The Roar » johnhunt92

Is Heath Shaw the right leader for Collingwood?

johnhunt92 — Tue, 07 Feb 2012 16:18:27 +0000

Heath Shaw is a very good footballer who is vital to the success of the Collingwood Magpies. But is he a footballer with the right leadership credentials?

Last week saw Melbourne, Collingwood and North Melbourne announced their leadership groups with each causing intrigue.

North Melbourne replaced stalwart Brent Harvey with the engine of the Kangaroos midfield, Andrew Swallow. This is a good move as it gives Harvey time to enjoy the twilight of his career while giving the captaincy to someone who embodies the Roos spirit.

Melbourne went back to the future after it dumped Brad Green for the combination of Jack Trengove and Jack Grimes (Trengove is the youngest captain in AFL/VFL history).

But the most intrigue came from Collingwood and the formation of its leadership group. While Nick Maxwell remains captain, the inclusion of Shaw is one that has raised eyebrows.

There is no denying that based on his on-field performances, Shaw is an example for young footballers. But his record off the field is far from exemplary.

In 2008, he and Alan Didak lied about the events of a car crash which resulted in him being suspended and nearly sacked by Collingwood.

Last year, he was suspended for eight matches and fined $20,000 for betting on teammate Maxwell to kick the first goal.

While I understand players are human, Shaw’s two indirections are essentially the foundations of sporting cardinal sins.

Shaw, lucky to still be at Collingwood after the car crash then betting scandal, now has a place in the leadership group.

If I was a Collingwood player, I would have serious doubts in his ability to be role model to teammates. How can someone who has committed grievous wrongs, lead the players by example?

Players at other clubs have committed lesser sins and been dropped from leadership group.

Shaw, however, seems to be given a lenient penance despite betraying the trust of Collingwood twice.

In Shaw’s defence, players who have committed similar offences have gone on to command leadership positions.

Simon Goodwin was the Crows captain when he got caught betting on AFL games a few years ago and despite being fined, he kept the captaincy.

Also, other industries are full of constant stories of individuals who despite committing serious offences in their professions rebound to head other corporations.

But does this make it right?

No longer are club leaders picked based just on the players and coaches whims. Sponsorship and PR are now also influential in any clubs decision on who should be the face of the values of a club.

Do Collingwood fans and sponsors feel easy about someone like Shaw, being placed in a position as the face of the club?

Collingwood have to hope that nothing untoward happens on the part of Shaw.

He will be under increased scrutiny as both players and coaches have invested a lot of faith and influential equity in his leadership credentials.

To rehash an old cliché, only time will tell.

Roaring Hot

Yesterday’s most commented articles

The real story of how John O’Neill turned Manchester City down [67 comments]
Australian teams at Super disadvantage [58 comments]
Does the A-League need an injection of humour? [43 comments]

Most read articles last 3 days

Article link: Is Heath Shaw the right leader for Collingwood?. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Australian cricket and tennis both have exciting times ahead

johnhunt92 — Sat, 04 Feb 2012 16:55:58 +0000

Give or take a few one-day cricket matches and a Davis Cup tie, the summer sports of tennis and cricket have come to an end. Compared to last summer, I am guessing most fans of these sports will have hope in their hearts. To understand this summer of sport, we have to take a trip [...]

Article link: Australian cricket and tennis both have exciting times ahead. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Andy Murray must get ruthless to win Grand Slams

johnhunt92 — Sat, 28 Jan 2012 18:14:40 +0000

There is an episode of American comedy show ‘How I met you Mother’ where Marshall, who wishes to jump from his dreary apartment roof to the fancy roof 100m away, cannot make the jump because his mentality is holding him back. The premise of the episode is a perfect analogy to explain Andy Murray’s tennis [...]

Article link: Andy Murray must get ruthless to win Grand Slams. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Australia a melting pot of football cultures

johnhunt92 — Mon, 23 Jan 2012 18:44:18 +0000

Our football culture has been a hot topic over the last week. Whether you are a Spanish passing nut or in favour of the British long ball, your chosen style of football has come under the microscope. It all started with a little ditty from Craig Foster, who questioned the coaching credentials of the new [...]

