Rugby league has never been in better shape
By MG Burbank, 28 Oct 2012 MG Burbank is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- AFL, Canterbury Bulldogs, James Graham, John Grant, NRL, Rugby League, Rugby League Commission
The Melbourne Storm's Ryan Hoffman (right) is congratulated after scoring a try against the Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs during the NRL Grand Final at ANZ Stadium in Sydney on Sunday, Sept. 30, 2012. (AAP Image/Paul Miller)
Related coverage
Today I read two articles from my esteemed colleagues, Paul Kent and Curtis Woodward, about the supposedly poor state of the NRL and its governing body, the Australian Rugby League Commission.
They echoed some scathing articles written recently by some reporters at The Daily Telegraph.
This relentless focus on the negative is a distortion of something which should be clear to anyone who not only watches the games, but is also prepared to take a look at the metrics used to define growth and success.
The quality, skill and athleticism of the players has never been greater. Yes, the play-the-ball needs to be sped up. But that doesn’t negate the entertainment that is provided to us on a weekly basis.
The TV rights deal is tremendous. These writers abandoned that bit of good news as soon as it was professionally feasible to do so.
Crowds have been on an upward trajectory for years now. Are there tiny peaks and valleys? Of course. But the trend is upward, and with clubs prepared to play more games at larger stadia while also attracting thousands of new members annually, the growth curve will continue.
The TV ratings are outstanding. League is simply dominant in this area.
Junior numbers are up. The AFL is not making the inroads it led us all to believe, as reported by Roy Masters recently in the Sydney Morning Herald.
Aussie Rules will always be a presence, but the ARLC has committed itself to strengthening the grassroots and now has the finances to do it.
Let us not forget that Melbourne recently blooded the first ever player to be developed within the local Victorian system, Mahe Fonua. This is an enormous development for our game and has been almost completely ignored.
Finally, we have a commission and it has made the right decision in almost every instance with regard to issues both on and off the field.
Installing the new finals system this year bore immediate dividends, with the top four teams facing off in the penultimate week of the season.
Resisting the urge to raise the salary cap beyond $5 million was a prudent decision, as was putting a hold on expansion – for now. This commission is dedicated to ensuring all 16 clubs are strong before league makes its inevitable move to the West, and possibly further south into New Zealand.
Yes, the season ended in deflating fashion with the James Graham biting incident and the Bulldogs’ Mad Monday fiasco. Many questioned the ‘absence’ of the commission in dealing with these issues.
Yet Graham received a lengthy suspension and the Bulldogs players were fined – a directive that came straight from the NRL. Any argument that their ‘voluntary donation’ of $30,000 was indeed voluntary is a fantasy.
Yes, more can be done to change the sexist hooliganism that exists in the game, but rugby league’s governing body was not silent.
Finally, there has been much criticism of the delay in hiring a new CEO for the game. This is nonsense. John Grant has merely shown restraint, and this approach will bear fruit with the very best person being given the job.
Rugby League received its biggest ever payday in 2012 because it has never been in better shape. The game will continue to grow, despite those who persist in focusing on the negatives.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Rugby League articles
- How to increase crowd numbers in the NRL (181)
- How rugby league should expand (132)
- All I am saying is give Pearce a chance (123)
- Why do NRL fans love empty seats? (115)
- Let me tell you why people don’t like Manly (103)
- Ease up on ASADA: NRL boss (90)
- It’s time for Channel Nine to get serious about the NRL (89)
- STEVE TURNER: Only one Origin newcomer for the marauding Maroons (19)
- Whittling down the Blues contenders for State of Origin I (38)
- Time for the NRL to introduce silver point (44)
- A Blues Origin jumper for everyone? Why not (7)
- Dugan for Origin? Lay off the Breezers! (24)
- NRL golden point must get the flick (24)
- Cronulla Sharks fighting a war they can’t win (43)
- Time for the NRL to introduce silver point (44)
- A Blues Origin jumper for everyone? Why not (7)
- NRL golden point must get the flick (24)
- Cronulla Sharks fighting a war they can’t win (43)
- Where were you when sport sold its soul? (27)
- NRL Power Rankings week 10: Where is your team ranked this week (12)
- Melbourne Storm vs Manly Sea Eagles: NRL live scores, blog (153)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- AFL, Canterbury Bulldogs, James Graham, John Grant, NRL, Rugby League, Rugby League Commission

October 28th 2012 @ 3:22am
paddyeff2 said | October 28th 2012 @ 3:22am | Report comment
Well said. Not enough emphasis is placed on the good in this game. Maybe it’s because gripes about refs and David Gallop is what sells papers. If that were the case it would be a shame.
