo said | September 25th 2012 @ 10:34pm | Report comment
Reynolds injury should have seen John Sutton stand up and prove he is a NRL player,can’t play under pressure and his decision making is woeful.