Swans close gap on Essendon, St Kilda

By Ryan Cook / Roar Rookie

The Sydney Swans have escaped with four points after defeating top-eight hopefuls St Kilda 10. 23. (83) to 10. 8. (68) in front of a small but optimistic crowd at ANZ Stadium on Sunday afternoon.

The Swans’ ineffective goal kicking looked likely to see a third straight loss following disappointing results against both Essendon and Richmond in previous weeks, until a fourth-quarter scoring surge proved too strong for Ross Lyon’s squad, leaving Sydney sitting comfortably in seventh on the AFL ladder.

St Kilda had the best of opportunities in the first half, and ran into halftime with a 10 point lead. The Swans on the other hand looked unsteady in front of the posts, kicking 10 straight behinds before Jared McVeigh slotted a crucial goal setting the stage for a big second half.

With two seasons on the line, the third quarter set up an even more dramatic final term. Sam Reid kicked his first goal of the game at the 10 minute mark, while Lewis Jetta’s four tackles kept the pressure on the Saints who were without Zac Dawson and Justin Koschitzke.

For St Kilda, fans were left holding their breath following an injury scare for key forward Nick Riewoldt late in the third quarter. Riewoldt’s courage when running back with the flight of the ball saw him cop some friendly fire, and things only got worse from there as the Saints began to fall apart.

Riewoldt entered the fourth with a heavily strapped knee, and his kicking in front of goal looked just as frail. After leading the way in the first half as the only multiple goal scorer on the ground, Riewoldt missed two crucial set shots late in the final term – both of which killed much of the Saints stirring momentum.

Stephen Milne followed suit not long after, and suddenly St Kilda resembled their former selves of three months prior.

As for best on ground, Shane Mumford was the talking point. Sealing the game winner with under three minutes to go earned the Swans some much-needed confidence just weeks before the finals, and a dominant 54 hit-outs helped Sydney up the middle.

The main negative fans could take away from today’s game was the variety of misses, creating doubt that either side is really top-eight material. Having previously won two out of their last eight, Sydney’s goal kicking looked just as sloppy as it had a month ago – 23 behinds at home tells the story.

Riewoldt’s injury scare could also prove to be the final twist in the Saints’ hot-and-cold season. Clinton Jones and Sean Dempster were the only two Saints players to have a fourth-quarter possession after three minutes of play, leaving Ross Lyon with plenty to ponder as the Saints prepare for a fired-up North Melbourne side next week at Etihad Stadium.

A lot will have to happen in the next two weeks if the Swans are to hold on to a top-eight spot. After today’s win, Sydney are now tied with Essendon and St Kilda at an even 42 points, but a trip to Skilled Stadium next week to face Geelong awaits John Longmire’s men.

St Kilda has it just as tough in Round 24 with a Saturday night game against Carlton fast approaching. The Bombers could still be the odd ones out with a last round bye, making Essendon’s clash with Port Adelaide next week even more meaningful as the Kangaroos continue to force their way into the picture.

The 25,025 folks who made it to ANZ Stadium on Sunday should feel relatively positive after the Swans showed resilience after a wobbly second half. Star man Adam Goodes made up for any criticism still smouldering following the Essendon game, and Mumford’s form is promising should Sydney reach the finals.

With Riewoldt finishing the game on the bench, the Saints have plenty to think about while Swan morale got a shot in the arm. Two weeks to go, and thankfully, the AFL fixture couldn’t have provided more entertaining games to look forward to.

The Crowd Says:

2011-08-22T04:50:58+00:00


I agree with all of the above. The turf on the wings was in a disgusting state and we can only thank the football gods that no one was seriously injured. Swans should dump this venue and if it doesn't improve GWS should look elsewhere also. It was good to see the Swans get back to playing as we expect (even though it cost me money.) The previous two weeks against Richmond and Essendon there was something missing.

2011-08-22T00:51:04+00:00

Matt F

Guest


Yes there's very little to gain from us playing there anymore. The fans hate it, the team doesn't play well there and the "event" nature of it has long gone, as indicated by the crowd figures being no more then a regular SCG game. Given the state of the surface, and GWS playing next door from next season, the sooner we get out of there the better. Although i can understand it being used for a GWS derby or prelim final due to capacity. Apparently though we do get a decent income from them for playing there (much like the Bulldogs/Souths get a good deal for playing NRL matches there even though it's far too big and there's never any atmosphere) and I'm not sure when our contract with them expires.

2011-08-22T00:38:48+00:00

Ryan Cook

Guest


Agreed Chris. I've never understood why the Swans don't just opt to play at the SCG all the time. As a Hawks fan I know how hard it is to play there, and ANZ is just a huge injury risk like the Gabba. I think Ross Lyon's comments might change a few things though.

2011-08-21T23:44:20+00:00

Chris

Guest


Can the Swans please not sign another contract with ANZ Stadium! 25,000 would have made for a nice atmosphere at the SCG - out at Homebush the atmosphere was non-existent. And don't get me started on the state of the turf...

2011-08-21T23:36:04+00:00

Matt F

Guest


It certainly was an important win for us and makes the race for 6-9 very interesting indeed. I fear that we will rue our innacurate kicking, not just yesterday but all season, as it looks like 6th will probably be decided on %. I've never seen a side be so consistantly poor at converting scoring shots whilst showing absolutely no improvement in the area over the season.

Read more at The Roar