Where to now for the baggy greens?
By David Lord, 6 Mar 2013 David Lord is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Australia cricket, Cricket, india cricket, Matthew Wade, Ravi Ashwin, Test cricket
Has David Warner gone too far with his latest Twitter outburst? (AP Photo/Andrew Brownbill)
Related coverage
There’s been one standout in India’s successive eight-wicket, innings and 35 maulings of Australia – Ravi Ashwin.
The 25-year-old offie conducted the music and the Australian batsmen couldn’t dance.
His career figures are 14 Tests for 81 wickets at 28.93, but he’s raised his performance bar in this series’ two Tests with 18 wickets at 16.78 and an economy rate of 2.5.
Very, very impressive.
And not far behind in the domination stakes were four Indian batsmen who dictated the outcome of both Tests.
MS Dhoni’s career-best 224, and Virat Kohli’s 127 at Chennai, followed by Chereshwar Pujara’s 204, with Murali Vijay’s 167 at Hyderabad.
Take those four digs out, and Australia would have been in with a big sniff.
But “IF” doesn’t win anything, so where to now for the battered Aussies?
The next Test won’t be until March 14 at Mohali, so there’s plenty of time to select from two options.
Go with what they’ve got in the 17-man squad, where Usman Khawaja, Steve Smith, and Mitchell Johnson have yet to get a run.
Or tell the BCCI, India’s governing body, that Shane Watson is going home for the birth of his first child, and on the plane with him will be Phil Hughes, Matthew Wade, Xavier Doherty, James Pattinson, and Mitchell Starc.
And none of the six will return.
Hughes needs no explanation, Wade was guilty yesterday of gross disrespect to his team with a mind-blowing stupid decision (more in a minute), Doherty isn’t up to it, and both Pattinson and Starc have 10 Ashes Tests in front of them, so why risk them in India?
With occupation of the crease paramount yesterday to try and save the Test, Wade called for a suicidal single to short cover, where Ravindra Jadeja fumbled his pick-up but still had time to throw down the stumps with Moises Henriques well short and yet to score.
It was the dumbest cricket for yonks. Wade deserves the bullet.
While this lot are flying home, another plane in the opposite direction will have Adam Voges, Ashton Agar, Steve O’Keefe, James Faulkner, and 22-year-old Western Australian keeper Tom Triffitt on it, heading for Mohali.
All five will add to the overall batting strength of the tourists.
That will leave Peter Siddle, Johnson, Faulkner, and Henriques to look after the pace scene, with Nathan Lyon, Glenn Maxwell, Agar, and O’Keefe the spin.
I’m still not convinced Henriques and Maxwell are Test men, despite Henriques’ 68 and 81* in Chennai, and Maxwell’s 4-127 at Hyderabad, both on debut.
But neither deserve to be overlooked, so they have two more Tests to cement their claim.
It will be interesting to see how selection chairman John Inverarity reacts to the two maulings.
If at all.
- Explore:
- Australia cricket, Cricket, india cricket, Matthew Wade, Ravi Ashwin, Test cricket

March 6th 2013 @ 7:13am
Johnno said | March 6th 2013 @ 7:13am | Report comment
Is cricket in worse shape David than the dark day’s of the 1980′s before we won the 1987 ODI world cup.
March 6th 2013 @ 8:51am
cuzza said | March 6th 2013 @ 8:51am | Report comment
not even close, welham, beard, mcclay, , bennett, hookes, davis (possibly the worst opening bowler in the history of test cricket.) craig matthews, kerr, o’donnell, emery, zoherer, holland, dodemaide, davis, and my personal favourite, tom hogan
March 6th 2013 @ 8:54am
David Lord said | March 6th 2013 @ 8:54am | Report comment
Johnno and cussa, you both have raised a really good point. While Australia cricket was going through the horrors of the 80s, all the other countries were much stronger than they are now:
ENGLAND had Mike Gatting, David Gower, Tony Greig, Ian Botham, Alan Lamb, Bob Willis, Bob Taylor, and Derek Randall.
WEST INDIES had Gordon Greenidge, Desmond Haynes, Viv Richards, Clive Lloyd, Larry Gomes, Malcolm Marshall, and Michael Holding.
INDIA had Sunil Gavaskar, Kapil Dev, Ravi Shastri, Dilip Vensarkar, Chetan Chauhan, and Gundappa Viswanath.
PAKISTAN had Imran Khan, Javed Miandad, Zaheer Abbas, Abdul Qadir, and Wasim Bari.
NEW ZEALAND had Richard Hadlee, Martin Crowe, Bruce Edgar, Lance Cairns, Jeremy Coney, Geoff Howard, and Ewan Chatfield.
SRI LANKA had Sidath Wettimonny, Ranjan Madugalle, Arjuna Ranatunga, Aravinda da Silva, and Duleep Mendis.
And South Africa wasn’t readmitted from isolation until 1991.
So the Aussies did it really tough in that era.
March 6th 2013 @ 10:14am
sheek said | March 6th 2013 @ 10:14am | Report comment
Hi David,
I like these exercises.
The Saffies could put a very strong side together in the mid-80s, which still included a 41 year old Graeme Pollock.
SOUTH AFRICA : Jimmy Cook, Henry Fotheringham, Peter Kirsten, Graeme Pollock, Kenny McEwan, Clive Rice(c), Alan Kourie, Ray Jennings(k), Steve Jefferies, Garth le Roux, Hugh Page.
Slow left-armer Alan Kourie is statistically the best spinner SA have had in 45 years, shame he didn’t play an official test.
Official Australia, c.1985: Andrew Hilditch, Graeme Wood, Kepler Wessels, Allan Border(c), Greg Ritchie, David Boon, Wayne Phillips(k), Simon O’Donnell, Geoff Lawson, Craig McDermott, Bob Holland.
Rebel Australia, c.1985: John Dyson, Steve Smith, Graeme Yallop, Kim Hughes(c), Mick Taylor, Mike Haysman, Trevor Hohns, Steve Rixon(k), Rodney Hogg, Carl Rackemann, Terry Alderman.
Wessels joined the Rebel Aussies in time for the 1986/87 tour.
March 6th 2013 @ 7:18am
Red Kev said | March 6th 2013 @ 7:18am | Report comment
Bring Bailey instead of Voges, leave Agar at home (O’Keefe and Lyon with Maxwell is enough spin) and Hartley needs to be the keeper whistled up, not a 22 year old who hasn’t been tested at all yet.
But the NSP won’t do that, too much face to lose.
The only question is really will Clarke bat at no.3 with Khawaja at 4 or the other way around.
March 6th 2013 @ 9:03am
Ken Hambling said | March 6th 2013 @ 9:03am | Report comment
I think it will be Khawaja at 3 and Clarkeat 4, i woudl be ok with the other way around as well.
March 6th 2013 @ 7:40am
dave gray said | March 6th 2013 @ 7:40am | Report comment
India is always a struggle, but the selections have made a hard task much harder. First issue is that Clarke should not be a selector. It use to be on tour only, but in this day and age with cheap airfares, not at all. Have another selector over there. Second issue, why has Bird not been replaced already? Why isn’t Watson’s replacement over there already acclimatising? Completely inept administration.
It starts at the top….
I agree with Bailey, he would be a good head to have over there and he’s right handed!
David, you maybe a bit harsh on Henriques, his FC averages this year put him on the plane. 60 with the bat and under 22 with the ball. Maxwell an average of 35 with the bat. That should not get you in the Australian side.
Why is Steve Smith there? Why isn’t SOK? Does Clarke have any influence in this regard do you think.. Give Agar more time.
Wade struggles, but who is to say the others wont on these pitches. His batting averages keep him there.
Voges…good player of spin but averages 33 this year…leave him at home too. India is no place to find form.
What do you do with Hughes…no idea…let’s rotate him…
March 6th 2013 @ 8:17am
Train Without A Station said | March 6th 2013 @ 8:17am | Report comment
So Triffit has leapfrogged Wade, Haddin, Paine and Neville now? Must have been quiet a summer he had.
Also David, you’ve been bagging the rotation of pace bowlers, yet are now advocating resting Pattinson and Starc? You’re hard to keep up with pal.
March 6th 2013 @ 8:40am
Hansie said | March 6th 2013 @ 8:40am | Report comment
And I think that’s the same Tom Triffitt who has been dropped by WA.
March 6th 2013 @ 8:55am
DCO said | March 6th 2013 @ 8:55am | Report comment
Wade’s call was poor judgement in the circumstances, but we know David has a complete biased view with Matt Wade. Every opportunity to pick on him in an article David takes. So yes it was a bad call, but watch it again and watch Henriques do two things himself that are attributable; (1) not concentrating on backing up far enough and (2) hesitates when he is called through. Wade was at fault though but not worth dropping him for. David can’t find too many reasons to criticise Wade’s keeping this series, particularly when you watch Dhoni keep. For a guy who has kept in India all his life and is use to keeping to spin, Dhoni has been far less impressive than Wade behind the stumpings. Dhoni has missed easy chances including two stumpings, plus has conceded 33 byes in 378 overs, while Wade has only conceded 19 in 330 overs. But you won’t hear David criticise Dhoni’s keeping. So given David can’t pick on Wade’s keeping this series, nor blame Wade for his poor batting when there have been many worse, let’s send him home because of his run out of Henriques.
March 6th 2013 @ 4:07pm
Jay said | March 6th 2013 @ 4:07pm | Report comment
It’s still not as bad nor selfish as Brad Haddin giving his wicket away with Australia at 5 for 18 at Newlands.
March 6th 2013 @ 8:56am
cuzza said | March 6th 2013 @ 8:56am | Report comment
why would you bring starc home? surely not to rest him for the ashes. he is just another hack left-hander who cannot swing the ball, hence his inclination to go around the wicket when bowling to right-handers, i dont understand why left handers do this unless they are akram and can come around the wicket and bowl an outswinger. (and from what i can see starc is no akram!). starc is in the same bracket as bracken and bollinger, over rated left handers. like hughes, he had cheap results in the summer and now we are finding out he is no good.
March 6th 2013 @ 9:35am
Brett McKay said | March 6th 2013 @ 9:35am | Report comment
Tom Triffitt, David? He lost his WA place before Christmas, and Michael Hussey for 20 overs was considered a better option by the end of the BBL.
Sam Whiteman, on the other hand, has done quite well. But even he has several others in front of him. Same with Ashton Agar…
March 6th 2013 @ 9:45am
sledgeross said | March 6th 2013 @ 9:45am | Report comment
Triffitt isnt even the best keeper in his state!
March 6th 2013 @ 10:33am
cuzza said | March 6th 2013 @ 10:33am | Report comment
is tiffet real, or is he make believe like mr snuffleuppergas? i live in wa and i have never heard of him.
March 6th 2013 @ 11:08am
matt h said | March 6th 2013 @ 11:08am | Report comment
Very very odd article
March 6th 2013 @ 1:56pm
Christo the Daddyo said | March 6th 2013 @ 1:56pm | Report comment
I can never work out whether David is serious with these sorts of articles, or whether he’s simply stirring the pot. He appears to be far too experienced for the former to be true, and yet…
March 6th 2013 @ 11:22am
Renegade said | March 6th 2013 @ 11:22am | Report comment
Why so many changes….it’s not going to change the result of this series.
Hell, may as well throw me on a plane and hand me a baggy green too…..this is absolutely absurd.
How can we justify that these players are not worthy after just 2 matches in of all places, India where we struggled to have success even with a team full of legends. This is an inexperienced team, going through this will pay dividends in about 2-3 years….even if we have to sacrifice a 4-0 whitewash……climbing back to number 1 isn’t going to be easy.
March 6th 2013 @ 1:54pm
Christo the Daddyo said | March 6th 2013 @ 1:54pm | Report comment
Anyone familiar with the pitch at Mohali? For some reason I had an idea it was a bit more pace friendly that your usual Indian dustbowl…
If so, surely you’d bring Starc back into the lineup instead of Maxwell and return Lyon to his rightful position above Doherty.
As for the batting, I’m hearing mixed messages about whether Watson actually is leaving the tour or not. Can anyone confirm either way? If so, then bringing in Khawaja is the logical choice. And I’d leave the rest of the team as is. The only way they will learn to better their techniques is to continue to play in India against good quality spin bowling.
March 6th 2013 @ 2:01pm
Red Kev said | March 6th 2013 @ 2:01pm | Report comment
Cricinfo and Suneer both made mention of it being more pace-friendly than Chennai and Hyderabad during the end of the fourth test commentary. I think “more” is a relative term though. If I had to guess I still think it is a two-spinner pitch but that there would actually be pace assistance on day one instead of the feeling of bowling onto an unresponsive surface.
March 6th 2013 @ 2:16pm
Renegade said | March 6th 2013 @ 2:16pm | Report comment
“The only way they will learn to better their techniques is to continue to play in India against good quality spin bowling.”
Exactly!
March 6th 2013 @ 2:27pm
Red Kev said | March 6th 2013 @ 2:27pm | Report comment
That is not a sensible use of test cricket.
If we suck at spin – have a spin academy tour to India during the BBL.
March 6th 2013 @ 3:02pm
Christo the Daddyo said | March 6th 2013 @ 3:02pm | Report comment
That’s a great suggestion for the next generation, but doesn’t do much for the current mob…
March 6th 2013 @ 5:47pm
Ian Whitchurch said | March 6th 2013 @ 5:47pm | Report comment
Heck, tour Bangladesh at any time during their season.
Theres been a lot of arrogance in Australian cricket, and now it doesnt have the cattle to back that arrogance.