Why the grand final draw must stay

By Brittany Shanahan / Roar Pro

Ten final excruciating minutes in the last quarter had me on the edge of my seat, clenching my fists in desperate hope of a Collingwood victory.

When the final siren sounded at 68 points apiece, I slumped into my chair in disbelief and a sombre mood instantly filled the room. The thought that beckoned of a grand final re-match had suddenly become a reality.

The drawn grand final has sparked a heated debate questioning its existence, but surely a season of hard work and determination can not be decided in time on. It provides both sides with a second chance to redeem themselves and create history.

It will take an enormous effort to get up this week in the re-match after both sides put their bodies on the line and were physically spent at the conclusion of the match. Every spectator was in awe of each player that took to the field, and Collingwood’s Nick Maxwell summed it up perfectly as he looked around the MCG soaking up the atmosphere.

“I don’t know if i have ever seen 44 guys to go to war like we just did then, that was amazing,” he said.

The first time since 1977 when North Melbourne and Collingwood were faced with same predicament. This will test everyone who plays a role at the club.

It will be a massive week for both clubs sports science director’s David Buttifant and Paul Montgomery, who will be major factors in preparing their players for the do-or-die battle come Saturday afternoon.

Mick Malthouse has been remarkably composed this last week prior to the grand final. We have seen the 57 year-old smile, make jokes and thoroughly enjoy the company of his players as the realisation of a final grand final appearance as Collingwood coach dawns.

Despite Collingwood being on the back foot, Maxwell described the draw as “an absolute joke”, but I think it’s a secret blessing in disguise. In all honesty, I believe Collingwood would’ve lost the 2010 grand final in time on.

Andrew Demetriou has defended the draw and says the commission won’t be forced to make a decision to change the current ruling system.

“As we sit here, we are not of a mind to changing the rules, we don’t change rules as a knee-jerk reaction to something that’s happened yesterday,” Demetriou said.

“People who were there yesterday witnessed something quite amazing, quite historical and quite exhilarating.”

The AFL will be releasing an extra 16,000 tickets for the members of Collingwood and St Kilda, which are normally allocated to non-competing clubs. It’s a credit to the AFL and a real positive coming out of a drawn grand final.

We will finally have an atmosphere of more genuine supporters who passionately follow their club rather than suited-up business corporates who couldn’t care less who wins.

I will be one of the many Collingwood supporters who will be hopelessly trying to secure tickets to the grand final and watch my beloved Pies on their quest to the holy grail.

The Crowd Says:

2010-09-29T07:01:42+00:00

Mister Football

Guest


I've just received this email from an old footy buddy, which I will now try to relay verbally (and no offence intended to all our Collingwood friends). The main charancter, Pig Dog, is visiting the doctor. Doctor: so what seems to be the prolbem? Pigdog: It's my a$$ doc...it's making strange noises....listen! (bending over) "Good ol' collingwood forever....they know how to play the game...." Doctor: It's nothing to worry about....you'll find a lot of a$$holes sing that!

2010-09-28T13:05:30+00:00

Walt

Guest


A replayed game is all good for Melbourne team but if it was West Coast V Sydney again - what a nightmare for players, fans and those trying to get them to the game again....

2010-09-28T09:02:29+00:00

Mister Football

Guest


Well done Stephen - you've earned yourself a flag!!

2010-09-28T08:13:02+00:00

Stephen

Guest


Agree with you. I was at the goal end at the MCG in 1977 when Twiggy Dunne squared the game up. Couldn't get a ticket for the following week but enjoyed watching Manassa's run on the colour TV. Have since been at 1979, 1980, 1981 and 2002 GFs. Missed a ticket for 1990! Have got a ticket for the replay... Here's hoping.

2010-09-28T06:07:21+00:00

beaver fever

Guest


I also had the worst hangover on sunday !!.

2010-09-28T02:03:14+00:00

Joel

Guest


Spare me the faux outrage. Every sport is awash with gladiatorial hyperbole and has been since the roman circus.

2010-09-27T23:22:09+00:00

Mister Football

Guest


Brittany I love this image: after the final 10 frenetic minutes, and the siren goes, everyone just slumps to the ground in disbelief and numbness....and that's just the people watching at home on TV!!

2010-09-27T23:13:51+00:00

sheek

Guest


Joel, In both 76 & 78 as I recall, Hawthorn beat North Melbourne..........

2010-09-27T23:12:18+00:00

sheek

Guest


Brittany, Firstly it's an incredible insult to compare any football match to war. There's isn't even the beginning of a comparison. You get smashed in football, 9999 times out of 10000, you'll be on your feet again. Get smashed in war, & there's a good chance you'll be 6 feet underground, or permanently maimed for life. Enjoy the first AFL repeat grand final, & only the 3rd in VFL/AFL history. Because if there's any practical common sense in the AFL, & They aren't stupid, this is the last time you'll witness two grand finals in one year.

2010-09-27T22:13:19+00:00

Joel

Guest


I couldn't agree more with that Demetriou quote, this Grand Final has now become a greater spectacle and more memorable as a result of the draw. Everyone remembers 77, but what happened in 76 or 78? Good luck in your ticket quest.

Read more at The Roar