The Roar » gatesy

Rugby the safe alternative to NFL headbangers

gatesy — Wed, 01 Feb 2012 19:18:10 +0000

Imagine a kid playing contact sport, like high school rugby. He dies of major concussion, after a seemingly innocuous tackle. Is this the kind of thing people should be worried about?

The case popped up in a legal show I watched the other day calledHarry’s Law. Maybe it’s funded by interest groups with an axe to grind, but the issue was interesting. In this fictional case it was a high school gridiron player who had died.

I don’t aim to offend, because I know the same thing has happened in our own game, and my heart goes out to those who have lost a loved one in that fashion. But I do believe that in rugby those situations are mostly unfortunate and isolated incidents.

One of the (many) theses in the show that I was watching was that the boy died of secondary concussions, which they explained as the many minor hits to the skull that happen in training and in games that rarely even go noticed. Just ordinary training incidents and game situations.

The recent science apparently supports this thesis, and if it does, it should alarm a lot of parents.

The theory (which is on solid medical ground) is that young brains are still developing well into their owner’s mid 20s, and even very minor concussions (the sort that largely go unnoticed) can be harmful to proper cognitive development.

There was a lot more to the theories than that, but it got me thinking. Yes, we have concussive injuries in rugby – Berrick Barnes is a classic example. But how much do those helmets contribute to the concussive injuries that they purport to prevent or minimise?

The evidence in the case (admittedy concatenated by the needs of the Hollywood producer) was that helmets make players over-confident, and in a game of American football, players lead into collisions with their heads, believing that they are protected.

They suffer lots of head impacts during a game, and in effect are trained to do so, in the mistaken belief that they will just bounce off.

Because the game is controlled by big business, and a big stake is held by equipment manufacturers, then it follows that the helmet manufacturers might find ways to make helmets even better suited to collisions, thus contributing to the overall problem.

The show’s point was well made that you will never get the powerbrokers of gridiron to admit that their game is dangerous, at least until parents and the people who matter start taking the science seriously.

What an opportunity for rugby.

As a lawyer watching the program, I was thinking, why didn’t they get a few rugby blokes to be their expert witnesses (a flight of fancy, I know).

If they had, they would have been able to postulate that rugby, with the many hundreds of thousands of people who play it every year around the world, is a relatively safe game to play.

They could have shown that, we, as the true warrior sport, could show those gridiron blokes a thing or two, but most importantly, they could show what a silly game gridiron really is.

I mean, what is it about a race of people that believe that the the tougher the players become, or the faster, or the fitter, or bigger, the more they should increase the size of the padding or the protective gear?

What is wrong with accepting that blokes can crash into each other without killing themselves, and do it while wearing shorts, a jersey, and socks hanging around their ankles?

As rugby coaches or players, we have all learned the concept of preparation for contact. That means, in that split second or two before you take or make the hit and know that you are in for some pain, you do what you have to do to minimise it.

You drop the shoulder and turn your head, you close your mouth, you turn and take the hit, you tackle the tackler, you get the leg drive going and generally do anything or everything necessary to protect yourself, while trying to inflict a bit of pain on the other bloke.

At the very least, you act like a ferret and try to dig yourself into the turf, or accept that your back is about to become something that your mother didn’t envisage when she bore you. Or as a last resort you chuck a Hail Mary pass and run like hell, but, as we all know, they rarely work!

I realise that American Football is a multi-zillion dollar industry, but does that make it sacrosanct? Are they heading in the wrong direction?

If so, what can rugby do to make inroads and win hearts and minds in middle America? Go slowly, creep up and bite them on the bum.

Wouldn’t it be great if the USA and Canada can finally be taken seriously on the world rugby stage and the North American public start to get it, largely because they realise that the sports that they hold so dear are killing people unnecessarily.

Football has done it, by promoting the virtues of the Soccer Moms who see the game as a way to provide healthy sporting activities for their kids without the fear of major injury. What a novel concept! Why doesn’t rugby follow suit?

