All Blacks could go all the way with SBW

By Fili S Tupua / Roar Rookie

England can take solace in the honour of having experienced first-hand, before any other nation, the phenomenal talents of rugby’s newest superstar Sonny Bill Williams (aka SBW) on debut.

The massive frame that was loitering right in the heart of the Twickenham perimeter, helped the All Blacks kick-start their Grand Slam project with a 26-16 old-fashioned, if not conventional victory.

Given the recent triumphs the All Blacks had achieved over their northern foes, it was merely a formality from the outset as to how the world’s number one ranked team were going to win this game.

They indeed produced a conservative approach with the dominant scrum once again laying the foundation, albeit another tough day at the office.

Somehow, French referee Roman Poite saw it differently as the match progressed and accordingly, the world’s best tighthead prop Tony Woodcock suffered in giving away a few penalties that he himself found rather confusing.

Even the ever-present and danger skipper Richie McCaw was heard to be a little flustered with the whistleblower. McCaw at one time late in the game sarcastically scoffed and jogged back to his defensive line after he couldn’t understand the gibberish from the referee (neither could we, the viewers) , after turning down an off-the-ball indiscretion the English had instigated which led to a minor melee between the players.

Otherwise for me personally, the highlight of this game – apart from the presence of SBW – was the non-appearance of Stephen Donald, who thankfully remained on the bench. Donald’s seating throughout the entire match was at a fairly high temperature, that next week the Wallabies would still feel the warmth of that bench when they arrive to confront the Englishmen themselves.

Fortunately for Donald though, it’s pretty much a foregone conclusion that he will get his chance at redemption when the All Blacks take to their next stop, Scotland’s pride of Murrayfield Stadium.

I will probably reserve my judgment until maybe after next weekend, because quite frankly by then I know I still wouldn’t have to make one. He is that bad, and as former All Black tackle-busting juggernaut known as “The Human Tank”. ‘Inga-the-Winger’ Tuigamala perhaps summed it up for us, that Stephen Donald should be axed from the All Black plans.

Despite the likelihood of an experimental side to be chosen, playing with history is definitely a preconception that coach Graham Henry would carefully like to avoid, fully aware of the startling fact that New Zealand has never been beaten by one of such proud traditional rugby union nations.

Nevertheless, the other reserves that saw no game time, namely Liam Messam and Hikawera Elliot, should slot in easily for the match with the Thistles and have duly earned their stripes as starters.

Incumbents Keven Mealamu and Jerome Kaino deserves a break and next week’s showdown would be ideal for them to come off the bench, if required, pending Andrew Hore’s recovery and the rotation of the loose forward positions.

A thoroughly deserving man-of-the-match honours, Dan Carter was always a step ahead of the pack in this particular game, thanks to his pin-point territorial accuracy from the boot, goal-kicking prowess and an outstanding all-round performance in general play.

His vision is peerless and to top it all off, he was willing to get down and dirty with some fantastic defensive efforts.
Names like Barry John, Hugo Porta, Grant Fox, Naas Botha, Phil Bennett, Jonny Wilkinson and Mark Ella are constantly reminded of their tactical brilliance and sublime distribution skills but arguably in a few years time, the name Dan Carter will sit on top of the tree, as the heir to the throne.

Some lowlights also came about and unfortunately for Joe Rokocoko, he may have confirmed his ‘has-been’ status to a perfect 10, after some ridiculous errors that you don’t, or should not expect from an experienced campaigner.

I had read somewhere how he played great, looking for work. Maybe I was watching a different game but the truth is, ‘Roks’ has lost the pace and flamboyance he was well-known for. The powerful return of Hosea Gear is putting increasing pressure on the coaches in continuing with the Fijian flyer, with Cory Jane recovering well, and a stack of other wing candidates left behind.

With the impressive Sam Whitelock brought in for his first start, the forwards seemed much more settled and on the verge of superstardom if they continue their dominance in the tight five engineroom, and the controlling influence from the loosies.

However, the All Blacks backline are not the full complement of world-class beaters and are admittedly shaded by their Wallaby counterparts, who arguably have the best backline troops going around at the moment.

