Swans on the cusp of a Golden Generation

By Subrasub / Roar Guru

In 2010, off the back of Sydney’s revival under the outgoing old master Paul Roos, respected commentator Dwayne Russell stated several times: “Paul Roos may end up leaving the Sydney Swans in better shape than when he took over.”

That is a big statement.

Given senior duties half-way through 2002 with the sacking of Rodney Eade, Paul Roos inherited a list that had lost three champions of the game that defined an era for the Swans, in Andrew Dunkley, Paul Kelly and Tony Lockett.

Many believed it was the end of an era. A fellow favourite son proved them wrong.

In 2003 the Sydney Swans made an unlikely preliminary final after finishing top-four, and were the big surprise packets of the AFL. With the unearthing and coming to age of some great unfulfilled talent, coupled with shrewd trades, a successful team and more importantly winning culture was forged.

Adam Goodes, Jude Bolton, Ryan O’Keefe, Tadhg Kennelly, Nic Fosdike,Lewis Roberts-Thomson, Adam Schneider, Jason Saddington, and Amon Buchanon were among the new brigade that stepped up immensely and from obscurity, in support of experienced players such as Barry Hall, Michael O’Loughlin, Jared Crouch, Ben Matthews, Leo Barry and Andrew Schuable.

A sprinkle of veterans in the form of Paul Williams, Stuart Maxfield and Jason Ball were complemented by the arrival of rejects from Brisbane and Collingwood in Craig Bolton and Nick Davis.

These two would leave an everlasting impression and memory on the club. A leader of the highest order was born under the tutelage of Roos in Brett Kirk, who blossomed into one of the most respected leaders and footballers for willing his team over the line no matter what adversity they encountered.

This was a generation of players from many different starts in AFL footy: young and maligned talents, risky trades, rejects, internationals, and veterans.

Yet the unlikely nucleus would achieve the ultimate glory in 2005 in an unforgettable year filled with trials and tribulations, and would establish an aura of toughness and determination that were the envy of others. It would catapult them into six consecutive finals appearances along with two grand finals.

In a period destined for doom, Paul Roos had performed a miracle.

In a market as diverse as Sydney, swayed by the success of its product like none other, Sydney could and would not allow itself to bottom out. It would be detrimental to its brand, fan-base and to the growth of the game itself in the city. It was essential and still is to have a quick fix remedy.

Season 2009 was a season of transition and disappointment. A generation of players and an era had drawn to a premature end. Little did they know something greater was evolving from within and nobody had even caught a glimpse.

The Sydney Swans are on the cusp of a golden generation of players unparalleled in its existence. Those before them were great and became immortals for ending the suffering of 72 years, but the ice-cold Roos has formed and handed over a list that is raw but ready to fire.

Two local products in Paul Bevan and Jarad McVeigh were drafted in 2004 with each playing a large part in upcoming seasons and are now the leaders of the club.

2006 saw the blooding of current converted full-back Heath Grundy and the recruitment of centre-half back Ted Richards, who has gone from strength to strength at Sydney. Nick Malceski had a breakout year after injuries had curtailed his career.

The feeble end to their 2007 season was met with a refreshingly new approach in 2008, with the blooding of several young talents in the form of Jared Moore, Craig Bird, Kieran Jack, Nick Smith and Jesse White.

The recruitment of Marty Mattner and Henry Playfair ensured deficiencies had ready made reinforcements. This was the year that began the smooth transition from one successful era to another.

2009 was a year that was emotionally draining for many reasons, not least the retirements of some if its greats and the ignominy in which some departed. Being well in the finals hunt until about the last two weeks, very short term pain was to be endured for the fruits of 2010.

Brett Meredith, Mike Pyke, Daniel Hannebery and the recuitment of Rhyce Shaw were all additions that loaded depth and experience.

2010 was much like 2003. Many stalwarts retired and the future was bleak. Paul Roos weaved some more magic and the Swans were within a kick for a place in another preliminary final after finishing an impressive fifth.

Gary Rohan, Lewis Jetta, Sam Reid, Campbell Heath and Trent Dennis-Lane would all impress and play important roles in the Swan’s rise. Ben McGylnn, Josh Kennedy, Shane Mumford, Mark Seaby and Daniel Bradshaw all made outstanding contributions thoughout 2010 and looked right at home in the Harbour City.

2011 has seen the unearthing of Nathan Gordan, Luke Parker and Alex Johnson. Matt Spangher and Andreijs Everitt have been part of Sydney’s recruitment plans and have adapted nicely.

There is a lot to digest here so what does this all mean? The list management has benn nothing short of extraordinary. The next generation which are under the guidance of veterans Adam Goodes, Jude Bolton, Ryan O’Keefe and Tadhg Kennelly, who form a strong core group.

Going forward, a defence that contains the ice cool Heath Grundy, 19-year-old Alex Johnson who at 19, Lewis Roberts-Thompson, Ted Richards, and a rebounding quartet of Kennelly, Shaw, Mattner and Malceski is sure to intimidate.

Nick Smith and Kieran Jack are quality taggers while Jack is also one of Sydney’s best ball winners and users. Rising Star Dan Hannebery and Craig Bird are A-grade midfielders in the making, while Brett Meredith and Luke Parker in their limited chances have shown enormous potential.

Lewis Jetta and Gary Rohan possess electrifying pace and have lit up the field, providing invaluable leg speed in a team notoriously criticised for lacking pace.

Josh Kennedy, Ben McGylnn and Jarad McVeigh represent a solid foundation in midfield who are all adept at extracting and disposing as well as getting forward and kicking goals from midfield.

Shane Mumford is among the best ruckmen in the league while Mark Seaby is a competent premiership ruckman. Daniel Currie is a weapon for the future while Mike Pyke remains an important auxiliary ruckman.

Sam Reid’s impressive 2011 has seen him touted as the next big thing. Jesse White could complete a twin towers attack if he can fulfill talent but must work harder. Jared Moore is a nugget that can burst through any pack and along with Jetta and Rohan will no doubt play crucial ground-level roles in this impressive attack.

It’s very early days and it’s easy to hype young talent, but the fact of the matter is that the majority of this team is 19-25 years old and have been very good in 2011. Fremantle, Melbourne, Adelaide and Richmond are teams that have some of the most exciting prospects in the comp, but Sydney’s young players are delivering already.

They seem to have all bases covered. There are a lot of variables in sport that can swing the pendulum very quickly and sharply, but Paul Roos has carved out a young batch of talents that Sydney fans could never have imagined.

While there is much debate as to what constitutes or merits a golden generation, in Sydney’s case it’s one that has come thick and fast which makes it all the more impressive.

The Crowd Says:

2011-07-28T23:27:40+00:00

Livvi

Guest


An interesting article and one which raises many great points. As a completely one-eyed Swans girl though, I'm going to try and be objective and unbiased whilst dissecting my beloved team. First off, the goodbyes. Vale Bradshaw and C. Bolton and I think Bevan will join them at season's end. LRT and Richards deserve another season if they want it. I think Daniel Currie has had more than enough time to make it if he was ever going to and should be moved on. Spangher would have to show something special and I'm increasingly concerned that Jesse White may become another Gareth John - exceptional physique and talent but lacking the mental 'something' which makes a footballer. As for the rest; Rohan and Jetta need to take big steps forward - speed is not enough. 2012 will be a make or break year for Gary Rohan. Jarryd Moore is dependable but slow, TDL will continue to grow as a player and Alex Johnston and Sam Reid have shown me enough to think they will be bookends for many years to come. Kieran Jack and Daniel Hannebery are stars, Nick Smith is Jared Crouch reborn and Luke Parker looks a good type but I'm still not convinced about Bird. Goodes, Mumford, Bolton and McVeigh will be solid for a few years yet, as will Shaw and Grundy down back (and Malceski if he can stay on two legs) and McGlynn and Kennedy; what were you thinking Hawks??? Kennelly and Mattner I'm not as sure about. In the 'there or there abouts' group of handy backups we look OK - Pyke and Seaby as bigs, Lewis Johnson and Byron Sumner as possible goal avenues, Brett Meredith as a tagger/small mid. I know I've missed quite a few players from the review but I think I've touched on all the high points. Our recruiting staff have done a superb job and now only need to fill a couple of holes. If he is fit I'd make a play for Brian Lake from the Dogs or perhaps a Ben Rutten. What we really need in an underfoot crumber in the Betts/Milne mold and a strong medium forward like a LeCras (Tom Rockliff from the Lions would be a good 'get') but finding those types won't be easy. All in all, it's too early to predict a golden age but the lining is certainly gleaming~!