These are probably the ramblings of a madman, but I thought, well, if Hollywood is interested enough to make a program about this, then it is a social issue that deserves to be discussed. What do you think?

Roaring Hot

Yesterday’s most commented articles

The real story of how John O’Neill turned Manchester City down [66 comments]
Australian teams at Super disadvantage [58 comments]
Does the A-League need an injection of humour? [43 comments]

Most read articles last 3 days

Article link: Rugby the safe alternative to NFL headbangers. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Super Rugby franchises must solve problem of ten times five

gatesy — Sun, 22 Jan 2012 19:41:57 +0000

As the 2012 Super Rugby competition looms, it is interesting to note that each of the five Australian franchises is still undecided as to who will be the number 10 this season. Queensland would be the only state not having to wonder about it, if not for Quade Cooper’s injury. But with Cooper out, even [...]

Article link: Super Rugby franchises must solve problem of ten times five. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

What makes a good coach?

gatesy — Fri, 18 Nov 2011 00:51:31 +0000

After the Rugby World Cup, all the journalist take long breaks so that their wrists can get over the RSI strain of holding a tape recorder under someone’s nose and then typing out what everyone else was typing out. I couldn’t wait for the World Cup to finish so that we could start reading something [...]

Article link: What makes a good coach?. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Robbie Deans and ARU take the long view

gatesy — Tue, 08 Nov 2011 21:44:28 +0000

I’m seeing some interesting things in the tea leaves, lately. Robbie Deans has all the hallmarks of a man who has been recruited by the ARU for a long term plan. Not just to establish ourselves now, and not just to win tournaments, for if that were the case, maybe we would have been more [...]

Article link: Robbie Deans and ARU take the long view. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

The men in the middle (or the muddle)

gatesy — Sat, 15 Oct 2011 16:56:12 +0000

I was going to get into the debate about poor old Paul Warburton, but the posts on that subject were bursting into flames by the time that I got there, but it got me thinking – we’ve had the poor performances by Bryce and that horrible decision by Alain Rolland tonight and we haven’t seen [...]

Article link: The men in the middle (or the muddle). Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

A word about English rugby, if you don’t mind

gatesy — Wed, 05 Oct 2011 19:27:37 +0000

You have to love the Rugby World Cup time. We get to read material from other journalists that we haven’t heard of before, not just the usual trite stuff from some Aussie journalist who spends his time turning up to press conferences, sticking out his tape recorder and repeating whatever everyone else heard. That’s not [...]

Article link: A word about English rugby, if you don’t mind. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

What have we learnt after after 7 RWCs?

gatesy — Tue, 27 Sep 2011 17:29:43 +0000

This was going to be a response to another article, but as usual my verbosity got the better of me. One correspondent made the point that the minnows are progressing. I tend to disagree. Japan has still not won a game after 20 years of trying. USA has probably marginally improved, yet they have been [...]

Article link: What have we learnt after after 7 RWCs?. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Have any colour so long as it’s (not) black

gatesy — Wed, 03 Aug 2011 15:43:45 +0000

Remember that bloke Roy G. Biv? The acronym for kids to learn the colours of the spectrum. Red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo and violet, and every shade in between. Except black, which isn’t there, because it’s not even a colour, just an absence of light and shade. And in the case of the UK’s [...]

Article link: Have any colour so long as it’s (not) black. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Back to the future: rugby from here

gatesy — Thu, 28 Jul 2011 15:39:54 +0000

How do we grow the mid-tier of rugby? We have this ARC discussion every couple of years. It’s dead and buried and best left where it lays, unfortunately. I used to espouse the ‘build it and they will come’ idea, but now I think it is a lot simpler than that. It requires evolution. Or [...]

Article link: Back to the future: rugby from here. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Why I’m not a gambling man!

gatesy — Sat, 18 Jun 2011 20:46:53 +0000

The reason that I don’t gamble for a living is that I would starve. Here is what I wrote on my blog in mid-January: The Rebels will be a force to be reckoned with and won’t finish in the red. The Brumbies will come home in a canter and the Waratahs will whither on the [...]

Article link: Why I’m not a gambling man!. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Who will the Wallabies send to the Olympics?

gatesy — Sun, 27 Mar 2011 20:22:57 +0000

Watching the Hong Kong sevens today, you can’t help but be impressed with what Michael O’Connor has done with the Australian Sevens squad. The only game I saw Australia play was Russia, and I was very impressed with the physicality of our players. When one of our guys made a break, they hit the line, [...]

Article link: Who will the Wallabies send to the Olympics?. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

The only place to be is to be a brumbeee

gatesy — Sun, 06 Mar 2011 20:14:07 +0000

Q: What’s the difference between a Brumby and a joke, mummy? A: Not much! Q. I’m tone deaf, do you think I’ll make it in the orchestra? A: it’s OK, dear, just find an orchestra where you can sack the conductor, if he doesn’t agree with you. I’m sure there are one or two out [...]

Article link: The only place to be is to be a brumbeee. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Global rugby season will be a reality soon

gatesy — Wed, 02 Feb 2011 17:53:00 +0000

In ten years time, I’m predicting that we will finally have a global rugby season, and the competitions will look very different from now. The insatiable appetite of television and the fact that year after year the Southern Hemisphere shows its superiority will finally be too much for the Northern Hemisphere to bear, and they [...]

Article link: Global rugby season will be a reality soon. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Beware the Rebels and Brumbies in Super 15

gatesy — Thu, 23 Dec 2010 16:49:10 +0000

I’ve been reading all the stuff that people are writing about the Waratahs, the Reds and so on, but with Stephen Larkham as the new backs coach, watch out for the Brumbies. Pound for pound, the Brumbies will match every team across the park in the Super 15. Here is my pick – first team [...]

Article link: Beware the Rebels and Brumbies in Super 15. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Rugby needs to remember its roots

gatesy — Sat, 11 Dec 2010 14:40:35 +0000

I read a really nice and impassioned Read More...

What will the Wallabies RWC squad look like?

gatesy — Wed, 08 Dec 2010 17:32:58 +0000

Just when you thought we had a settled line-up after the Northern tour, it is worth speculating on those who couldn’t go for one reason or another, those who couldn’t be selected because they haven’t been seen yet, those coming back from injuries, those who will be next season’s “bolters.”

It’s time for the great scrum debate

gatesy — Mon, 29 Nov 2010 18:16:23 +0000

Well, it’s too late for this Rugby World Cup, but I still think that it is timely to talk about where scrums are going. From our experiences on the Spring Tour, it is obvious that the Wallabies can win no matter what happens in the scrums.

Wallabies begin journey of the underdog

gatesy — Sun, 11 Jul 2010 20:36:41 +0000

The All Blacks have won Round 1 – the Boks are analysing their performance. Everybody is asking why Bakkies Botha had such a brain snap that he now misses the next nine weeks. Are the two related, is there a problem with their coaching, or their attitude? The knives are probably being slowly unsheathed. No reason [...]

Article link: Wallabies begin journey of the underdog. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Live stream of Baa Baas game one for the purists

gatesy — Tue, 08 Jun 2010 15:25:49 +0000

I loved the live stream of the Barbarians game on Fox. What a great way to watch rugby. No commentators, no instant replays, no going upstairs to the video ref – it was just like being there (TV stations, take note). The only off-putting thing was that Facebook panel on the right. Some of the [...]

Article link: Live stream of Baa Baas game one for the purists. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

How the Brumbies can win the Super 14

gatesy — Sun, 02 May 2010 20:51:58 +0000

With two rounds left in this year’s Super 14, and following on from the Brumbies’ impressive victory over the in-form Reds, I thought it would be worthwhile analysing exactly what needs to happen for the Brumbies to make the finals. For those who might be interested, here’s how the Brumbies can/will claim the Super 14 [...]

Article link: How the Brumbies can win the Super 14. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Brumbies play Super disgracefully again

gatesy — Fri, 16 Apr 2010 15:01:23 +0000

I have just watched one of the worst rugby games of the professional era – the Brumbies versus Hurricanes. What a load of rubbish! When you have a team that: * has the best players (on paper) * has had a run of home games – no travel excuses * where the forwards have scored [...]

Article link: Brumbies play Super disgracefully again. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Super 15 just a smokescreen for Wallaby woes

gatesy — Wed, 02 Sep 2009 18:45:49 +0000

The Super 15 sideshow is just a diversionary tactic to take the heat off the fact that the Wallabies are not winning. Let’s assume: 1. Robbie Deans has the full support of the ARU on the basis of the Business Plan that he has presented to them (we don’t know what it was, but we [...]

Article link: Super 15 just a smokescreen for Wallaby woes. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Three simple facts say Australian rugby is on the up

gatesy — Tue, 18 Aug 2009 14:43:21 +0000

Three seemingly unrelated events have occurred recently. You might find this fanciful, but when I connect the dots, it becomes interesting. First, the most apparently insignificant of the three, at first glance at least, was that the final of the Australian Schoolboys Championships was played recently between Queensland (nothing unusual there) and Combined States! Not [...]

Article link: Three simple facts say Australian rugby is on the up. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Lote, what happened mate?!

gatesy — Thu, 02 Jul 2009 15:01:15 +0000

Tahs Lote Tuqiri salutes after scoring - AAP Image/NZPA, Ross Setford

I don’t think that Lote is necessarily in the top four wingers, so it might be right that he didn’t make the squad. But that said, there are some very interesting issues at play here.

The development of rugby in America

gatesy — Fri, 06 Feb 2009 16:37:03 +0000

I’ve been having a bit of correspondence with Kurt Oeler of gainline.us in the last couple of days about the development of Rugby in America, since a couple of interesting posts popped up on the web in the last few days. Here is the thread:- John Gates wrote: Hi, Kurt, I haven’t spoken to you [...]

Article link: The development of rugby in America. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Rugby media serve up same nonsense

gatesy — Tue, 27 Jan 2009 16:04:32 +0000

Here we are again, about to enter into a new season. The journos are all refreshed and ready to get into it, after a long summer layoff, where we were served up the usual rubbish. Do they think that the rugby fraternity is made up of idiots? In this, my comments do not include anything [...]

Article link: Rugby media serve up same nonsense. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Burgess is good, but Gregan was better

gatesy — Thu, 19 Jun 2008 18:00:26 +0000

Why is everyone suddenly down on George Gregan? Luke Burgess has come along and suddenly we’re all comparing the two of them. Yes, I will agree that if Gregan and Burgess both started the same year, then Burgess may well have gotten the nod. But they are from two different eras. Luke Burgess is potentially [...]

Article link: Burgess is good, but Gregan was better. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

The Northern Hemisphere is lazy when it comes to ELVs

gatesy — Fri, 25 Apr 2008 15:36:44 +0000

Here’s a theory. Why does the Northern Hemisphere seem hell bent on opposing the ELV’s without even trying them? I think it is just sheer laziness, and an in-grained dislike of trying anything new. In the South we take the view that you can have change for the sake of change, and you can have [...]

Article link: The Northern Hemisphere is lazy when it comes to ELVs. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Where to from here? – how to restructure Australian rugby

gatesy — Sun, 18 Nov 2007 21:08:58 +0000

It seems ludicrous to me that on one hand we are saying “where are all the big props going to come from?” while on the other hand virtually ignoring the potential for expansion of the game if we can’t get away from that private school thinking, and develop the clubs as regions in their own [...]

Article link: Where to from here? – how to restructure Australian rugby. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

ARC: not a bad start

gatesy — Tue, 31 Jul 2007 01:49:19 +0000

Gatesy writes: I read my first anti-ARC article this morning, so it’s started. When are the Sydney clubs going to realise that the landscape has shifted? If people want to de-stabilse the competition, before it even kicks off, then how do we progress? Maybe the format is not right but someone had to do something [...]

Article link: ARC: not a bad start. Written by gatesy, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion