The AFL fumbles the ball

John Bushby Roar Rookie

By John Bushby, John Bushby is a Roar Rookie

24 Have your say

    Barry Hall of Sydney look dejected after the AFL 2nd Semi Final between the Western Bulldogs and the Sydney Swans at the MCG. GSP Images

    My Irish mate Fitzy, as usual, met me in the pub on Friday night. With the continuing lack of success of his AFL team, he increasingly finds satisfaction in unrelenting criticism of the AFL. So it was another few hours of angry input from my mate that led me to wonder just how deep dissatisfaction runs amongst the true fans, as distinct from the pampered superbox crowd.

    The initial trigger was over the match draw for next season.

    Fitzy contended that not only had the AFL ruined his 2009 season before he had even renewed his membership, but apparently had the hide to admit that the draw favours the top sides of the 2008 season at the expense of the sides battling for success.

    The free to air TV rights have been allocated so that Fitzy’s mob can only be seen on cable, which he can’t afford.

    “What bloody future have we got? An irrelevant draft system designed to feed new teams and nobble my mob from attracting sponsors.”

    I reminded Fitzy that the AFL is in the entertainment business and has the need to maximize income.

    “What happened to the family game? All my family and I want is a fair go, and it isn’t happening.

    Under the current plan of expansion, it wouldn’t surprise to see Sarah Palin approached to become a footy mum and have Alaska play away matches in nearby Russia.”

    His difficulty in bringing his family to night matches at the MCG in the middle of a Melbourne winter, pay exorbitant food prices, and attempt to survive the unsafe train travel home were also emphasized in an angry voice.

    Having settled down over a couple of more beers, he then pondered as to whether his passion would continue as it has for 30 years.

    The relentless change in the rules and the use of the pre-season competition for testing sometimes-bizarre concepts clearly had him confused. He reckoned that the AFL couldn’t help themselves.

    Yearly rule changes are the norm.

    Just as I began to think we could have a quiet beer, the TV came on with the hybrid Australia V Ireland series.

    Fitzy quickly became animated and, much to my surprise, barracked with a fervour unseen since his team’s last win over the Adelaide Crows.

    The one point win cheered him immensely.

    “Isn’t that anti-Aussie, mate?,” I asked him.

    “No, anti-AFL, mate,” he answered, with a smile.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (24)

    • October 28th 2008 @ 9:46am
      Ken Guy said | October 28th 2008 @ 9:46am | ! Report

      I’m with Fitzy! Being a pensioner and a cancer patient, I can’t afford Foxtel either. However, I do have a good mate who takes me to the Gabba as he’s a member of the Gabba Trust, otherwise I couldn’t attend games at all. I ceased being a Lions member a few years back because of cost, even though I’m Foundation member No 75 of the club.

    • October 28th 2008 @ 11:58am
      Michael C said | October 28th 2008 @ 11:58am | ! Report

      The thing that get’s me is it’s only AFL folk who think that AFL folk have it bad and that the AFL isn’t serving them well.

    • Roar Guru

      October 28th 2008 @ 12:24pm
      Redb said | October 28th 2008 @ 12:24pm | ! Report

      The AFL is not the only sport that modifies its rules.

      rugby union currently has bottom half of the globe playing a different set of rules to top half re the ELVs.

      rugby league is ‘grappling’ with rules changes.

      soccah would, but its structure is so unwieldy they can’t agree, plus your relying on a bunch of Europeans to agree.


    • October 28th 2008 @ 12:53pm
      Savvas Tzionis said | October 28th 2008 @ 12:53pm | ! Report

      When I hear supporters bemoan the “ever-changing rules” I know that they have no idea.

      If the AFL had not fixed up the game this year regarding the interpretation of the rules, the downward slide of a once great game would have continued.

      The standard of football this year was the BEST since as far back as 1993.

      I NEVER want to see football played in the manner it was during the 2005 Grand Final between West Coast and Sydney.

      It was a blight on the game.

    • October 28th 2008 @ 1:08pm
      Lazza said | October 28th 2008 @ 1:08pm | ! Report


      For an AFL man you just can’t seem to stop talking about FOOTBALL. FIFA has 214 members, only 53 from Europe.

      Where’s the pressing need to make changes in Football? It has the biggest event in the World, the biggest league, the most nations, participants, TV Ratings, interest etc? Do you want it to become even bigger?

      Sports need to make changes when they’re a minority sport trying to expand or interest is waning.

    • Roar Guru

      October 28th 2008 @ 1:22pm
      Redb said | October 28th 2008 @ 1:22pm | ! Report


      I mentioned all codes, not just soccah.