Article link: Australia a melting pot of football cultures. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Is Sam Stosur mentally weak?

johnhunt92 — Tue, 17 Jan 2012 17:10:41 +0000

Day one of the Australian Open showed us the mental fortitude of one Aussie under enormous pressure, resulting in a famous victory. Day two, unfortunately, has left us questioning the mental fortitude of another great Aussie player. Yesterday, Sam Stosur, the sixth women’s seed at the Australian Open, lost her first round match to world [...]

Article link: Is Sam Stosur mentally weak?. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Friday night showed how Australian football needs to be played

johnhunt92 — Sun, 15 Jan 2012 20:32:47 +0000

For those who watched the A-League match between Melbourne Victory and Adelaide United on Friday night, something was different about the game. It was subtle but an important change in the way the game should be played to best develop our players. Watching the first half especially, it was amazing to see the pace at [...]

Article link: Friday night showed how Australian football needs to be played. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Why Australia needs Ed Cowan

johnhunt92 — Sun, 01 Jan 2012 19:40:58 +0000

In watching Australia’s performance against India, I saw that Australia’s most important player for the next five years was one who was playing his first test. Ed Cowan is a rock that Australia can build its house on, the perfect partner to a player like David Warner, Phillip Hughes, or Shane Watson. He is a [...]

Article link: Why Australia needs Ed Cowan. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

State passion trumps fake Big Trash League

johnhunt92 — Thu, 22 Dec 2011 17:28:20 +0000

A few games into the Big Bash League and Cricket Australia will be wondering where they have gone wrong. It seems people aren’t flocking to the revamped league. While they will ponder, the answer comes from a fatal error of judgment. Australian sport fans don’t like being taken for a ride and they respond by [...]

Article link: State passion trumps fake Big Trash League. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Sheffield Shield shunted to the sidelines

johnhunt92 — Tue, 13 Dec 2011 19:33:22 +0000

The melancholy that is our system of cricket showed how broken down it is with the loss to New Zealand. While you may be inclined to think that is the worst of it, the biggest current issue lurks quietly in the dark, hidden by the pomp of the Big Bash League. From now until the [...]

Article link: Sheffield Shield shunted to the sidelines. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

When and where will Australia next host Olympics?

johnhunt92 — Fri, 09 Dec 2011 20:13:17 +0000

Melbourne 1956 and Sydney 2000 are the two times the world’s biggest sporting event has visited our shores. It is likely that we will see the games return to Australia, but where and when should we enter the bidding fray? The AOC has signalled since the 2008 Beijing Games that it will one day try [...]

Article link: When and where will Australia next host Olympics?. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

The Goodship Baggy Green needs stability

johnhunt92 — Tue, 22 Nov 2011 22:08:05 +0000

The question being asked from the Lodge to the Simpson Desert: what is the direction of the Australian Cricket Team? Despite the test win in South Africa, the rudder has come well off the Good Ship Baggy Green. Embarrassing collapses, poor bowling and just a general lack of confidence has Australia heading towards looking like [...]

Article link: The Goodship Baggy Green needs stability. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Moving days ahead for golf

johnhunt92 — Sat, 19 Nov 2011 17:15:44 +0000

For the first time in well over a decade, golf has a swagger about it in Australia. The golfing world has had its collective eyes on Sydney and Melbourne in the last fortnight and Australia’s golf administrators have to seize the momentum. This week has given golf in this country, a chance for the sport [...]

Article link: Moving days ahead for golf. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Where has the Adelaide United flair gone?

johnhunt92 — Tue, 15 Nov 2011 17:46:44 +0000

When Adelaide United began the season, it was full of excitement and there was hope for a soccer-mad town that over the last few years have experienced a lot of pain. Six games into the season, however, the wheels are looking quite shaky. There is no doubt that Adelaide coach Rini Coolen is trying to [...]

