The Roar
The Roar

Advertisement

Rob Simmons' injury could make way for new and old

Rob Simmons is a valuable player for the Wallabies, so how do they replace him? (AFP PHOTO / PETER MUHLY)
Roar Guru
2nd August, 2015
27
1656 Reads

Wallaby lock Rob Simmons’ unfortunately-timed wrist injury could see some young blood or some old talent in the second row this weekend in the Bledisloe Cup against New Zealand and going into the World Cup in September.

Beyond his presence and size on the field, Simmons is a key component in the Wallabies set piece as the lineout caller.

Professional rugby lineout calls are both numerous and complex, but surely it is prudent to have more than one lock who is completely versed in calling them? Simmons’ value is often spoken with reference to this component of his game. It’s a dangerous secret to leave only to one soldier.

Simmons has caused his fair share of trouble in the Test matches he played last year and through the Super Rugby season.

He is often found niggling off the ball and infringing at times where his team is at its most desperate. He seems prone to engaging in the style provoked by such South African players as Eben Etzebeth. Most players are guilty of it from time to time, but Simmons’ persistent lazy cleanout and breakdown etiquette has seen him penalised in key moments of matches.

Melbourne Rebels player Luke Jones has played three Tests in his short Wallabies career but would be the perfect young inclusion to the squad. He might well be a candidate for some lineout calling lessons from Simmons going forward. However, he may find it hard to get noticed with fellow youngster and Brumbies lock Rory Arnold filling the youth position in the squad.

Waratahs captain Dave Dennis may also have a show. Far from setting the world of fire in his recent club hit outs for Sydney University, his workmanlike attitude and leadership may prove to be valuable to the Wallabies.

He also has the added ability of being able to play lock and back row, as well as providing a jumping component to the lineout. All that said, Dennis will most likely find it difficult to break into the squad, even with these credentials.

Advertisement

Kane Douglas is another obvious selection, however he is not available this week due to injury, even after signing for the Queensland Reds next year.

Douglas will be available for the World Cup and will feature in the squad in some way. The lock stocks are looking good for the Wallabies with the likes of James Horwill, Will Skelton, Rory Arnold, Dean Mumm and Sam Carter eventually coming back from a knee injury all vying for a place on the side.

Simmons might find his spot isn’t so comfortable after his wrist is healed.

The power and experience of Horwill and Mumm with the boost of Skelton for 30 to 40-minute bursts may find Simmons occupying the bench a bit more. He may be running a few lineout calls sessions too, just so that everyone is on the same page…

close