October 28th 2012 @ 4:05am
Johnno said | October 28th 2012 @ 4:05am | Report comment
League is in good shape but has lots to work on. Yes the crowds have improved but have they improved inr eal terms too compared say the AFL. Have the crowds increases in real terms been good, or in real terms when you consider population increases of places etc maybe they have gone down I don’t know i don;t have that type of statistical population data. Canberra for example have had big troubles with getting higher crowd numbers as have the sharks, and now it seems Gold Coast titans. Rooseers too are a worry crowd numbers as are Manly, and Penrith.
-Rugby league has some big issues ahead and it knows it. It has to work out where it wants to stand as a global sport. I believe rugby league has to globally expand to go forwad and get market share. AFL can get away with it, bit becoz of rugby league’s links with rugby union, I don’t think it can.
-International test match rugby league must come 1st not origin in priority. I am glad next year there is a stand alone rep weekend for the test, and city VS Country match which i would still scrap by the way it hasn’t been a rep trial for 20 years. And with pay tv country people see the stars in tv all the time now anyway. On rep weekend i would defiantly have like a Moari VS indigenous game for example. And a few PI tees eg Fiji VS Samoa at Auckland or sydney.
-And the origin eligibility stuff has to be sorted out too which I admit they are doing and trying to sort put. It is not an easy issue let’s be honest.
-Loved the Townsville test showed the passion fans have for test match footy, it felt far more speciall than Origin,. A match played between 2 states should be the pinnacle of the game . It should be internationals. Hope ASHES gets restored they do talk about hope they do it.
-A 4 year cycle is best for rugby league like in rugby union
EG:
– YR 1- ASHES
- YR 2- 4 nations
-Y3- rest in off season
YR 4- Rugby League World cup
Can’t wait for rugby league world cup will be best ever. ANd rugby league can’t abandon suburban ground totally either. Manly fans will not travel across spit to SFS to watch matches. it is in worst location for a team Manly. Brooky will never be redeveloped it seems as state govt isn’t giving many more money to suburban grounds. The North Sydney Bears geographically are such a good team for sydney northern Zone compared to Manly which they came back as North Sydney not central coast if they comeback. Such a big business district too North Sydney. SO bring back the bears in expansion.
-2nd brisbane team a must, and Perth , and a 2nd NZ team maybe another 1 in Auckland or in wellington. And I wouldn’t mind if league went to conferences more local derbies is what sells, and helps QLD expand even more in the catchment eg places like Rocky, and Ipsiwich get a team. And also the IC must make the BBL stronger and build on it a great feeder rugby league heartland.
Thanks Townsville for putting on a great test match, great ad for game. Next years test is in Canberra going to be great test match footy in Canberra a full Canberra stadium is a greta sight in rugby league like in Townsville.
And keep getting international rugby league strong IC i hope they do:
Asia-Pacific: Australia/NZ/PNG/Fiji/Samoa/Tonga/Cook Islands/Lebanon
Africa:STH Africa
Americas:USA/Canada/Jamaica
Europe: England/IWales/Scotland/Irleand/France/Italy/Croatia/Serbia/Ukraine/Poland/Czech Republic/Russia/Denmark
-SO rugby league is in good shape going forwad if it develops right and spends cash wisely. A reserve grade comp too is a must as well I think. Or a 3rd tier NSW/QLD cup combined wouldn’t be bad.
-And I’d allow the strip, and also soccering for possession at play the ball time like the old days. Play the balls are so lazy and shocking as players know the marker can’t soccer back possession. And the clean strip of the ball is good too, . Just need to bring new ways in league to keep the unprediciabtlity of fighting for possession. new ways to contest possession then it will be better spectacle. And cut interchange back by 2 spots to.
October 28th 2012 @ 9:58am
oikee said | October 28th 2012 @ 9:58am | Report comment
Hey Johnno, you have heard of the term quality over quantity. I think the league calender is pretty full. What does this mean, well internationals will come more to end of season games. Next year World Cup will be fantastic, no dought.
The quality is Origin and the All-Stars game is making a name for itself as well. The Anzac test match is traditional and should be kept.
Again, you cant jam to much into a season. I repeat, your better off having Quality over quantity, playing more games just makes it become too much. You only have to look at the amount of times the Wallabies and Allblacks play now, to often, the shine loses it luster, to much polish.
The Brissy Raor last nite paid the price of a poor quality game, only 13 wanderers fans turned up, and not many more roar fans either. The scoreline reflected the poorness of this contest, 0-1 to wanderers.
Keeping the fans entertained is the prize, the Brisbane public is without predjudice, they will support top class entertainment and players. Just dont serve up rubbish, that goes in the bin where it deserves to be.
October 28th 2012 @ 3:28pm
MG Burbank said | October 28th 2012 @ 3:28pm | Report comment
You’re right, Oikee- although Johnno has some good ideas spread out between some questionable ones. He said the Test in townsville showed the ‘passion’ league fans have for international footy- yet the game was a sleeper, with neither side displaying much in the way of desire. And yes, you’re right, we can’t crowd the schedule any further although I agree with Johnno that the City-Country game is a nonsense. If we want to sell the game in the bush we need to be employing our superstars much more regularly in the way of clinics, exhibiition games and the odd NRL game.
We do need to create a regular international schedule that fans can get behind, such as regular Ashes and Trans-Tasman series like we used to. How we fit that into the season is anyone’s guess.
Johnno is way off the mark with reinstating the strip and “soccering” for the ball. Thank god we’ve removed those grubby fights for possession and taken the game away from the mess that is Rugby.
Oikee you are absolutely right about quality not quantity. I’d prefer a 22-round NRL premiership to give the players some breathing space with all the rep games that should be there.
October 28th 2012 @ 6:09am
db swannie said | October 28th 2012 @ 6:09am | Report comment
Great read MG.
October 28th 2012 @ 6:17am
NF said | October 28th 2012 @ 6:17am | Report comment
MG
A common occurrence in rugby league is the constant negativity that flows through the fans, media, administration & everyone else involved in the sport. Out of all the codes RL tends to be the most cynicism and pessimistic although is has good reason to be when you consider everything they had happen to it over the past decades and what it causes mentally to the fanbase & the code itself.
RL still got a long way to go but it’s in a better shape than previous years which is a positive which should be embraced it seems us leaguies struggle to embrace positivity we always seem to nitpick at our code while the rest of the sporting media & co. gladly join in kicking the code down whenever they have the chance.
October 28th 2012 @ 9:33am
Tommy said | October 28th 2012 @ 9:33am | Report comment
NF wrote “we always seem to nitpick at our code while the rest of the sporting media & co. gladly join in kicking the code down whenever they have the chance.”.
That is about the truest summation I have ever seen written about RL.
The code in Sydney in particular has an ingrained culture that thinks kicking the crap out of the game is not only funny & a sign of their wit, but adds to an ongoing soap opera that keeps the profile of the game up.
If RL media & people behave like that when it comes to RL, no wonder many from other codes jump on the bandwagon.
Before the mid 1990s RL in Sydney had no serious competition from any rival code in the media or public support. The above logic could be got away with back then. Now with Sydney having four professional footy codes & clubs it is dinosaur thinking.
Unfortunately too many in RL still can’t look beyond being the next to make a RL potty joke & smearing the game with it. RL has given them a livelihood but few respect it or care what the next generation will have to win back.
October 28th 2012 @ 6:45pm
yewonk said | October 28th 2012 @ 6:45pm | Report comment
does anyone else see similarities between the james graham incident and higginbotham kneeing and headbutting of mc caw ? look how the two played out so differently.
November 1st 2012 @ 6:18pm
mushi said | November 1st 2012 @ 6:18pm | Report comment
Not really – head butting and biting are viewed a little more differently.
November 1st 2012 @ 6:39pm
yewonk said | November 1st 2012 @ 6:39pm | Report comment
both are aggressive forms of foul play both are acts that are unexpected to the victim.
one got an appropriate twelve weeks the other two weeks.
what in your opinion is the difference.
October 28th 2012 @ 7:37am
Steve b said | October 28th 2012 @ 7:37am | Report comment
MG I want a job with you as boss , the clubs that were hoping for inclusion have been going at this for three years they had sponsership in place they have a good fan base , but no wait till 2015 and well think about it then . All this b.s. about the money yes that,s great they got the money but when are they going to make some positive decisions , according to you we have been focusing on the negative , so they have been so great since the deal was done haven’t they , The country FTA Viewer got told if you want to watch the games go and fork out $500 bucks for a vast sat dish and box , yes thats a positive a mate . Or go and get Fox on and add to your already increasing living cost’s , yes mate their looking after the fan’s .Six month’s no new CEO , but you say o give them more time WTF HOW BLOODY LONG . Their was nothing in the deal for the fan but yeh thats a positive , the invisable men are still doing nothing except sacking people with no idea who is going to replace them yeh top job . I am glad i’m not paying their wages , but mate as long as everyone is happy with the way they are performing then the NRL is in good hands according to you and many more ,who agree with you above , But for mine and many others in the game they need to pick their act up fast …
October 28th 2012 @ 8:40am
james said | October 28th 2012 @ 8:40am | Report comment
typical RL negativity right here that MG was talking about in the article.
the TV deal was done for the future of the game
mattiske is doing an acceptable job as temp CEO at the moment IMO
expansion can wait till the current clubs are in a decent position and can stand on there on two feat
anyone they have fired has been a good option. the minimal leaks to reporters over TV deal and CEO hunt has been an impressive turn around.
October 28th 2012 @ 2:24pm
Chris @ the Old Barbershop said | October 28th 2012 @ 2:24pm | Report comment
I agree with Steve. What is so great about the TV deal? Rugby League was underpaid for years and is now only getting what it is worth(should be more in my opinion). I pay for Foxtel yet still can’t watch my team play live games. What other fans of professional sports have to put with that BS. Not to mention the night grand finals.
Also there will be games on 5 days a week next year – how is that good for the players with families?
You can put a positive spin on anything you like. Rugby League will always be awesome but there is a crap load wrong with the running of the game.
October 28th 2012 @ 3:35pm
MG Burbank said | October 28th 2012 @ 3:35pm | Report comment
Steve, if you’ve been following league for a while you should remember the last time large-scale expansion occurred: 1995, with the game in its best position ever, at its peak of popularity and 2 of the new 4 teams collapsed. Yes, there was the Super League war but even so, we need to be careful now before we expand again and not listen to the ravings of businessmen who only care about short-term profit. You say these teams have sponsorship and a good fan base- but will those dollars and people exist in a few years, if the team performs poorly? We have to be confident the answer to that question is yes and I for one am not.
Also, we are at another peak moment now, better than ever, and it’s a good idea to ride this for a while and ensure all 16 teams have a chance to compete every season. Back to 1994, there were already 5 or 6 clubs (Wests, Balmain, Souths, Illawarra, Gold Coast and Cronulla) who had become almost 2nd-division teams and yet we STILL added four more. Insane.
There’s a reason Fox and Nine paid ove a billion dollars for the TV rights. They know how popular and marketable the game is right now. Give credit where it’s due.
October 28th 2012 @ 9:05am
Hardwick said | October 28th 2012 @ 9:05am | Report comment
Couldn’t agree more. The game is in great shape overall.
October 28th 2012 @ 9:36am
oikee said | October 28th 2012 @ 9:36am | Report comment
MG, you have outperformed yourself again. Brilliant report mate. I agreee we could have done a bigger song and dance around mahe Fonua, this is really a media promblem, they just dont have the nack for a good story. It is the constant negative that has been with league for too long, and is why league is always on the back foot, always trying to defend.
You can see where i am going with this, yes another cleanout of deadwood reporters in our game, starting with Kenty and that buzz dude, why weedler still has a job is beyond me, i have not read one of his stories for 2 years now.
Do i hold a grudge, you bet ya.
Some recent developments i have taken notice of, before i go back to read Johnno’s small novel.
Joey Johns and Freddie have finally woken up and decided to do some work in the islands. ? What was holding them back, surely not waiting for support from the old NRL,
we all know where that takes you. No ex=league players have got to start taking their own inniecetives, and Joey, (who happens to be a immortal now) and Freddie, who i still rate as one of our best ever halves, are now going to spread some love, some gospel over on the Islands, of Fiji, Tonga and Samoa, i also hope they do the others as well, Like Solomons and Cook Islands.
The second thing i noticed was Indonesia, the international they played only this weekend. This surely can open up a better development path now for Japan as well, the team we should be pitting them against is PNG, they would be the perfect benchmark for a 3 nation series, or 4.
Finally i read about Hawaii, and the talent sitting over their not being utilised. They have 1.2 million, this is a state of America as well, lets not forget that.? The island boys are perfectly suited our game, thank goodness we have a boy on the ground over their who can see and further advance our cause.
This is where Tonga Samoa and Fiji as well as the Cooks come into develpoment, playing a 4 nation series with Hawaii is a fantastic plan. It will be a hard competition for Hawaii, bring them up to speed quickly.
Anyhow, John Grant has done a fantastic job, it is just a shame our reporters are not anywhere near his class, apart from you MG.
