The Roar » simonjzw

Setting the scene for an epic clash

simonjzw — Mon, 20 Sep 2010 16:11:00 +0000

Collingwood will go into the 2010 AFL Grand Final as deserved favourites – they finished on top of the ladder, their form during the finals series has been excellent, and they have very few injury worries.

However, students of AFL form and statistics will recognise the current bookmaker odds don’t reflect the true probabilities of the outcome.

I rate Collingwood a 53.5 per cent chance to win with St.Kilda’s probability sitting at 45.5 per cent (and a 1 per cent chance of a draw).

Therefore the true odds for the match are Collingwood – $1.87 and St.Kilda – $2.20.

Of course the bookies consider more than just the probabilities when setting a book (they also have to factor in where the weight of money will come from and set odds that will deliver a “balanced” book”). This means there’s often value for the canny form analyst. The value bet this week is St Kilda and that’s where a little bit of my hard earned will be going (not that value bets always win, mind you).

It promises to be a fascinating match.

This year Collingwood has taken a leaf out of the 2009 St Kilda play book and employed crushing defensive pressure all over the ground. They spread well from the contest and move the ball quickly forward around the flanks. They have a wonderful midfield with the right blend of hardness, pace, youth and experience and depth.

Collingwood’s tall forwards look suspect on paper but they’ve stood up all year.

St Kilda has a similar game style based on defensive pressure (although it hasn’t been quite as effective as last year), but they use the centre corridor to move ball forward a bit more than Collingwood. St Kilda’s midfield is also a quality unit that is battle hardened. It may lack the pace and depth of Collingwood, but it has more experience.

On paper St Kilda’s defence looks suspect but like the Collingwood tall forwards they’ve stood up all year.

The match committees of both teams will have much to think about all week.

Each team has an outstanding player that is just about unstoppable. For Collingwood it’s Dane Swan and for St Kilda it’s Nick Riewoldt. Who to play on them?

For mine, St Kilda’s number one tagger Clint Jones gets the job on Swan and runs on and off the field with him. His aerobic motor and pace are underestimated.

On the flip side, if he’s fit, Prestagiacomo comes into the team and plays on Koschitzke. This allows Collingwood to rotate Reid and Brown on Riewoldt and Maxwell can float across the backline in support.

Whoever plays on them, expect Swan and Riewoldt to have big influences on the game.

In other key match ups, don’t be surprised to see Baker brought into the St Kilda team to play on Didak because there’s no obvious match up for Didak in last week’s St Kilda 22.

Does that open the door for Leon Davis to be selected and stretch St Kilda’s ability to cover quick, clever small forwards?

I’m tipping Lenny Hayes and Luke Ball to go head to head in a fascinating midfield/clearance duel between former team mates.

One advantage St Kilda does have is the depth of it’s ruck brigade. McEvoy is better than whoever Collingwood will use to give Jolly a rest. Does that mean Josh Fraser comes under selection consideration?

It promises to be a great game, with many sub plots to salivate over between now and 5:30pm on Saturday.

Bring it on!

Roaring Hot

Yesterday’s most commented articles

The real story of how John O’Neill turned Manchester City down [67 comments]
Australian teams at Super disadvantage [58 comments]
Does the A-League need an injection of humour? [43 comments]

Most read articles last 3 days

Article link: Setting the scene for an epic clash. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Is it time to re-think the Olympics?

simonjzw — Fri, 10 Sep 2010 15:34:14 +0000

I realise I run the risk of bringing the ire of the entire Roar community down upon me, but I really think the Olympics, in its current format, has had its day. I’m sick of the IOC having such a powerful say in the operation of sport and becoming rich off TV broadcasting deals. I’m [...]

Article link: Is it time to re-think the Olympics?. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Why not introduce a 5 Minute Power Play?

simonjzw — Tue, 27 Jul 2010 15:23:47 +0000

Let me preface this article by saying upfront that rugby isn’t my number one football code and I had very little exposure to the sport when I was growing up. However, I’ve been living in Sydney for sixteen years now and I’ve developed an appreciation for both League and Union. I follow the fortunes of [...]

Article link: Why not introduce a 5 Minute Power Play?. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Socceroos’ showing raises questions

simonjzw — Tue, 15 Jun 2010 14:43:50 +0000

The Socceroos lamentable performance against Germany has raised some serious questions about our national team and our high performance development plans. I know it’s not wise to pass judgements based on one bad game but on the back of a plucky performance in the last World Cup, are we actually just deluding ourselves? Maybe our [...]

Article link: Socceroos’ showing raises questions. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

NAB Cup hints St Kilda may struggle this year

simonjzw — Mon, 15 Mar 2010 14:54:12 +0000

Admittedly it’s only the pre-season, but any objective analysis raises some serious question marks over St.Kilda this year. They haven’t played well in any NAB Cup game. They scraped home by a point in two matches they could easily have lost (and would have been beaten by the Swans if not for Seaby’s brain fade) [...]

Article link: NAB Cup hints St Kilda may struggle this year. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

There will not be a code war in Western Sydney

simonjzw — Tue, 10 Nov 2009 16:40:58 +0000

There’s been a lot of conjecture about whether or not the Western Sydney AFL team will be successful and even more about the ignition of a “war” between the NRL and the AFL now Kevin Sheedy has been appointed. It all makes good press and it keeps both codes on the back pages during the [...]

Article link: There will not be a code war in Western Sydney. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Will football overtake other Australian codes?

simonjzw — Wed, 28 Oct 2009 15:35:36 +0000

Whilst I applaud the passion and fervour with which football fans follow their sport, I’m always bewildered by their assertions that the sport is going to overtake the other football codes in Australia. There is absolutely no evidence to suggest this will ever happen. Not only does football have to become much more popular than [...]

Article link: Will football overtake other Australian codes?. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Protecting the integrity of the game

simonjzw — Mon, 31 Aug 2009 15:04:00 +0000

Jason Blake and Colm Begley of St KIlda collide with Grant Birchall of Hawthorn during the AFL Round 19 match between the Hawthorn Hawks and the St Kilda Saints at Aurora Stadium. Slattery Images

We’re entering an era of exponential growth in football betting. Internet and mobile phone technology have made it easy to access on shore and off shore betting companies.

Judd picked ahead of Ablett in dream team

simonjzw — Wed, 26 Aug 2009 16:04:18 +0000

Clearly the two best fielders in the game at the moment are Gary Ablett and Chris Judd. Gary Ablett is a magnificent player and I love watching him play. He’s fast, skilful, beautifully balanced, reads the play well, is nearly impossible to tackle and he handles the ball at top pace as well as anyone [...]

Article link: Judd picked ahead of Ablett in dream team. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Don’t despair, Australian cricket isn’t that bad

simonjzw — Tue, 25 Aug 2009 15:48:05 +0000

With the loss of the Ashes, we’re seeing the usual and expected recriminations and calling for heads to roll. Sells a few papers, but does it offer any substance? Really, it’s not as if we were flogged in England. Actually the series was quite close. I hated losing the Ashes and it hurts me to [...]

Article link: Don’t despair, Australian cricket isn’t that bad. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion

Resting players is just flirting with form

simonjzw — Mon, 17 Aug 2009 15:12:57 +0000

Most media commentators believe Geelong and St. Kilda have been smart to give key players some time off in the lead up to the finals. But is there any evidence to support this idea? It’s difficult to recall any premiers in the last 20 years who have used this policy to advantage. In fact, Malcolm [...]

Article link: Resting players is just flirting with form. Written by simonjzw, on The Roar - Your Sports Opinion