The Roar
The Roar

Advertisement

Should rugby end chest-high tackles?

The ball-and-all tackle carries with it a number of risks, including increased possibility of head clashes. (AAP Image/Paul Miller)
Roar Guru
22nd April, 2015
114
1527 Reads

Is it time to lower the dangerous tackle line from below the shoulders to below the chest?

Tackles to the chest area are increasingly dangerous in professional rugby – not just because they have a high chance of moving to the player’s head, or causing a head clash, but because chest-high tackles are dangerous in themselves.

The number of players who have been injured by legal chest-high tackles is growing, and the number of head injuries caused by tacklers aiming too high is a contributing factor in the growing spate of concussions.

The traditional rugby tackle is taught to younger players to be aimed between the knees and chest.

Ball-and-all tackles from the front may need to be changed in technique so tacklers are less upright. Wrap around, choke-hold tackles are one of the contributors to head clashes and head injuries, as tacklers attack at chest height and any error moves them towards the head.

The Guardian made a positive argument that such a law change would cause attacking players to have their passing arms free more often, causing more passes and likely more tries. Hardly a bad result?

Secondly, there are increasing calls for the reserves bench after this World Cup to be reduced from seven players to five, the aim being to have players staying out longer and getting more fatigued.

The NRL is conducting a comprehensive review of interchange rules in a move aimed at making the game safer and more exciting, including reducing the number of substitutions on the four-man bench from the current ten to either eight, seven or six.

Advertisement

Reducing the reserves bench in rugby union would inevitably mean a three-two backs-forwards split, with the players being more utility than the specialists they currently are.

This may in turn make it less likely for coaches to put them on early and lead to more fatigue for the starting XV.

close