In memory of rugby at Sydney Boys High School

Spiro Zavos Columnist

101 Have your say

Popular article! 18,873 reads

    Related coverage

    Sydney High Rugby 2003. Photo from the High Rugby Friends website

    On a sunny winter afternoon some twenty years ago, I was standing at the gates of the venerable main buildings of Sydney Boys High School, chatting with Tony Hannon, the knowledgeable and intense English teacher and long-time coach of the school’s First XV.

    A tiny Vietnamese boy carrying a violin case eased his way past us.

    “Look at that lad,” Hannon said in mock-outrage. “I’m expected to create First XVs from boys like that.”

    He was joking, and we both had a good laugh because it was a good joke. And like all good jokes it was grounded in real life.

    The fact was that, more and more, Asian kids were moving into Sydney Boys High, and rightly so as they had the academic qualifications and potential to make the most of their education at the selective high school.

    Unfortunately, though, most of these boys were far too small for rugby, even if they were interested in playing the rough game, which they weren’t.

    It was a logical ending of a sorts from the Vietnamese lad to the announcement on 24 August, 2007 by the SBHS Headmaster Dr K.A. Jaggar that he was withdrawing the SBHS First and Second XVs from the GPS competition, with the intention of seeking “more competitive’ fixtures.”

    “Depending on the strength of our First XV,” the statement continued, “it may play more than one GPS fixture at first grade level next year.”

    For all practical purposes, then, the sight of the High boys in the blue and brown stripes playing out their hearts at Mackay Oval and the other GPS venues, and generally losing more games than they won, is now relegated to the sepia-recesses of the collective memories of those who played over the years and those of us, parents, family members and old boys, who loved to watch the teams go round in one of the oldest schoolboys tournaments in world sport.

    Wikipedia has a list (unfortunately one that needs updating) of sports stars who have come out of Sydney Boys High School.

    In the rugby category, there are some recognisable names: John Brass, Phil Smith (his partner at SBHS and in the Wallabies, who is not on the list), Bob Dywer, Alan Gaffney, Peter Johnson, Jason Jones-Hughes (a centre for Australia and Wales), Duncan McRae, Marc Stcherbina, John Thornett (one of the greatest Wallabies), Chris Whitaker, Jamie Holbrook (not on the list) and Craig Wing.

    Those players on the list who were at SBHS in the last twenty years were all products of Tony Hannon’s inspired and generous coaching.

    And the mark of all of them? They were all backs, which was a consequence of clever coaching and the fact that they played behind beaten packs.

    As a result, they were resilient and intent on doing something with the ball when they had it in their hand.

    I remember being on the sideline with coach Hannon when High were playing The Kings School. Kings took an up-an-under penalty. The captain, before booting the ball high into the air and chasing after it enthusiastically, shouted out to his team mates: “Watch McRae’s side step!”

    The steepling kick was safely caught by McRae.

    The captain hurtled forward to knock him over. At the last moment, like a matador evading a charging bull, McRae deftly faked to move right and moved silkily to his left. And the captain charged on past him as McRae ran up the field to set up a strong counter-attack.

    Then there was the time when High went to the fabled fields of St Joseph’s College Hunter’s Hill. The Joeys First XV put on an awesome display to defeat our boys (with Matt Burke leading the way) by 76-0.

    After it was all over, and amid the small boys in their blue blazers running around excitedly, I said in awe to one of my sons, “We were lucky to get 0.”

    One other memory is of a bitterly cold day with Sydney Grammar playing High. A wiry, good-looking player at first five-eights absolutely carved up the Grammar defence and virtually won the game on his own.

    Time after time he burst through a strong defensive line to set up attacks and tries.

    After the match Tony Hannon said to me about Craig Wing, with the pride of an old coach who has seen great talent come and go in his time: “He’s the best kid I’ve ever coached.”

    So no more Craig Wings, no more John Thornett’s, no more the hundreds of Sydney kids who for over 100 years had that special thrill of pulling on the Sydney High School First XV jersey.

    When the writer John O’Hara heard of the death of his friend George Gershwin, he wrote to another friend, “George Gershwin died yesterday. But I don’t have to believe it if I don’t want to.”

    GPS rugby for Sydney Boys High School died this season but I don’t have to believe it if I don’t want to.

    This is part one of a two part essay by Spiro Zavos. Part two will look at what needs to happen with schoolboy rugby in NSW. Photo from the High Rugby Friends website

    Spiro Zavos
    Spiro Zavos

    Spiro Zavos, a founding writer on The Roar, was long time editorial writer on the Sydney Morning Herald, where he started a rugby column that has run for nearly 30 years. Spiro has written 12 books: fiction, biography, politics and histories of Australian, New Zealand, British and South African rugby. He is regarded as one of the foremost writers on rugby throughout the world.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (101)

    • September 5th 2008 @ 1:44am
      Steffy said | September 5th 2008 @ 1:44am | ! Report

      What a shame that there are kids who are too small to play the game for all shapes and sizes.

    • September 5th 2008 @ 3:10am
      mcxd said | September 5th 2008 @ 3:10am | ! Report

      Please change the record and remove that massive chip on your shoulder regarding Rugby you ever have any positive or even constructive critisism to comment on ?…Im sure Daily Telegraph has a league article or two for you to add your well thought out comments on.

    • September 5th 2008 @ 8:11am
      matta said | September 5th 2008 @ 8:11am | ! Report

      yeah it is a shame…

      Is Hight a bording school? surely they can get some funding for sport as well as academic students?

      • April 8th 2013 @ 1:59pm
        a sydney high student said | April 8th 2013 @ 1:59pm | ! Report

        No point making it a boarding school. The majority of the students wouldn’t pay to board, because if they had that kind of money they would be at a private school. We are disadvantaged for being an academic school, and we are also disadvantaged for being a public school.

        But we can still beat Grammar

    • September 5th 2008 @ 8:20am
      Recidivist said | September 5th 2008 @ 8:20am | ! Report

      The real shame is that the kids who were getting beaten by 110-nil last year and this year didn’t mind. They just enjoyed playing!!

      Is there a way we can have Steffy permanently removed from The Roar for persistently being stupid?

    • September 5th 2008 @ 8:32am
      Midfielder said | September 5th 2008 @ 8:32am | ! Report

      In not just Sydney Boys its all the selective schools are just hanging im, Epping Boys, North Sydney Boys, Normanhurst Boys, Then look at articles like the one by by Sebastian Hassett

      Much more in the article but just copied a liitle .

      Earlier in the week, Knox Grammar in Wahroonga played host to a match between the Central Coast Mariners and the New Zealand under-23 men’s team bound for the Beijing Olympics.

      Despite the Tuesday afternoon timeslot, the school community braved the cold in an unmistakable show of support for the world game.

      Knox’s headmaster, John Weeks, said the match was the culmination of the school’s insatiable desire for football.

      “In the past few years football has grown enormously, and amongst the CAS [Combined Associated Schools] and GPS [Great Public Schools] boys’ schools we’re finding that there are equal numbers of football and rugby teams, and in a number of the CAS schools, football teams are beginning to outnumber rugby teams,” Weeks told the Herald.

    • September 5th 2008 @ 8:50am
      True Tah said | September 5th 2008 @ 8:50am | ! Report


      North Sydney Boys has been struggling for many years as a rugby playing school, well before the A-League or the 2006 WC. Epping Boys Im not sure, they used to have a decent rugby program and go on tours overseas as well.

      Generally speaking Asian parents would rather their sons focus on academic achievements than sport, they represent a substantial part of the Australian population, yet are majorly under-represented in our professional sporting teams, whereas certain other ethnicities are over represented in codes, Aboriginals (AFL and NRL), Islanders (RU and RL) and Yugoslavs (futbol).

      It may be the same in the US as well, although I know that guys of Asian descent have played in the NFL and NHL.

      I guess if rugby is to continue at high schools, it needs to adapt to reflect this…having said this, we have had plenty of Asian blokes playing at our club…Im interested to see Part 2 of your article Spiro.

      The answer is a P & R system for the schools, they implemented this in Brisbane.

    , , , ,