2011-07-19T04:34:57+00:00

kick to kick

Guest


No way Swans will unload LRT and no need to. Has handled the second ruck/ forward role admirably in the way the Roughead has at the Hawks - though admittedly with less athletic grace - and LRT remains a very competitive and robust fullback when needed. Miller would be madness and just won't happen. Mooney is near the end and won't figure. Speaking of Cat's though, Tom Hawkin's though is an interesting suggestion, even if there are questions about his motor. A left field suggestion might be to trial Pyke at full forward. It might surprise some but in 2010 he was one of the best Swans per game in contested marks (he actually took the same number of cms that year as Brendan Fevola in the same number of games). Pike is very quick for a big man and could create a contest for crumbers and take pressure off Reid who will be star.

AUTHOR

2011-07-16T13:20:43+00:00

Subrasub

Roar Guru


with a few more pre seasons under their belts this team can achieve anything in the near future. I would be inclined to giving pykey,LRt and bevo the tap on the shoulder. Possibly lrt to richmond for brad miller so syd have an experienced forward to free up goodes and give reid,white and johnston a mentor. Bevan is a tough nut p player and uncompromising footballer but lacks the overall quality and would be taking another more talented kids spot. Pykey looks like he would be wasting his career honestly should go back to rugby, not because his bad he has adapted really well but syd have plenty of options. I would be have a crack at kozzi or if the hungers still there a mooney because the attack lacks experience and a goalsquare presence. Jesse white has to step up when he gets an opportunity. The team this year has been whooped once by the hawks and have mixed it with the very best without winning. Its a learning curve and they will become better for it next yr and beyond.

2011-07-16T07:59:26+00:00

jake

Guest


Swans need to dump a few players mentioned in this article. We are about 4-5 players short of breaking the top 4. I won't name the ones that I think should go, but most supporters know who they are. They are players that are performing in only 33% of the games they play as opposed to at least 75%. Unfortunately I think 2-3 will stay and we'll miss our opportunity in 2012 and 13. Having said that, our defence looks quite good at the moment. Grundy has been superb, Richards has improved together with Mattner whom is likely having his best year. This is even without LRT back there who I personally think has been one of our better more consistent players since 2005. Agree with comments regarding a forward. Now that Bradshaw has left we might be lucky and pick up one of the Adeliade forwards next year. Lets hope so.

2011-07-16T07:11:21+00:00

Horatio

Guest


Tom Hawkins will be the answer - not sure what the question was though!

AUTHOR

2011-07-16T05:15:38+00:00

Subrasub

Roar Guru


i really dont see the relevancy of your comment to this article

AUTHOR

2011-07-16T05:14:29+00:00

Subrasub

Roar Guru


just noticed so much has been edited out of the original piece omg.

2011-07-16T04:07:03+00:00

Brad

Guest


I find it hard to believe the Swans are that squeeky clean. I think it's more likely that Sydney just does not care. League players have reporters following them around looking for a scoop. AFL players are unknown in Sydney, people just don't care. If an AFL player was in trouble in Sydney it would sell 0 extra paper sales, so I suspect they just can't be bothered.

2011-07-16T03:05:41+00:00

Karmikel Funk

Roar Rookie


Swans can play some good footy, but they seem a bit lost to me and a million to one to win anything this year. Falling crowds and ratings are a worry to them too with GWSG coming at them full speed next year.

2011-07-15T23:06:14+00:00

clipper

Guest


A lot of AFL and NRL clubs could learn a lot from the Swans and how they've managed to build a respected club that doesn't have one or more players in the news for all the wrong reasons.

2011-07-15T22:38:56+00:00

Ian Whitchurch

Guest


As someone who remembers Simon Minton-Connell, the Swans still need a burly key-position forward - not necessarily tall, but definitely strong. Without that, the ball will do as it so often does with the Swans and rebound straight off half-forward.

2011-07-15T22:21:59+00:00

Lachlan

Roar Guru


lovin' it

Read more at The Roar