Ricky Ponting has been let down by people in “formal leadership roles” in Australian cricket, former coach John Buchanan says. Buchanan, who coached Australia to World Cup triumphs in 2003 and 2007, said such leaders had allowed Ponting to be overburdened.
“Ricky still has an incredible amount to offer Australian cricket, but at the same stage he has to be in the right frame of mind to do that,” Buchanan told AAP on Friday.
“I think for the last 18 months or so that hasn’t been the case because he has, in a sense, tried to take on too much responsibility for the whole team – his game play as well as his all-round leadership.
“I’m disappointed at other people around him, basically people in senior formal leadership roles, who have allowed him to do that.
“And I think that has contributed to making life very difficult for him in the role.
“… better leadership from other people around him might have guided him in a slightly different direction.”
Buchanan declined to identify those he felt had let down Ponting.
“I will leave it to people to interpret a little bit, but I will just say people in other formal leadership roles in and around the team,” he said.
Ponting’s job was to captain and lead by example, rather than build a side, its culture and selection matters, Buchanan said.
“That is what we saw last night,” he said, referring to Ponting’s century in Australia’s World Cup quarter-final loss to India.
“He was able to have his energies directed to one game … so all the thinking about how you are going to develop a side and build a culture and selections here and selections there, were irrelevant.
“It was all about that one game and I think that showed last night, that is what he is capable of doing when his attentions are in the right direction.
“I think therefore there is a range of other people who relied on him to do more of the other work – building a team, building a culture, looking at selection – which are things that he has carried and felt very personally involved with, but I think are much bigger than he anticipated and that he should not have been allowed to burden himself with.”
palak sharma
Guest
we all will miss you ricky. in my opinion you should join your team. you are the best. we luv u
Aware
Guest
Buchanan was one of the very people in a formal leadership role who was letting Ponting down over that period. During the Ashes of 2005 in England, Ponting was in a state of confusion over England using a specialist fieldsman while Buchanan sat their laughing. Buchanan needs to look at his own performance as well.
p mitra
Guest
Buchanan is inaccurate on several fronts. Firstly, It hasn't just been a poor "18 months" for Ponting. Ponting has been a mediocre performer since 2008- i.e 3/4 years now. Ponting had a great 4/5 years from 2003 on. Those great years are being made out to be the whole of Ponting's career. Prior to that as well Ponting did well in patches, not onsistently. Pontings innings in the QF vs. India too needs to be put in perspective. It will go down as a great knock "individually'- given Ponting's bloody mindedness and determination to somehow score runs. But the extreme slowness of his innings (in the earlier parts- he didn't accelarate till much later) put extreme pressure on first Haddin, then Clarke, Hussey,White to score at a faster clip.