Goosen and Taute gets a pass mark in Springbok win
By biltongbek, 1 Oct 2012 biltongbek is a Roar Guru & Live Blogger
- Tagged:
- Rugby Union, Springboks, The Rugby Championship, wallabies
Related coverage
After watching last night’s performance of the Springboks versus the Wallabies my thoughts go back to the past seven Springbok Test matches.
It brings to mind utter frustration experienced due to inconsistent performances by the forwards, inaccuracy of goal kicking, the lack of numbers to the ruck, poor decision making and half baked executions.
There have been some serious questions asked about a number of players and the thinking behind their selections and also some added misery for the frustration felt by injuries to prominent players.
Losing Bismarck du Plessis, Schalk Burger, Coenie Oosthuizen and JP Pietersen were probably the biggest losses, which were compounded by the retirement and unavailability of John Smit, Gurthro Steenkamp, Victor Matfield, Danie Rossouw, Bakkies Botha, Juan Smith, Fourie du Preez and Jaque Fourie.
The fact is Heyneke Meyer has also been rather deliberate about the type of players he wanted to continue with, guys like Heinrich Brussow, Gio Aplon and Juan de Jongh negated for bigger and stronger players.
It has taken seven tests, two gut wrenching draws and two frustrating losses for Meyer to change the makeup of his backline.
Granted, Goosen only came back from injury a month ago and ditto for Taute.
According to Meyer both these players have been in his long term plans since the beginning of the season.
After quite extensive experimentation with a largely inexperienced bunch of forwards it seems Meyer has found his group of players who rightly will be selected accordingly to opposition and conditions.
It has however been the back line that has been mostly ineffective in attack and rather pedestrian.
Enter Johan Goosen and Jaco Taute.
If ever there was a need for the Springbok back line to perform, simply to prove to Heyneke Meyer that decision making is something inherent to the individual player and that positive play can make a world of difference even within a conservative game plan, then it was tonight.
Although expectedly Goosen showed some nerves and Taute knocked his first contact with the ball, both came through the game with their reputations intact.
Although I don’t think there is any need to wax lyrical about their performances, there was definitely enough proof that a player that attacks the gain line, makes the right decision (albeit not every time) and has the ability to beat the defender can create gaps rather than simply run onto the opposition.
South Africa even though against an injury ravaged Wallaby team showed in the first half what a difference an attack-orientated backline can muster.
But let’s not forget it started with quick ball, the South African forwards in specific Duane Vermeulen and Frans Louw ensured quick ruck ball and were absolute menaces at the defending rucks.
Willem Alberts, Eben Etzebeth, Adriaan Strauss and Andries Bekker carried the ball forcefully and got behind the advantage line on numerous occasions, often offloading to the support player and avoiding the breakdown point.
This allowed Pienaar to provide crisp service to Goosen who in turn used his options well and got his backline over the advantage line and breaking the line on numerous occasions.
Bryan Habana once again showed his enthusiasm is back and was looking for work all night long, scoring a hat trick of tries.
Jaco Taute after dropping his first two balls, started gaining confidence and carried the ball with effect, was superb in defence and undoubtedly his extra pace at 13 made the difference on attack.
At the post match interview Meyer was adamant that the game plan has not changed, and I wholeheartedly agree with him, there were no new moves, no angled running and no fancy stuff, but what was different was the pace players ran onto the ball, the fact that with Goosen there the backline was not stationary and the runners were always looking for the offload.
If the intent is there to attack, that positive mindset is a darn sight better than crash balling into the defence at every given opportunity.
A thought to the wallabies, it is near impossible to be competitive in a match where the injury toll is so high that a team has to finish the last 10 minutes of a game with fourteen men.
Adam Ashley Cooper in my view is the epitome of Australian sport, his total commitment and never say die attitude should be an inspiration to his team and country, it makes one wonder how much pride a guy like Quade Cooper has for representing Australia when you see the commitment of his team mates that are lying bleeding and concussed on the sideline.
Kurtly Beale showed in the second half when he does get the opportunity to get front for ball why he should be the Australian ten.
It has been a step forward for the Springboks, but there are still some worrying issues, goal kicking again left a lot of points on the field, and the scrimmaging is not satisfactory.
The importance now is not to make too many changes, and allow these youngsters to settle.
