Live scores
Live Commentary
Warriors : 6
Titans : 2
| 22:00

Will the Manly Sea Eagles soar in 2011?

babblingbrookesy Roar Rookie

By babblingbrookesy, babblingbrookesy is a Roar Rookie

 , , , , , ,

7 Have your say

    Related coverage

    After winning the 2008 NRL Grand Final by a record 40-0 margin against rivals the Melbourne Storm, the Manly Sea Eagles seemed like they were on the verge of building a dynasty to rival their successful teams of the 1970’s.

    No one would have predicted the chain of events that would occur to bring the proud club crashing down from their grand final high.

    Off the field altercations involving high-profile players Brett Stewart, Anthony Watmough and Steve Matai as well as boardroom dramas with owners Scott Penn and Max Delmege had the Sea Eagles on the back page for all the wrong reasons.

    After going down in the first round of the semi-finals in 2009, the Sea Eagles looked to put it all behind them and go forward in 2010. They had to do it without playmaker Matt Orford, second-rower Glenn Hall and hooker Heath L’Estrange who all decided to ply their trade over in the U.K. Super League.

    Manly’s bad luck started early with season-ending injuries to star fullback Brett Stewart and winger David Williams. Manly had a great start of the season winning six of their first nine matches.

    However an alarming trend developed in the three losses – squandering half-time leads.

    They battled with consistency throughout the season but provided a couple of sublime performances for their fans at Fortress Brookvale. Wins against St. George-Illawarra (24-6) and Melbourne Storm (26-6) were season highlights for the Brookie faithful and kept them within striking distance of a top four position.

    The Eagles scraped into eighth position after losing three of their final four matches including another second-half capitulation against the Roosters. After dominating the first 40 minutes and leading 14-6 at half-time, Manly let the Roosters score 24 unanswered points losing the pivotal match 30-14.

    With injuries and suspension causing major changes to the regular side, they bowed out in week one of the finals, going down 28-0 to the eventual champions, St. George-Illawarra at WIN Jubilee.

    Manly 2011 Depth Chart

    Starter: Jason King & Brent Kite
    Depth: Matt Cross, George Rose, Tim Robinson

    With the loss of Josh Perry, 2008 Clive Churchill Medal winner Brent Kite will now be required to start up-front with captain Jason King in the front row. King had another solid year for the Eagles, winning his second consecutive Best and Fairest award. However, ‘Kingy’ will need to cut down on conceding penalties in 2011 after being pulled up for 17 infringements in 2010 (equal 7th most in the NRL)

    Matt Cross could be a surprise this year. In his first season with the club, Cross played 16 matches and scored three tries. He has a similar game to that of former Titans teammates Matt White and Luke Bailey. Cross is also pretty handy with the bat, smashing 63 off 44 balls in Manly’s victory over the Wests Tigers in their annual 20/20 cricket match. Look for him and ‘Gorgeous’ George Rose to step up in Perry’s absence.

    Starter: Matt Ballin
    Depth: Terrence Seu Seu

    It was a big 2010 for the Manly rake. Ballin got his first taste of Origin football replacing the injured Cam Smith in the Queensland side in Game 1. He was one of only three Eagles to play in all 25 games. Ballin asserted himself as one of the league’s top tacklers recording 914 and averaging just over 37 per game, placing him 4th in the NRL.

    With the loss of Matt Orford, Ballin provided some solid kicking from dummy-half and even connecting on a 40/20. He will need to keep improving and show leadership, helping take the load off the rookie halfback Dale Cherry-Evans.

    Second Rowers
    Starters: Shane Rodney & Anthony Watmough
    Depth: Joe Galuvao, Daniel Harrison, Darcy Lussick, Vic Mauro

    Anthony Watmough’s season was plagued by injury. It seemed as though the NSW & Australian representative played throughout 2010 with a serious of foot and ankle problems.

    It really affected his game especially his signature runs where he was significantly down in metres, tackle busts and line-breaks. His frustrating season could have been the reason why the Australian representative was tied with Warriors pivot James Maloney in conceding the most penalties (25) in the NRL.

    His second-row partner, Shane Rodney was a great surprise for Manly last year. He was able to lock down the second-rower position left vacant by Glenn Hall’s departure. Rodney provided help for his front row, averaging 14 runs per game and barely making a mistake, conceding only four errors throughout the season. His goal-kicking was an added bonus after Jamie Lyon sprained his ankle in a Round 12 victory against the Cowboys.

    Manly have some decent depth in the back row with veteran Joe Galuvao and promising youngsters Daniel Harrison, Darcy Lussick and Vic Mauro.

    Starter: Glenn Stewart
    Depth: Jamie Buhrer

    Stewart was missed down the stretch, missing their final two matches with losses to Canterbury and St. George-Illawarra. Initially signed as a throw-in deal with brother Brett back in 2002, Glenn has become one of Manly’s most reliable and hardworking players since getting the chance to play regular football in 2007.

    Stewart will most likely give you 80 minutes and at least 25 tackles. One of many Manly players who had career years in 2008 but have struggled to re-create that form, the return of brother Brett may just be the spark that gets this former Australian representative back on track.

    Starters: Kieran Foran & Dale Cherry-Evans
    Depth: Gary Riccardi

    Kieran Foran will look to improve on a successful 2010, where he was selected to represent New Zealand in the ANZAC Test and Four Nations series. In his first full season, Foran showed great composure and played like an NRL veteran.

    The Kiwi crossed for four tries and possessed solid playmaking skills generating 11 line break assists and 17 try assists. His play and combination with rookie Hodkinson had the Eagles over achieving throughout the season with such a young halves combination.

    Rookie Dale Cherry-Evans comes into the halves with the departure of Hodkinson. Cherry-Evans followed the exact path as Hodkinson, with both players coming from their feeder club, Sunshine Coast Eagles in the Queensland Cup.

    With a combined total of 32 first grade games (32 – Foran, 0 – DCE) Manly will again possess the least-experienced halves combination in the NRL. Jamie Lyon has the ability to play five-eighth if required and Kieran’s brother Liam has been signed from the Roosters as an option at halfback.

    Starters: Michael Robertson & David Williams
    Depth: Tony Williams, Michael Oldfield

    Robertson was again one of Manly’s solid performers in 2010. Playing on the wing and filling in at the back with the injury to Brett Stewart, Robertson played in all 25 games and scored 11 tries. Robbo came over from Canberra in 2006 and has made 129 consecutive appearances since debuting in round two that season.

    ‘The Wolfman’, David Williams will slot back into the right wing after missing the whole of 2010 with a shoulder injury. However, that return could be delayed after a hamstring injury in a trial to the Warriors.

    Manly have solid depth out on the wings. Tony Williams had his best season to date. T-Rex was Manly’s top tryscorer in 2010 with 16 four-pointers and proved a hard man to stop, leading the NRL in tackle busts with 147. Williams is likely become an important player for Manly in 2011.

    Coach Des Hasler will have the option of using Williams as an interchange to cover not only the wing position, but also the centres and back-row. Rookie Michael Oldfield impressed in his first three games in the top grade last season and will be itching to get a start.

    Starters: Steve Matai, Jamie Lyon
    Depth: Tony Williams, Dean Whare

    Probably their most talented player, Jamie Lyon will be crucial to the success of the Sea Eagles in 2011. His versatility – ability to play in the centres and at five-eighth, goal-kicking and experience makes him one of Des Hasler’s first selected. He has that match-winning quality that only a handful of players possess. Lyon will be coming off a career year where he scored 11 tries and kicked 69 goals for a total of 182 points.

    Steve Matai who tends to miss games due to injury or suspension, had one of his best seasons so far playing in 21 games for the Eagles, and scoring a personal best 14 tries. Unfortunately some poor discipline in a heated final game of the regular season cost Matai a chance to play in the finals. The Kiwi international received a seven-match ban for a late hit on Bulldogs hooker Michael Ennis which will rule him out up until round five.

    Dean Whare scored three tries on debut against the Cowboys. It was the first time a Sea-Eagle scored a hat-trick on debut since legend Ken Irvine achieved the feat in 1971. He will fill in respectably whilst Matai sits on the sidelines. Some outstanding play could force Hasler to switch Lyon to the halves to accomodate his talents.

    Starter: Brett Stewart
    Depth: William Hopoate

    The return of Stewart will be a major boost for the club. After two knee surgeries, reports suggest that ‘The Snake’ is nearly running at full speed. Stewart holds an incredible strike rate, scoring 98 tries in only 118 matches. If Stewart hasn’t already cracked the ton in after their first two matches, then their round three home opener against the Knights could have a double celebration for the fan favourite. It will be Stewart’s first match at Brookie in 18 months.

    William Hopoate son of former Eagles winger John had a good debut in 2010. The 18-year-old showed that he can play at fullback after a solid appearance at the back in the 26-6 win against the Storm.

    Looking ahead for 2011

    Manly will benefit from the return of Stewart and Williams however they still managed without their repesentative duo last season. Their long-term injuries allowed players such as Dean Whare, Michael Oldfield and William Hopoate to get a taste of first grade and give the Eagles a talented base of young outside backs that would be the envy of most NRL teams.

    Manly were first-half specialists, who rarely went into half time trailling in 2010. They were the NRL’s most potent side in the first fourty minutes, scoring 361 points. It was a different story in the second stanza where they consistently struggled to close out matches, scoring an NRL worst 181 points. Manly’s second half attack or lack thereof may have been a direct link to their poor discipline and fitness.

    Manly gave away an average of 6.3 penalties per game – three of their forwards (Watmough, King and Stewart) were in the top 15 penalised players and with Steve Matai’s current seven-game suspension, makes it evident that they should be clean up their discipline and relationship with the referees.

    Manly were one the quieter teams with regards to recruitment. Their forward pack, which has been arguably the best in recent years has taken a hit with the loss of Perry and Bailey.

    Gone are the Delmege/Meyer days of the ‘marquee signings’ of the mid-2000’s where players like Brent Kite, Ben Kennedy, Matt Orford, Steve Bell and Jamie Lyon were lured to the club with massive contracts. It could possibly outline some financial issues with the club rather than Des Hasler and Manly management having faith in the current squad.

    Manly have no better test to start the season than the challenge of travelling to AAMI Park for a first round encounter against rivals Melbourne Storm, who have been anticipating the start to the 2011 season after being basically shutdown in competing in the 2010 NRL season after being found to have breached the NRL’s salary cap over a number of seasons.

    It will be a tough year for the Eagles to keep up with the rest of the league with most teams improving their squads in the off-season. In what looks to be a tight 2011 season, Manly will struggle to make their eighth consecutive finals series.

    Do you find yourself logged out of The Roar?
    We have just switched over to a secure site (https). This means you will need to log-in afresh. If you need help with recovering your password, please get in contact.

    If you could choose from any and every NRL player in the competition, who would you pick in your rugby league dream team? Let us know with our team picker right here, and be sure to share it with all your league-loving mates.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (7)

    • March 2nd 2011 @ 9:09am
      oikee said | March 2nd 2011 @ 9:09am | ! Report

      Des is a great coach. I never realised how consistent the Sea Egles have been over the last few years. I already have written them down as the team to beat again this year. Mate, one thing, they need a new Jersey, something with a little more flash about it, and those chest pads the boys ware, not a good look. If they cant get a decent sponser, lets put a spectacular looking Sea Eagle on the front or back of the Jersey. To be honest, they look like a bunch of fumpy muppets.

      Yes tighter jersey’s, highlight those mussles, and lets add some sex appeal to this club. Get out their Manly, live up to your name.

      • March 2nd 2011 @ 9:47am
        Mals said | March 2nd 2011 @ 9:47am | ! Report

        Oikee – I like your optimism! A top 8 finish would be a good result for Manly this year with a rookie half-back.

        Babblingbrookesy – great summation! It definitely looks like the club has financial difficulties – with the current squad i would not be suprised if it is considerably under the salary cap. I can’t understand why they have failed to attract a major sponsor…? The Penn Health/Quantum home/away sponsorship is just a stop gap measure. Is Graham Lowe up to the CEO job? I do like the club’s initiative with giving kids under 9 free membership – these kids are the future of the club. Give them a taste & get them hooked 🙂

        • March 3rd 2011 @ 4:07pm
          babblingbrookesy said | March 3rd 2011 @ 4:07pm | ! Report

          The sponsorship is a worry. I don’t understand why they have in-house sponsorship? Surely its not that bad for them trying to find a jersey sponsor?

      • March 3rd 2011 @ 4:09pm
        babblingbrookesy said | March 3rd 2011 @ 4:09pm | ! Report

      • March 3rd 2011 @ 4:10pm
        babblingbrookesy said | March 3rd 2011 @ 4:10pm | ! Report

      • March 3rd 2011 @ 4:11pm
        babblingbrookesy said | March 3rd 2011 @ 4:11pm | ! Report

        Yeah those jerseys are horrendous. But I think they might need to change who is in the jersey rather than what’s on the jersey to start with!

    • Roar Guru

      March 2nd 2011 @ 3:38pm
      John Davidson said | March 2nd 2011 @ 3:38pm | ! Report

      It could be a tough season for Manly, and your opening statement about 2008 being the start of a dynasty similar to the 1970s was half right. Manly have had a solid 4 to 5 year spell, which is probably the most any club can enjoy in the modern world of rugby league. The salary cap doesn’t allow dynasties to be built anymore, so there wont be any 70s style dynasty, we wont see the Dragons will 11 comps in a row again or Parramatta having another dream run like in the 80s. Manly were knocked out of the semis by the Dragons in 2006, lost to a salary cap cheating Melbourne in the 2007 grand final, beat the Storm in the grand final in 2008 and then were knocked out of the first round of the semis in 2009 and then in 2010, by eventual winners the Dragons. By anyone’s account, that is not a bad record. One grand final win, one grand final loss (to a cheating team) and three finals appearances in 5 years.

      At the moment Manly is in the midst of rejuvenating its squad, and in the past few years have left older players leave (Menzies, Orford, Hall) and blooded new players. At the same time many of its players have made it into rep football (the Stewarts, Kite, King, Matai, Williams) which has bumped up the worth of their contracts. So Manly has had little room to move under the salary cap. Realistically a top 8 finish this year would be a very good result. The key person at the club is Des Hasler. He is the linchpin, the driving force behind the club’s move from the bottom of the table to the top since he became coach. Manly need to sign Hasler up to a new long-term deal as soon as possible.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , , , , , ,