I agree Soap. Forgive but don't forget. Cooper is a prime example. He seems to be doing ok nowadays.
However I do not think JOC has done his time. It's less than a year. Why trust him with Cooper again when together (with Beale) they disrupted a number of teams. The Reds have enough trouble without the risk of JOC adding to it.
when his pack is going forward great but when not - rubbish
cooper is rubbish unfortunately