The Roar » Cattledog

For the good of Aussie rugby, let’s not win the RWC

Cattledog — Sun, 19 Sep 2010 19:16:39 +0000

For all my Kiwi compatriots out there, let me say it for you that there’s really not much chance of this happening. OK, now that’s done and dusted, let’s look at the real issues.

The mid to late 90s into the early 2000s was a watershed in Australian Rugby. The moons were aligned so to speak and Rod McQueen could do no wrong. Interestingly, the administration within the Australian Rugby Union appeared on song.

But what happened?

Change happened. Now, I’m a great advocator of change, not for change sake, but to improve a process, situation or outcome. I’m also an advocator of ‘if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’.

Change also brings new ideas to the table and whilst there was perceived depth in Australian Rugby, structures were not how they should be if we were to remain competitive and dominate on the world stage.

Our Super 14 (now 15) players were stepping up from the club scene and it appeared the gap between club (Premier Rugby) and Super 14 was significant. Both SA and NZ had that next tier providing the necessary competition so as the players were ‘battle hardened’ so to speak for that next level.

Enter the ARC. This looked the goods to allow Australia to have that next level of competition so as the Wallabies could remain a dominant force in provincial and world rugby.

So what happened?

Whilst change is inevitable, unfortunately management of that change isn’t! And whilst it was generally agreed this was the way forward, there didn’t appear to be the correct structures or resources allocated to such a bold move.

Subsequently, the ARC folded due to a lack of funds and a perceived lack of interest. I would have loved to have seen the business plan for this project! Who in their wildest dreams would have thought a project such as this would be a ‘cash cow’ in its first year of operation?

Clearly, the ARU was on the right track but had neither the long term plan nor commitment to see it through. I fear internal politics played a hand in this to some extent so it would seem, due to management changes; the scheme was doomed to failure.

Do we actually need this next level? From what I have read on this site and in other forums, I strongly believe it would benefit Australian Rugby moving forward.

However, there’s another thought process that would argue the structures currently in place for Australian Rugby are adequate and ‘why fix something that ain’t broke’. As a result, my great fear is that should Australia, against the odds, win the RWC, there will be a quorum of folk who will accept that everything is good with Australian Rugby so let’s not change for change sake.

We have depth and we have good, perhaps great players coming through our various systems. However, unless those players just shy of the Super 15 mark get competitive rugby above Premier level, I, like many other rugby followers, fear we may fall from the shaky position we currently hold.

More so, if we were to win the RWC there would be less chance of the correct structures being implemented. So, for the good of Australian Rugby, let’s not win the RWC.

Roaring Hot

Yesterday’s most commented articles

The real story of how John O’Neill turned Manchester City down [67 comments]
Australian teams at Super disadvantage [58 comments]
Does the A-League need an injection of humour? [43 comments]

Most read articles last 3 days

Article link: For the good of Aussie rugby, let’s not win the RWC. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Is the Haka losing its relevance?

Cattledog — Thu, 16 Sep 2010 19:08:05 +0000

A fine was imposed on the Wallaroos during the recent Women’s Rugby World Cup match where the Aussie girls dared to cross the 10 metre line toward the New Zealand girls whilst they were performing the Haka. What a load of rot! What were they meant to do, stand rigidly at attention and not move? [...]

Article link: Is the Haka losing its relevance?. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

A letter to the IRB from the ARU

Cattledog — Sat, 11 Sep 2010 16:08:50 +0000

Gentleman; A wonderful Tri-Nations once again showcasing to the world the best three teams in world rugby reside south of the equatorial line around middle earth. Now, whilst there was a spectacle of rugby in all matches, I have some concerns about the amount of rugby being played by these fine athletes. Whilst I haven’t [...]

Article link: A letter to the IRB from the ARU. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Quade Cooper: the buck stops at Super 15

Cattledog — Thu, 19 Aug 2010 16:20:11 +0000

I’m sure many of us have been quite dismayed to read all the hullabaloo with Cooper’s possible defection to league. Is it a ploy for more money? Is he genuinely interested in switching codes? Or is it perhaps a bit of both? Whilst we can only speculate, it’s Cooper and his manager and perhaps a [...]

Article link: Quade Cooper: the buck stops at Super 15. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

If the Rugby World Cup was held next week

Cattledog — Mon, 30 Nov 2009 16:27:01 +0000

The season is finished and although it’s possibly a season better forgotten by Wallaby supporters, there were many positives to come from the Northern Hemisphere tour. As an armchair critic like the rest, it’s easy for us to sit back and criticise selections, refereeing, coaching and the like. However, none of those tasks are easy, [...]

Article link: If the Rugby World Cup was held next week. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Intentional Knock On rule a load of baloney

Cattledog — Tue, 03 Nov 2009 15:59:20 +0000

As a retired referee, I am perhaps more critical of the man with the whistle than some. However, when we expect them to be mindreaders, then I must draw the line. The contencious issue of the intentional knock-on is the matter to which I am refering. When will logic dictate that if a player is [...]

Article link: Intentional Knock On rule a load of baloney. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Referees shouldn’t be mindreaders

Cattledog — Sun, 20 Sep 2009 22:19:38 +0000

As a retired referee, I am perhaps more critical of the man with the whistle than some. However, when we expect them to now be mindreaders, then I must draw the line. The contentious issue of the intentional knock-on is the matter to which I am refering. When will logic dictate that if a player [...]

Article link: Referees shouldn’t be mindreaders. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

A small score change will bring the crowds back

Cattledog — Sun, 13 Sep 2009 21:43:26 +0000

Ever wandered why the crowd roars when a team decides to go for touch rather than kick for goal? They want to see tries and a team ‘back’ itself. OK, so why not make a conversion from a try 3 points? What this would do is change the mindset of the team to go for [...]

Article link: A small score change will bring the crowds back. Written by Cattledog, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion