The Roar
The Roar

Advertisement

Peter Nevill's stumping was entirely within the spirit of cricket

16th August, 2016
Advertisement
Editor
16th August, 2016
28
1831 Reads

Watching Peter Nevill stump Sri Lankan batsman Dimuth Karunaratne live in the third Test I immediately saw it as a great piece of wicketkeeping.

Commentator Brendon Julian thought it may have been a dead ball due to the time it took Nevill to make the stumping, but the dead ball ruling is completely up to the umpire’s discretion as seen in the dead ball rule of Law 23.

Ball finally settled

Whether the ball is finally settled or not is a matter for the umpire alone to decide.

When you watch the moment in full speed Nevill had around three seconds after catching the ball before he took the bails off. Three seconds. That’s it!

It was completely Karaunaratne’s fault and he knew it. That’s why he didn’t complain when he walked off.

Advertisement

All this nonsense about it being against the spirit of cricket to make a stumping because the batsman didn’t realise the ball was still in play is absurd.

Mitchell Johnson had some stinging replies when he congratulated Nevill on Twitter.

It’s the batsman’s responsibility to check their crease like their life depends on it.

Anyone who’s watched a decent amount of cricket or played the game will know that a batsman will make it known he is going for a wander down the crease in between deliveries.

Advertisement

He or she will look at the square leg umpire in acknowledgement that the ball is dead so they can leave their crease for ‘gardening’ of the pitch or to speak to the non-striker.

Karunaratne didn’t do that. He wasn’t thinking and forgot about where the ball was. He didn’t check his surroundings and should have no sympathy from anyone.

Nevill should be applauded for keeping an eye on the foot and pouncing so quickly. He literally had a split second to take the bails off.

Nevill had tried a similar tactic in the first innings but the batsman’s foot didn’t lift.

It is a sneaky stumping but a good one. Up there with one of the best wicketkeeping plays of all time when Ian Healy ran out Curtly Ambrose when his bat got stuck in a crack at the Adelaide Oval.

Advertisement

Those who think Nevill’s stumping was against the spirit of cricket probably think Healy should have recalled Ambrose for the unfortunate crack getting in the way.

close