Farewell to some true legends of the game

By manalien / Roar Pro

There has been much written in the press this week celebrating the remarkable career of Brad Thorn, and rightfully so.

His retirement from international rugby got me thinking: who will we never see again on the biggest stage of them all, the Rugby World Cup.

Richie McCaw:
It is not beyond the realms of possibility that he will still be around in 2015, but with over 100 caps at one of the most physical positions, it is hard to believe his body will let him.

The first man to reach 100 caps for the All Blacks, captaining them more than 60 times, including to their first world title in 24 years – is there any more to be said.

In a golden age of number 7s (George Smith, Phil Waugh, Serge Betsen, Neil Back) he is/was the best, and it isn’t close.

John Smit:
Much like Jonny Wilkinson (see below), he stayed on far too long and while that will tarnish his reputation now, in a few years time, he will be remembered for the player and leader he really was.

Capped over 100 times in the front row, he was a ferocious scrummager, smart and most importantly, one of the finest leaders in the modern area.

He united a dressing room of strong and often divisive personalities, with the highlight being lifting ‘Bill’ in 2007.

Jonny Wilkinson:
Half the player he was in his pomp, it was very sad to watch his play over the last six weeks. Metronomic with the boot (New Zealand 2011 aside), the finest defender at 10 the game has seen (just ask Emile N’Tamack).

His crowning moment was that drop goal in 2003, but to focus solely on that would be to do him a disservice. He was the key to so much of the success of England in that era.

Brian O’Driscoll:
The first name on this list who hasn’t won a World Cup, but arguably would have made it into any of the World Cup-winning sides from 2003 onwards.

Another fine leader and the most iconic of Ireland’s so-called golden generation, he produced numerous highlight reel tries (any of his hat-trick in Paris, or for the Lions in Australia in 2001), but was the consummate defender, a Lions captain to boot.

Victor Matfield:
The finest lineout operator of this or any generation. He ruled the skies in what is such a crucial part of the modern game.

He was so much more than that, powerful in the tight, strong in the loose and another fine leader; who was unlucky to play at the same time as John Smit in terms of his captaincy aspirations.

Brad Thorn:
A freak. Nearly 400 games of professional rugby across both codes, and still going strong aged 36.

Set the cat among the pigeons by turning down touring with the All Blacks early in his career, he has more than made up for this by adding steel, and sheer physical might to the All Black pack.

The rock around which the 2011 World Cup-winning forward pack was built.

Paul O’Connell:
Often overshadowed by his more celebrated countryman, O’Driscoll, he was arguably more important to his nation.

Phenomenal desire and a great physical presence, he was the heartbeat of the Ireland-forwards for many years. Another fine leader, as was illustrated by skippering the Lions in 2009.

Mils Mulliana:
Only the second man to reach 100 caps for the All Blacks, he has been Mr. Reliable over the last decade.

When the form of many around him has wavered (Rokocoko, Sivivatu etc), he has never let the side down. In a nation that seems to produce more classy outside backs than anywhere else, to achieve all he has is remarkable.

Unfortunate to be injured for the latter stages of the 2011 tournament, although he would likely have spent the games watching from the bench; you can be sure that the consummate professional would have done so with pride and been more than happy to contribute in any way he could.

There are many others that I could and probably should have spent more time discussing, including: Nathan Sharp, Chris Paterson, Lewis Moody, Mike Tindall, Rocky Elsom, Bakkies Botha, Danie Rossouw, Stephen Jones and Lionel Nallet to name but a handful, but the eight men above are those that have really stood out for me.

If the next generation can be half the players these men have been, the game is in very good hands.

The Crowd Says:

2011-10-30T22:33:02+00:00

Jackal12

Guest


Thats a good one..

2011-10-30T22:31:11+00:00

Jackal12

Guest


no doubt CR..when he was replaced in the second half against ABs, can see that he was very emotional, shows the passion and dedication he has for the game and for his country..certainly one the greats!!!..farewell mario ledesma!!!..

2011-10-30T08:44:54+00:00

Muzza

Guest


Nice.

