Brayshaw queries AFL over Goldsack case

By Greg Buckle / Roar Guru

North Melbourne chairman James Brayshaw says he can’t understand how Collingwood’s Tyson Goldsack has escaped a fine over an AFL betting scandal.

Brayshaw said the Goldsack case and the incident involving Collingwood captain Nick Maxwell were similar, yet treated differently by the league.

“You’ve got the captain of the Collingwood Football Club who has been fined heavily for doing something that 17 games earlier a team-mate did exactly the same thing and has been absolved of any responsibility,” Brayshaw said while hosting Nine’s AFL Footy Show.

“How does that work?,” Brayshaw added on Sunday.

“He (Maxwell) will be sitting back saying … ‘a bloke did exactly the same as what I’ve done and you could argue, more importantly, because it was a grand final and it was a collect, and he’s got no case to answer while I’m out of pocket’.”

The AFL suspended Collingwood’s Heath Shaw for eight matches and fined him $20,000 on Friday for his part in a $20 bet at a TAB agency.

Maxwell was fined $5000 after his family members placed bets.

The AFL punished the two players after a betting plunge on Maxwell kicking the first goal in the round-nine match against Adelaide.

Maxwell told family members he would start forward in the Crows game.

They decided to also place three bets totalling $85 on Maxwell kicking the first goal.

Maxwell was fined because he did not tell them they were not allowed to use the information for gambling.

The bets prompted a plunge on Maxwell’s odds, from $101 to $26, but he did not kick the first goal.

Goldsack’s mother Wendy had placed a $5 bet – at 80-1 – on her son kicking the first goal of last year’s grand final replay.

The defender came off the bench and kicked the first goal.

Goldsack said after the match he had joked with his mother that he would go forward and kick the first goal.

AFL spokesman Patrick Keane said there was no suspicious activity around the replay.

“There hasn’t been any a fluctuation in the betting. There was no issue that we felt required action,” Keane told AAP on Sunday.

Collingwood’s third betting drama of the week is not the only issue confronting the competition leaders following Mick Malthouse’s explosive TV interview on Thursday night.

Malthouse agreed in 2009 to step down as coach after 2011 and serve as director of coaching for another three seasons under new senior coach Nathan Buckley, his current assistant.

But Malthouse has since guided the Magpies to the 2010 flag and they’re on track for another triumph this year.

Malthouse has left open the slight possibility of leaving the Magpies next year to coach at a rival club, unless he’s satisfied his yet-to-be-finalised role isn’t “insignificant”.

Maxwell denies he had begged Malthouse to remain as senior coach in 2012.

The skipper told Seven’s AFL Game Day he was excited about Buckley taking over next year and he was also certain that Malthouse would stay on as director of coaching.

The Crowd Says:

2011-07-18T05:28:52+00:00

Swampy

Guest


James Brayshaw brays on about Heath Shaw. Sam Newmans lap dog barks inane protest at percieved roarting of the industry he promotes on the footy show. Realy.

2011-07-18T00:25:56+00:00

Richard

Roar Guru


Brayshaw got it wrong. The two incidences, Goldsack and Maxwell, are entirely different. Maxwell's relatives acted on confidential information which was not available in the public sphere, i.e. Maxwell would be starting up forward. That's "insider trading". Goldsack's mum acted on information which was already widely available in the public sphere i.e. that Goldsack was selected for the GF replay. It's not against the rules for Mrs Goldsack to be proud of her son. Completely different situations Mr Brayshaw.

2011-07-17T23:59:39+00:00

bongo lang

Guest


Lets hound these young men guilty of stupidity like most there age (i got two of them) until one of them gets depressed .There are so many small minded people in football who love to pontificate for there own gratification.In case you dont know bongo lang and other Carlton players were pinched in 1910 for throwing games so it isnt new.Heath Shaw i hope is getting support from club and family so he can come through this he isnt that smart but he isnt evil either.

Read more at The Roar