It will still take them a few games to prove their worth, but I think there might just be a new era of positive Bok rugby ahead.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby Union articles
- SPIRO: ‘Captain Magic’ Quade Cooper goes down with all flags flying (333)
- Deans confirms no spot for Quade Cooper (281)
- SPIRO’s Lions Diary: Foley does Australian rugby a disservice (261)
- Want to beat the Lions? Pick Quade Cooper (229)
- SPIRO: All Blacks learning to live without Carter (218)
- Wallabies’ six worst-kept secrets confirmed (204)
- A lesson in Deans-speak (154)
- British and Irish Lions teams post WW2 (part 3) (13)
- Fifteen reasons why the Lions will beat the Wallabies (23)
- Lions vs Wallabies: the teams I’d pick (16)
- My Waratahs vs Lions experience (2)
- Brumbies vs British and Irish Lions: Tour match live scores, blog (220)
- These British and Irish Lions are different (49)
- Robbie Deans can learn from those Randwick Greens (27)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- Rugby Union, Springboks, The Rugby Championship, wallabies

October 1st 2012 @ 10:03am
Gerald Arendse said | October 1st 2012 @ 10:03am | Report comment
Congrats Bilt, and you too Susie. Watching the Goose run put me in mind of Henry H. Old time Bok running rugby. We assume, repeat, assume, that HM will be convinced now.
Will the win carry the Boks to a victory next week? Considered it all night long and I doubt it. The ABs will get up in the second half. Now that they’re clicking they’re number one with a bullet. Damn it, we have to wait another week to see what’s going to be a great game.
October 1st 2012 @ 4:38pm
chris said | October 1st 2012 @ 4:38pm | Report comment
I wouldn’t focus too much on the individuals in this game. Goosen and Taute were both decent, but not the reason for improved performance. What Goosen did show is that, without shining, the anyone-but-Steyn brigade have been right all along.
For me the biggest positive was the forward display. This was the game where the forwards had to show that Dunedin was a turning point, rather than blip. They were fantastic and dominated every facet, including the line-out that misfired badly in New Zealand.
The backs played with more freedom and enthusiasm, but still looked a little clumsy at times.
The major area for improvement is still converting opportunities into points. Loftus is a kicking paradise, yet I think they left 16 points on the pitch, there were the three closely missed tries and I felt both first half tries were scored despite being butchered in the build-up. The Springbok generosity went unpunished in this game because they were so completely dominant and the wallabies were facing their own issues, but if they are going to run down the All Blacks at the top of the rankings they will have to win games where each score is vitally important. Unless they improve their conversion rate, they run the risk out-playing opponents only to be out-scored after eighty minutes.
October 1st 2012 @ 5:25pm
biltongbek said | October 1st 2012 @ 5:25pm | Report comment
Chris, it is true points were left on the park again, but we must distinguish against 50 meter hail Mary kicks and regulation kicks.
If I am not mistaken 2 or 3 penalties were 50 meter kicks, I know Goosen’s first one and at least one of Pienaar’s kicks were 50 plus meter kicks, usually when Frans Steyn kicks them he has a 50% success rate. In Duneden realistically only 9 points worth of kicks were regulation, as with this weekend there were only 2 penalties that were regulation kicks that were missed and of course the conversions.
Still we have had a moghty poor season with goal kicking.
And yes you are correct about the anyone but Morne statement, Jantjies, Lambie and Goosen are all three more suitable to 10 in the modern era.
October 1st 2012 @ 6:39pm
chris said | October 1st 2012 @ 6:39pm | Report comment
I am not arguing that they threw away sure-fire points, but if they want to at the top of the pile they have drive their dominance home. A fifty-five kick is well within Goosen’s ability. What I want to see is a narrowing between potential and results. Also a ruthlessness where the opponent’s head drop every time point scoring opportunity presents itself knowing that they will be punished.
I would hate for the boks a repeat of the quarter final in 2011, where the boks dominated the game but end up losing out because the could not put the ball down over the line or slot their goals.
October 1st 2012 @ 6:55pm
biltongbek said | October 1st 2012 @ 6:55pm | Report comment
Absolutely, the opportunities must be realised into points, it reminds me a lot of the Lions tour in 1997, we were all over the Lions, outscoring them 3 tries to nil in the one test and yet lost because we missed each and every kick.
The importance of any opportunity to score points must be fruitful and this year we left a lot of tries unscored, a lot of kicks unconverted.
October 1st 2012 @ 6:09pm
IvanN said | October 1st 2012 @ 6:09pm | Report comment
If the Boks can dominate the Kiwi pack again, with the backline having a crack – i think we can win in Soweto.
The ABs are great, but not unbeatable.
This will be a clash of the Top 2 teams in the World. Thats for sure.
October 1st 2012 @ 11:03pm
mactheblack said | October 1st 2012 @ 11:03pm | Report comment
It just shows Ivan that the problem is Saffers and the players are too in awe of the ABs; if you are a team worth your salt you should BELIEVE you can beat any team on the day! Statements like them not being unbeatable is actually laughable. Confident fans and confident players (as you all have suddenly become) shouldn’t be making these kinds of statements. Envy perhaps? I’m sure the ABs don’t regard themselves as invincible. They just play the game they are best suited to, and employ a game that works for them. But on that first point one can understand why Saffers are in awe of the ABs. The ABs epitomise what rugby is and how it should be played! I’m no New Zealander but I have been following this team long enough to know that rugby in Kiwi land has a lot to do with culture, (hence the success) and we thought rugby was a ‘religion in SA’. Boks are damn good but are still a distant second and have a lot to do to get up to par with the standards that the No.1 rugby nation has set – and of course it hasn’t happened in one season – but over many generations – you think on Mourie, Leslie, Jock Hobbs, Meads, now McCaw etc. Please don’t think an afternoon at Loftus and another this coming Saturday in Soweto can suddenly make the Boks world-beaters again. And that’s the problem with the fickle SA rugby public, they continue to live in the mindset of : One Swallow a Summer does make!
Goosen, Taute played well – but what is expected of players in key positions such as these? Habana continues to be the standout player – for long he has been denied the ball by a stultified Bok team but continued to give it his all – and finally the dam wall broke on Saturday. Does biltongbek mention him in his article, while he waxed lyrical about Taute and Goosen? (Haven’t read the entire article but hope he has). The problem with the Boks .. they tend to be a bit inconsistent at times. Play absolutely poorly and then the big backlash comes when the pressure is off (meaning the tournament is lost). They need to prove it (after one outstanding game at Loftus) consistently from here that they have made strides. Not just over two or three games. The other problem in the Bok team is poor support play, selfishness (not passing to the player next to you, which admittedly improved a bit last week). The All Blacks’ support play is unrivalled; there is an undeniable absence of selfishness, as they always seem to play for each other. Please guys, don’t give the ABs grudging respect; their success has not come over a few seasons, but over many generations. Of course the ABs are beatable on Saturday .. Great game in prospect!
October 2nd 2012 @ 3:55am
biltongbek said | October 2nd 2012 @ 3:55am | Report comment
Mac, firstly mate I didn’t wax lyrical about any player, secondly you are talking about the Boks, they are not in awe of the All Blacks, they are their main rivals.
Yes we have an issue with players not wanting to pass, however you’ll be surprised to know that every try we scored in thecchampionship prior to Saturday there were never more than one pass and then a try.
On Saturday the only try that id not have more than one pass was the forward try.
We are pogressing, that is the important thing.
October 2nd 2012 @ 7:07pm
matthew said | October 2nd 2012 @ 7:07pm | Report comment
Of all the rugby teams in the world the Boks are the least in awe of the AB’s. Where other teams are frightened and fearful as well as awestruck the Boks are fired up and cant wait to face the haka and draw energy from it. They respect the AB’s but believe they can get the better of them on any occasion, hence their strong record over the Kiwis the last couple of years. Boks have no fear of the AB’s in stark contrast to the other rugby nations (perhaps excluding France), but haven’t been able to mimic their intense performances against the Blacks against other lesser rugby nations with enough consistency.
Now that Goosens running the show at pivot I think we’ll begin to really pull away from the rest of the world, just as the likes of Wales were starting to gain on us. The AB’s still currently have an edge, but pretty soon the Boks will join them as the deadly duo strides ahead of the rest of the rugby world.
October 3rd 2012 @ 5:24pm
7andabit said | October 3rd 2012 @ 5:24pm | Report comment
SA looked so much better with a 10 not standing 30 meters deep