Frankel’s Legacy: the margin of his victories
Related coverage
- Horse Racing news
- Horse Racing news
- Black Caviar Group 1 wins news
- Black Caviar's first trial win news
- Black Caviar's career news
Last Saturday’s Champion Day at Ascot was a defining day for Frankel’s legacy.
Excelebration’s three length QE11 victory in a field that included Group One winners Cityscape and Elusive Kate complimented Frankel nearly as much as the feature race.
Excelebration has now won eight races, four of which were Group One’s, without Frankel presence. There is now every reason to believe that Excelebration would have been a champion miler in another era.
Frankel’s performance in the Champion Stakes answered one main question about the horse, that is that conditions, tactics and the quality of opposition are irrelevant to him. Here lies the true greatness of Frankel.
He started the race poorly, Queally had to ride the horse back into the race at an early stage and he was up against Cirrus Des Aigles who had ground conditions and distance in his favour, but none of these could deter the colt that has always pushed the boundaries.
Out of champion racehorse and sire Galileo and Danehill mare Kind, Frankel is equine perfection, a result of 300 years of selective thoroughbred breeding.
Ever since his annihilation of 2000 Guineas field as a three year old, anyone who viewed this race knew this was a special horse.
The defining moment for the horse that year was the ‘Dual on the Downs’ in the Sussex Stakes against Canford Cliffs. Canford Cliffs, rated 133 by Timeform, had previously beaten the mighty Goldikova in a high class renewal of the Queen Anne stakes. Frankel was imperious in his performance that day, smashing Canford Cliffs by five lengths.
In the Queen Anne this year, Frankel gave his visually most impressive performance destroying a field including Excelebration and Caulfield Guineas winner Helmet by 11 lengths.
That’s what made Frankel so unusual, the margin of his victories.
I heard Irish trainer John Oxx talking about this on Champions Day. He described the horse as having abundant energy, if he could win with lengths to spare he would and he did on several occasions. That’s what set him apart from other recent champions like Sea the Stars.
Sea the Stars would do just enough in front whereas Frankel couldn’t win by enough. Critics of Frankel will say he never ran abroad, in truth I don’t think he ever had to, his form lines were international and he defeated the world’s best horses at home.
Cirrus Des Aigles, Canford Cliffs, Nathaniel and Excelebration are or were among the best middle distance and mile performers around.
Likewise there is a sentiment among some that Frankel’s connections should have stepped him to 2400m in the King George and the Arc. There might be some justification in this, it would have been interesting to see him perform at this distance to see if he could be as dominant. However I believe that this years Champions Stakes field was far more superior to that of the Arc’s.
The popularity of Frankel with general public was unusual for an English flat horse, this adulation is usually reserved for National Hunt/Jumps horses.
Frankel transcended this. He was magnificent.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Other Sports articles
- You can’t trust your sport to self-regulate (23)
- Nadal, Serena affirm favouritism for French Open (14)
- Cheap Seats Podcast: episode two (14)
- Durant is a superhero, but not super enough (13)
- Can boxing great Pacquiao return to his former self? (12)
- Protecting sport or an infringement of human rights? (12)
- Will Mayweather vs Pacquiao happen? (11)
- The significance of Steven Bradbury’s winter triumph, 11 years on (4)
- The endless talent that is Stephen Curry
- Lowndes leads way in V8s’ US debut
- Spain 2013: McLaren plays it safe (3)
- NFL off-season outlook: AFC North (6)
- Will Mayweather vs Pacquiao happen? (11)
- Swim team wounds all but healed: Missile (4)
- The significance of Steven Bradbury’s winter triumph, 11 years on (4)
- The endless talent that is Stephen Curry (0)
- Spain 2013: McLaren plays it safe (3)
- NFL off-season outlook: AFC North (6)
- Will Mayweather vs Pacquiao happen? (11)
- ‘Wild’ Will willing: Tomlinson targets American assault (8)
- Durant is a superhero, but not super enough (13)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- Horse Racing

October 25th 2012 @ 8:06am
Ron Smyth said | October 25th 2012 @ 8:06am | Report comment
Canfords Cliff suffered an injury when he ran against Frankel in the Sussex Stakes and had to be retired afterwards, so i don’t think it is fair to take that race as a reflection of his ability.
October 25th 2012 @ 5:54pm
johnny nevin is a legend said | October 25th 2012 @ 5:54pm | Report comment
Fair point, but maybe the pressure exerted on him by Frankel caused the injury, who knows, I think its generally accepted that Frankel was a 3-5 length better horse than Canford Cliffs
November 2nd 2012 @ 1:22am
Bill said | November 2nd 2012 @ 1:22am | Report comment
Canford Cliffs’ injury ( if there was an injury ) was exaggerrated. The concesus among British racing aficienados was that Collmore ( who had just bought the colt ) didn’t want to race against Frankel again and the “injury” was a ready made excuse in order that they could pack Canford Cliffs off to stud earlier than planned. Richard Hughes, jockey of Canford Cliffs said in tv interview recently that Frankel is the best horse he has ever seen and that his horse would never have beaten Frankel at any time – injury or no injury.
October 25th 2012 @ 9:37am
Mike from tari said | October 25th 2012 @ 9:37am | Report comment
Didn’t win the Arc, Cox Plate or any of those other big races, good horse but I wouldn’t use your money to pay a stud fee.
October 25th 2012 @ 5:49pm
johnny nevin is a legend said | October 25th 2012 @ 5:49pm | Report comment
This years running of the Arc was not as high a standard as the Champion Stakes. Each race no matter how much prestige it has should be judged on its merits. The fact is even if Frankel ran in and won the Arc it wouldn’t have been as impressive as his victory in the Champion Stakes unless it was by a massive margin.The standard of the Cox Plate has been average the last few years, apart from So You Think, last years winner was an average horse.
February 18th 2013 @ 3:44pm
Ronnie said | February 18th 2013 @ 3:44pm | Report comment
You got that backwards! the Champion has no 10 furlongs horse in that race. THe Arc will always be the most prestigious race in europe because only classic 12 furlongs horse are capable of winning it. Frankel is not a classic distance horse.
February 18th 2013 @ 9:45pm
Bill said | February 18th 2013 @ 9:45pm | Report comment
Ronnie, do you even know anything about horse racing ? Firstly, you state that the ” Champion ” ( Stakes ) has no ten furlongs horse in that race. What ? It is a ten furlongs race. Frankel had previously won a Group One over an extended ten furlongs at York, and until the Champion Stakes, Cirrus Des Aigles was ranked ( by the International Classifications ) as the best ten furlong horse in the world. You also ( wrongly, as it happens ) state that Frankel is not a classic distance horse. How do you come to that conclusion There are five bona fide classic races during each flat racing season in the UK – they are, the 2,000 Guineas ( one mile ), the 1,000 Guineas ( one mile ), The Oaks ( one and a half miles ), The Derby ( one and a half miles ) and the St Leger ( one and three quarter miles ). Frankel won the 2,000 Guineas – thus making him a classic distance horse. The Arc has been won by many great horses but also by many less than great horses. Frankel ‘s brilliance is not even up for debate. His legacy will live on.
March 4th 2013 @ 8:42pm
johnny nevin is a legend said | March 4th 2013 @ 8:42pm | Report comment
Ronnie there is a growing belief among commentators and breeders that 10 furlongs is the most desirable distance for a Group 1 horse to win at. You’ll rarely see a top class 12 furlong horse not attempt 10 f, this distance has the right blend of speed and stamina.