The Roar
The Roar

Percycutor

Roar Pro

Joined June 2017

13.9k

Views

18

Published

57

Comments

NZ based. 44 years old, started reading the League Week when I was 8. Loved how that magazine presented the game.

Published

Comments

Agreed Abbot! What form Drinkwater has been in though! Outstanding. But Surely with Leniu not in the 17 he would have been the nominated player for the HIA replacement etc. It sure is another baffling call no doubt. Good luck Blues fans, all the best to Qld fans, what a game we are in for!

NSW way out of touch as whitewash beckons

Forty Twenty, yes it is a critical article/opinion piece.

NSW way out of touch as whitewash beckons

Same game. Next game it’s back to a new 80mins, whitewashes are rare as are large scoring comebacks in Origin since 1980.

NSW way out of touch as whitewash beckons

The context was the margin was approximately four converted tries between the sides, this is not “not far away.”
As described, nothing was mentioned of Fittler’s desire or non-desire to chase those points. I’m not sure how many Origins you have watched out of the 120+ matches but I think historically, chasing down four converted tries at Origin level, as stated is a very very rare occurrence. Most readers would see how this writer presented Fittler’s analogy and some, mostly informed followers of the game know all too well to be behind 26 points is almost impossible to chase down at the highest level of rugby league that Origin is. Not impossible but that’s only my opinion, but the margin of Game 2 was certainly not “not far away.”

NSW way out of touch as whitewash beckons

Informed opinions are always healthy.

Is Brad Fittler the reason for New South Wales' Blues?

Talakai a good case in point ????

Is Brad Fittler the reason for New South Wales' Blues?

Very good read Mike, two ‘references’ Sheens has used that disappoint me adding to your piece, was firstly pre-Xmas stating Brooks is our half back and doesn’t deserve the criticism. This came off as ignorant, also a much more defiant statement within the past fortnight that Adam is the tigers best fullback in the club. If Sheens is not a fan of Dane Laurie, he doesn’t have to say as much after making this moronic statement. Laurie was one of the tigers best last year, and could have benefitted greatly by this new ‘coaching super-group.’
He’s on the outer. As is there other best performing and longest serving playing David Nofoaluma. Does look like this is year 1 of at least a five year plan, this current squad would be bottom of the table in any Reserve grade competition in the 90s, 2000s etc. But I wish them well and hope they can improve.

ANALYSIS: The Tigers are a rabble, Doueihi is not a fullback and the Broncos are a serious threat

Well you took us on a journey there. 100% agree, good read!

Ian Foster is an ethical, likeable guy but his indecision casts a shadow on the darkness

It’s ok, Foster is “not panicking, I don’t know what anyone else is doing”
No humility, no idea.

All Blacks squad for Springboks series suggests Foster is about to make the same mistakes all over again

Has the Ruck speed average for both sides been made available anywhere?

Origin boilover: Fittler fuming over slow ruck as Slater inspires Maroons to upset over shellshocked Blues

He has also become a lot more humble and has evolved as a player. Looks a lot fitter the past few seasons than he was during his Broncos days also. Great fit for Bennett and the Bunnies and off the bench will continue to be a great foil for Mitchell and Walker.

Benji Marshall may join NRL greats in rare feat

He’s had his ups and downs that’s for sure, and has experienced plenty. Has won big games has starred in big games.. Souths look certainties for a top 4 spot and from there anything can happen. If they were to make the GF I’m sure Wayne wouldn’t do what Tim Sheens done to Kevin Walters for Canberra in 1989 and leave him on the sideline itching to get on !!! Thanks Paul appreciate your comment.

Benji Marshall may join NRL greats in rare feat

I can’t agree but wish you and the Knights well. Something not quite right with the balance of the squad and despite top 8 success last year, the coach does seem a little unpredictably volatile! I’m going to predict 10 or 11 wins, which won’t be enough to see semi-final action this season.

Are the Newcastle Knights a top-four side? Damn right!

Will be very interesting if Papalii and Munster are unavailable. If they can play (and there are no other injuries) I reckon this series (just like every other) is going to be a bit closer than most believe.

Is this the worst Queensland Maroons team in history?

Our opinion is it’s good that he did. Their are similarities to when Andrew McFadden took over the team. That produced mediocre results. No doubting Payten has shown potential but the club is crying out for an experienced NRL coach (and more Australian players). Having cast aside Toovey, if Green turns down the expected offer, it could be Griffin for 1 year and maybe Bennett in 2022. Bennett said he has no interest for 2021, fair enough but he will have more than $1 million reasons to shift to Auckland after that..

Warriors find winning recipe

100% the roster needs to be ripped to shreds but their is a base of personnel that gives some optimism for next season. BUT at least three if not more quality signings are required. The Warriors are meant to have the best recruitment agent in the game !!! Where is he!!

Warriors find winning recipe

Same scenario all clubs face! Cheers Peeeko

Kearney has the Warriors heading in the right direction

Well detailed Albo, 100% agree.

Kearney has the Warriors heading in the right direction

Poor % so far, but he’s less than 100 games in (and head coach of two very challenging clubs on his CV). Easy to be critical of him before this season at NRL level, but he seems to be in a great spot now, he has made significant changes on and off the field at the Warriors and they are performing better as a result. With the natural addition of new signings they are certainly on the up. Great achievement to make the 8 this season but they should be challenging closer to the top of the competition from next year onwards. As they say, they just have to close the gap between their best performance and their worst. Cheers FT

Kearney has the Warriors heading in the right direction

Whare

Maguire must move on from Mannering

Mannering is leaning towards retiring from all Rugby League at the end of this season.

Maguire must move on from Mannering

The author knows the many minutes and heavy defensive workload that Mannering has had for more than a decade has caught up with him. In a case by case basis yes 31 is not too old to continue. ‘Mannering’s international career is nearing the end’ that’s what I stated. It has to be mentioned because Maguire is set to overlook him, despite the KIWI great being available. The article wasn’t stating Mannering is too old.

Maguire must move on from Mannering

Rory I’m NZ based. Maguire is between countries and has stated he intends to look after the grassroots of NZRL but is also open to an NRL coaching gig ‘when the right opportunity arises’. What that does to his KIWIS position who knows.

Maguire must move on from Mannering

Title should read “Maguire to move on from Mannering.”

Maguire must move on from Mannering

Tough competition for 26 rounds Jacko. It was more designed to point out probably more to NZ Warriors fans the toughness of the competition. In NZ a lot of people don’t understand just how much of a high level of Rugby League the Premiership is. But thanks for your comment.

A big couple of months for resurgent Warriors

close