Article link: Where has the Adelaide United flair gone?. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

After hefty loss, Test cricket very much alive

johnhunt92 — Mon, 14 Nov 2011 18:24:10 +0000

In between the decay and despair of Australia’s loss to South Africa, something positive came out of the match. It may not bring any comfort to Clarke and co., but the match could be a pivotal moment in the future of Test cricket. Cutting through the decay that was Australia, what a great Test match [...]

Article link: After hefty loss, Test cricket very much alive. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

RWC semi finals sure to be classics

johnhunt92 — Thu, 13 Oct 2011 21:55:00 +0000

One win left for a shot at glory. This weekend sees four teams in France, Wales, Australia and New Zealand clash for a place in the Rugby World Cup final and the matches should be beauties. These matches are also interesting for the composition of opponents. Three teams have lost a match and finished second [...]

Article link: RWC semi finals sure to be classics. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Caulfield Guineas Day review

johnhunt92 — Sun, 09 Oct 2011 20:24:57 +0000

Superlatives aside, Caulfield Guineas day was a fantastic race meet. Champions continued their quest for glory, new stars were born and the markets were changed for the next two big races. Despite three Group 1s, the feature race seemed to be the Group 2 Schilliaci Stakes where the Black Caviar juggernaut rolled on for a [...]

Article link: Caulfield Guineas Day review. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

RWC quarters leave us frothing for semi finals

johnhunt92 — Sun, 09 Oct 2011 20:11:53 +0000

Thy cup ranneth over with glorious rugby over the weekend as the Rugby World Cup semi finalists were decided. All four games provided stories and intrigue and of course thrilling and impressive rugby. The first quarter final was probably the purest match of rugby over the weekend. Wales and Ireland both controlled the match at [...]

Article link: RWC quarters leave us frothing for semi finals. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Caulfield Guineas Day preview

johnhunt92 — Fri, 07 Oct 2011 22:41:43 +0000

Caulfield Guineas day is when the Spring action really heats up. With three Group Ones and a Group Two event that could see history made, this is a going to be a classic opening day of the Spring Carnival. Today, I am going to preview the Schillaci Stakes (G2, 1400m), Caulfield Stakes (G1, 2000m), Toorak [...]

Article link: Caulfield Guineas Day preview. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

It’s just not right to include New Zealand

johnhunt92 — Wed, 05 Oct 2011 19:04:59 +0000

Manly Sea Eagles Brett Stewart celebrates their win in the NRL Grand Final at ANZ Stadium in Sydney, Sunday, Oct. 2, 2011. Manly defeated the Warriors 24 - 10. (AAP Image/Dean Lewins)

Alright, I am not a fan of the code wars. In fact, I openly detest the wars that happen on the blogosphere. However, I cannot stand by while I read putrid rubbish coming out of Sydney’s NRL heartland.

Race to Bill heats up this weekend

johnhunt92 — Mon, 03 Oct 2011 17:26:19 +0000

40 wonderful games down and eight cracking games to come in the race to take ‘Bill’ home. This is how the Rugby World Cup is set up for the next three weeks and this weekend sees four massive quarter-finals. While the pool stage was very close, it’s now down to real business in the tournament [...]

Article link: Race to Bill heats up this weekend. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Channel Ten’s contribution to the AFL underestimated

johnhunt92 — Fri, 30 Sep 2011 18:02:21 +0000

10 years ago, the 2001 AFL Grand Final was tinged with the emotion of Channel Seven exiting the footy telecasting business. It was marked with a lot of publicity in the lead up to the Grand Final (it was almost bigger than the match). 10 years on, we are in a similar position that is [...]

Article link: Channel Ten’s contribution to the AFL underestimated. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

So much on offer in 2011 AFL Grand Final

johnhunt92 — Tue, 27 Sep 2011 17:18:29 +0000

Collingwood celebrates on the dais during the 2010 Toyota AFL Grand Final replay between the Collingwood Magpies and the St Kilda Saints at the MCG, Melbourne.

It’ll either be damn close or a massive blowout in the 2011 AFL Grand Final between Collingwood and Geelong. Whatever the result, this decider will be the most intriguing finale in a while.

Tennis Australia served a double fault

johnhunt92 — Mon, 19 Sep 2011 20:52:38 +0000

The Davis Cup tie over the weekend between Lleyton Hewitt and Stanislas Warwinka was a tense classic that included a spray from the generally calm Pat Rafter over the issue of light. While Rafter can scorn match referees over the lack of light, the source of the problem is much closer to home. While I [...]

Article link: Tennis Australia served a double fault. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Three observations from the Fremantle coaching saga

johnhunt92 — Sun, 18 Sep 2011 21:30:27 +0000

Not since Malcolm Blight’s axing as St Kilda coach has there been a bigger coaching shock in Australian Rules Football than Ross Lyon’s move to Fremantle. The rapidness of the coup by Fremantle management would rival Julia Gillard’s move into the Prime Minister’s job. In watching this unfold and analysing the situation three aspects have [...]

Article link: Three observations from the Fremantle coaching saga. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

AFL log-jam in the hunt for September

johnhunt92 — Thu, 25 Aug 2011 17:34:07 +0000

Five teams are in the hunt for the AFL finals, three positions are left. Based on the rules of maths five cannot fit into three positions, meaning two miss out. Get ready for a nerve-racking sprint to the finish as the final eight is shaped in the final two rounds. As stated, there are five [...]

Article link: AFL log-jam in the hunt for September. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Port Adelaide all at sea, needing a lifeboat

johnhunt92 — Wed, 17 Aug 2011 19:50:46 +0000

The ironic thing about season 2011 for Port Adelaide is that it is the first season of the ‘One PAFC’ merger of the SANFL Magpie team and AFL Power side. Ironic because Port Adelaide Football Club is far from united. This is beyond an annus horriblis for the Power. 2011 has been a watershed for [...]

Article link: Port Adelaide all at sea, needing a lifeboat. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Rothfield and Gould, give it a rest

johnhunt92 — Thu, 11 Aug 2011 22:06:02 +0000

Phil Rothfield writes an article that makes Phil Gould look like a buffoon, Phil Gould scolds the Daily Telegraph and the NRL for writing it or being complicit in its construction, and Phil Rothfield returns fire through his newspaper. It’s a cyclical war of words in the Sydney NRL scene and I’m sick of it. [...]

Article link: Rothfield and Gould, give it a rest. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Yes to AFL State of Origin, but questions still remain

johnhunt92 — Sun, 07 Aug 2011 21:52:28 +0000

In a week which the AFL would rather forget, it was encouraging to hear that the players, AFL and club CEO’s are supportive of a return to State of Origin football from 2013. While I am a great supporter of the return of state football the big question is, how can State of Origin football [...]

Article link: Yes to AFL State of Origin, but questions still remain. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Demons’ shame over Bailey sacking

johnhunt92 — Mon, 01 Aug 2011 15:46:42 +0000

While the Melbourne Football Club’s 186-point loss to Geelong was disgraceful, what was more sickening was how Dean Bailey was treated, with Demons’ management axing the coach as it looks toward the future. Dean Bailey paid the ultimate price for his players’ woeful attitude on Saturday afternoon and the board, led by club legend Jim [...]

Article link: Demons’ shame over Bailey sacking. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Neil Craig made the right call

johnhunt92 — Mon, 25 Jul 2011 21:50:57 +0000

Neil Craig, the coach of the Adelaide Crows finally stepped down today after two years of absolute torture for Crows fans. Especially torturous for Crows fans was last weeks match against St Kilda. The game saw the Crows put up the lowest ever score in Adelaide’s 20 year history. The call for Craig’s sacking was [...]

Article link: Neil Craig made the right call. Written by johnhunt92, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion