Jamie Soward and Dean Young during the NRL, Round 4, Brisbane Broncos v St George Illawarra Dragons match at Suncorp Stadium in Brisbane, Friday April 3, 2009. Dragons won 25-12. (AAP Image/Action Photographics, Colin Whelan)
With finals in the two biggest sports in the land taking place, every weekend in September is filled with drama, excitement and tension. It’s the time of the year where legends and infamy are forged.
The question I want to look at today is if the pedigree of some clubs dictate their fortune? Is there DNA in the uniform which affects the outcome.
In the AFL, the top four consists of St Kilda, Geelong, Collingwood and the Western Bulldogs.
Between the four of them, you only have only two Premierships in the last 40 years.
On the flipside, the quartet share plenty of September heartache and tragedy.
Geelong has dominated the last three years and thus far only has one flag to show for their efforts. Should they not win this year, they will match the efforts of the Melbourne Storm who have appeared in the last three Grand Finals, but yet only won one.
Many thought the Cats had smashed the hoodoo when they annihilated Port in the 2007 Grand Final, but all the ghosts returned last year after the defeat to the Hawks.
Port may have won it all in 2004 but it should have done so it both in 2002 and 2003.
The biggest underachiever in the NRL would be St George.
Fifteen titles in 39 years between 1941 and 1979, but not a single one in the 30 years since.
It has lost four grand finals since then. More recently, it has lost preliminary finals in 2005 and 2006.
Apart from its purple patch in the early 1980s, you would have to say that Parramatta do not cut the mustard in September.
Their bitter rivals, the Sydney Bulldogs, seem to be the masters of September. Not that they win every year, but they always seem to make a splash when they are there.
In 1998, the Bulldogs finished ninth, which normally wouldn’t be good enough to make the finals except it was a ten team finals that year.
It defeated the Dragons and Bears before coming back from 16 points down against both the Knights and Eels. It ran out of gas in the Grand Final against the Broncos, but it had been an amazing effort just to get there.
The interesting thing with the Bulldogs is that, of the last six times it has won the Grand Final, only on one of those occasion (1984) was it the minor premier.
In 1980 and 2004 it defeated the top placed Roosters in the Grand Final; in 1985 it defeated top-placed St George; in 1988 it was sixth placed Balmain; and in 1995 it was the top placed Sea Eagles.
Someone has to win every year, but in the case of teams such as St Kilda, Western Bulldogs, Parramatta and St George, it seems to be anyone but them.
NRL September Underperformers: St George, Parramatta, North Sydney, Cronulla, Roosters, Any Bob Fulton-coached team
AFL September Underperformers: Geelong, St Kilda, Western Bulldogs, Port, North Melbourne (1994-20)NRL September Overperformers: Brisbane Broncos, Bulldogs,
AFL September Overperformers: Adelaide (1997-98), Sydney (2003-06), Hawthorn (1976-91), Brisbane Lions (2001-04),North Melbourne (1994-20)
JVGO
Guest
Cronulla and St George as a single entity won 11 straight premierships until they were spit in 67. Both clubs struggled after the 67 split, Cronulla to establish itself supporterwise and finanially in the shadow of St George and St George due to the fact that it lost most of its juniors when Cronulla was formed. Net result the unbeatable St George/ Sutherland Shire juggernaut was derailed and the other clubs got a chance. I see Cronulla as overachievers actually overrall in the context of their resources and St George primarily as an Illawarra side now, especially in regards to juniors. If you put StGeorge Illawarra and Cronulla back together they would again be unbeatable anyway.
Mack
Guest
>>>The biggest underachiever in the NRL would be St George. Did someone delete Cronulla's wikipedia article? What about Souths, who haven't won a title since 1971. Which, if you didn't notice, is a longer time than St George.