2011-10-29T23:14:31+00:00

Goose Step

Guest


Let's not also forget O'Gara who made the Irish 10 jersey his own for so long

2011-10-29T02:27:00+00:00

klippies101

Guest


i think you left out habana and bakkies

2011-10-29T01:32:10+00:00

dc

Guest


Great article, in the true spirit of the world of union. Now that we Kiwis have monkey off back, I promise to watch the game with both eyes. I have also picked Russia as my second team. They were impressive in the RWC. I also hope the USA improve alot...!

2011-10-27T22:18:15+00:00

Harry

Guest


Fine article and fully support your views. An uplifting read. I was sad for O'Driscoll when Ireland went out at the quarters, nevertheless he's done plenty in his career, including absolutely owning England over the last 5 years - time and again he's led the Irish walloping them. Thorn and Matfield performed at the highest level right till the very end. Matfield effectively singlehandedly totally destroyed the Australian lineout in the quarters, IMO the finest lieout exponent to have ever played the game. Wilkinson is a very complete player and not just a kicking machine - look at his fine work in setting up the Engalnd try in RWC 03 final - and was a fearsome defender (which probably negatively effected his career, he wasn't fit for much of it after the early damage).

2011-10-27T16:04:39+00:00

Ben S

Roar Guru


So who has officially retired from Test rugby? At last count: Ledesma, Smit, Thorn, Matfield, Moody and Muliaina. I am presuming that Afoa, Tialata and Donald won't be returning to NZ either.

2011-10-27T09:01:52+00:00

Emric

Guest


let it go Nostradamus

2011-10-27T08:54:21+00:00

CizzyRascal

Roar Guru


Most of them actually will make it and there are even more guys coming through. Hopefully some backs emerge from somewhere though over the next 4 years.

2011-10-27T08:49:23+00:00

CizzyRascal

Roar Guru


I actually think Paul O'Connell has been playing fantastically well of late. One of the few Irish players who played well in the run up to the Australia game.

2011-10-27T03:11:00+00:00

King of the Gorgonites

Roar Guru


Surely we wont see the entire Georgian pack again. they all looked 42. But boy could they play some hard rugby. Gorgonzilla was a standout for me. his cameo on the wing for the final 10 mins against the poms was memorable.

2011-10-27T03:09:18+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Interesting to observe the above greats of the game. Thorn & Matfield formwise are certainly leaving on top. BOD, POC and Mils are still playing well but obviously not at the top of there game. Smit and Wilko like George Gregan, played one Cup too many. As for McCaw playing another Cup, he will need to switch to Number 6 for self preservation and probably have a sabbatical in the form of a year off completely from the game.

2011-10-27T03:01:33+00:00

mace 22

Guest


Can't believe their aren't more comments on this story. I suppose it's to much of a feel good story. Human nature . Rather moan and bee atch. The two that have my utmost respect are john smit and victor matfield. Smit for his modest follow me into battle attitude. Victor matfield for his never give up and fair play. I remember watching some of the all black tries made by wings, and seeing matfield doing the cover tackle. thinking how the hell did he get there,when he was at the breakdown on the ot her side of the field. Also brad thorn no need to elaberate further. All of the men mentioned have been great ambassadrs for the game.

2011-10-27T02:54:17+00:00

Worlds Biggest

Guest


Lewis Moody deserve to be on this list also. A real warrior & terrific player.

2011-10-27T00:42:04+00:00

Nostradamus

Guest


What about Quade Cooper? I'm pretty sure he will never be in another RWC.

AUTHOR

2011-10-26T22:31:23+00:00

manalien

Roar Pro


CizzyRascal: I couldn't agree more, in fact I left off a few argentinians Contempomi, Roncero, Albacete, Fernandez Lobbe and of course Ledesma. Ross: Well said

2011-10-26T22:29:37+00:00

Brett McKay

Guest


nice one manalien, a fitting tribute. I do think McCaw might still be around for RWC2015 though, especially if he misses chunks of Super Rugby time through injury or "workload management"..

2011-10-26T19:10:37+00:00

Ross

Guest


Great players who deserve to be thanked for their service to the game. Shane Williams is another one who will be missed, not only for his brilliant ability but also because he showed that even in the professional era you don't need to be a muscle bound monolith to succeed in first class rugby.

2011-10-26T18:44:25+00:00

CizzyRascal

Roar Guru


How about Mario Ledesma, who unlike all the above players has actually retired fully from playing rugby. He may never get the attention of others but I believe he is probably the best hooker of the professional era.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar