Can't recall seeing Duncan Hall play sheek, that's the criteria.
GPH1980, I respect your rating of Andrew Johns, but for mine he can't live with Johnathan Thurston, nor Peter Sterling.
With apologies to Manly's pocket rocket Geoff Toovey, he was in my rough notes, but I didn't translate that into copy. Toovey played well above his 168cm-70kg frame, leading Manly to a premierhip in 1996, and two other grand finals in 1995 and 1997 during his 238 games for the Sea Eagles, and 49 for the ill-fated Northern Eagles.
Add to that 16 games for NSW and 13 Tests, and Toovey was as tough as they come.