But if the All Blacks were given the luxury of injury-free options, a dream backline of Piri Weepu, Dan Carter, Hosea Gear, Ma’a Nonu, Sonny Bill Williams, Cory Jane and Mils Muliaina could quite possibly be one of the best ever assembled. Even though the likes of Conrad Smith, Richard Kahui, Isaia Toeava, Sitiveni Sivivatu, Rene Ranger and Israel Dagg are more than capable themselves, the fact that Australian coach Robbie Deans’ youth-policy is bearing the fruits of labour at his disposal, which may perhaps be the catalyst of his World Cup ambitions.

Meanwhile, Shontayne Hape’s no-try sour grapes of the so-called Toeava shoulder-charge is quite laughable to say the least. Any rugby player on the planet would’ve done exactly the same thing, in order to prevent the try. What was Toeava suppose to do, slide in with his boots in a dangerous manner ? Or was he meant to fly kamikaze wrestling-style with both feet to ram Hape’s head ? Maybe leap with the knees to his back or ribs ? Fortunately, Toeava – on instinct or not – sensibly chose the safest choice and not only were both players uninjured, but the officials did not even see any malice at all – end of story.

As for Sonny Bill Williams, he passed his first major hurdle and will be confident after a full 80 minutes of Test rugby.

His introduction resulted to just two simple things for the unfortunate Red Rose to remember fondly about the ‘SBW’ specimen. They ran into a ‘Solid Brick Wall’, as well as witnessing a ‘Superb Ball Wizard’.

The rest of the world have been warned.

The Crowd Says:

2010-11-11T18:28:32+00:00

Cattledog

Guest


Hmmm. They well may. Just hope you haven't put your house on it, Jus.

2010-11-11T14:51:21+00:00

jus de couchon

Guest


All Blacks looked stale.If the game had gone on 10 minutes The Red Rose would have triumphed. I predict the Jocks to surprise everyone come Saturday thereby nipping SBWs fledgling career in the bud.

2010-11-10T09:23:43+00:00

remy

Guest


Luke Mc'Alister as no10 backup RWC time 'nuff said ditch Donald and roko if they're still there then Henry is a petulant child. More devoted to proving everyone wrong then whats in the best interest of the team. Victor Vito, Israel Dagg (isn't he injured?) and Renee Ranger should be in the NH squad. Hosea Gear breaking through the Henry barrier to becoming an AB was ridiculous. While roko, Toeava and Donalds reinstatments were pathetically easy--Roko is a good humble AB but he shouldn't be there. Sonny Bill I think will have the goods but its really early days and Conrad is "silky smooth" at centre at the moment. Sonny as the other above players (minus the Roko's) will inject real energy into the team. A special jolt when something is needed (if they are nurtured properly) Roko didn't energise anything, (Toeava's try save against Hape was a good jolt). Ranger and others are in form and form should be a major crucible in becoming an AB anybody see Vito's pick up off the dirt awesome, he did immediately pass it to the opposition but still fantastic skills.

2010-11-10T06:38:33+00:00

Holty

Guest


of course.... Blame the Aussies for that as well, why not!! Ha.

2010-11-10T02:57:36+00:00

Ralph

Guest


You can't fight the press. We sometimes forget every major daily newspaper in New Zealand is owned by Aussies.

2010-11-09T21:25:03+00:00

Ben S

Roar Guru


It was a stop-start game, a bit like Hong Kong, with two rusty teams. Hoping for better this weekend, from all sides really. The quality of rugby wasn't great last weekend IMO.

2010-11-09T21:18:56+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Fair enough - to be honest, I think the inexperience wasn't that much of a factor in the defensive lapses for the most part. It probably did play a part in both sides failing to capitalise on most of them though - eg both Gear and Hape's poor technique in the corner. One bombed try and one within an inch of being bombed, cause they didn't go low properly and get the ball to the line early.