Keep up the good work. It would be great to have a reporter full time following the progress of these ventures. That would be great tv veiwing.
One last thing, lets not forget the work Big Mal Meninga puts into PNG. The guy is not only coach of the Mighty Maroons, but also is coach of the PM’s 13′s..
Behind the scenes alot id happening in PNG, and big Mal and the QRL are leading the charge. Great work.
We dont hear anything about this because again, it never gets reported. And this is why i am so down on Kent and Buzz, all they see is a bubble inside a caccoon.
October 28th 2012 @ 3:37pm
MG Burbank said | October 28th 2012 @ 3:37pm | Report comment
Thanks Oikee- you always criticize me where you think it’s warranted but aren’t afraid to give a wrap as well. I wish more reporters were prepared to acknowledge what they see as both the bad AND the good.
October 28th 2012 @ 10:08pm
Moya kin said | October 28th 2012 @ 10:08pm | Report comment
Oikee, some good stuff there. You Aussies want RL to spread into Pacific and the globe, but you are not putting your money where it will count. dont you guys know that RL is a national sport in PNG? I am a PNGian and these few here are some points people higher up hopefully will see; 1) put money into Junior development at the junior school levels in the pacific region. 2) I like your idea of a pacific competition including PNG, FIJI, Tonga, Samoa, Cook Islands, A Maori team and an Aust Aboriginal team.Yes scrap that City/country thing. In PNG nobody watches it. They only wait for the real thing, State of Origin! 3) In our local Intercity Competition, we have so much tallent up here. It is surprising that PNG players are never drafted into the NRL. They usually lack some size and fitness but why not…look at players like Dean Lance, Trevor Gilmester, Fatty Vautin and the current captain of the Sharks. They are not that big….but they have huges heart for the game and buckets of mental strengths. In PNG, our players are as hard as rock, what ever size they come! 4) publicity is something thats never been kind to us up here. There are so many good things you guys can write of about PNG…Why touch a few negetaives all the time…Rugby League is the same!
cheers olgeta wantok!
October 28th 2012 @ 10:33am
Renegade said | October 28th 2012 @ 10:33am | Report comment
Spot on MG.
Although, i would have liked to have seen the two expansion teams enter in 2015.
These bids have been going for some time now and we need a presence in WA and another team in Brissy ASAP.
Apart from that your right, the game is only going from strength to strength….unfortunately most of the media are aware that writing hyperbole will get people reading the article even if its just for a reaction.
October 28th 2012 @ 11:21am
Col Quinn said | October 28th 2012 @ 11:21am | Report comment
Well thought-out article. The problem for RL will remain as long as the politics (or those who practice them) of the Super League wars, are still around. Murdoch did not win or lose the Super League wars but his resentment at not an outright win is still there to see, through his paid hacks. RL is in very good shape because it is honest about its state of play, juniors etc. Another code has not been so honest and will eventually pay the price. RL is also in good and growing shape internationally. Another international code’s supporters hate this and deride the expansion of RL but expand it is and 10 or so years RL will be in an interesting position with the continental Europeans challenging Australia’s dominance.
October 28th 2012 @ 12:56pm
nzmate said | October 28th 2012 @ 12:56pm | Report comment
I don’t think so Col. Looking towards the 2013 world cup; by making half the Italy squad ex Australian players and seeing them still get smacked by the likes of the kangaroos does not lead me to believe continental Europe will be challenging Australian dominance in the next 10 years. rugby union certainly isnt without criticism here, but it seems that the league world cup aims to put the best players on show regardless of their affiliation to a particular country – which isn’t in itself necessarily a bad thing because it improves competitiveness – but it does look like it is ‘a made for Australia and to a lesser degree England’ tv production – already knowledgeable league countries – at the expense of perhaps local players who are not as good, but might better showcase the growing game that league is…
October 28th 2012 @ 3:33pm
Col Quinn said | October 28th 2012 @ 3:33pm | Report comment
NZ you should check out RL development in Europe, currently funded by the EEC. Player numbers and skills growing at an impressive rate. This right across Europe. Some European RL countries play more tests that Aus. Standard is somewhere between NSW Cup and NRL but it is a start. I dont think 10 years is an unrealistic time frame.
October 28th 2012 @ 11:36am
roarr said | October 28th 2012 @ 11:36am | Report comment
Crowds have been stuck on 16k average for about 7-10 years havent they?
As for the negativity… it sells. Just ask anyone at the Daily Telegraph, Julia Gillard, Tony Abbott or my girlfriend!