Live scores
Live Commentary
Melbourne Victory : 2
Adelaide United : 1
| Full Time

Heart’s santa hat yellow card lacked Christmas spirit

Luke Doherty Roar Guru

By Luke Doherty, Luke Doherty is a Roar Guru

 , ,

10 Have your say

    Melbourne Heart - Germano's santa hat celebration (image courtesy FoxSports)

    Related coverage

    Robbie Keane has his hit, roll and rifle routine, Tim Cahill likes to punch the corner flag, but a santa hat … well that just crosses the line when it comes to acceptable goal celebrations.

    When Jonatan Germano nodded home in the 12th minute of the Melbourne Heart’s 2 – 1 win over the Brisbane Roar on Friday night he pulled old Saint Nic’s headgear out and put it on.

    Referee Kris Griffiths Jones didn’t see the funny side of it and gave Germano a yellow card.

    The whistleblower was only following FIFA rules so you can’t really blame him. Players are banned from revealing advertising, religious or political slogans after finding the back of the net, but surely there needs to be a little wiggle room with law 4.

    It’s … only … a … santa … hat!

    Who was offended? Of bigger concern for the Heart should’ve been how Germano managed to play professional football with the hat hidden for 10 minutes.

    He must have been fairly confident of scoring. Would he have shown the same commitment to the cause in the 89th minute?

    The rule does have some merit. The previously prolific flow of messages on t-shirts was risky for officials around the world.

    A player could create headlines with a permanent marker, but there should be exceptions.

    The Australian sports market is tough to crack and even tougher without a sense of humour. 

    The fact Brisbane has now lost two games in a row is a great talking point for football fans who find tactical numbers like 4-2-3-1 and 4-3-3 interesting. I confess I’m one of them, but for everyone else the fact a man wearing a santa hat was punished may not project the best image.

    It’s not the FFA’s fault because the rules are black and white. It’s not exactly the biggest issue facing the game either.

    If men with deep pockets showed up on Frank Lowy’s door step offering to fund a team in western Sydney under the proviso all the players got to wear festive hats, I’m sure he’d welcome them into the A-League with open arms.

    Sport worldwide is slowly being cleansed of characters. Far too often a character is thought of as someone who goes out on the drink all night and rocks up 10 minutes before a game to score four tries or score a century.

    But there’s a difference between a character and a nuisance. The issue is that shades of grey exist in life, but not in most rule books.

    The NFL is one competition that has been able to find a more acceptable blend. They’ve cracked down on post touchdown antics, but only those deemed excessive.

    In a recent match Buffalo Bills wide receiver Stevie Johnson mocked New York Jets opponent Plaxico Burress by pretending to shoot himself in the thigh after he’d scored a touchdown.

    Burress has only recently returned to the NFL after serving a 20 month sentence for illegal gun possession. He went to prison after accidently shooting himself in a night club in Manhattan three years ago.

    The incident sparked a response from NBC’s Bob Costas who also commented on the nature of post touchdown celebrations in the NFL.

    “For those of you too busy keeping up with the Kardashians to notice, we live in a culture that in many ways grows more stupid and graceless by the moment,” Costas said.

    “Sports both reflects and influences that trend, so on playing fields everywhere, true style is in decline while mindless exhibitionism abounds.”

    “There is a difference between spontaneous and/or good-natured displays of enthusiasm and calculated displays of obnoxious self-indulgence,”

    “That train has already gone so far down the wrong track, there’s probably no turning back. So our suggestion here is a more modest one. Hey, knuckleheads, is it too much to ask that you confine your buffoonery to situations that don’t directly damage your team? Week after week, game after game, we see guys who think nothing of incurring penalties for unsportsmanlike conduct, costing their team’s valuable yardage, even late in close games.”

    Germano’s santa hat stunt cost his team because he was shown a yellow card and was therefore in danger of being sent off.

    But it was, as Costas says, a good natured display of enthusiasm.

    If we’re forced to lose that then sport will be poorer because of it.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (10)

    • December 12th 2011 @ 7:42am
      Stu said | December 12th 2011 @ 7:42am | ! Report

      Just as good natured as feigning injury or blatantly wasting time? I think the tactics employed by the Heart did more damage to the image of the game than the yellow card.

      Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.

    • Roar Guru

      December 12th 2011 @ 8:23am
      mds1970 said | December 12th 2011 @ 8:23am | ! Report

      The yellow card for a player that takes his shirt off to celebrate is standard – a player not wearing the team uniform during game time will always be penalised.
      I don’t have a problem with the card. Yes he was wearing his uniform, but also something else. I’m sure Germano was expecting a card. But it was funny.

    • December 12th 2011 @ 10:04am
      TomC said | December 12th 2011 @ 10:04am | ! Report

      I mostly agree with the article. The rules are absolutely clear and it was stupid of Germano to pretty much guarantee himself a yellow card, but at the same time I thought it was hilarious and it was good to see some colour in the game.

      It’d be nice if there could be some leeway, but then again there needs to be consistency.

      So I guess I’m pretty torn on this one.

    • December 12th 2011 @ 10:12am
      Cpaaa said | December 12th 2011 @ 10:12am | ! Report

      Fifa dont even follow their own rules, so that would make Kris clown Jones a muppet, a party pooper, a spit bucket, and most importantly the christmas grinch.

      Who has been pulled up by the cops for doing the wrong thing only to be warned, “dont do it again”, stay safe, have a nice day?
      this was one of those situations.

    • Roar Guru

      December 12th 2011 @ 11:24am
      Rellum said | December 12th 2011 @ 11:24am | ! Report

      I just hope Labinot Haliti doesn’t have a massive season.

    • December 12th 2011 @ 1:38pm
      damo said | December 12th 2011 @ 1:38pm | ! Report

      “Of bigger concern for the Heart should’ve been how Germano managed to play professional football with the hat hidden for 10 minutes.”

      Exactly what i was thinking. GOod thing it wasn’t the one i wore to my work christmas party, covered in bells and tinsel, pretty sure he would of been found out much earlier.

      Isn’t FIFA missing something here to? I agree with Stu in that the card was more off putting than the celebration; if you want bums in seats, shouldn’t we be encouraging spectacle?

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    , ,