2010-11-09T21:03:48+00:00

Ben S

Roar Guru


I referred to the inexperience of the English backline in response to your suggestion that England managed to get anywhere the NZ tryline due to NZ inexperience. If both sides are inexperienced then both sides should both be flawed in attack and defence. The fact of the matter is thus: a) the inexperience of that NZ backline is nothing extraordinary in the current international context, b) any inexperience was padded by huge experience and c) the inexperience in 3 positions isn't even anything extraordinary for NZ this season given there have been four Test involving combinations of Cruden, Slade, Ranger, Dagg, Guildford, Kahui and Stanley. I'm not trying to kick up a fuss, but cries (not from you) of "It was our 18th Best side!" are slightly boring given we hear them every other Test from the same poster.

2010-11-09T20:50:04+00:00

Jerry

Guest


Ben - the English team's inexperience isn't relevant to the point that was being made. You said it was notable that the English backline had performed well against an AB team that hadn't conceded a try in ages. But that ignores the fact that it was actually a largely different backline that they were up against. The English team's inexperience isn't relevant to that point, cause they're not the thing being compared.

2010-11-09T19:48:45+00:00

Bayboy

Guest


I was referring to the article and tieing it in with your statement that the Australian back line would have exploited his defence every time. By making this statement you are agreeing or insinuating they actually are the so called "best back-line in the world" myth

2010-11-09T14:52:00+00:00

Colin N

Guest


KPM, there was a sizable gap and the England defence was far too narrow, much like the lead-up to the second try.

2010-11-09T14:49:17+00:00

Colin N

Guest


He made six metres, Tindall 29 and Hape 31. He did well I thought, but he wasn't outstanding and he missed a couple of tackles.

2010-11-09T14:45:46+00:00

Colin N

Guest


"the aussie team isnt particuarly that young." No, he said it wasn't inexperienced, which it isn't. There's a difference. You can play test match rugby at 17 and by the time you're 20, you're still young but an experienced test player.

2010-11-09T14:07:38+00:00

Mike

Guest


I've got to admit that as a Kiwi it's a little embarassing the amount of attention SBWs is getting. The AB's are a team that traditionally let the results do the talking rather than the hype and shit talking that other nations rely on to abate for their 50% win rates (if theyre very lucky). I think the media are just really bored right now so they keep coming back to this guy. I wish they'd give it a rest though. I'm sure SBW will get better in time but why can't we just wait until then? His debut was the best that anyone could have realistically expected - solid work effort, glimpses of high promise and a few errors. He was never going to be marauding through the entire English line scoring 3 trys on his first game..

2010-11-09T14:05:36+00:00

brad

Guest


SBW overated? yes. He broke a tackle wow! Robbie Fruean is better and so is rene ranger. Sadly for both those youngsters they do not bring in the headlines. Nobody can justify the SBW experiment. I watched the NPC games and Slade was alot more awsome than SBW. the quickest path to getting a union test cap is to play in the NRL. by the way Jaque Fourie is bigget than this man

2010-11-09T13:39:30+00:00

goldenbull

Guest


I wonder how long hes been dating SBW for?

2010-11-09T13:29:17+00:00

goldenbull

Guest


I wonder why Ohtani's jacket.... isnt this an aussie site?? where aussie fans come to talk about their team in a positive optimistic way?? anyways aussie backline is better then the kiwis!

2010-11-09T13:26:44+00:00

goldenbull

Guest


listen to Ben S again, this coming from a guy who truely beleives that 1. the aussie young players arent very good and 2. the aussie team isnt particuarly that young.

2010-11-09T13:23:01+00:00

goldenbull

Guest


yeah your right its a bit like how quade cooper carved up italy in his first game to score an amazing individual try! im with TembaVJ keep building it up, he is superman with no weakneses at all! amazing defence (no more shoulder charges though) and amazing attacking ability, no one in league could come close! haha yeah right!

2010-11-09T13:01:29+00:00

GavinH

Guest


- would be good to see SBW with Conrad this w/e - halfback still a problem for NZ as weepu is only world class in the last 20 mins of the bench (bring back kelleher anyone..?) - Dallaglio wrote in the UK press it was NZ's top team, which is a poor mistake for a full time pundit - i agree with the general consensus that rocco needs to go

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar