Hey AFL, there can be a happy draw!

By Ben Carter / Roar Guru

What is it with people always applying the phrases “dreaded” or “silence” or “shocking” to a drawn Aussie Rules footy match? It happens, people, so you might as well figure out how to get happy about them.

It’s easy – go and talk to anyone who follows the English Premier League.

Now, I am not suggesting you go and also stir up the usual over-wrought guff about which sport should dominate the cosmos – merely the reactions from fans to a game where the outcome is a tied score and split competition points.

Jason Akermanis tells people via his Herald Sun column on April 6 to have extra time and shootouts to decide draws, even during the regular season.

The Americans used to do that in the Major League Soccer series before sanity prevailed. Let’s not even consider going there.

According to Aker, he’d rather “lose with honour any time than feel emotionally flattened by a no-result”.

He goes on, saying sharing the points with the opposition is “unemotional” and “weird”.

And that AFL players who say they are happy with such a result are nothing but “naïve neanderthals”.

Really, please. As far as Aker is concerned, all four draws he played in during his career didn’t make him feel he’d achieved anything.

Again, try telling that to the supporters of, say, Stoke City, when they snatch an incredible point from say, Manchester City at the latter’s home ground. But no, Aker calls such people “fools”.

Unemotional? Weird? What rot.

To the underdog, a draw can mean as much as a win on some days. To the high-flyer, it can be the kick in the pants, the club probably needed or a wake-cup call for a coach in terms of his tactics.

Take the AFL’s draws from rounds one and two this year. Melbourne v Sydney at the Melbourne Cricket Ground. In front of 33,951 fans, the Dees came back after trailing all the way up to the last two minutes and forced the Swans to accept just half the spoils.

Brilliant I’d say if I was a Demons supporter. There was even a goal-square volley from Melbourne’s Brad Green. Stirring stuff. Hurrah.

Fast forward a week to St Kilda and Richmond doing the same at the same venue in front of 41,465. In this case, you’d have to say that the Saints were fortunate to escape without a loss, having produced 30 scoring shots to the Tigers’ 25 but they still couldn’t make them count.

AFL.com.au’s Jennifer Witham said the result spelled “hope” for Richmond, having pushed the 2010 grand finalists all the way.

Tiger boss Damien Hardwick wished his team had actually won, telling Witham “it feels like a loss – we’re really disappointed to be honest…It’s unacceptable as far as we’re concerned. We should have won.”

So, there is clearly more to a draw, Aker and all you other draw-haters.

A mate of mine went to the Dees-Swans match with his fiancée, she being a Melbourne fans. Said mate described the result as “stunned silence”.

Said fiancée admitted to almost falling asleep during the first half because it was, as she put it, a boring spectacle.

Since when do honest AFL-obsessed die-hards associate what to some is the greatest sport in the known universe with the word boring?

The horror! Obviously no-one thought too much about what had transpired. Dees fans should have been dancing in the aisles, probably. It’s mad, mad stuff.

Who would’ve thought it then – draws can actually be valuable, folks.

Particularly if you’re the away team, unfancied to win ahead of the opening whistle or had to stage a second-half comeback.

All three reasons are valid ones for that team’s fans to have something to celebrate as they exit the stadium. Even not winning has it’s uses: it’s better than a loss.

And the other side has to share the points with you, for starters.

The Crowd Says:

2011-04-08T02:09:18+00:00

The Roar

Guest


Restoring comments after outage – apologies for this issue. The Roar =============== oikee Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 5:44 pm NRL is lightyears ahead of other codes with golden point. Its like the NRL season never stopped because of golden draw. The rivalries are bigger, the game is larger than life. Your heart stops, then it starts to pump again, you hearing me, imagine your heart stopping only to start beating again, coming to life until you finally live or die. The greatest game ever will be a one all draw in origin, and golden point, mate, bring it on, i am going to live, yes live to see this game. And that my friends sums up golden point. Full-stop. You can have your shootouts, have your replays, but nothing comes close to golden draw. You live breath go to work and pay the bills for golden draw. Roosters tiggers game last year, golden draw, what was everyone talking about last year, golden draw, do i need to say more. ???? Golden draw, its all in the naming, “GOLDEN” draw. Its Gold i tell ya, Gold. =============== EvertonAndAustralia Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 5:15 pm The draw should be kept in the normal season AFL game but extra time should be used in the Grand Final. =============== AlfredC Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 1:18 pm “Hey AFL, there can be a happy draw!” Give both teams 4 points. Everybody wins! Share Premierships! Imagine the tactics come round 22 when a team wants to block another one from making finals. =============== Justin Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 12:45 pm The thing makes me laugh with draws in AFL is the players reactions – they are more cut up about getting two points for a draw than they are if they were to have lost the match! Its astounding really – get on with it. You got 2 points which maybe crucial at seaons end. A draw IS better than a loss. No one has died for heaven’s sake! =============== Stevo Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 9:54 am As a league fan, I would implore you guys for the good of your game not to go the extra time in regular season matches. It’s been the worst decision the powers that be ever made in the NRL. And I say this as a fan of a team that nearly always wins them. There is nothing wrong with a draw, it is a legitimate result. =============== The_Wookie Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 8:56 am i think most AFl people are happy with the draw. hell we still use it for the grand final. =============== Redb Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 8:02 am Draws are a valid result, they are so rare in AFL football I dont see the need to change the rules. Enough! =============== Football United Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 7:43 am ugh the NRL has regular season shootouts and it drives me mental. there is just something really tacky about them =============== Sports fan Submitted on 2011/04/07 at 7:38 am I can never understand why some people have this need to have a winner. Is it an ego problem? Why can’t these people grasp the concept of equality: On any particular day, two teams can be evenly matched and therefore the score reflects that. Enough with this silly notion that someone’s d**k has to be bigger than someone else’s.

Read more at The Roar